News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by sologoub on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:08AM (#4916274)
This is so typical - a government agency screws up, so it blames the fact that it didn't have enough powers, and does another power grab:

"However, Mr. Abdulmutallab and his underwear did alter U.S. intelligence-gathering. A Senate investigation revealed that NCTC had received information about him but had failed to query other government databases about him. In a scathing finding, the Senate report said, "the NCTC was not organized adequately to fulfill its missions."

"This was not a failure to collect or share intelligence," said John Brennan, the president's chief counterterrorism adviser, at a White House press conference in January 2010. "It was a failure to connect and integrate and understand the intelligence we had.""

From what I'm reading here, this person would have been within the jurisdiction of the previous rules as a person connected with terror activities. The agency just failed to connect the dots. If I recall recall correctly, the guys own father had contacted US Embassy to tell them that his son is trying to get involved with terrorists...

The solution to this problem seems to be better data interconnection between agencies, in order to ensure that as much detail about identified threats is available. I don't see how have more data about a much broader set of citizens is going to help... if anything, it's going to make the identification process more complex.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by EliRivers on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:09PM (#4916686)
At risk of stating the obvious, the false positive rate will create a vast number of innocent citizens flagged for further investigation. This automated flagging will overwhelm the human investigators, creating a situation in which terrorists find it easier to hide and operate amongst the citizenry, with the added feature that innocent citizens swept up will become truculent and less likely to cooperate. Net result; the US government makes terrorism easier, at vast expense to the US taxpayer.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by jalanco on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:48AM (#4916535)
A couple of key paragraphs:

"Now, NCTC [National Counterterrorism Center] can copy entire government databases—flight records, casino-employee lists, the names of Americans hosting foreign-exchange students and many others. The agency has new authority to keep data about innocent U.S. citizens for up to five years, and to analyze it for suspicious patterns of behavior. Previously, both were prohibited. Data about Americans 'reasonably believed to constitute terrorism information' may be permanently retained.

"The changes also allow databases of U.S. civilian information to be given to foreign governments for analysis of their own. In effect, U.S. and foreign governments would be using the information to look for clues that people might commit future crimes."

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by csense on Thursday December 13, 2012 @04:09PM (#4918109)
> The changes also allow databases of U.S. civilian information to be given to foreign governments for analysis of their own.

What forces those foreign governments to comply with the safeguards of US law?

Especially if when they hand over the data, the feds say "do what you need to do to tell us what we need to know (wink wink)". It's nothing less than "extraordinary rendition" for data.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by suprgeek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:12PM (#4917108)
A very telling line in the Article - "The guidelines provide rigorous oversight to protect the information that we have, for authorized and narrow purposes," said Alexander Joel, Civil Liberties Protection Officer for the Office of the Director of National Intelligence"

A "guideline" is supposed to provide rigorous oversight...how many guidelines have you heard of that provide rigorous Anything? Basically the government wants to be able to Datamine every single database within their control for anything suspicious. Unfortunately the definition of "suspicious activity" can be elastic enough to be almost anything.

Occupy Wallstreet? - suspicious

Protest against Oil drilling - suspicious

Blog post criticizing NY police "stop & frisk" - suspicious

Criticize the Feds for overstepping on something - suspicious

Sad - we are sleep waking into the Total information awareness state. The terrorists attacks have worked - they have destroyed the very values that America was built on

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:18PM (#4917153)
Add to it that paying with cash is suspicious and should be reported immediately. http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/02/14/fbi-perfect-terro...
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dr_doom on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:43PM (#4917326)
If you are a regular “cash customer” of a restaurant, you get treated like a king.

Good inside move.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by epoxyhockey on Friday December 14, 2012 @03:49AM (#4920113)
If you pay cash anywhere, not only are you treated like a king, but you will get a nice discount due to the vendor not having to pay CC processing fees (at the least). I highly recommend that frugal HN'ers explore this phenomenon.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by mcantelon on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:53PM (#4916986)
No mention in this article (that I saw) that points out that this data is also used to find new candidates for the extrajudicial "kill list" using the "disposition matrix":

>the "disposition matrix" has been developed and will be overseen by the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC). One of its purposes is "to augment" the "separate but overlapping kill lists" maintained by the CIA and the Pentagon

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/oct/24/obama-te...

