News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by glimshe on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:26AM (#49327864)
One thing Dario said is important reflecting on (but from another angle): where's the big deliverable from AI? If AI makes us 10x more productive, the 3 years since its popularization were enough for a product that would have taken 30 years to build without AI, for instance.

I'm an AI advocate but that question makes me feel that AI is simply "very useful" rather than being a historical game changer for humanity.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by ben_w on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:45AM (#49327980)
Anyone saying 10x as a serious claim is clearly using a round number and vibes; however, even if it were so, AI getting popular 3 years ago does not mean what you say.

The earliest used models in this category would easily 10x (what did I just say) the creation of one-off short scripts, but you're not writing a 30-year app out of just a bunch of short scripts.

The METR time horizons graph suggests we can now get 10x (ahem) speedup on solving most coding problems that take us a few hours and about half of problems that take 2 days. Amdahl's law bites: even infinity speedup on half your problems is only 2x overall.

If you let an LLM loose, with a huge budget, what's the biggest artefact it can make before it drowns under the weight of bad decisions? The C compiler and web browser headlines a while back? The maths papers we see now that solve problems which stumped the maths world for decades?

But this is the other side of the same coin: teamwork. One person getting a thing made in twelve months vs a team of a hundred, you can scale up fast with money when you have a proof of concept, and an LLM can make a lot of proofs of a lot of concepts even in free accounts.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by pas on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:57AM (#49328095)
LLM-assisted software engineering seems to be very efficient if you have a deterministic target. (bun rewrite from zig to Rust, 100% Node.js compatibility, pnpm compatibility -- https://github.com/oven-sh/bun/pull/38333)
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by Sharlin on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:13AM (#49329616)
And how long will it take to rewrite the Rust rewrite to idiomatic safe Rust?
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by croon on Monday August 17, 2026 @06:55AM (#49328993)
My pushback on that would be that all of the "engineering" concering a rewrite was already done the first time around. It's a glorified translation.

I do agree that the port would've taken a lot longer without LLMs though.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by QwenGlazer9000 on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:40AM (#49329895)
Problem with that is that it's not proper rust code, it's some kind of franken zig style rust port.

The actual hard part is getting it into idiomatic, safe rust, and I don't believe the LLM port makes the full transition any easier than doing things the old fashioned way: a dual lang code base like Linux.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by pas on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:38AM (#49331780)
> I don't believe the LLM port makes the full transition any easier than doing things the old fashioned way: a dual lang code base like Linux

...

how so?

let's say Linus opens a branch, rust-temp, and in 2 weeks pushes ~15 million lines of code deleting most of the old C code. and then it gets merged in a few weeks. and then there's still a few months of the "merge window" and RC process. and each day folks report bugs, and automatic fuzzers make sure that both versions "behave the same".

I was pretty skeptical (still am), but what the Bun team did is pretty great so far.

https://bun.com/blog/bun-in-rust details the process, we see the results (Node.js compat [0], more than 3 thousand of issues fixed since since 1.3 [1], more than 900 issues fixed in ~24 hours [2], and it's live/in-prod [3])

> 50 dynamic workflows in Claude Code run continuously over the course of 11 days.

so let's say 500 workflows could do something similar for the kernel. the reported cost is 165K USD, so let's say this would cost 1.65M USD, plus CI costs [4] (which is ~200K/year for bun, so let's say it's 2M USD for the kernel)

How much the world is spending on kernel bug bounties and various security programs each year? (rough estimate says that just the visible kernel testing programs cost at least 15-30M / year)

The bar is not perfect. The bar is something better.

[0] https://xcancel.com/bunjavascript/status/2087436767054213517...

[1] https://xcancel.com/bunjavascript/status/2082298681223680002...

[2] https://xcancel.com/bunjavascript/status/2080882189663907859...

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48966569

[4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49070494

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by QwenGlazer9000 on Monday August 17, 2026 @11:09AM (#49332303)
Because they are still dealing with memory safety issues to this day. They ported it to rust, completely introduced a bunch of bugs, went through all that effort, just for the codebase to be not much safer.

I'm actually basing my opinion off the blog post, specifically the code. While they do get a few changes for free with the port, most of the code looks identical. And the number of unsafe statements certainly agrees.

