I understand where you're coming from on that, but there are a ton of people living in slavery, or in unsafe working conditions, or with food insecurity, or dying of preventable disease.
There will always be something to strive for, even if it's made up. You think that the best football players in the world are doing something real? No, it's a made up game. We'll make up more games.
Regarding entertainment jobs like sports star, musician, artist, actor, etc., the problem is those are professions where, for the most part, only the very best can make a living. Nobody is that interested in seeing the matches of the 324th best tennis player in the world, despite that person being in the top .01% of tennis players globally. Similarly, only a tiny percentage of actors "make it", everyone else does it for a few years and then leaves because they enjoy eating, or they accept poverty wages for a long time.
I get pretty scared when I hear the AI utopianists rattle off all the benefits that are coming (and when they play down the risks) because it feels clear to me that they really haven't wargamed out what society would look like with very powerful AI.
That said I expect humans will work at stuff because the prefer to do that.
This reminded me of something. https://www.sbnation.com/a/17776-football
As a more silly comparison, forklifts didn't stop people from weightlifting.
Bill Gates talks about this in his recent missive, but as robotic technology improves (and, perhaps more importantly, as the cost comes down) there will be huge competitive pressures for companies to replace workers with robots wherever they can.
Robot burrito makers for who, if no one has jobs and can afford burritos?
Something very huge has to change before all of this happens
I somewhat get the point, but I think stuff like this is very often said by very privileged people. I don't think it's a serious threat to humanity as a whole. Perhaps to some humans, but there will always be ambitious people, even in a world where most things are provided by benevolent AIs for free. There is simply so much more harm caused to actual humans today by resource insufficiency than by them having too much, that I don't think we should worry about this scenario today.
https://web.archive.org/web/20100211181147/https://marshallb...
wut.
Just look at the legions of people that have moved from Chinese rural areas to big cities. For many, many people, life in the cities is worse and kind of dystopian - much more overcrowding, "drone-like" jobs indoors, horrible pollution, and especially for men an often abysmal sex ratio if you want to find a mate. But people do it because it offers the dream of advancement and a better life - and of course some people do achieve that dream, even if the majority do not. That's versus life in rural areas which is guaranteed to be static, no chance for advancement and often crushing boredom.
People everywhere want to strive, work hard and get ahead. This is not just a privileged rich people issue.
> People everywhere want to strive, work hard and get ahead.
i think you need to visit more countries and cultures because you would discover this is not at all trueNow you might say “but those would be fake jobs.” If so, I have bad news about how many present-day jobs are fake jobs.
> There are even bioengineered human-like creatures (to humans what corgis are to wolves) sitting in office-like environments all day viewing readouts of what’s going on and excitedly approving of everything, since that satisfies some of Agent-4’s drives.
I'll leave it up to you to decide if that's an enviable/desirable future.
Also I believe our socialness was crafted out of the need for survival. If removed it's all gonna run wild since nobody needs anybody, and it might end up as doom scrolling but for human relationship. Short bursts from time to time and that's it
In many ways they don't apply to humans, and I think a lot of the modern critiques are valid, and the overpopulation concerns in particular don't map well to the modern world. Still, I believe it helps to think deeply about what happens to societies when innate drives and motivations have "nowhere to go".
It's only going back. Raw urban human connections will be the only thing left to exercise.
It is three videos. This is one of them: https://www.lenkaclayton.com/work#/the-distance-i-can-be-fro...
In these three videos she sets up a tripod and tells her toddler to walk away from her. She is behind the camera. He toddles away, occasionally looking back at her or checking out something on the ground or falling on his butt. At some point he is too far away and she runs after him, entering the frame from behind the camera. The video stops and shows the distance he was able to be away before she had to chase after him.
The videos are sweet and funny but also engrossing and powerful. The tension builds as you watch it. Is this the moment where he is too far away? What if that were my son? Would I have run after him at this point? He sure is getting close to those trees.
But most importantly it expresses parenthood. The video only works because a real human experienced that very particular feeling of worry as her child was just a bit too uncomfortably far away. Because an AI can never have this feeling it can never create this art.
I do not believe that a labor-less world is around the corner. But if it was, we can just make things like this. And the world would be beautiful.
We will very quickly get to a point where very few people will be able to contribute economically because they will be worse than AI (including robotics) at most domains. A world where people just have their whims catered to is not a utopia. We have tons of sayings and idioms about this, e.g. "no pain, no gain", "only the hard stuff is worth doing", etc.
The humans all running around on their Wall-E carts doesn't feel like utopia to me.