It might kill the economy or grow a black market, but it is easily legislated into oblivion. The thing is: legislation can decrease $X and/or increase $Y. Put a $1000 a barrel tax on oil, and proportionally on other sources of energy, and abolish income taxes and you will find that people are willing to pay close to $Z for manual labour.
Yes, that is exaggeration, but any increase of the cost of capital relative to that of manual labour will have some effect. It will either put companies out of business or it will create manual labour jobs.
Problem is that this requires international cooperation or unilateral restrictions on trade (import bans or high import tariffs)
I understand that, and I don't mean to demonize business by any means. A minimum wage might well stifle competition somewhat, but I think the lack of one would do more harm than good. Given the choice between harm to business and harm to people, I'll choose to harm business.
Who was harmed? The business or the people?
The $5 per hour may not seem like much, but to the teenager it is $5 per hour, plus a chance to learn to manage their own money, a chance to learn people skills, a chance to learn work ethic, a chance to have a good reference from you for later jobs, etc.
But back to your question about what happens when employers lower their wages to $2 per hour, they would probably lose all of their employees and have to raise wages if they want workers. Believe it or not, wages do correspond in some way to the amount of benefit an employee brings to a company.
Lets say you want to hire someone to clean your house. How much would you have to pay in order to attract someone with enough skill to do the job? You couldn't just say you'll pay $0.50 per hour and magically get people to clean your house at that rate. There might be some people you'd attract for $5 per hour. As the price goes up, so does the pool of people you could pull from. However, above a certain price, it isn't worth it for you to pay someone else to do it. You might do it yourself or just live with it being dirty.
If having your house cleaned is worth only $5 per hour to you and someone is willing to do house cleaning for $5 per hour should you be allowed to hire them? They probably aren't going to be willing to work for $5 per hour if they can make $10 per hour somewhere else. Does it make sense for the government to say, "You can't hire this person unless the value they provide is greater than $7.25 per hour"? I don't feel that benefits you or the person who you want to pay. I don't feel it benefits society as a whole because I think we benefit by having money flowing through more hands not fewer. Minimum wage says that transactions below a certain hourly rate are not allowed, so it prevents money from flowing through some of the hands that might get it otherwise.
The least worst situation, in my opinion, is the minimum wage, and the only cost is that it has an overhead on society (in the form of benefit pay outs for jobs that got destroyed by the minimum wage).
I suppose for some types of jobs it may be. If a coffee shop closes, and it's competitor opens another branch to soak up the extra demand, the additional coffee shop will probably use approximately the same number of employees as the old one fired. But can the same be said of, say, factories? What if the second factory, while filling the same demand as the first, was more successful because it used more effective automation?
Perhaps the answer (at least in the US) would be to reduce the cost of reeducation to facilitate transition, and socialize healthcare? Lower wages might not be so bad where healthcare and education don't represent potential lifetime burdens for people. But then the tax burden for that would fall disproportionately on the poor wouldn't it? And also, there might just not be jobs at all to replace the ones lost.
I don't know.
The trend of people squandering their education and ending up in low paying jobs anyway disturbs me, but I think that could be solved by offering only majors that are in demand for free. Free STEM and medical sciences would be my initial suggestion, but I would want to see any decision like that backed up with some solid data (perhaps the data would reveal my concern is unfounded).
But all organizations have a choice: I can either pay a worker $X or replace labor with capital for $Y, within the budgetary constraint $Z. If $Y < $X, they'll do that, or be outcompeted by organizations which do choose to do that. (If $Y and $X are both >$Z, well, that's when the organization closes up shop.)
That's a real choice, and it's not easily legislated into oblivion.