And now they're going little by little, playing whack a mole with seg faults... My point is that the step they're at right here is the important part, and that mechanically converting the entire codebase to rust was an optional step when incrementally rewriting would've worked just as well if not better.

Being "only" 165k USD doesn't mean anything, because you didn't do a complete port, you did a port in a trench coat. If they went for the more targeted module by module approach, and did a clean and proper rewrite, LLM assisted or not, they would reach their end goal much less turbulently and without the effort of that initial frankenport.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by pas on Monday August 17, 2026 @11:35AM (#49332737)
are they dealing with more or less memory safety bugs?

for me it was already "don't run in prod" quality before. (at least after this I'm considering adding it to the CI to see how it fares.)

segfaults. I don't know. I looked at their CI and GH issues over the past few weeks. (though now GH is down so I can't do a search, but I didn't see thousands of segfaults.)

by all accounts and measures it seems it made their house of cards more manageable. despite the frankenport, no?

they already had a zig compiler fork, wanted to upstream it, but the zig maintainer(s) said it's low-effort. now they don't have to maintain their compiler fork. (or wait for the zig team to deliver the features they wish for.) no need to maintain a hybrid codebase. (though it has C++ because of the embedded JSC.)

also I have no idea what's the zig-rust FFI status, but getting over with a rewrite faster is usually better, even if you are left with non-idiomatic code.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by jacquesm on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:53AM (#49332057)
Great example. There is no way I would run that in production anywhere.

Long term stability is the thing that matters, such a move would be immensely threatening to long term stability.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by pas on Monday August 17, 2026 @11:10AM (#49332335)
the neat part is that you don't have to, millions will do it for you!

the point is that it's a quite obvious opportunity that was just some pipedream years ago.

by the time v8.0 comes around we'll have more data on the bun rewrite. also we'll see how LLMs will affect the productivity of kernel developers, and the overall stability/maintainability.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by QwenGlazer9000 on Monday August 17, 2026 @11:25AM (#49332592)
> the neat part is that you don't have to, millions will do it for you!

You're not wrong. We're already seeing something similar with all the outages and buggy software updates these days.

We little choice in the matter, you will have ze (software) bugs!

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by dist-epoch on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:57AM (#49330097)
And compiler generated assembly code is ugly and spaghetti, unlike beautiful hand-crafted human written assembly code, the kind you see in ffmpeg codecs, ...

Doesn't matter.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by QwenGlazer9000 on Monday August 17, 2026 @09:06AM (#49330213)
It does matter, because that's the entire point of the language. You know, memory safety?

The vibe coded rust port did not get them any closer to full compiler verified memory safety. They still need to go file by file, bit by bit, and make it memory safe, at which point, why not just do that from zig.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by pas on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:44AM (#49331885)
> at which point, why not just do that from zig.

because for the same effort you get a better result if you can and do use a better tool?

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by QwenGlazer9000 on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:52AM (#49332031)
I didn't say don't use LLMs. In fact, I'm quite certain they could help quite a bit.

But I don't think they did it in a way that actually provided a meaningful gain. My point is that the state of the codebase right after the code is just a worse version of the original zig code with few of the rust advantages. Going from that Frankenstein rust code to actual memory safe rust is a similar leap to going from zig.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by stnikolauswagne on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:57AM (#49328091)
Can only speak for my own project, but can give an example:

After an aquisition earlier this year I got the task of doing an SAP-Integration for the new company, last time I did this 5 years ago it was a 6 month task, but with the experience and skills ive gained since I estimated it would be a 3 month project (with or without AI, most work is just logistics, AI cant help much there).

In those 3 months I was able to not only integrate SAP but also deliver a completely modernised user-facing software for that integration. While I could have written that software myself in a vacuum it would have never been worth it financially, since it would have delayed the launch of the integration by 6+ months. Building the software post-launch of the integration would have easily taken 2.5 years at minimum.

But this is also basically a "spherical cow in a vacuum" scenario, where I was essentially acting as a solo dev, in full operational control of the project, with deep domain knowledge of the topic and an allready fully set up codebase that I knew perfectly while working down ideas I've had in my backlog for 5+ years.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by jatins on Monday August 17, 2026 @07:03AM (#49329061)
> Building the software post-launch of the integration would have easily taken 2.5 years at minimum.

