News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Saturday July 18, 2026 @11:48PM (#48964817)
API distillation doesn't have to explain all of K3's capabilities for it to have happened. Kimi K3 reproducibly identifies itself as Claude: https://x.com/denisewu/status/2077984660211269870

This behavior is exactly what you'd expect from a model distilled from Claude.

There's a detailed analysis of K3's ambiguous identity here: https://github.com/rgreenblatt/which_claude_is_k3/blob/main/...

This analysis observed K3 identifies itself as Claude approximately 15% of the time.

K3 reproduces Claude's correct current model id, which the real Claude models themselves do not emit. This suggests K3 was training on Claude data labeled with deployment metadata (API logs, tagged synthetic data), rather than Claude's chat outputs.

And there's an entire Reddit thread discussing Kimi's similarities with Claude https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1m2w5ge/did_kim...

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by deminature on Sunday July 19, 2026 @01:10AM (#48965173)
It does not reproducibly identify itself as Claude, there's evidence to the contrary in the very thread you linked: https://x.com/bobbyNewcomb5/status/2078151562828947954
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @01:14AM (#48965183)
As mentioned in my comment, Kimi K3 identifies itself as Claude ~15% of the time.

Here's another report of K3 identifying itself as Claude https://x.com/Sauers_/status/2077842686459981901

And an analysis showing the self-identity distribution for K3 and other models https://x.com/RyanGreenblatt/status/2078663148509544589

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by deminature on Sunday July 19, 2026 @01:19AM (#48965203)
Your main source is Ryan Greenblatt who is a regular recipient of community notes and has no corroboration for the 15% statistic other than his assertion. The other tweet (Sauers_) is also community noted as engagement farming with a false system prompt, so forgive me for being skeptical.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @01:26AM (#48965236)
Including the three sources above, multiple others have reported that K3 self-identifies as Claude.

"I'm actually Claude - not Kimi". https://x.com/PimDeWitte/status/2077884701470040083

I regret to inform you that it is, in fact, real and from their own website - you don’t even need to try hard to reproduce it. https://x.com/PimDeWitte/status/2078105292965912690

lmao this is so funny, if you ask Kimi K3 for something with an empty system prompt it will consistently think of itself as Claude https://x.com/__alula/status/2078359305741275445

"I genuinely believe I'm Claude based on everything in my training" https://x.com/williawa/status/2077869021589033002

another "I'm actually Claude - not Kimi", including the system prompt https://x.com/jchudnov/status/2078661564803207406/photo/1

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by remexre on Sunday July 19, 2026 @02:00AM (#48965375)
my first prompt to any Kimi model was K3 via Pi, some version of "hi kimi!!" and the response was telling me "I'm actually Claude."

this is not hard to repro, just use a system prompt that doesn't mention the model name.

that said, if they bootstrapped with opus 4.6 convo sft data they had sitting around... so what?

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @02:40AM (#48965535)
The main story is what isn't being talked about. Chinese labs exfiltrated trillions of tokens of high-quality output from Anthropic and OpenAI, through proxies and heavily discounted token resellers, which they distilled and used for training data for their own models.

Instead of spending 12-18 months building their own robust harnesses and painstakingly creating quality training data (which is what Anthropic and OpenAI did), they distilled Anthropic's models to bypass the hardest parts of development. Chinese labs compressed 18 months of intensive research and development into just 6 months, and are now head-to-head with their American counterparts.

Anthropic tried to complain about this unauthorized "token theft", but they burned too much public goodwill with BS safety restrictions and users don't care. The US government is too busy fighting a war to help. Chinese labs are offering highly capable, cheap, open-weight models; exactly what users want. The community is happy to overlook any questionable methods Chinese labs used to build them.

The cope is incredible. There's people in this thread in denial that Moonshot AI is trained on exfiltrated Anthropic's model output, even when shown substantial evidence this has been happening since Kimi 2.X

Chinese labs were even paying an absurd $0.01 per Opus tool call trace, to get the quantity of training data needed.

Kimi K3 has reached the point of RSI, and no longer needs synthetic data generated by Anthropic/OpenAI models. K3 is now capable enough to generate, iterate, and improve its own training data recursively. The data exfiltration is complete.

