News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:09PM (#4913012)
Given the option to legally cut their lower-tier employees' wages to zero tomorrow, I wonder how many companies would do so, and still expect those people to show up for work?

When horses' labor became uneconomic, we just turned them to glue. What do we do with people?

Force companies to pay a living wage.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by scarmig on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:22PM (#4913075)
Trust me: I believe that people deserve an honest living. I believe people have the right to housing, warmth, good food, healthcare, and the ability to have plenty of autonomy and free time to do what they love and achieve self-fulfillment. I am not averse to governments passing laws to achieve this.

But all organizations have a choice: I can either pay a worker $X or replace labor with capital for $Y, within the budgetary constraint $Z. If $Y < $X, they'll do that, or be outcompeted by organizations which do choose to do that. (If $Y and $X are both >$Z, well, that's when the organization closes up shop.)

That's a real choice, and it's not easily legislated into oblivion.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by Someone on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:06PM (#4913281)
"That's a real choice, and it's not easily legislated into oblivion."

It might kill the economy or grow a black market, but it is easily legislated into oblivion. The thing is: legislation can decrease $X and/or increase $Y. Put a $1000 a barrel tax on oil, and proportionally on other sources of energy, and abolish income taxes and you will find that people are willing to pay close to $Z for manual labour.

Yes, that is exaggeration, but any increase of the cost of capital relative to that of manual labour will have some effect. It will either put companies out of business or it will create manual labour jobs.

Problem is that this requires international cooperation or unilateral restrictions on trade (import bans or high import tariffs)

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by dllthomas on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:02PM (#4913264)
It's easily legislated into oblivion for any particular instance - just ban the automated looms (or whatever else is replacing workers), or require that the companies still employ people to watch the capital do its thing (some unions have gone this route, at various points). It's not, however, easily solved well - both the above are things I'd object to; particularly the latter, where I feel like we're removing not adding dignity.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:40PM (#4913175)
That's a real choice, and it's not easily legislated into oblivion.

I understand that, and I don't mean to demonize business by any means. A minimum wage might well stifle competition somewhat, but I think the lack of one would do more harm than good. Given the choice between harm to business and harm to people, I'll choose to harm business.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by markshead on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:59PM (#4913525)
Lets say you run a small movie theater. You hire a 5 people for $5 per hour to sell tickets. Many of these are teenagers and other people who have schedules that can't work a normal job. The government comes in and says minimum wage needs to be $10 per hour. After doing the math, you decide that financially you can't afford to keep all those people on at $5 per hour. So you keep one to help run the front of the theater and put in a machine where people can swipe their credit cards to buy tickets.

Who was harmed? The business or the people?

The $5 per hour may not seem like much, but to the teenager it is $5 per hour, plus a chance to learn to manage their own money, a chance to learn people skills, a chance to learn work ethic, a chance to have a good reference from you for later jobs, etc.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:14PM (#4913581)
I understand your point, and I admit it's complex. But what happens when the government says I can pay whatever I want and I tell those people they're now making $2 an hour because nobody's buying the six dollar popcorn anymore? A minimum wage may have its downside but at least with it, people have an expectation of how little they can expect to make and plan accordingly. It provides a measure of stability at least.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by markshead on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:48PM (#4913685)
To me the ability to find a job is a more important measurement of stability than the government saying that no job worth less than X and hour can be had.

But back to your question about what happens when employers lower their wages to $2 per hour, they would probably lose all of their employees and have to raise wages if they want workers. Believe it or not, wages do correspond in some way to the amount of benefit an employee brings to a company.

Lets say you want to hire someone to clean your house. How much would you have to pay in order to attract someone with enough skill to do the job? You couldn't just say you'll pay $0.50 per hour and magically get people to clean your house at that rate. There might be some people you'd attract for $5 per hour. As the price goes up, so does the pool of people you could pull from. However, above a certain price, it isn't worth it for you to pay someone else to do it. You might do it yourself or just live with it being dirty.