What you have said is correct, it lets you build software much faster. The question however is: is that software making money for the company? (Not talking about what you built but in general)

I think, with AI, companies are saying yes to a lot of things they would have said No to ik say 2020. And as a result realizing “just building it” is not the answer.

Previously your GTM team or Product team would say “If we ship some big project X, we unlock $Y in revenue” but now people are realizing that those projections were really more of a hope. So companies are spending so much more tokens and shipping so many more PRs based on hope but a lot of it just doesn’t turn into meaningful revenue, especially not in short term

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by stnikolauswagne on Monday August 17, 2026 @07:22AM (#49329202)
Yeah, thats why I meant I was in a spherical cow-situation, this was a situation where we took over a company in the exact same field and I had 5 years of experience on which tweaks would need to be made to be able to rationalise away positions.

This sort of system only works with internal software and an unusual amount of data. If we were in the business of selling that software we could not have charged a higher price for the new version over the old, the tweak could only be unlocked because we were able to control staff hiring and staff onboarding fully to make use of the new changes.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by jacquesm on Monday August 17, 2026 @07:46AM (#49329356)
And it quite possibly creates a huge risk for the company in the longer term, there is only one person who knows how that all works.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by stnikolauswagne on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:05AM (#49329538)
Honestly not super sure if that is more of a risk than it was pre-llm.

As part of the aquisition I got access to their previous codebase which was some sort of incomprehensible PHP monolith, with the persons who wrote that code long gone. Thanks to LLMs I was actually able to extract the core useful concepts (again, sufficiently deep domain knowledge that I knew exactly what to look for). Without LLMs i would have probably extracted the absolute minimum and let the rest rot.

There is no reason a dev of comparable skill and domain knowledge would not be able to do that for what I built here.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by jacquesm on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:34AM (#49329841)
But that codebase was written by people, so you'd be well positioned to take it over. I wonder if the same would be the case if you were to take over a codebase that was written by AI.

By that point it might no longer matter though, but I suspect that such code would have a lot more exposed edge cases than one where someone actually thought things through before coding.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by blfr on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:43AM (#49327968)
First, it's not three years since. The real improvements in programming ability arrived in the last 6-8 months.

Second, the Internet didn't show up much in GDP and similar measures either!

But your point stands. Where are the amazing digital products/stuff? I get that it might take time to arrive as we scale up compute and learn new paradigms. But so much infra already exists (deployment pipeliens, everyone reachable on a smartphone) that we should be seeing something.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by ben_w on Monday August 17, 2026 @06:04AM (#49328617)
> But your point stands. Where are the amazing digital products/stuff? I get that it might take time to arrive as we scale up compute and learn new paradigms. But so much infra already exists (deployment pipeliens, everyone reachable on a smartphone) that we should be seeing something.

I'm definitely seeing indie-sized games that appear to have had significant input from AI, though I'm not sure the balance between AI for coding and AI for assets. My experience attempting this directly suggests that the current level they work at can make very simple games as one-shots, but anything more than trivial will produce outputs only as good as the developer's combined willingness to put in effort tweaking things and taking it all one step at a time, and their taste about what "good" even is.

I'm using spare credits to build and improve an isochrone map renderer, which I otherwise wouldn't have had time for (apart from anything else, I'd have had to become skilled in JS+wasm, somewhat of a pivot from iOS). This also requires taking it all one step at a time, having UX and UI taste.

Having lived through GeoCities since before it was bought by Yahoo!, taste is… well. Most people make things that nobody else actually wants.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by dandellion on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:51AM (#49328033)
I remember people moving the goalposts like that since, let me check... when did AI Dungeon go viral? Wow, 2019.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by blfr on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:56AM (#49328078)
What's moving the goalposts? I am very much amazed at what Fable can do. I push its code straight to prod.

But I am just as amazed with how little real life consequence it seems to have! Even software houses were hit more by interest rates than by this magical revolution.

If I couldn't directly observe Fable in action, I wouldn't believe in AI.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by well_ackshually on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:29AM (#49328358)
> What's moving the goalposts? I am very much amazed at what Fable can do. I push its code straight to prod.

>> What's moving the goalposts? I am very much amazed at what Opus 4.8 can do. I push its code straight to prod.

>>> What's moving the goalposts? I am very much amazed at what Opus 4.6 can do. I push its code straight to prod.

>>>> What's moving the goalposts? I am very much amazed at what GPT5 can do. I push its code straight to prod.

