Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by throwaway27448 on Friday July 24, 2026 @02:33AM
(#49031886)
I see you didn't grow up cracking apps and games, this is quite easy with a hex editor and bintools. Well, until codesigning came along, but that doesn't seem relevant to this analogy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by kennywinker on Friday July 24, 2026 @03:21AM
(#49032219)
Cracking games is and was illegal. Fine tuning an open weight model isn’t. Well, not yet anyway
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by throwaway27448 on Friday July 24, 2026 @03:32AM
(#49032296)
> Cracking games is and was illegal.
Only distribution.
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by kennywinker on Friday July 24, 2026 @04:00AM
(#49032515)
Don’t think that’s correct, i think creating the cracked version of a piece of software is infringement of copyright even without distribution.
But even if distribution is required to trigger the law - you are free to distribute fine-tunes of most open weight models.
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by selfhoster11 on Friday July 24, 2026 @05:37AM
(#49033163)
Interoperability clause in the EU might make it legal? Not sure.
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by TaLiTr on Friday July 24, 2026 @01:17PM
(#49038798)
> creating the cracked version of a piece of software is infringement
Depending where you are it might be "DRM circumvention" all the way up to some bollocks hacking charge.
It's pretty murky in places because lots of copyright laws protect DRM but also have carve-outs for personal backups.
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by kennywinker on Saturday July 25, 2026 @02:03PM
(#49049983)
I think cracking might fall under “derivative work”, but idk
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by amelius on Friday July 24, 2026 @05:19AM
(#49033059)
The big AI companies have shown us that caring about copyright is apparently for losers.
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by shwaj on Friday July 24, 2026 @01:31PM
(#49039016)
I didn’t grow up with that hobby. The point stands anyway.
Cracking a binary circumvents authorization to provide full access to functionality the program already has. That’s very different from modifying the program to add new features.
Re:The arguments against open source AI are bad
by throwaway27448 on Saturday July 25, 2026 @08:55PM
(#49053506)
Not really. It's a social structure that separates these two things, and a social structure nobody really needs to recognize.