There's been a slow, steady consolidation of state power post-9/11, including the establishment of NORTHCOM: a command post for war in North America. It seems like they're worried about domestic insurgence rather than conventional terrorism.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by jamesmcn on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:06PM (#4916660)
If you haven't committed a crime how could you possibly need privacy, comrade?
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:22PM (#4916790)
You really do enjoy having lots of people watch your sex tapes, or know about your financial situation or about how you and your parents haven't been talking for so many years or knowing that your girlfriend/wife dated and slept with crowd of men before meeting you, huh?
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by jamesmcn on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:29PM (#4916831)
(psst: might want to have your sarcasm detector recalibrated, it appears to be giving erroneous readings)
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by mindcrime on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:53PM (#4919525)
(psst: text only communication is a really shitty way to convey sarcasm. Sarcasm on the Internet is fundamentally Broken)
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:52AM (#4916558)
Bin Laden won the war on terror. They're all scared now. Even China does not monitor its own citizens like that. Soon Chinese citizens will enjoy more freedom and privacy than western citizens.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:06PM (#4916661)
Sure. I mean, their local police are allowed to arrest people and send them to "Reeducation Through Labor" camps for 1-3 years without trial. But sure, the US, China, same thing.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by guelo on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:09PM (#4916687)
Are you saying the US does not detain people without charges for years at a time?
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:22PM (#4916784)
I'm saying that the local police in China can, on a whim, send you to a labor camp for 1-3 years, and that even after "reforms", the hearings that spring you from labor camps take longer than 1-3 years.

And I'm saying that the police in the US can't.

Equating civil liberties in the US with those of China make you, prima facie, a nutjob.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:48PM (#4916953)
Please reread the NDAA 2012 (keyword: indefinite detention) and dispense with the ad hominem attacks. If you can't make your point without calling someone a nutjob, maybe you don't have a point to be made...
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:53PM (#4916980)
Just citing the NDAA in this context is a tell that you haven't read it. The authorization to detain persons without trial doesn't come from the NDAA, it comes from the 2003 AUMF. The NDAA narrows the detention powers available to the US; the ACLU (rightly) is upset that it doesn't narrow those powers sufficiently.

And, obviously, the detention powers available to the US under the AUMF/NDAA are nothing like those available to any local Chinese constabulary.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:34PM (#4917265)
I have read it, and I submit the relevant text from section 1021 below.

Namely, the NDAA affirms the "authority of the Armed Forces of the United States to detain covered persons pursuant to the Authorization for Use of Military Force". A "covered person" is someone who has "planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored those responsible for those attacks" or who "was a part of or substantially supported al-Qaeda, the Taliban, or associated forces that are engaged in hostilities against the United States or its coalition partners, including any person who has committed a belligerent act or has directly supported such hostilities in aid of such enemy forces." But no trial needs to be held in order to make the aforementioned conclusions: "Detention under the law of war without trial until the end of the hostilities authorized by the Authorization for Use of Military Force."

So, our government can detain anybody it (who's that exactly?) deems is a "terrorist", without trial, until the end of "hostilities" (let me make a prediction: the "war on terror" isn't ending any time soon, hence "indefinite").

So, no, I am not making and will not make any comparisons between the United States and China. I am, however, backing up guelo's point that the US can legally "detain people without charges for years at a time", and very few people seem to care.

SECTION 1021

  Sec. 1021. Affirmation of authority of the Armed Forces of the
  United States to detain covered persons pursuant to the Authorization
  for Use of Military Force. 

  (a) IN GENERAL.—Congress affirms that the authority of the 
    President to use all necessary and appropriate force pursuant to 
    the Authorization for Use of Military Force (Public Law 107–40; 
    50 U.S.C. 1541 note) includes the authority for the Armed Forces 
    of the United States to detain covered persons (as defined in subsection
  (b)) pending disposition under the law of war.

