News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by azinman2 on Monday July 20, 2026 @02:57PM (#48983294)
It’s in the same neighborhood but isn’t really apples to apples. Distilling LLMs is to take a synthesized result that comes from huge amounts of innovation and computation, while the other is scraping what already exists as is. It is fair to say you stole our multi-billion dollar intellectual output in that scenario.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by lelanthran on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:06PM (#48983419)
> It’s in the same neighborhood but isn’t really apples to apples. Distilling LLMs is to take a synthesized result that comes from huge amounts of innovation and computation, while the other is scraping what already exists as is.

Hang on, why is scraping the public pool of knowledge not taking "a synthesized result that comes from huge amounts of innovation and computation"?

You think that that all those github repos that LLMs trained on, were not the result of innovation and computation?

How many years of human innovation and cycles of computation during compilation were involved in bringing something like GCC or LLVM to their current status?

Those LLMs trained on every single research paper available online - were those papers not the synthesised result of billions of dollars of research, effort and (importantly, for you anyway) computation?

LLMs trained on the collected works of every author in existence. Were all those works just "as is"?

> It is fair to say you stole our multi-billion dollar intellectual output in that scenario.

No, we didn't. We simply took the model as-is.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by azinman2 on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:12PM (#48983508)
The Chinese models are the result of just as many papers, GitHub repos, etc… AND the synthesized results of those.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by vrganj on Monday July 20, 2026 @04:18PM (#48984344)
Yeah real convenient that the line would be exactly after pilfering all of human knowledge work, but before American model providers.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by lelanthran on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:28PM (#48983715)
> The Chinese models are the result of just as many papers, GitHub repos, etc… AND the synthesized results of those.

Right, but they aren't the ones whining that other people are getting "the synthesised results" for free.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by adventured on Monday July 20, 2026 @05:57PM (#48985395)
I'm pretty sure the Chinese cloning isn't being arrived at for free regardless. Fable is quite expensive for example.

If Anthropic has a real problem with API use, they can always raise the price.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by api on Monday July 20, 2026 @06:58PM (#48985941)
... and they're at least releasing the results.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by anigbrowl on Monday July 20, 2026 @07:02PM (#48985972)
And you can download the Chinese model weights and run them yourself - admittedly not too practical for Kimi K3 unless you're a big corporation, but eminently doable for others. The hardware to run Deepseek r4 uncompressed is about about $30k no=ew, well within the power of a small company or financially secure individual. Compressing and/or getting creative with hardware could bring that down quite a bit.

The difference is that the Chinese are sharing the models with everyone.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by flaunf221 on Monday July 20, 2026 @04:11PM (#48984259)
> comes from huge amounts of innovation

Thousands of years of human innovation taken without any permission.

Everyone should steal everything not nailed from other AI companies. Then steal everything nailed and take the nails too. At least this way a tiniest bit might return back to society.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by Danox on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:53PM (#48984039)
Sorry, no leg to stand on and relatively speaking no sympathy for the model makers or the data-center builders…
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by azinman2 on Monday July 20, 2026 @04:06PM (#48984203)
I assume you don’t use any LLMs then
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by kbelder on Monday July 20, 2026 @07:54PM (#48986413)
I use them and I'm fine with them training on our information and knowledge. It's what it's for. No one takes it or steals knowledge; they just copy it.

But because of that, I'm also ok with the Chinese doing it. The worst they might be guilty of is breaking a terms of service.

The only incoherent position is that it's good for one and not the other. You can consistently think it's bad in both cases, or good in both cases.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by azinman2 on Friday July 24, 2026 @01:44PM (#49039212)
First, it’s more than breaking a terms of service. That language sounds very minimizing, as if the scale and effect is tiny. It’s basically espionage out in the open that bootstraps other models years into the competition, which is effectively stealing billions worth of development, compute, and leadership status.

Next, just look at the lawsuit against anthropic by the book authors. What’s the recourse for those same authors in China?

Last, one continues a leadership position for your own country vs handing over leadership to a major competitor who is not allied. This has ripple effects on the economy and ability to recruit/keep talent, which then affects social fabric and political ramifications.

Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by ciupicri on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:04PM (#48983397)
You could say that both of them stole, but different stuff.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by azinman2 on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:06PM (#48983426)
Don’t forget that the Chinese models are also built on top of huge amounts of “stolen data” as well, beyond the distilled. So it’s basically all of the above. However, there’s no mechanism for the NYT or an author or anyone in the US to sue the Chinese companies that took their work.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by ChrisLTD on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:28PM (#48983724)
and if you're an author that lives outside the United States?
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by jdkee on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:13PM (#48983523)
You can't steal intellectual property, only infringe on the copyright holder.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by azinman2 on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:26PM (#48983694)
The Chinese models poked and prodded better models for training data and to avoid having to pay humans to RLHF themselves. You can call it infringement, theft, whatever, but it’s quite obviously “not ethical” to me.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by throw-the-towel on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:35PM (#48983802)
Looks like these humans' jobs got replaced by AI.
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by polymer8563 on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:07PM (#48983434)
bet
Re:American AI is locked down and proprietary. It's losing by anigbrowl on Monday July 20, 2026 @06:43PM (#48985803)
a synthesized result that comes from huge amounts of innovation and computation

The published algorithms like the transformer architecture are not patentable. You spent a lot of money on compute and China used the uncopyright-able output to steer its own training models? Too bad. I feel especially unsympathetic to OpenAI, who went from being a presenting itself as a benevolent nonprofit to a very-much-for-private private entity over night.