News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:50PM (#49205722)
Unless you want all cables to be thick, $60, and cap out at 1 meter long, this is not a reasonable standard. 480mbps USB-C is perfectly adequate for many applications. Likewise for 60W cables.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by ryandrake on Thursday August 06, 2026 @11:53PM (#49205739)
So, call it USB-D or something, if one cable is significantly different (in purpose, performance, form factor) than another cable. Don't just call everything the same label, and let the non-technical buyer beware.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by MetaWhirledPeas on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:09AM (#49205812)
The naming could be better for sure.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:20AM (#49205863)
Okay, great, it’s called USB-D. Is this a new connector? Or do we now need to resort to labeling cables and checking the label?

Do we do this for every new version and combination of versions for USB? USB-PD? Thunderbolt? DisplayPort?

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by dmos62 on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:50AM (#49207187)
Ehem, we already do that. USB-C is an umbrella term and everyone has a homebaked organizing system to tell which USB-C cable can do what, or a homebaked testing routine where we run through 5 cables each time we need to connect something.

That's what the article is about. Calling all these cables USB-C and making them look indistinguishable is a very leaky abstraction.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by brookst on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:59AM (#49209078)
So there are 4 different current-carrying levels, from 2.5A to 5A EPR.

There are 6 different transfer speeds, from 480mbps to 120gbps.

There’s DisplayPort yes/no.

There are 4 thunderbolt genrations, each with its own marker.

Some of those are dependent (480mbps cables don’t have markers), so it’s not a full permutation problem. Only about 20 different combinations are valid.

Is the proposal to have 20 different physical connectors? Or to prune the space down to 6 or so by requiring all cables to be very thick, or to support higher transfer speeds than make any sense for a charging cable?

It’s not a leaky abstraction. It’s a physical interface standard that does not guarantee electrical properties. Same way you can plug a 6A cord and a 20A cord into the same electrical outlet.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by josephg on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:04AM (#49210632)
That can be solved the same way it was solved for SD / CFe cards. Just have a single mark which guarantees a baseline set of requirements.

- "USB Speed 2" means [20gbps, thunderbolt 3, displayport, 20 watts].

- "USB Speed 3" means 100gbps, thunderbolt 4, etc.

- "Power 100" means 100 watts minimum.

Make a little logo for each standard - "S2" / "S3" / "P100" which can be branded onto each end of the cable. People who care can look at the logos and tell what a given cable can do.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by ProZsolt on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:25PM (#49215790)
You mean something like this, which we have since 2021: https://learn.adafruit.com/understanding-usb-type-c-cable-ty...
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by josephg on Saturday August 08, 2026 @02:24AM (#49219342)
Yes, like that but something that actually gets used. And it'd be good to have a way to know how much power a cable supports too.

Thanks for the link. I didn't know those labels also tell you if a cable supports displayport alt mode and thunderbolt 3.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by KronisLV on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:09AM (#49210705)
USB3-5A-10Gbps-DP-TB3-C would be pretty gnarly as a label even if it’d still be a Type C at the end of the day.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by phil21 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:34AM (#49210167)
I mean, if you care about this and it annoys you the fix is very simple and relatively cheap.

Just set a minimum baseline/standardization for the type of cable/capabilities you need for your highest end device. Only keep those cables, give away the rest, and buy a half dozen new cables so no matter which you select you will always get the right one.

I've rarely found I need a "special" USB-C cable outside of connecting Thunderbolt ports. Those are mostly static on my monitors, with one in my laptop bag. They also happen to be decently labeled on the connector with what they are.

Once in a while I get an incredibly cheap horrible one from some throw away style device and I simply toss the cable immediately.

The only exception I can think of are USB-A -> USB-C adapter cables where the device is so cheap it doesn't implement USB-C PD delivery at all and expects a "dumb" 5V connection. That is a charger issue though, not a cabling one. Those devices are luckily starting to become much more rare.

