News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:46PM (#4917660)
I'm the one bringing up Alex Jones, as a way of being derisive about people who equate the US and China on the auspices that "the US has made policy mistakes and China has made policy mistakes so what's the difference?". I'm sorry that I accidentally implied that you, specifically, were regurgitating Infowars points.

You ask, in effect, if the administration already had the ability under its war powers to detain people, why create a new bill that re-affirms that power? The answer is political. The conservative GOP wanted to re-affirm those war powers that benefited the CIA, and at the same time some (but not all) liberal elements of the Democratic party wanted to clarify and rein in those powers. There was a fight, and then a compromise bill, which, reading between the lines, attempts to punt the thorniest parts of the debate to the Supreme Court while creating an immediate statutory authority for CIA and DOD to continue doing what they're already doing.

Yes, this is a clusterfuck.

The problem in the US is that we were hit with one of the most damaging, best organized terrorist attacks by a non-state actor during the least competent administration of the past 50 years. Congress panicked and granted the Bush administration a wish list of military powers, and we're spending the ensuing decades gradually cleaning up after the resulting mess.

That's a problem. But it's not a sign that the US is gradually turning into a dystopian hellscape.

I don't care, except for two things. First, when people bring up the NDAA, they set off a "someone's wrong on the Internet" sensor that, as a nerd, I am unable to suppress. Second, as much as Internet psuedo-activists do not want to hear this, the "NDAA" issue is in fact a corner case in US policy. Indefinite detention of political dissidents in China is not a corner case. It is a daily fact of life, as it is elsewhere in the world.

You can make millions of dollars spinning conspiracy theories about the evils of the government and big corporations in America, and the reality is, nobody really cares. Try doing that in Russia; see how long it takes for you or your coworkers to end up dead.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @03:02PM (#4917751)

  I'm the one bringing up Alex Jones, as a way of being
  derisive about people who equate the US and China on the
  auspices that "the US has made policy mistakes and China
  has made policy mistakes so what's the difference?". I'm
  sorry that I accidentally implied that you, specifically,
  were regurgitating Infowars points.
No problem. I just wanted to make it clear that I wasn't.

  Yes, this is a clusterfuck.
That's something we definitely agree on ;)

  That's a problem. But it's not a sign that the US is gradually
  turning into a dystopian hellscape.
At the risk of sounding crazy myself, I've seen too many recent videos of "peace officers" dragging peaceful protestors into the streets by their hair and group beating them with batons before handcuffing and arresting them, to believe that myself. But that's my opinion. And I really do wish that was the case.

  I don't care, except for two things. First, when people bring
  up the NDAA, they set off a "someone's wrong on the Internet"
  sensor that, as a nerd, I am unable to suppress. Second, as much
  as Internet psuedo-activists do not want to hear this, the "NDAA"
  issue is in fact a corner case in US policy. Indefinite detention
  of political dissidents in China is not a corner case. It is a daily
  fact of life, as it is elsewhere in the world.
I don't have any examples of the provisions outlined in the NDAA and documents prior being used, so I can't speak to that.

  You can make millions of dollars spinning conspiracy theories
  about the evils of the government and big corporations in America,
  and the reality is, nobody really cares. Try doing that in Russia;
  see how long it takes for you or your coworkers to end up dead.
"Try doing that in Russia; see how long it takes for you or your coworkers to end up dead." Let's be fair, you could make that same case for the death of Andrew Breitbart.
Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by tptacek on Thursday December 13, 2012 @03:56PM (#4918040)
Wait what? Breitbart died of a heart attack. He had a history of heart disease. He was also beloved of roughly half the US government. Russian activists with inconvenient positions and personal beliefs appear to routinely end up shot to death.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_in_R...

Anna Politkovskaya did not have a history of bullet disease.

Re:U.S. Terrorism Agency to Tap a Vast Database of Citizens by willurd on Thursday December 13, 2012 @06:05PM (#4918638)
Yea I'm not saying Breitbart was murdered lol. I'm just saying, if we're going to talk about governments murdering inconvenient people, a case could be made for it and we shouldn't put it past our own government to do so.

In any case this is tertiary to the original point that the situation is a mess, regardless of whether the NDAA has anything to do with it.