  (b) COVERED PERSONS.—A covered person under this section 
  is any person as follows: 
    (1) A person who planned, authorized, committed, or aided 
      the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, 
      or harbored those responsible for those attacks. 
    (2) A person who was a part of or substantially supported 
      al-Qaeda, the Taliban, or associated forces that are engaged 
      in hostilities against the United States or its coalition partners, 
      including any person who has committed a belligerent act or 
      has directly supported such hostilities in aid of such enemy 
      forces.

  (c) DISPOSITION UNDER LAW OF WAR.—The disposition of a 
    person under the law of war as described in subsection (a) may 
    include the following: 
    (1) Detention under the law of war without trial until 
      the end of the hostilities authorized by the Authorization for 
      Use of Military Force. 
    (2) Trial under chapter 47A of title 10, United States 
      Code (as amended by the Military Commissions Act of 2009 
      (title XVIII of Public Law 111–84)). 
    (3) Transfer for trial by an alternative court or competent 
      tribunal having lawful jurisdiction. 
    (4) Transfer to the custody or control of the person’s country 
      of origin, any other foreign country, or any other foreign entity. 
  (d) CONSTRUCTION.—Nothing in this section is intended to limit 
    or expand the authority of the President or the scope of the 
    Authorization for Use of Military Force.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:56PM (#4917407)
The problem isn't the NDAA. It's Public Law 107-40, the original 2001 Al Qaeda AUMF. Here's the problematic language:

    (a) IN GENERAL.—That the President is authorized to use all necessary
    and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons
    he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist
    attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such
    organizations or persons, in order to prevent any future acts of
    international terrorism again the United States by such nations,
    organizations or persons
Compare to the 1991 AUMF for the first Gulf War:

    (a) AUTHORIZATION- The President is authorized, subject to subsection
    (b), to use United States Armed Forces pursuant to United Nations
    Security Council Resolution 678 (1990) in order to achieve
    implementation of Security Council Resolutions 660, 661, 662, 664,
    665, 666, 667, 669, 670, 674, and 677.
     
    (b) REQUIREMENT FOR DETERMINATION THAT USE OF MILITARY FORCE IS
    NECESSARY- Before exercising the authority granted in subsection (a),
    the President shall make available to the Speaker of the House of
    Representatives and the President pro tempore of the Senate his
    determination--
     
    (1) that the United States has used all appropriate diplomatic and
    other peaceful means to obtain compliance by Iraq with the United
    Nations Security Council resolutions cited in subsection (a); and
     
    (2) that those efforts have not been and would not be successful in
    obtaining such compliance.
Notice that the 2001 AUMF, which was written in a panic, authorizes arbitrary force with no mitigating effort required not only against nations but against "organizations" and "persons", and continues to authorize those efforts so long as they might prevent future acts of terrorism.

It is hard to get much worse than that. The NDAA doesn't make it worse; in fact, by putting pen to paper and outlining specific circumstances in which the US can use its military to detain people, it ostensibly makes it better (it is hard to imagine making the 2001 or 2003 AUMF better without repealing it and starting over, though).

The Alex Jones take on the NDAA would be that it's a huge executive overreach and a sign that the current administration favors an overt authorization of Latin American-style "disappearings" of suspected terrorists. Apart from the 2001-2003 context those febrile rants exclude, there is also the fact that the House and Senate GOP wanted the 2012 NDAA to expand the powers available to the executive to combat terrorism.

It is also possible to be disquieted by detention and due process provisions in a war powers act while simultaneously understanding the context in which a reasonable person could assert them. For example, without some provision for detaining US citizens abroad, how would you lawfully handle any armed conflict with the Taliban? There are more than 300MM Americans. Some of them will win the lottery, and others will in fact fly to Pakistan to train with militants, as has already happened repeatedly. US military forces will eventually encounter them in armed conflict. In every war, there is always going to some due process concern regarding the handling of possible US citizens taking up arms to fight alongside our opponents.

The Al Qaeda AUMF is ridiculously overbroad and needs to be fixed. But the NDAA, a utility bill that happens every year to fund the military, is not a re-ratification of that act, nor does it create a civil liberties regime in the US comparable to that of China.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:30PM (#4917592)
Thanks for the info about the AUMF. I'll definitely have to look into that further.