I purged the house of the worst 5W USB-A charges long ago in a fit of rage. Anything that couldn't do 15W was tossed. We still have more 15W chargers than I could ever use in a lifetime.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by josephg on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:00AM (#49210558)
> Just set a minimum baseline/standardization for the type of cable/capabilities you need for your highest end device. Only keep those cables, give away the rest

I don't have a cable tester, and I don't want to buy one. The companies who make USB cables should be responsible for this testing. I don't want to do expensive homework on behalf of USB cable companies.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by rtkwe on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:53AM (#49212354)
Buy nice cables from a trusted brand and bin anything else. You're going to be overpaying though because there's not a lot of reason to be powering your laptop with a 480 Gbps TB 4 USB-C cable.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by threecheese on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:34PM (#49218108)
That’s not all you need to do though; once you have bought all Cable Matters or Anker cables, you still need to remember which one charges your iPhone quickly, and which one is thunderbolt-capable but missing the lightning bolt, which one is charging-only, etc. I have a whole mess of cables - and several of these dongles (you need a usb-a capable one, and only that other one reads thunderbolt markers, etc). I spend the time to label any cable that I buy myself, and wish the vendors would do it instead.

From reading TT, it seems there’s just no easy solution to complexity if we want interoperability.

I didn’t hate lightning cables…

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by rtkwe on Sunday August 09, 2026 @05:15PM (#49235984)
I've done this and the answer is they all charge my phone quickly and I know the handful that are the highspeed cables either by the markings or knowing which of them are the good cables.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by selicos on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:04PM (#49212538)
They are all USB C form factor port cables. The actual functionality being different is a USB spec/labelling failure not one of naming.

Thunderbolt is also a USB C form factor/port, just has better naming and private control over usage.

I have a similar USB tester as the author. It's rather useful and inexpensive. Good bit of homelab kit.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by ReactiveJelly on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:52AM (#49206017)
The computer / phone should auto-detect and tell you on-screen
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by mrheosuper on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:16AM (#49206532)
They've already done that afaik, like warning about charging at slower speed.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Filligree on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:36AM (#49208850)
Haven’t ever seen a warning like that in KDE.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by dwedge on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:50AM (#49208997)
Some chargers will re-negotiate depending how many cables are plugged into the adapter. Which is fine, but sometimes makes it tricky to know if it's the cable, the plug, or the number of cables causing a slow charge
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by zx8080 on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:28AM (#49206212)
The hell Apple or Google cares.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by QuantumNomad_ on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:50AM (#49206330)
Apple should care because customers will blame slow charging times and slow transfer speeds on the phone
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stingraycharles on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:51AM (#49206789)
I think Apple much rather tells users that this is exactly what they warned them about when they were forced to support USB-C and will advise users to only buy official cables from Apple.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by brookst on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:00AM (#49209090)
You mean USB-C, the standard that they largely led development of?
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:52PM (#49216663)
No, they mean USB-C, the port they switched all but a handful of their devices to before any other manufacturer.

While GP’s take is ridiculous (if common), I do think the notion that Apple led the charge on USB-C is mostly a myth, outside of them being active participants on the USB Implementor’s Forum.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by brookst on Monday August 10, 2026 @09:18AM (#49243241)
Eh, I can’t find it now so a thousand grains of salt, but I read a good article back in the day about how much Apple’s experience with in-market Lightning shaped USB-C’s physical connector and electrical handshake.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by a2ff6eeb0 on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:22AM (#49208731)
Yes, a new connector would be great. It could be a notch on the standard usb-c form factor, so that usb-c connectors could fit into usb-d plugs.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by hulitu on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:58AM (#49209069)
> Do we do this for every new version and combination of versions for USB? USB-PD? Thunderbolt? DisplayPort?

Yes.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:55PM (#49216683)
I don’t think you fully comprehend the matrix of legal possibilities for a cable with USB-C connectors.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by josephg on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:57AM (#49210506)
> Or do we now need to resort to labeling cables and checking the label?