>>>>>> What's moving the goalposts? I am very much amazed at what Opus 3.5 can do. I push its code straight to prod.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by blfr on Monday August 17, 2026 @06:31AM (#49328803)
I am definitely not impressed by Opus. Quite the opposite usually.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by RGamma on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:50AM (#49330006)
I read the lack of real-life consequences as a sign that gains through digital technology as a whole become ever more marginal.

What would produce huge "gains" (depends on who you ask) again is the automation of the myriad non-digital roles/companies, but good luck with that...

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by simoncion on Monday August 17, 2026 @02:43PM (#49335728)
Yep. I've been hearing «Look, we only got tools that are really capable in the past 6->8 months... everything prior to that was unusable garbage, so anything anyone said about the field prior to that is totally invalid.» for years now.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by KronisLV on Monday August 17, 2026 @06:22AM (#49328742)
> Where are the amazing digital products/stuff?

I've done amounts of refactoring and fixes and written tooling that just wouldn't have happened before.

I'm not sure what amazing new stuff y'all expect but the amount of technical debt in my projects is actually going down, cause I can finally get good enough test coverage, including E2E/load tests that actually prove whether the software works and scales or doesn't - just last week I diagnosed issues with SeaweedFS failing under concurrent writes when backing Sentry and could swap it out for Garage in a day, caught by a monitoring tool I slopped together that integrates with the Sentry API, no issues since.

The environment around me has gone from drowning in tech/ops debt to sort of swimming and at least holding above water for now (cause nobody will pay for 5x more tokens).

It's also insanely good for prototyping and being able to actually explore various ideas and shoot the bad ones down quickly instead of handwaving and looking at a loaded calendar, alongside being able to address well bounded tasks in parallel, better than human developers can - like I can give 5 GitHub issues to the slop machine and have it fix all of the annoying bugs. Issue with how some data shows up? Just feed it the DB dump and let it find out what's up.

Some projects have gone from around 500 code tests to around 4000, and before anyone says they're meaningless, at least 5% of those have caught real issues and helped a bunch, alongside linters and other tooling (including some tools I wrote myself). I've also written both native utilities and some web platforms for myself, side projects that I never would have gotten around to.

I'm measurably more productive than I've ever been (since I did measure that, looking at my commits over the last 2 years) but also burnt out. Still, it's the kind of burnout that's the consequence of context switching and lots of work, rather than the kind that I had years ago, where I had to manually untangle deeply nested Spring Boot service logic all over the place at like 2 AM cause the made up deadlines were kicking my butt.

In contrast to others, I don't need to move the goalposts - the productivity for me is here and now. Any future models will just make it better, unless we experience model collapse.

Disclaimer: you do need a LOT of code tests and validations, otherwise it all goes to shit. Maybe I'm just extending how much time it will be until it goes to shit for me as well, but go figure. You also have to babysit the models more than anyone would like or should, most of my work usually has 20-60 minutes of planning before dispatching the agent.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by Sharlin on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:19AM (#49329670)
For that you need a management that actually lets you use the token budget for stuff like refactoring, fixes, and test coverage. Unfortunately I'd wager that's an exception and the rule is (still) that to most managers LLMs are "feature machine go BRRRRT", leaving even less time for anything else besides pushing out features at a breakneck speed because you're supposed to be 10x more efficient now.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by KronisLV on Monday August 17, 2026 @11:46AM (#49332906)
Don’t ask for permission then?

Implement features at a viable pace and drown any unrealistic expectations in reports of CVE fixes - usually a version bump of dependencies, but quite often also some migration work within the app; write tools to make that work visible like I did with scanning and reports, and enjoy living without having to complain about how you can’t keep up with releases while letting your software rot until it’s a multi-year migration.

Alongside that, do the same for test coverage as well because it’s the humans that have been sloppy for years and didn’t work enough on the test harnesses or good enough coverage, introduce Testcontainers and load testing tools and anything else that makes sense.

Use their money for tokens to build software that is actually good and make your life easier and ensure that their shortsightedness won’t sink the product on a few years.