  Notice that the 2001 AUMF, which was written in a panic,
  authorizes arbitrary force with no mitigating effort
  required not only against nations but against
  "organizations" and "persons", and continues to authorize
  those efforts so long as they might prevent future acts of
  terrorism.

  It is hard to get much worse than that. The NDAA doesn't
  make it worse; in fact, by putting pen to paper and
  outlining specific circumstances in which the US can use
  its military to detain people, it ostensibly makes it
  better (it is hard to imagine making the 2001 or 2003
  AUMF better without repealing it and starting over,
  though).
Yea, that's definitely horrendous. That being said, the entire purpose of Section 1021 of the NDAA 2012 is to affirm those governmental powers. There's even a section which I cited which specifically states that the NDAA doesn't limit the President's powers at all: "(d) CONSTRUCTION.—Nothing in this section is intended to limit or expand the authority of the President or the scope of the Authorization for Use of Military Force." Which basically means "everything we just said about limits and expansions means jack squat when it comes to the president; (s)he can do whatever". So yea, the AUMF started this, and it was broad and allowed everything. The NDAA is still a problem because it continues it and doesn't actually limit anything when it comes to the President.

  The Alex Jones take on the NDAA would be that it's a huge
  executive overreach and a sign that the current
  administration favors an overt authorization of Latin
  American-style "disappearings" of suspected terrorists.
  Apart from the 2001-2003 context those febrile rants
  exclude, there is also the fact that the House and Senate
  GOP wanted the 2012 NDAA to expand the powers available
  to the executive to combat terrorism.
I don't think I mentioned Alex Jones. Also "huge executive overreach and a sign that the current administration" and "the House and Senate GOP wanted the 2012 NDAA to expand the powers available to the executive". Both of those are right :) Both parties are responsible for this. This is a bi-partisan effort haha.

  It is also possible to be disquieted by detention and due
  process provisions in a war powers act while
  simultaneously understanding the context in which a
  reasonable person could assert them. For example,
  without some provision for detaining US citizens abroad,
  how would you lawfully handle any armed conflict with
  the Taliban? There are more than 300MM Americans. Some
  of them will win the lottery, and others will in fact
  fly to Pakistan to train with militants, as has already
  happened repeatedly. US military forces will eventually
  encounter them in armed conflict. In every war, there
  is always going to some due process concern regarding
  the handling of possible US citizens taking up arms to
  fight alongside our opponents.
If a US citizen is engaging in a firefight with US armed forces, then yes, there's your proof they are "terrorists". If you can a US citizen in the act of building a bomb, then yes, there's your proof. However, if through the grape vine you gain "intelligence" that a certain US citizen is a "terrorist", by constitutional law you must provide that citizen a fair trial by a jury of their peers (i.e. not a military trial). If overseas, bring them back to the US. The AUMF generally and NDAA more specifically do away with that requirement (which is, in my opinion, one of the most fundamental aspects of american freedom).

  The Al Qaeda AUMF is ridiculously overbroad and needs to
  be fixed. But the NDAA, a utility bill that happens every
  year to fund the military, is not a re-ratification of
  that act, nor does it create a civil liberties regime
  in the US comparable to that of China.
If it's not a re-ratification, then why mention it? If the government doesn't need it, why put the language in there? I think it's important to keep in mind that few things are put into legal documentation without express purpose, especially at the level of government.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:46PM (#4917660)
I'm the one bringing up Alex Jones, as a way of being derisive about people who equate the US and China on the auspices that "the US has made policy mistakes and China has made policy mistakes so what's the difference?". I'm sorry that I accidentally implied that you, specifically, were regurgitating Infowars points.

You ask, in effect, if the administration already had the ability under its war powers to detain people, why create a new bill that re-affirms that power? The answer is political. The conservative GOP wanted to re-affirm those war powers that benefited the CIA, and at the same time some (but not all) liberal elements of the Democratic party wanted to clarify and rein in those powers. There was a fight, and then a compromise bill, which, reading between the lines, attempts to punt the thorniest parts of the debate to the Supreme Court while creating an immediate statutory authority for CIA and DOD to continue doing what they're already doing.

Yes, this is a clusterfuck.

