News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @07:54PM (#4913495)
If you're meaning to reply to me, then no. I don't even see how you can draw that inference.

I'm only suggesting that a minimum wage is necessary, because there is a cost of living in a modern society. Money pays for shelter. Money pays for healthcare. Money pays for education and food. And unless you're in a socialist system, that money comes from wages. So a standard should be met. Especially in cases where a corporation would otherwise consider someone's labor to be essentially worthless.

And yes, perhaps if that standard itself were fair (assuming it's currently unfair), then in some places and in some jobs it might be less than whatever the current minimum wage is, where the minimum wage exists. Elsewhere it might be higher. I don't know, and I'll readily admit I might be bringing a checkers set to a chess match when discussing economics on this forum but I honestly believe it should be something.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by orangecat on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:15AM (#4914338)
there is a cost of living in a modern society. Money pays for shelter. Money pays for healthcare. Money pays for education and food.

That's a good argument for a guaranteed minimum income. It's a bad argument for a minimum wage laws, because at least sometimes they result in people earning zero instead of low wages.

And unless you're in a socialist system, that money comes from wages.

We're already in a partly socialist system. Minimum wage laws are a convoluted and inefficient form of welfare; it's better to just directly give money to poor people, and then avoid doing anything that interferes with their ability to increase their income.

Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by baddox on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:28AM (#4914745)
You seem to imply that unrestricted companies in a capitalist society would obviously set wages lower than current minimum wage laws require, but that model has no explaining power for the huge portion of jobs which already pay more than minimum wage.
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by icebraining on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:23PM (#4913612)
The question is, how much shelter, healthcare or food can you pay when your job is replaced by a machine or an offshore worker because your wage is now too high (relatively to the alternative) to be worthwhile keeping you employed?
Re:The Minimum Wage Machine by krapp on Wednesday December 12, 2012 @08:48PM (#4913686)
Would those companies necessarily choose not to outsource or automate those jobs if they had the option to do so, without a minimum wage requirement?

If the standard of living is low enough that, taking the same wages as an outsourced worker, someone doing that job could still survive, you might have an argument against the minimum wage standard there.

Otherwise, if only option to retain local employment is to pay what those outsourced workers are making, or less, in a market where more than that means living hand to mouth, then it's a distinction without a difference to me.