Of course you could also get fired if they’re stupid, but then I don’t imagine that working for those that are delusional is exactly great either, unless the goal is explicitly to make slop to get investor money in which case the whole thing will probably need to be rewritten from scratch anyways so who cares.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by chrislusf on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @02:10PM (#49349963)
Hi, KronisLV, I work on SeaweedFS and would like to know about the "issues with SeaweedFS failing under concurrent writes when backing Sentry". You can reply here or create a github issue for this. Appreciate it!
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by chrislusf on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @06:31PM (#49353722)
Actually, I managed to reproduce this. It was caused by upstream grpc connection pool (https://github.com/grpc/grpc-go/issues/9330). Fixing it now.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by Sol- on Monday August 17, 2026 @07:29AM (#49329254)
Definitely something I've come around to as well, even though I am very pro-AI and think it's an amazing technology. But the bottlenecks just hit too hard. I notice every day where my usage of AI is so constrained, by myself and my imagination, by external factors like slow feedback loops (gathering requirements), by the AI still not being good enough for certain details (you need to heavily steer it, give feedback, even in long running agentic sessions).

So yes, many aspects of my job are now 10x as productive, but turns out that improves my overall throughput only very little.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by onion2k on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:41AM (#49327948)
I think it's more that it shifts the thought process from "If this is going to take 30 years then we won't bother, because the investment can be spent on things that pay off sooner" to "If we can do this in 3 years then we'll make that investment because that's a good bet."

The way it changes the game is by lowering the cost of making radical bets so we end up trying more moonshots.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by dgellow on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:59AM (#49328109)
Do you have examples of such moonshots? Ideally not themselves AI related
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by ReptileMan on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:42AM (#49327954)
Right now we are in the golden age where we do the same and take time off. Employers have not yet fully caught up with the workforce. I can't think of people that are not putting less hours this year for the same salaries.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by margorczynski on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:39AM (#49328434)
The questions is what happens when they catch up. They'll cut like 50%+ of the workforce? What happens then to the demand that makes their companies work?

Or an example of MS - their main cost like most software companies are people, especially software devs, which are to be replaced by AI so on the surface they would greatly benefit from it. But their products are centered around helping out people do stuff on the computer. Why would you need that when the AI will do it better and faster directly operating on the data or using e.g. Python?

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by ReptileMan on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:47AM (#49328497)
Who knows. What I tell is that the AI productivity boom is here. Just for a change right now it is not shown on businesses balance sheets, because it is captured by the workforce in non monetary ways.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by mschuster91 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:35AM (#49327921)
> If AI makes us 10x more productive, the 3 years since its popularization were enough for a product that would have taken 30 years to build without AI, for instance.

A product still requires a lot of handholding and human thinking, at least if one does not want everyone even throwing a glance at it to immediately be repulsed by the usual AI slop tells.

> I'm an AI advocate but that question makes me feel that AI is simply "very useful" rather than being a historical game changer for humanity.

It absolutely already is a historical game changer on par with the Industrial Revolution when it comes to the amount of jobs destroyed and economies screwed up - and the impact will be even worse in 10+ years as existing seniors retire but no new seniors rise as AI has destroyed entry level career paths.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by afavour on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:46AM (#49327985)
> It absolutely already is a historical game changer on par with the Industrial Revolution when it comes to the amount of jobs destroyed and economies screwed up

Which economies are already screwed up?

IMO it can’t ever be on par with the Industrial Revolution because AI can only really affect the information economy. Things people do with their hands/bodies have either already been automated or can’t be with current tech. If you’d asked people decades ago they might say no one will ever work in factories by 2026 because they’ll all be automated. It didn’t work out that way. I think AI will go the same way: absolutely game changing to some industries (of which software engineering will be one) but a great many will still survive with less dramatic changes.