The problem in the US is that we were hit with one of the most damaging, best organized terrorist attacks by a non-state actor during the least competent administration of the past 50 years. Congress panicked and granted the Bush administration a wish list of military powers, and we're spending the ensuing decades gradually cleaning up after the resulting mess.

That's a problem. But it's not a sign that the US is gradually turning into a dystopian hellscape.

I don't care, except for two things. First, when people bring up the NDAA, they set off a "someone's wrong on the Internet" sensor that, as a nerd, I am unable to suppress. Second, as much as Internet psuedo-activists do not want to hear this, the "NDAA" issue is in fact a corner case in US policy. Indefinite detention of political dissidents in China is not a corner case. It is a daily fact of life, as it is elsewhere in the world.

You can make millions of dollars spinning conspiracy theories about the evils of the government and big corporations in America, and the reality is, nobody really cares. Try doing that in Russia; see how long it takes for you or your coworkers to end up dead.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @03:02PM (#4917751)

  I'm the one bringing up Alex Jones, as a way of being
  derisive about people who equate the US and China on the
  auspices that "the US has made policy mistakes and China
  has made policy mistakes so what's the difference?". I'm
  sorry that I accidentally implied that you, specifically,
  were regurgitating Infowars points.
No problem. I just wanted to make it clear that I wasn't.

  Yes, this is a clusterfuck.
That's something we definitely agree on ;)

  That's a problem. But it's not a sign that the US is gradually
  turning into a dystopian hellscape.
At the risk of sounding crazy myself, I've seen too many recent videos of "peace officers" dragging peaceful protestors into the streets by their hair and group beating them with batons before handcuffing and arresting them, to believe that myself. But that's my opinion. And I really do wish that was the case.

  I don't care, except for two things. First, when people bring
  up the NDAA, they set off a "someone's wrong on the Internet"
  sensor that, as a nerd, I am unable to suppress. Second, as much
  as Internet psuedo-activists do not want to hear this, the "NDAA"
  issue is in fact a corner case in US policy. Indefinite detention
  of political dissidents in China is not a corner case. It is a daily
  fact of life, as it is elsewhere in the world.
I don't have any examples of the provisions outlined in the NDAA and documents prior being used, so I can't speak to that.

  You can make millions of dollars spinning conspiracy theories
  about the evils of the government and big corporations in America,
  and the reality is, nobody really cares. Try doing that in Russia;
  see how long it takes for you or your coworkers to end up dead.
"Try doing that in Russia; see how long it takes for you or your coworkers to end up dead." Let's be fair, you could make that same case for the death of Andrew Breitbart.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @03:56PM (#4918040)
Wait what? Breitbart died of a heart attack. He had a history of heart disease. He was also beloved of roughly half the US government. Russian activists with inconvenient positions and personal beliefs appear to routinely end up shot to death.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_R...

Anna Politkovskaya did not have a history of bullet disease.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @06:05PM (#4918638)
Yea I'm not saying Breitbart was murdered lol. I'm just saying, if we're going to talk about governments murdering inconvenient people, a case could be made for it and we shouldn't put it past our own government to do so.

In any case this is tertiary to the original point that the situation is a mess, regardless of whether the NDAA has anything to do with it.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by minimize_me on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:50PM (#4916962)
Sounds a lot like federal drug law enforcement coupled with mandatory minimums.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:32PM (#4917247)
So the rhetorical options you'd like to open up with this comment are, either:

(1) A rebuttal that supports drug enforcement and mandatory minimum sentences, or

(2) An agreement that drug enforcement in the US creates a civil liberties environment comparable to that of China, where a local bureaucrat can sentence you to 3 years of forced labor for making unfavorable comments.

Seems legit.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by smokeyj on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:52PM (#4916973)
> And I'm saying that the police in the US can't.

Until they sprinkle some crack on you. Take of the rose tinted glasses my friend.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:55PM (#4916997)
When did this place turn into Infowars.com?
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by smokeyj on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:12PM (#4917110)
I'm not trying to challenge your unwavering nationalism. Just pointing out that the constitution is dead and we're entering a police state :)
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:16PM (#4917139)
The sad thing is that actually reading primary sources and not buying into the Alex Jones take on any given policy question does in fact make me a turbonationalist right winger on HN. One can't even think about the issues; one must instead keep the game of conspiracy-theoretic telephone going.

