However, if we choose to ignore this for a moment, there's a good counter-argument: the way to get rid of debt is to pay it back, and the way to pay it back is to work more and invest wisely. The individual or household that needs to pay off some debt would do better if, say, the people in the household got jobs (if they don't have them) or extra hours at work (if they do). Allowing the unemployment rate to rise as it has done in countries operating "austerity" doesn't fit that analogy at all.
My point is not that the above argument is correct, just that it's possible to argue both for and against austerity using "intuitive" arguments based on analogies with households, and these are rarely correct. That said, neither are most of our mainstream economic theories! (At least some of them must be dead wrong, as they can't all be right).
The part with governments "can print their own money" is actually incorrect for many European countries. That is the main problem for the PIIGs right now.
In many developing countries, there is no option to work harder, get another job, or work at all. The opportunities just do not exist, and the cycle perpetuates. This is why the New Deal was so necessary, it was a jumpstart to the economy by getting people back to work anyway possible.
The part with governments being "immortal" is actually incorrect. The fact is that for example UK paper money is just that, colored paper, when it comes to paying up debts taken in foreign currency. A couple of failed States come to mind as examples, like Germany in the early 1920s and Argentina in the late 1990s.
Here's a better example:
Imagine a grandmother taking a loan for her grandchild so they can have a car to drive to work. The household income increases as a result.
If she stops paying the loan the car gets repossessed. The grandchild can no longer earn money. The household income decreases.
The grandmother does this for all her many grandchildren. The grandchildren all work and the family become rich.
In our modern economies the now-wealthy grandchildren refuse to pay the grandmother back, but they agree to pay the interest on the loans. She doesn't push it because her house is big and busy and her family have a lovely lifestyle.
Should she default and let the cars be repossessed or would it be better to get her spoilt grandchildren to start paying back the loans?
But scrounging poors are literally dying on their feet, so I'm guessing that's seen as a win.
Hyperbolic? Maybe a little. But I currently live in a country where people are dropping dead after failing "medical" tests for incapacity benefit and being told to get a job.
http://blogs.mirror.co.uk/investigations/2012/04/32-die-a-we...
It's fucking disgraceful.
So I don't really know what you mean by switching away from imaginary money. That's not actually possible to do. I guess you could go with the resource-based economy guys, but that's not actually money anymore.
Yes, austerity results in lowering the value in the economy, which in turn makes it difficult to back money with said lack of value.
Now I know Krugman says the value should appear in a puff of smoke once money is thrown in thin air, but that's more a matter of personal belief. Did it help curing the Great Depression? Perhaps; however there are numerous examples of where societies bankrupted themselves with borrowing and spending.
It can't change the fact that if you live beyond your means long enough, you run out of means one way or another.
I'm confused about your scenario. Are you continually borrowing, or are you living off a finite quantity of borrowed money? Does an income exist, and if so, where does it come from? Who are you borrowing from, and why did they give it to you in the first place and in what form do they expect it back? Are you obligated towards anyone besides yourself, such as children, aside from the established debt?
The real question is: why were you borrowing in the first place? Your story here indicates you assume the initial borrowing happened because we were "living the high life", purchasing luxuries we simply couldn't afford on our incomes, while our incomes remained steady.
In the real world, what has almost universally happened is that our incomes dropped, and we started borrowing to maintain the same standard of living we always had. "Austerity" thus involves a double-whammy: the initial drop in income from straight-up income reduction plus a further drop in standard of living from debt service.
Then we notice that the same guy who owns our credit card and our mortgage is the one who cut our salary. And that's when someone calls me a Communist ;-).
In order to pay back the debt, your standard of living is going to necessarily drop below that of what it would be if you'd never started the borrow and spend, and certainly would be far less than it was when you were living on borrowed money.
Does that mean your austerity program is a failure?