If anything it might result in more focus on the human aspects. How many people out there earn their stripes putting together slide decks? In a world where an AI can put together the snazziest presentation you’ve ever seen in a heartbeat it’s going to matter more how you stand at the front of the room and present those slides than it does today.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by glimshe on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:40AM (#49327942)
Not disagreeing with you, but adding to my argument. Despite the human handholding, I feel that 3 years would have been enough for 18 months of thinking about the product plus 18 months where a team could get 3-5 years worth of coding/development done. Yet, we haven't seen anything big yet, like a new Youtube/Instragram, an amazing videogame, a major cure etc. Maybe they are coming, but every day that passes is an indication that the net productivity positive of the technology isn't as big as advertised. In my own personal use of AI, I experienced a 30-50% increase in productivity, but no more than that.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by lukeschlather on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:51AM (#49328037)
It's only been at most the past year where AI has been unambiguously helpful and not a hindrance. 3 years ago it gave the appearance of being helpful but it tended to be more of a hindrance.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by nacozarina on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:53AM (#49328057)
perhaps being 30-50% ‘busier’ is something quite different from being 30-50% more ‘productive’ and ppl are just bad at detecting the difference
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by glimshe on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:08AM (#49328187)
Maybe so, but least for me in my personal coding projects, I'm going through my own task list noticeably faster. I had created this list before getting a ChatGPT Pro subscription and the number of bugs found in AI reviews and rate of closing tasks has certainly increased. I'm not saying my anecdote scales to teams or even other people, but I have no doubt about my personal productivity change. I wouldn't be paying for it otherwise.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by creshal on Monday August 17, 2026 @06:34AM (#49328832)
IMO the constraint is that AI is still rather anaemic at sustainable green-field projects: It's good at one-off oneshots, and also at refactoring or fixing bugs or adding features to existing projects, where test suites and significant architectural scaffolding already exists, but the more you move away from that, the more wobbly the results get, and the more the human once again becomes the bottleneck, for all the hard work of coming up with all the conceptual scaffolding in the first place. Typing speed rarely was the bottleneck there anyway.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by zer00eyz on Monday August 17, 2026 @09:05AM (#49330193)
> where's the big deliverable from AI ... AI is simply "very useful" rather than being a historical game changer for humanity.

The last 30 years of tech has been about big, the dot com boom, the next unicorn, the magnificent 7 or 11 or whatever.

The thing is that the missing solutions people want have never been the one sized fits all multi Tennant we need 6 rounds of seed funding kinds of problems.

The "app boom" should have been a clue that smaller, niche services are viable.

IF tech were like construction, then most of HN, most of SF Bay Area, most of "tech" seems to be concerned with building the tallest building, or a massive housing development. Your average office worker is more akin to a home owner, who has a busted outlet, a sticky door, a dripping faucet, they just work around it because the resources to fix it (programers) are going to build the next big thing.

Those workers now have tools to address those problems, themselves.

I have lawyers and writers (far removed from tech) talking to me about cron jobs and scripts they are running that solve real problems for them. AI has allowed them to accomplish this.

These things arent showing up on GitHub. They dont make quarterly reports at a publicly traded company. The mountain(s) of change are happening by stacking grains of sand, not one solid rock.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by mrhottakes on Monday August 17, 2026 @09:53AM (#49330914)
So then shouldn't someone be able to see these huge mountains of grains of sand?
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by zer00eyz on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:52AM (#49332036)
Hey boss, I just wrote a script that saves me 3 hours of work a week, you got anything for me to do?

Hey, I just found 3 niche businesses that I can run because of AI and clear a million a year after costs.

Fight club rules apply, you dont talk about your advantages.

You get lawyers talking about their AI use (sometimes) because they are protected by the requirements of the bar. You people in niche businesses, or where it's about personal productivity, talking about it cause you cant replicate what they have done. You get folks in the sciences talking about how they are using LLM's to generate the python & scripts that make their world function with easy (rather than be a bottomless pit of time). These are people who might talk about their AI gains, but often have better things to do and don't run in programing / tech circles.

Unless you seek these people out you're not going to find their gains. It would be pretty hard for someone like anthropic to even begin to quantify time savings from generated code by "non programers" - because they don't have the data.

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by moomoo11 on Monday August 17, 2026 @01:08PM (#49334313)
here's how I think of it.

Maximalists: 10x

Minimalists: were always close to 0x individuals, so opinion rejected 99% of the time

Realists: 30-50% productivity gains

Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by shimman on Monday August 17, 2026 @02:55PM (#49335882)
50% productivity gains would be seen in real economic data tho, you're talk about potentially $5-15 trillion in real GDP gains; all we are seeing is just more mass consolidation of wealth into the hands of the few, we're even at the stage were we are designating extinction zones to empower these individuals even more.
Re:Amodei Re. Regulation by moomoo11 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:39AM (#49429138)
we're 3 years in. there are still people who are copy pasting code into chatgpt web ui.

80% of the engineers out there are the 0.5-1x baselines that we have to optimize the 10-20% around to carry...