If having your house cleaned is worth only $5 per hour to you and someone is willing to do house cleaning for $5 per hour should you be allowed to hire them? They probably aren't going to be willing to work for $5 per hour if they can make $10 per hour somewhere else. Does it make sense for the government to say, "You can't hire this person unless the value they provide is greater than $7.25 per hour"? I don't feel that benefits you or the person who you want to pay. I don't feel it benefits society as a whole because I think we benefit by having money flowing through more hands not fewer. Minimum wage says that transactions below a certain hourly rate are not allowed, so it prevents money from flowing through some of the hands that might get it otherwise.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by chii on Thursday December 13, 2012 @09:30PM (#4919305)
the danger you run into tho, is that the whole neighbourhood conspires (whether deliberately or not) to fix the price at $2. Price fixing like this completely favours the employer, and they can do it if they have the knowledge that the employee can't possibly find employment elsewhere.

The least worst situation, in my opinion, is the minimum wage, and the only cost is that it has an overhead on society (in the form of benefit pay outs for jobs that got destroyed by the minimum wage).

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by jlgreco on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:50PM (#4913221)
Do the people actually benefit in that situation? When a business closes up shop, do other businesses naturally expand their labor force in a linear manner to provide new jobs for the ones that were lost? Ideally the competing businesses will easily expand of course, since they have less competition after their competitor dropped out, but is that expansion linear?

I suppose for some types of jobs it may be. If a coffee shop closes, and it's competitor opens another branch to soak up the extra demand, the additional coffee shop will probably use approximately the same number of employees as the old one fired. But can the same be said of, say, factories? What if the second factory, while filling the same demand as the first, was more successful because it used more effective automation?

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:24PM (#4913364)
That is a fair point. But what's the benefit in lower wages across the board, to the workers making them and to the economy?

Perhaps the answer (at least in the US) would be to reduce the cost of reeducation to facilitate transition, and socialize healthcare? Lower wages might not be so bad where healthcare and education don't represent potential lifetime burdens for people. But then the tax burden for that would fall disproportionately on the poor wouldn't it? And also, there might just not be jobs at all to replace the ones lost.

I don't know.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by jlgreco on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:43PM (#4913446)
Free education and healthcare definitely seem like good first steps to improving the situation to me. Letting the prospective workers be as smart and as healthy as they care to make themselves seems to have no obvious downsides to me. With any luck that would create an expanded middle class that could be taxed to pay for it.

The trend of people squandering their education and ending up in low paying jobs anyway disturbs me, but I think that could be solved by offering only majors that are in demand for free. Free STEM and medical sciences would be my initial suggestion, but I would want to see any decision like that backed up with some solid data (perhaps the data would reveal my concern is unfounded).

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by gwright on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:33PM (#4913135)
> Force companies to pay a living wage.

So what is a living wage for a teenager living at home? What is a living wage for a college student going to school full time but still supported by their parents? What is a living wage for a retired grandparent that wants to 'stay young'? How about for a spouse who just wants to be out of the house because the other member of the marriage brings home sufficient disposable income?

The notion that there is a single administratively selectable price point that is the 'minimum' wage for any and all job situations is a fallacy.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by scarmig on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:39PM (#4913168)
Some countries--Germany from what I understand, for instance--have sector and job class-specific minimum wages, which seems so eminently sane that it's impossible in the USA.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by scarmig on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:13PM (#4913313)
No direct statutory universal minimum wage. But sector-by-sector minimum wages are set by collective bargaining agreements. In Germany in particular, 70% of the labor force are covered by them.

I admit to not knowing the full details of how it works in Germany--not many good sources on the Internet immediately apparent, so I'd be plenty eager to hear if I'm misunderstanding how it works.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by bmmayer1 on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:03PM (#4913270)
There is no minimum wage in Germany.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by lostlogin on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:15PM (#4913319)
Could you expand on that please? Surely there is some kind of protection against 20 hour shifts for $20? How are workers protected?
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by bmmayer1 on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:23PM (#4913610)
Many industries have strong union presences that negotiate wages. But there is only a statutory minimum wage for 5-6 different jobs--painters, mailmen, etc. But in general, the best protection against low wages is the high mobility that low wage jobs offer.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by markshead on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:49PM (#4913477)
>Force companies to pay a living wage.