YES oh please yes! Give me labels! I'm sick of playing guessing games with my USB cables. Which one should I use for my external drive? This cable is thick! Will it work? Maybe it's only thick so it can send power? It seems impossible to tell, even if I plug it in to my computer. The files are there, I just need to somehow guess that it's a bit slower than it's supposed to go. Another cable feels expensive but its 1m. Will it work? Do I get slower data rates? I can't tell. I hate guessing. Label the cables!

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by econ on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:36PM (#49213757)
Color coding seems good
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:24AM (#49205881)
USB-A has many variants and we don’t call it a different connector. Heck, USB-B and micro USB both have 3.0 variants that are physically different and we don’t call them something different either. I don’t see the problem here. This is just semantics, especially when they aren’t even labeled period… people just see a cable and will try plugging it in.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by godelski on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:52AM (#49206795)

  > USB-A has many variants
  > especially when they aren’t even labeled period
What are you talking about? USB-A is color coded. You'll frequently see white and blue. Admittedly this is harder with USB-C because the size, but I don't see why we can't label these things. Not labeling just leads to confusion and fraud.

https://www.corsair.com/us/en/explorer/diy-builder/storage/u...

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by consp on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:36AM (#49207492)
The color coding is optional and ambiguous: Blue is recommended, not required, and there is no difference for 3.0, 3.1 (10gbit) or others. And you now also have red, yellow, green, purple and orange, which have no defined meaning in any standard and are just whatever a manufacturer wants to do. There is nothing preventing someone from selling standard 4 conductor A ports with red coloring.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by tremon on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:27AM (#49209369)
> You'll frequently see white and blue

I've never seen white; in order of prevalence, I've seen black, blue, red, and yellow. But such colour coding is not standardized, every manufacturer is free to choose their own rainbow.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:08AM (#49209846)
Sometimes. They’re not required to be labeled, though. I would agree that the blue connector for USB3.0 is more common… but again it’s not universal and certainly not every device ever does this.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by ryandrake on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:44AM (#49205978)
The other USBs are no better TBH. I still remember USB Full Speed and USB High Speed. Do you remember, without looking it up, which one is faster? Same form factor, same physical connector.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:55AM (#49206031)
USB2 has been backwards compatible from the beginning though. I can’t think of a time in the past… 15, maybe 20 years where a USB cable wasn’t capable of high speed, unless it didn’t have data lines at all.

(And yes, I don’t need to look it up. But also I’m extremely familiar with the USB spec and have been tangentially involved with the USB-IF)

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by godelski on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:53AM (#49206805)
No, but I can tell you which is faster by looking at the color
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by cameldrv on Friday August 07, 2026 @01:09AM (#49206087)
There are names for all of the features. It would be cool if there were some sort of color code or physical indication of a cables capability, but one of the cool things about usb-c is that the same connector works for really cheap stuff and really high end stuff. For example, in a pinch I can charge my MacBook (slowly) from a $5 gas station usb charger.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by brookst on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:02AM (#49209101)
It could be like resistors, different color stripes for each capability: transfer speed, maximum amperage, DisplayPort, thunderbolt, etc.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by malkia on Friday August 07, 2026 @02:52AM (#49206797)
USB-C1, USB-C2, USB-C3, etc... we had the CAT naming for a while
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by locknitpicker on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:07AM (#49206899)
> So, call it USB-D or something,

USB-C is the connector type, not the cable. The connector type supports multiple protocols, including for interoperability with other connector types as a cable can have USB-C in one end and something else in the other end and users expect the cable connection to just work the USB way.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by gchamonlive on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:17AM (#49209262)
The terminology is something like

  TECH PHYSICAL-TYPE
  USB  A/B/C
So a USB-D would imply a different physical connection and end up confusing the consumer even more.