Here's a clue: not believing that the evil "NDAA" bill creates a secret police force that disappears Americans off the streets doesn't make me a supporter of US counterterrorism policy.

If you don't want to hear mitigating/moderating sentiments about what the NDAA is, then don't say manifestly silly things about it, like that it creates a detention regime comparable to that of China. The 2001/2003/2012 AUMF/NDAA powers are not a good thing. Lots of things aren't good. That doesn't make them Hitler.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by jivatmanx on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:49PM (#4917355)
If this is truly a new precedent, a new lowering of the bar for freedom, than one can chart all of the legislation you list as data-points, and create a simple graph of freedom. That graph is negative. Expand that chart out, and eventually it does indeed reach Hitler.

Though perhaps it's more "Brave New World" than 1984. Color-Coded terror alerts and terrorists-as-wolves commercials seem to have gone out of style and replaced with more subtle phenomenon.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by smokeyj on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:54PM (#4917393)
> The sad thing is that actually reading primary sources and not buying into the Alex Jones take on any given policy question does in fact make me a turbonationalist right winger on HN.

Saying the US doesn't detain people without charges makes you a turbonationalist right winger. And ignorant of history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_American_internment

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:58PM (#4917422)
This comment is about as insightful as one saying that anyone who serves in the German armed forces in 2012 must be a Nazi sympathist.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by smokeyj on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:07PM (#4917473)
You don't have to find history insightful. You're still wrong. If you don't think there's people in gitmo with no charges, you're blinded by your fairy-tail fantasy.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:13PM (#4916727)
Same thing for Barry's NDAA. Except there's no chance to be reeducated. The only option is to be waterboarded. The only salvation for the United States is the total bankruptcy of their own government.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:20PM (#4916776)
The odds that you've read the text of the NDAA based on this comment: zero.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tokenadult on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:09PM (#4916680)
Soon Chinese citizens will enjoy more freedom and privacy than western citizens.

Only if the one-party rule of Communist Party of China (CPC) ceases. Right now, under a policy introduced by that party as it consolidated power, there is not even freedom to change residence addresses in China.

http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-china-hukou-20121212,0...

And Chinese citizens enjoying "more freedom and privacy than western citizens" is not likely even if the CPC allows free and fair elections, in the near term. But I wish the common people of China well in gaining more freedom, as their cousins in Taiwan have done over the last thirty years.

中共下台.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:34PM (#4916869)
Oddly enough I learned last week that there can be other political parties in china. It's just that the Communist Party is enormous by comparison. http://shanghaiist.com/2012/12/05/not_at_all_pointless_zhigo...
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by grecy on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:13PM (#4916717)
> Soon Chinese citizens will enjoy more freedom and privacy than western citizens.

Soon Chinese citizens will enjoy more freedom and privacy than AMERICAN citizens.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:19PM (#4916768)
Didn't you read anything about how the British are imitating the Americans and installing microphones and cameras in EVERY lamp post? Google around.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by danielweber on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:22PM (#4916791)
The British have been a surveillance society with cameras everywhere, but it's nothing they copied from America.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by mikegioia on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:01PM (#4916624)

  Now, NCTC can copy entire government databases—flight records, casino-employee lists, the names of Americans hosting foreign-exchange students and many others. 
You don't think China has this info?
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:09PM (#4916684)
Chinese don't care what their own citizens do as long as they don't blow things up (or out of proportion).

People should note that while in the Western world technology has increased the powers of the wealthy minority, in the east it's the people that have learned to harness it. The Chinese "human flesh search" is notorious for bringing corrupt officials to justice and to find lost children. In the west it's just iSheep staring blankly into their shiny iDevices and not giving a rat's ass about anything.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:26PM (#4916814)
Some people just can't stand the truth and downvote...
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by dragonbonheur on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:03PM (#4917062)
Apparently writing iSheep anywhere on Hacker News is really offensive...

COME ON! KILL THAT KARMA! :D

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by pge on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:50PM (#4917364)
I'm guessing they would prefer to be referenced as a "Counterterrorism Agency" rather than a "Terrorism Agency"...