News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by EvanAnderson on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @08:34AM (#49625531)
The quickest way to get dragnet surveillance banned would be for citizens to collaborate and create a massive publicly-available surveillance network.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by DrScientist on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:11AM (#49626941)
It's legal to film publically - what's not necessarily legal is what you then do with that.

There are already precedents - for example it's legal to film ICE agents in public spaces, it's not necessarily legal to use information to dox if that can be construed as harassment.

Even if you crowd sourced the identification of somebody involved in a potentially criminal act, you can only share that with the police and not the wider public.

The law is asymmetric here because the police have powers reserved for themselves to stop vigilantism.

Perhaps an interesting angle here would be if you can make the case that companies like flock are involved in harressment themselves...

Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by hilariously on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:21AM (#49627098)
It's legal for ICE to kill you in the street, lie about what you were doing, and nothing will happen to them.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by 15155 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:31AM (#49627268)
> it's not necessarily legal to use information to dox if that can be construed as harassment.

This is an incorrect understanding of the issue, these individuals are protected using a unique and unusual statute. In a mass broadcast scenario, without identifying their profession in context, there's arguably no crime here. There's certainly no crime to broadcast that you've seen their license plates with no association with their names (the statute doesn't cover that.)

> Even if you crowd sourced the identification of somebody involved in a potentially criminal act, you can only share that with the police and not the wider public.

What are you talking about? This is most certainly legally false in the United States. If you are incorrect about someone you might be found against for libel, but there's no crime here. This is basic First Amendment activity. Have you never watched the news or read a newspaper? Allegations are part and parcel.

These are also entirely the wrong analogies. Both of these are highly individualized scenarios that are not akin to Flock. "Public Flock" is more like a public traffic cam that anyone can view, and these already exist without issue.

Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by DrScientist on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @12:18PM (#49628981)
I'm trying to distinguish the collection of information from the use. Collection is legal - however there is no point to collecting it if you can't actually use it for anything.

For example:

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/federal-prosecutors-char...

or https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/santa-monica-man-pleads...

Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by 15155 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @05:45PM (#49634859)
I'm well aware of these cases (and have commented about the specific statute in question in the past here.) The originally-purported analogy of a "public Flock" that you can "actually use" is completely different than what the statute protects. "Hey! Look! Here's an ICE agent's home address" is a lot different than "here's a list of vehicles who traveled down this street on a given date and time."

The statute in question is 18 USC ยง 119: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/119

To preface: this statute is very arguably prior restraint and unconstitutional, which is likely why you only see those cases (non-affluent, non-connected defendants.) Furthermore, you'll notice that it requires "intent to threaten, intimidate, or incite the commission of a crime of violence."

I hate to get specific into this one very questionable statute, but no general/broad restrictions exist with regards to disseminating the video data or license plate information contained within. License plate data doesn't fall into the statute's definition of "restricted personal information," and the operator of a hypothetical service that doesn't single out these "protected" individuals amongst the rest of the population cannot be possibly construed as having malicious intent. This is an extremely unusual statute, few others like it exist.

A "public Flock" would let any interested party query the entire database of observed license plates. Collection isn't individualized to any one person, use and intent resides with the individual consuming the service.

Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by DrScientist on Thursday September 10, 2026 @09:29AM (#49643405)
The original posters premise was the way to make government dragnet surveillance banned was to do a public one. In general it's a good principle however I'm not sure in this case.

I can see how a public flock, which is just a queryable database, would be ok under the current rules. But would it make the government want to regulate? They could just continue to go after data use where legal asymmetry already exists.

You could frame almost any use as some sort of stalking/harassment.

Even in this case if they shut it down, government carve outs would apply.

Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by pocksuppet on Monday September 14, 2026 @05:46AM (#49694242)
So if we all collect information and don't know who uses it, and the police can't find who uses it, nobody gets charged.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by sicktriple on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @08:46AM (#49625670)
Yes. Once the application of force happens outside the state's monopoly, they'll shut that shit down so fast.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by deltoidmaximus on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:51AM (#49627588)
I guess I'm more cynical at this point. This isn't the 1970s when a congressman freaked out that his video rental history might leak and passed a law making them private for everyone as cover. They've evolved beyond that. They'll pass a law banning it for individuals but leaving a loophole for themselves. Like how Chat Control always contains a provision so that officials messages aren't a part of the dragnet.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by bilbo0s on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:34AM (#49626299)
I loathe surveillance networks. As much as I loathe them, I'm sadly forced to concede that probably citizens setting up a trivially join-able, anonymous, open source surveillance network is probably the only way to get the powerful to think about what they're doing.

Every door man, every hotel employee, every uber driver, every concert-goer, every grocery shopper, every student, and on and on and on. Anonymously streaming their encrypted feeds. Have them turn their cameras onto the street. Especially, say, in front of hotels or at certain restaurants and resorts. Ohhh, and at convention centers as well. Just to show it can pick out subjects at busy places and track them around any city reliably.

Naturally, we'd need some sample facial recognition queries just to show how to use the system. We could start with, say, public figures like Representatives, and Senators? And just to prove it works for less famous people, maybe we could have some example names of regular, everyday employees. Like employees at, I don't know?? Palantir, Flock and Clearview maybe? Just to demonstrate the value and effectiveness of public surveillance networks.

Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by arealaccount on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:04AM (#49626798)
Good luck getting permits to install your citizen flock in public areas.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by 15155 on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @10:22AM (#49627118)
Enough private businesses abut major thoroughfares that this is a non-issue.
Re:Flock Wants a Closely Surveilled World with No Exit by WaitWaitWha on Wednesday September 09, 2026 @09:01AM (#49625859)
... of politicians. Because they are the ones who could write the laws to ban privacy invasive solutions.