It's easy to be safer, as long as performance can be sacrificed for it.
Complaining about a relatively small performance price for Fil-C in that context honestly feels like that one famous newspaper photo of a smoking pregnant woman drinking a beer with a caption saying she's wbrried about the effects of the loud construction noises next door on her unborn child.
Except even that is wrong, because at least she had a point about the construction noises, while this is more of a "refusing to eat your vegetables" kind of situation.
It took over two years and help from contributors to get to the point where WebKit could be made fully memory safe.
It’s only very heavy calculations that see a boost in performance. But, realistically, how many websites require this or currently use this today? <1%? Maybe <.1%?
This is pretty typical across JIT engines, too. PHP also sees only a slight increase in performance from the JIT. Because of the nature of PHP applications, most time is spend on the network and database. Only very CPU-heavy code sees a significant speed up.
That’s even the case for C#, which is why the dotnet runtime only conditionally JIT compiles code. Only hot path code is eligible for JIT compilation.
It still uses a WKWebView today, even in the EU, despite Apple now allowing alternative browser engines in the EU as of 2 years ago.
I'm sure Chrome will eventually ship Blink+V8 in the EU. It will take some time
In synthetic benchmarks, there was a 40-80% reduction in performance when disabling the JIT. But in a simulated test on YouTube.com, the performance delta was only 6%.
This isn’t the best source as it’s a bit old, and it wasn’t just JIT that was disabled. But the core idea is the same: calculation-heavy code can see an improvement, but most code won’t. Why this matters is how people actually use JS on the web. It’s not for cryptography and such, it’s to manipulate the DOM.
Microsoft also has some benchmarks here: https://microsoftedge.github.io/edgevr/posts/Super-Duper-Sec...
For PHP the RFC analyzes it: https://wiki.php.net/rfc/jit
We see a similar pattern: in synthetic benchmarks, the performance gain is large. But Wordpress, by far the largest PHP deployment in the wild, only saw ~3% performance gain. It again comes down to how PHP is used. It’s mostly HTML construction and database calls, neither of which will see any performance gain from a JIT. And, PHP has extensions, where most heavy code is moved to. Things like cryptography are done in PHP extensions, in C, where the JIT doesn’t matter. I’m more familiar with PHP, so I’ve known about the history of PHP not shipping a JIT due to the lackluster performance.
The only .NET implementations that interpret CIL were the .NET Compact and Micro frameworks due to hardware limitations, nowadays mostly gone as .NET workloads, and alternative implementations like Mono.
Yes, if your JavaScript engine is written in C++, it’s going to be very hard to avoid very gross bugs. We have better options now.
The ability of adversaries to find and exploit very gross bugs in C++ codebases should have already compelled the industry to move to memory safety. Now that AI has democratized the ability to scour C++ codebases for really gross and exploitable bugs, I should think that our hands are at last being forced. I’m not impressed by what I’ve seen in the industry with respect to taking memory safety seriously.
I also cringe at projects that "compile C to WASM" and then believe that it is immediately "memory-safe". (It really is not.)
The only exception for C/C++ projects is Fil-C which that is memory-safe. New projects at this point should just consider using Rust instead.
Sir, do you happen to have instructions for doing this? We who benefit from your philanthropy salute you.
That said, I think that the V8 team has done a fantastic job of securing their engine. Their heap sandbox feature is really inspiring! It's really wild that (as far as I can understand this issue) someone is able to bypass it.
(Posted from a memory safe browser - WebKit MiniBrowser compiled with Fil-C. Pretty sure this is safer than even V8 and the heap sandbox.)