If the cable supports 60w charging or only 25w, if it's full or half bandwidth, those characteristics seem to me like we are talking about grading quality, so a better expansion would be:

  TECH PHYSICAL-TYPE GRADE
  USB  A/B/C         1/2/3
And define which quality the cable should present to achieve higher or lower grade levels, depending on the convention.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by MichaelZuo on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:19AM (#49209958)
Why not just USB-C Type 123?

That allows for 999 possible permutations of usb-c cables.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by gchamonlive on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:21AM (#49210000)
because USB-C is a shorthand for USB Type C
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by MichaelZuo on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:58PM (#49215502)
So? Is there a hard limit on just one “Type” in the formal name?
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by gchamonlive on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:01PM (#49215533)
Not if your aim is to confuse your costumer
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by MichaelZuo on Saturday August 08, 2026 @08:55AM (#49221434)
Spec committees arent rigid automatons, they can clearly decide on say USB Type C-123 for practical implementation if they chose to.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by gchamonlive on Saturday August 08, 2026 @11:24AM (#49222722)
This is better, USB Type C Grade 123, or USB Type C-123, or just USB-C-123
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by advisedwang on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:21AM (#49211852)
Right... label them differently. Now you're just arguing what the label should be
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by revolvingthrow on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:30AM (#49205902)
I have several 1m long TB4 cables (100W, video, 40Gbps) and they’re neither particularly thick nor were they anywhere close to $60.

The best you can get is TB5 (240W, up to 120 Gbps data transfer) and at 1m long they’re $32 or so from CableMatters. Those are admittedly somewhat thicker, but not stiff.

I wish there was a higher baseline data transfer mandated for usb-c. Sure, 40gbps isn’t needed for all cables, but is some piddly 5gbps too much to ask? We had usb 2.0 speeds back when CPUs just barely entered 1 GHz range, it’s practically ancient technology. Admittedly most people never transfer any data over usb, but with this logic we might as well have usb-c that does charging only. Being able to pick any cable and have 5 gbps baseline means that any usb-c cable is fundamentally usable, if slow. 480 mbps is… ugh.

I don’t have an issue with 60W being the baseline, it’s enough for most laptops and the average GaN charger is 65 W (or less) anyway.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:39AM (#49205951)
> Sure, 40gbps isn’t needed for all cables, but is some piddly 5gbps too much to ask?

5gbps means you add 8 additional wires to every cable, and also would require that both devices on each side implement 5gbps PHYs for their USB (if you mandated it on devices too). It’s a large cost, especially when you’re talking about billions of cables.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by ProZsolt on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:15PM (#49215678)
I need at least 100W, but I’m fine with 480 Mbps. There really is no single baseline that works for everyone.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by maccard on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:49AM (#49207594)
And for the applications it not adequate for, a different cable should be used. But instead I have a drawer full of USB c cables and no idea which ones are which.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by functionmouse on Friday August 07, 2026 @07:16AM (#49208667)
Actually, different cables should be called something different.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by hulitu on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:02AM (#49209109)
But they ran out of names. The S in USB still sucks. Just try to transfer a lot of small files over USB.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by tremon on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:22AM (#49209320)
That's still an astonishing design failure: different ports have different connectors for a reason. Can you imagine a what would have happened if the car charging infrastructure would have used your regular 120/230V plugs? There is zero reason why 480mbps USB-C should exist when we already had 480mbps USB-A, except for misguided designers prioritizing aesthetics over usability.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by jrmg on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:27AM (#49209361)
Can you imagine a what would have happened if the car charging infrastructure would have used your regular 120/230V plugs?