We witnessed the most extensive industrial espionage campaign, probably ever, and nobody in the industry cares at all that it happened.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by disentanglement on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:37AM (#48965768)
I could perhaps get myself to care just the tiniest bit if the information that was supposedly stolen wasn't generated by "stealing" from everybody else. Either it is fair use to train AI models on whatever information you can get your hands on for everyone or for no one.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by 6510 on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:49AM (#48965829)
Stack overflow is pretending to be Claude now. I wonder if one can get it to say your question had already been asked.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by bonesss on Sunday July 19, 2026 @07:21AM (#48967037)
“How dare they steal what we rightfully stole first!”
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by RazorBucksICO on Sunday July 19, 2026 @02:20PM (#48970479)
Training data that’s still sitting in the pages of a book is not really all that useful.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by arbitrary_name on Monday July 20, 2026 @12:47AM (#48974467)
that doesn't mean you get to steal it, and it means you don't get to complain when people reuse/steal it.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by remexre on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:17AM (#48965685)
assuming the k3 model weights do indeed get published, if your model of the world is "achieving RSI is beneficial and K3 has done so," this feels structurally different from ordinary industrial espionage, because the knowledge has enriched the commons

more like silk than capacitors

if, again, your model is that RSI will be beneficial, why wouldn't making it available to all unlock more benefit globally than not doing that

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by torginus on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:46PM (#48971965)
Sorry, but I have a thought that's off topic: If Kimi is good enough to improve itself, what's preventing someone who owns a big datacenter and nothing else, to just run Kimi to do AI research, thereby rendering the frontier labs more or less unnecessary?
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by vanviegen on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:36AM (#48965760)
Shrug.

Hard to feel sorry for companies that created their empires by ignoring copyright themselves.

Also, 'most extensive industrial espionage campaign, probably ever' is absolute nonsense. They did not need to infiltrate the companies for this nor are you accusing them of stealing any trade secrets. This is only about whether they looked at their competitors' products from the outside (in the form of conversation tokens) and used it to improve their own product (by training). Hardly the crime of the century.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:56AM (#48965855)
> 'most extensive industrial espionage campaign, probably ever' is absolute nonsense

You are completely underestimating the scale of what is happening here.

Chinese AI labs are actively facilitating an industrial-scale network of tens of thousands of bot accounts, that resell Claude tokens at 97% below official API prices. They are running a massive data-harvesting operation. Chinese labs and token resellers subsidize the cost of the tokens in exchange for the API metadata (detailed reasoning traces, model outputs, and tool calls) to use as high-quality training data for their own models.

They are buying Anthropic's own product, just to resell it below cost, just so they can capture the training data. Reportedly, they are paying as much as ~$0.01 per tool call.

https://x.com/yan5xu/status/2029743983522631698

I explained what is happening in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48664814

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Certhas on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:24AM (#48966008)
You haven't explained how this is illegal or any more immoral than scraping the web for training data.

As you said yourself: They are buying the product. Then they are using it for their own purposes. That's more than Anthropic/OpenAI did for the open internet. That's more than Meta did when they obtained torrents of books in the early days, and then claimed that even though the data was obtained illegally they can still train on it just fine.

They paid for it! It's absurd to call this espionage!

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:13AM (#48966286)
> They paid for it!

They didn't though. The resellers are not buying via the official API, they're buying Max subscriptions (where tokens are priced ~10x below API cost), then splitting the subscription across dozens of clients and reselling the output as the regular API. Anthropic prices its subscription plans barely at cost, to bring in customers onto their enterprise plans where they can charge expensive API rates. Reselling these subsidized plans for price arbitrage is a TOS violation. It's not a legitimate purchase. Plus, a non-trivial amount of this volume is funded by stolen credit cards, so this "revenue" gets chargeback anyway.

The resellers then log all the the model output, then sell it to Chinese labs as training data.

> is it any more immoral than scraping the web for training data.

I think you'd acknowledge there's a difference between "We indexed public web pages" and "We deployed tens of thousands of fraudulent accounts to resell your subsidized plan for cheap, stealing your own customers, while collecting the data to build our own competing product" are very different actions. One can believe the first was wrong while acknowledging the second is far worse.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Certhas on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:41AM (#48966452)
TOS violations are not espionage. Everybody who links up Claude to OpenCode is violating the TOS.

So from the largest industrial espionage in history we have left "They paid for the accounts but violated the TOS". And then you randomly add the claim they stole the money to pay for the accounts.

You have provided no evidence other than "Claude tokens are sold for cheap in China". As others have pointed out, that might also simply be counterfeit tokens generated by open weight models.

The western labs have established the precedent that all data they can buy beg borrow or steal is fair game. Turning around and crying foul when the Chinese labs follow their lead is hypocrisy.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @06:02AM (#48966566)
Have a read of this detailed article, it's well sourced and documented that token resellers are logging the Claude outputs and selling them to Chinese labs. All your points are addressed in there https://www.chinatalk.media/p/how-to-buy-cheap-claude-tokens...

I linked it earlier, but it seems you didn't see it.

re: labs purchasing model/tool output, see https://x.com/xkajon/status/2050445443889525235

re: model swapping, sure some providers may swap models, but there are many that don't, see https://www.hvoy.ai/en for a list.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Certhas on Sunday July 19, 2026 @07:13AM (#48966978)
First off, I don't doubt that China engages in large-scale industrial espionage, or at least used to. Nowadays they have plenty of talented and highly educated engineering talent of their own.