Who determines what a "living wage" is? Does it include having cable? Internet? A car?

But beyond that, why do you want to put up any barriers to what jobs companies can hire workers for? Lets say you own a company that employees 20 people and it sits on one acre of land. You need to get someone to mow the grass. You can hire company to come in for $80 per week to mow for you. They have big expensive lawnmowers and can do it very quickly. Or you can hire Joe to mow it using an older push mower you have. Joe isn't super fast and it will take him 10 hours. So you decide the value is $8 per hour in order to be on par with the company that will do it.

I wouldn't want the government to come in and make laws that make it better for you to hire the big company than Joe. I wouldn't want them to make it harder for you to justify taking a chance on hiring Joe and giving him a shot at a job just because someone doesn't think that $8 per hour is a living wage.

If Joe works for you for a year and has good track record, who knows. Maybe he will prove dependable enough that you can find other things for him to do. Maybe some of those things will be worth paying him more. Or maybe he can get a higher paying job working for the big lawn-mowing company based on his track record with you.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by chii on Thursday December 13, 2012 @09:50PM (#4919355)
The situation is more complex that that, because the mowing company uses a great big machine, and they constantly try to improve it. Say it now only takes $40 to mow instead of $80 due to efficiency increases and whatnots.

Do you now fire joe and hire the mowing company? or do you instead choose to pay hin $4 an hour? Ovbiously joe can't increase his speed of mowing beyond a certain limit - he is human after all.

The real underlying question is - if the value that joe provides can be instead provided via a cheaper source, then the business _should_ use that cheaper source, joe's life shouldnt and won't come into consideration. This method of thinking seems incompatible with the concepts of compassion and empathy, but it seems this is the way the real world works...

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by natrius on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:40PM (#4913176)
You can force a living wage, but you can't force companies to hire people at that wage. I mean, you can, but most people would find that pretty extreme.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by parsnips on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:33PM (#4913136)
Let them eat cake!
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by jussij on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @11:56PM (#4914272)
+1 Those that don't learn from history are destined to repeat it
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by lhnn on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:17PM (#4913061)
So, when a person's job becomes outdone by technology or automation, we should force companies to pay them more?

?

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:29PM (#4913113)
Companies shouldn't be able to set wages at an arbitrary low. Because then companies could simply set them as low as possible, without any regard to the standard of living for the employees making those wages.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by benaiah on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:42PM (#4913183)
But then any company willing to pay a decent price would instantly have their pick of anyone in the workforce.

It's called supply and demand. If there's no demand for cheap laborers, the answer is not to make them more expensive to hire, or to force companies to pay them a minimum. That just exacerbates the problem - now they can't even work for wages they might be able to be worth. It's very difficult to get better at a job unless you're either working at it or have the resources to do it in your free time. Someone who can't get a minimum wage job probably doesn't have the resources to learn the skills to move up.

I can personally attest that it's not just teenagers trying to find minimum wage jobs. I am a teenager, and I while I was looking for a summer job (I'm now employed as a software consultant) I was regularly (i.e., every single time) competing with people in their 20s or even, in some cases, older than that, who were simply unable to find work elsewhere.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by EricDeb on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:10AM (#4914520)
A minimum wage affords unskilled workers some amount of time to learn new skills or improve their lot in life. An unskilled worker who has to work 18 hours a day at $2 an hour to make ends meet will never be able to learn new skills and claw their way out of that hole. It's the same with unemployment benefits - it affords citizens time to learn new skills without worrying about what they will eat that night.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by chii on Thursday December 13, 2012 @09:37PM (#4919321)
perhaps unemployment benefits should give food and other basic necessities in the form of vouchers, and force the benefit taker to take (gov't provided) classes that will reskill them.

This way, they can either look for a real job to earn cash, instead of living on "vouchers/food tickets", or have to take classes to reskill/up-skill. They won't be battling for their next meal, but they also can't have leasure time.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by wwwtyro on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:16PM (#4913324)
Hmm. I'm not following the logic, there. If that were true, wouldn't every company have their wages set to the minimum wage right now?
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:03PM (#4913536)
I will admit I can't argue against that.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by markshead on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:24PM (#4913615)
> Companies shouldn't be able to set wages at an arbitrary low.

