News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by alt227 on Sunday August 02, 2026 @11:50AM (#49145648)
The point is when you go to Wikipedia and they are on a funding drive with their very prominent ads for donation requests, they dont mention any of this. They make it sound like wikipedia is very much at risk of dying due to lack of funds when in reality they are looking for more funding for programmes like this, which is where a lot of the mistrust and 'deceptive advertising' opinions come from.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @12:17PM (#49145870)
They could tell us which programs.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by alt227 on Sunday August 02, 2026 @12:29PM (#49145959)
They could, but if their donation ads said for example 'please help us to take more photos of live events' instead of 'we need your help to keep wikipedia alive' then they would not get half the donations they do currently, which is the point.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by inigyou on Sunday August 02, 2026 @12:37PM (#49146016)
I agree, that you can lie to people to make more money. That's called fraud.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by Sabinus on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:43PM (#49149935)
I wonder how well they would go if you could target your donation. Humble bundle did this and I appreciated it.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by bawolff on Monday August 03, 2026 @04:18PM (#49160886)
If the ads only mentioned a program that gets less than 1% of the budget, that would also be pretty deceptive
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by joshspankit on Sunday August 02, 2026 @01:17PM (#49146353)
Honestly, I’ve never donated bc “keeping Wikipedia up” could be a solved problem by now. Not just cheaper processing and bandwidth costs, but p2p hosting, etc. Every time I see that ad, I say to myself “it should not be that expensive”.

Now, if they had said “We need 200k to send CC photographers to the Olympics”, count me in. That sounds bigger and way more interesting!

Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by ReactiveJelly on Sunday August 02, 2026 @01:32PM (#49146481)
I don't even use Wikipedia anymore, I use the free online P2P encyclopedia. It's called
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by Gander5739 on Monday August 03, 2026 @05:42AM (#49153452)
Hosting isn't the expensive part, maintaining mediawiki is. For example, unifying the parser for the markup language: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Parsoid/Parser_Unification/en
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by account42 on Monday August 03, 2026 @06:41AM (#49153923)
Maintaining a shitty PHP website isn't that expensive either.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by bawolff on Monday August 03, 2026 @04:17PM (#49160866)
Depends on how you define "hosting". CapEx costs for buying the servers is a non trivial expense (note: in accounting statements this isn't considered part of internet hosting). Not as much as software, but still expensive.
Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by bawolff on Monday August 03, 2026 @04:13PM (#49160832)
P2P hosting doesn't really work in reality, especially for websites that change regularly and require quick propagation of those changes. Its not just Wikipedia. Name a high traffic site that actually uses p2p hosting. I'll wait.

Bandwidth is also the sort of thing that gets way cheaper at scale than most people expect. When you are big enough there comes a point where the telecom companies want to connect to you because all their users want to access your website. It wouldn't surprise me if a lot (not all) of Wikimedia's bandwidth is actually free.

Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by joshspankit on Monday August 03, 2026 @07:38PM (#49162749)
Actually, I think your argument is almost entirely about P2P tech inspired by BitTorrent. We’ve had good be the enemy of great here.

No, no high-traffic sites actually uses P2P hosting but that doesn’t mean we’re not at a point where they can. In fact, I’d say the biggest impediment to P2P sites in 2026 is the absolute unit that is advertiser data. We have P2P databases, and round trip on the earth is ~300ms (aka “quick propagation” can be seconds which is more that enough for 98%). We have VPS and serverless. We also have content addressing and symmetric cert verification, but when a site’s “traffic” is P2P you lose visibility on most of it. And can you imagine the nonsense of advertisers adding client side tracking data to the public db so that they can query it? Woof.

Re:Wikimedia Foundation refuses union recognition, hires uni... by bawolff on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @01:09PM (#49171777)
> No, no high-traffic sites actually uses P2P hosting but that doesn’t mean we’re not at a point where they can.

Even if true, being the first to do anything is usually an expensive proposition.

> We have P2P databases, and round trip on the earth is ~300ms (aka “quick propagation” can be seconds which is more that enough for 98%)

I dont know how you are defining "p2p database" or which product you mean, but in general distributed p2p solutions where you do not trust the peers cannot propagate information in a single round-trip, or anything even remotely close to that.

> We have VPS and serverless

Neither of these are p2p technologies. They are also a terrible fit for something like Wikipedia.

> We also have content addressing

Sure, but that is like 1% of a solution

> symmetric cert verification

Do you mean mutual TLS? That is indeed a technology that exists, but i dont know how its relavent.

> And can you imagine the nonsense of advertisers adding client side tracking data to the public db so that they can query it?

Which kind of brings up the other flaw with p2p - privacy.

It obviously depends on what technology is chosen, but p2p often has poor privacy properties. Think media companies sending threatening notices to people who download movies. People often look up private things on Wikipedia. Think sexual health topics. Do we really want malicious people to be able to track that?