News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by pluc on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @05:04PM (#49528181)
> Apple alleges that Liu ran a simulation in March using the circuit schematic file in LTspice, an electrical engineering tool. In messages from around that time, Liu said his AI “agent” learned to run LTspice and review the results.

"I didn't steal it, I fed it to an agent who then fed it back to me".

> Apple argues that when trade secret information is fed into an AI agent or model that learns from it, that learning “may create irreversible and continually propagating uses of the trade secret.

Ok I'm hooked

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by newtonapple on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:29PM (#49529114)
I'm not arguing for either side, but here's a fun thought experiment I've been thinking about a lot lately. If I learned things at one company, took my experience and memory to another company, and applied what I had learned there, am I technically stealing that company's secrets? What if I trained a team of agents to think and code like me at work, then exported those agentic skills and took them with me to another company? At what point would they still be considered the old company's property? Let's say I didn't take any code or proprietary information from the old company, just the coding style and best practices my agents learned from the old company's live metrics. Is that considered stealing from the company? Is that any different from me learning those patterns and skills personally and then reapplying them elsewhere?
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by pornel on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:48PM (#49529332)
There doesn't have to be any meaningful analogy here. Laws don't have to treat humans and machines equally. Laws are for people and allow things that are less than ideal, but necessary for people to function.

Humans can't leave their old brains at their previous employer, can't delete their experience learned on proprietary data. It wouldn't make sense for the law to fight this.

But the law can control what can be done with information stored outside of your brain.

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by mulderc on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:55PM (#49529406)
Your training of a team of agents is a product you developed while working for that company and would be owned by them. You could in theory train a new team of agents after leaving the company, but it could not be trained on anything that isn't in your brain. If you gave it anything, like the old company's live metrics, then you'd be stealing trade secrets. The key difference from you personally learning those skills is that an agent trained on company data turns personal knowledge into a portable, structured artifact, which crosses from "your skill" into something that looks a lot more like company property.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by newtonapple on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:07PM (#49529510)
This is my personal conclusion as well. But think about where this leads. In the future, agents will do most of the coding and our job is to guide and train them. Most of our skills would be externalized somehow, living in the agents instead of in our heads. Which means once you leave a company, you may have effectively lost a lot of your hard earned skills and experiences.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by mulderc on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:18PM (#49529638)
I'm pretty sure Marx has some things to say on this. When your skills live in company-owned agents instead of in your head, you've been alienated from your own labor in a way Marx predicted. This is exactly why companies like Meta have been so aggressive to integrate AI tools into the day-to-day work for their employees. The more your skills live in their systems, the less you can take with you.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by Almondsetat on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:08PM (#49529520)
I don't understand the point of your question. The "problem" of an ex-employee consciously or subconsciously bringing his learned experiences at your company to a competitor is literally the reason why non-competes exist. In fact, this topic is quite old.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by newtonapple on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:19PM (#49529650)
My real point is this: if you're not allowed to bring your experiences with you, then the company exists to extract your creative thinking and skills. You can argue that's a fair trade for money. I don't necessarily disagree. But I think most of us find joy in learning, in building our own skills, in being able to reapply them elsewhere. And before LLMs and agents, I couldn't lose those skills and experiences no matter where I worked. As we progress, though, we've hit a point where we have to ask ourselves: at what price are we willing to trade complete ownership of our thinking and experiences for money?
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by newtonapple on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:09PM (#49529541)
It is also illegal in CA.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by mandeepj on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:05PM (#49529496)
> At what point would they still be considered the old company's property?

It depends on your contracts (aka NDAs). Sometimes employers do ban for that very same reason from joining a competitor(s) for x years from date of separation

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by ted_dunning on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:44PM (#49529865)
It also depends on your law. In California, some companies still try to put these restrictions into contracts, but that contradicts state law so it has no legal effect. The intended effect is intimidation, however, which may work with some people.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by chaostheory on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @08:11PM (#49530108)
[delayed]
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by nkrisc on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:08PM (#49529523)
The difference is you’re a human with the right to self.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by modeless on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:35PM (#49529193)
> If I learned things at one company, took my experience and memory to another company, and applied what I had learned there, am I technically stealing that company's secrets?

The fact that California allows this to happen (banning non-competes and rejecting "inevitable disclosure") is exactly why Silicon Valley started here and remains here. It's exactly why ex-OpenAI people could start Anthropic. It's why neither OpenAI nor Anthropic have a monopoly on AI today. It's great both for employees and for the general public.

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by pjmlp on Friday September 04, 2026 @05:28AM (#49562355)
No need to single out SV, non compete clauses are pretty much an American concept, hardly used in the rest of the world.

On my 50s and never saw one of those, that could be legally enforced anyway.

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by vkou on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:49PM (#49529342)
> If I learned things at one company, took my experience and memory to another company, and applied what I had learned there, am I technically stealing that company's secrets?

Human brains are in many ways privileged agents in a legal and copyright system, because it exists to serve the needs of humans.

Artifacts produced by human brains are not.

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by outside1234 on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @05:20PM (#49528394)
Let's do intellectual property from books next!
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by elonfboy on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @05:27PM (#49528483)
lol oh no the plagiarism machine got plagiarized!
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by outside1234 on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @05:44PM (#49528674)
Apple is essentially arguing that once an LLM system is tainted with IP that the whole system is tainted...

<gets out popcorn>

Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by tw600040 on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:06PM (#49528890)
is it not?
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by Xirdus on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:07PM (#49529513)
Obviously it is. Just like when you give a monkey a camera and it takes a selfie, the photo is obviously yours. But the legal system doesn't care about obviousness.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by znpy on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:13PM (#49528962)
I wonder how they trained siri
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by petcat on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:57PM (#49529426)
I thought Siri was just Google Gemini
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by ted_dunning on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @07:47PM (#49529894)
It's not nearly that simple. Apple used Google frontier models in training Siri, but Siri is not just a pass-through to Gemini.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by tw600040 on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:30PM (#49529127)
definitely not by someone asking it about circuit schematics
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by jayde2767 on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @05:32PM (#49528535)
Has anyone seen Pandora? I want to have a look inside that box she's been carrying around...it's time we start suing the pants off this "generative" stuff...
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by pjc50 on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:52PM (#49529377)
In IP law, the party with the most money wins.
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by eviks on Wednesday September 02, 2026 @02:25AM (#49532455)
Hasn't the book dust already (been) settled in court?
Re:Apple reveals 'shocking evidence' from ex-employee's MacB... by qingcharles on Tuesday September 01, 2026 @06:53PM (#49529390)
Leopard ate my face.