Why not? You seem to think that there is only one big company setting wages for everyone. If company X needs good workers and is only willing to pay $5 per hour, but company Y is willing to pay $12 per hour, company X is not going to get the good workers. If they want better workers they will have to raise their wages.

> without any regard to the standard of living for the employees making those wages.

The clients who pay me do so without any regard to my standard of living. They pay me with regard to the value I provide. If you are suggesting that low skill employees need to be paid based on something other than the value they provide then you are suggesting that they be given charity rather than wages.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by EricDeb on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:04AM (#4914498)
Absolutely they should be given charity, and wages not solely determined by value provided. The American economy (and world economy to some degree) is evolving in a way that eventually only high-skilled workers will be needed, as most unskilled work will be fully automated. This continues to raise the bar on citizens for even entry-level positions.

10 years ago a college degree in business or communications was enough to land a salaried-job. Now, to obtain a well-paying job straight out of college either a STEM degree or graduate work is usually required. It is extreme to suggest that citizens either acquire a high-level of education (which many simply cannot complete) or perform work for $2 an hour.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by chii on Thursday December 13, 2012 @09:40PM (#4919333)
> It is extreme to suggest that citizens either acquire a high-level of education (which many simply cannot complete)

why is that a wrong ideal to move towards to? I agree that current education is poor, but thats an implementation problem. The idea that every citizen should be highly educated is a good one, and that in the future, in order to provide value (which is rewarded in the form of money), you can't just labour.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by baddox on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:41PM (#4913435)
Then I suppose you would consider it stupid and irrational for any company to pay more than minimum wage.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:54PM (#4913495)
If you're meaning to reply to me, then no. I don't even see how you can draw that inference.

I'm only suggesting that a minimum wage is necessary, because there is a cost of living in a modern society. Money pays for shelter. Money pays for healthcare. Money pays for education and food. And unless you're in a socialist system, that money comes from wages. So a standard should be met. Especially in cases where a corporation would otherwise consider someone's labor to be essentially worthless.

And yes, perhaps if that standard itself were fair (assuming it's currently unfair), then in some places and in some jobs it might be less than whatever the current minimum wage is, where the minimum wage exists. Elsewhere it might be higher. I don't know, and I'll readily admit I might be bringing a checkers set to a chess match when discussing economics on this forum but I honestly believe it should be something.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by orangecat on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:15AM (#4914338)
there is a cost of living in a modern society. Money pays for shelter. Money pays for healthcare. Money pays for education and food.

That's a good argument for a guaranteed minimum income. It's a bad argument for a minimum wage laws, because at least sometimes they result in people earning zero instead of low wages.

And unless you're in a socialist system, that money comes from wages.

We're already in a partly socialist system. Minimum wage laws are a convoluted and inefficient form of welfare; it's better to just directly give money to poor people, and then avoid doing anything that interferes with their ability to increase their income.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by baddox on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:28AM (#4914745)
You seem to imply that unrestricted companies in a capitalist society would obviously set wages lower than current minimum wage laws require, but that model has no explaining power for the huge portion of jobs which already pay more than minimum wage.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by icebraining on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:23PM (#4913612)
The question is, how much shelter, healthcare or food can you pay when your job is replaced by a machine or an offshore worker because your wage is now too high (relatively to the alternative) to be worthwhile keeping you employed?
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:48PM (#4913686)
Would those companies necessarily choose not to outsource or automate those jobs if they had the option to do so, without a minimum wage requirement?

If the standard of living is low enough that, taking the same wages as an outsourced worker, someone doing that job could still survive, you might have an argument against the minimum wage standard there.

Otherwise, if only option to retain local employment is to pay what those outsourced workers are making, or less, in a market where more than that means living hand to mouth, then it's a distinction without a difference to me.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by robryan on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @06:25PM (#4913100)
Ideally provide them with a better safety net and the means for which to develop skills which would give then a value over the minimum wage.