This isn’t a great example because, on the ‘other side', car chargers also have different size cables between the ‘charger’ (EVSE) and the car, with the same plug used on them all (especially with NACS, which doesn’t even differentiate between AC and DC plugs). They rely on negotiation to tell the car how much power it can draw. No-one complains about this.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by po1nt on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:52AM (#49209673)
We are lucky we don't need to transfer (so much) data over these. Just imagine looking for Gen 2x2 or Gen 2 SuperSpeed charging station.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by asteroidburger on Friday August 07, 2026 @11:02PM (#49218547)
No, we need to transfer a lot of power instead. So those with 800v cars need to be mindful to visit certain charger stations/types over other ones in order to get a fast charge, vs relying on the car to boost it from an older station.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by po1nt on Saturday August 08, 2026 @05:11AM (#49220092)
Just imagine you would visit such charging station and it would support the fast charge. But only the connector, not the cable.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by sokoloff on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:49AM (#49209632)
In a world following your proposed rules, we’d never get to 480Mbps USB-A, because we already had 4-wire 12Mbps USB-A ports with just D+/D- and power and creating 480Mbps USB-A from that would be “an astonishing design failure: different ports have different connectors for a reason” and not all 12Mbps capable USB-A cables would support the 480Mbps spec.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:14AM (#49209907)
> Can you imagine a what would have happened if the car charging infrastructure would have used your regular 120/230V plugs?

They largely do. I’m not sure I understand your point? The amount of current pulled by the car in an EV is dictated by the car (equivalent to the PD controller on USB-C) and the amount of current max is indicated by the EVSE (which, is sort of like an emarker). When you plug that EVSE into the wall, there is absolutely nothing telling it how much current it can pull.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by sokoloff on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:38AM (#49210218)
"absolutely nothing" is overly strong wording for a plug-in EVSE.

The standardization of the receptacles tells how much current is safe to pull. "This receptacle is 50A rated and can supply 40A continuous" is given by the 14-50 receptacle shape.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:12PM (#49212668)
But you can buy an EVSE capable of pulling 40 amps and plug it into a 20A rated receptacle. It will happily pull 40 amps until the breaker pops. Most EVSEs that are plug in have adapters to do explicitly this purpose.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by jauntywundrkind on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:53AM (#49209688)
Except usb-c will have a baseline level if working even with your very lightweight cheap flexible usb2 60w cable.

Adding connectors to obstruct functionality, to make each specific use physically incompatible with every other use, was hell. No thanks.

Usb-c rocks, it's flexibility is amazing, and anytime you need a serious business use, good cables are well labelled. This is just yet another HN lightning rod issue where all the very narrowly intolerant particular people come out in hordes, but it's just not really an issue. And everyone else is living much more happily.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by sokoloff on Friday August 07, 2026 @09:52AM (#49210414)
> anytime you need a serious business use, good cables are well labelled.

Unfortunately, many not-good cables are also labeled similarly as good cables (fraudulently).

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by eek2121 on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:05AM (#49210647)
It’s not hard to make a functional standard, the USB folks just don’t care, IMO. If they had simply worked on better naming, things would be much more clear.

(now they’d need to do something crazy like USB-C 40G PD60 as a name in order to fix things, unless the next version of USB is a clean break)

Now they’ve made a mess of things, and cables AND connectors are all over the place.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:16AM (#49210819)
How would better naming make things more clear when manufacturers don’t want to put labeling on cables, generally? Even if it was a USB-IF requirement, that doesn’t have any teeth. Ports tend to be decently well labeled, but you can only cram so much into these things.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by ProZsolt on Friday August 07, 2026 @04:34PM (#49215897)
We have standard labeling since 2021, the problem manufactures don't use it.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by itsamario on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:08AM (#49210692)
Now that EU made USBC a power standard I expect the 4k/8k/16k, 3.0/3.1/3.2, and 5/10/20gbps to be replaced with 60/120/240watts.

This way it's simpler to enforce a standard across the industries

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Kirby64 on Friday August 07, 2026 @10:17AM (#49210837)
Why would speed capability be replaced with power capability? They are orthogonal capabilities intentionally so you don’t have to overbuild cables in either direction if you don’t intend to.