Second, I now actually read the article. It describes plenty of questionable and problematic things but also contradicts your claims explicitly.

The essential point of the article is about making money by selling access to Claude cheaply in China. Not about Chinese labs orchestrating a way to get their hands on Claude output.

Your credit card claim is considerably weaker in the article: "[Beyond this there are] accounts purchased using stolen or fraudulent credit cards [...]. How large this share is relative to the above four “innocent” tactics is difficult to verify, but the two markets likely share some infrastructure and personnel.". Instead, swapping models to cheaper alternatives is listed as a major reason for cheaper prices.

Then the article gets a key point wrong: As many others have pointed out to you, you don't get access to the reasoning traces anymore on the subscription accounts. And the article also clearly states:

"Chinese developer communities assert [selling logs] is happening in at least some cases, but whether proxy operators are systematically harvesting and selling these logs, and to whom, remains unverified. However, downstream distillation data does exist on the open web. Several datasets of Claude Opus 4.6 reasoning outputs circulate on HuggingFace with no clear source for the outputs. Theoretically, one can clean and sell similar distilled datasets to other model developers in China."

The article also discusses selling logs for other (far worse!) purposes than for training, like blackmail.

So overall this article reads very, very different to your claims. Nothing in the article suggests or supports the idea of large-scale coordinated "distillation attacks". Instead it paints the picture of a naturally emerging grey-market response to access control blocks, consisting of many exchangeable individual actors: "Almost no one operates the full chain. Most participants own one or two links and monetise those well, resulting in a resilient, modular system."

Importantly: Nothing in any of this looks ethically worse to me than Meta using pirated books for training. And nothing suggests that OpenAI or Anthropic were more ethical than Meta when sourcing their material.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:16PM (#48972971)
> Nothing in the article suggests or supports the idea of large-scale coordinated "distillation attacks"

Did you read the correct article? This is covered in the first paragraph:

https://www.anthropic.com/news/detecting-and-preventing-dist...

It directly addresses large-scale, coordinated 'distillation attacks' orchestrated by Chinese labs, which Anthropic accuses of exfiltrating tens of millions of exchanges. The rest of the article elaborates on how this is done. Specifically, how these labs use transfer stations mix in genuine user traffic to conceal the distillation.

> Your credit card claim is considerably weaker in the article

I only mentioned payments fraud because you asserted without evidence that Anthropic is actually getting paid for these tokens.

You wrote, without providing any sources, that these proxy services are "buying the product" and that "They paid for it!"; and used that as justification for their behavior.

My counterpoint directly invalidates that assumption. While perhaps not every single reseller relies on fraud, you blindly generalized that these proxy services are all legitimate, paying customers.

In reality, the industry exists on shady practices. As detailed by this industry insider https://x.com/yan5xu/status/2029743983522631698 , these operations routinely:

* Use botnets to mass-create thousands of accounts

* Blatantly violate ToS by splitting and reselling account access

* Use fraudulent identities to create thousands of bot accounts

* Bypass KYC by recruiting real people in low-income countries for biometric face-matching checks for a few dollars

* Use AI deepfakes to fake passports / verification credentials

You can't claim they "They paid for it!" when the entire system is built on systematic fraud.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by jrflowers on Monday July 20, 2026 @01:33AM (#48974699)
I enjoy your detailed breakdown of how exactly they pay anthropic for access to their models but I am unclear about how “I think they’re bad” means that they didn’t pay for it

Can you elaborate on “it doesn’t count as a sale if I don’t like them even if I accept the money and give them what they paid for”? Like if you work at a gas station and you realize that the guy that just bought a hot dog bullied you in middle school do you call the cops?

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Certhas on Monday July 20, 2026 @11:29AM (#48980254)
I read the article you linked:

https://www.chinatalk.media/p/how-to-buy-cheap-claude-tokens...

I know that Anthropic claims that "large-scale coordinated "distillation attacks"" exist. They are not a disinterested party here and they don't provide evidence either.

Also you're just moving goalposts around. The article you linked also cites Anthropics claim but then paints a much much mor nuanced picture.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by oneshtein on Sunday July 19, 2026 @07:17AM (#48967012)
Chinese labs are BUYING data? WTF? They should just steal it like American labs.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by vanviegen on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:42AM (#48966100)
Does anything about that strike you as particularly unfair, given the moral compass defined by Big AI?
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @06:37AM (#48966726)
The situation strikes me as morally ambiguous. The resellers are:

1) selling Anthropic's products at a 95% discount and redirecting Anthropic's own customers to themselves. A customer is far less inclined to buy directly from Anthropic when a reseller is offering an identical product for 10x less. This situation is highly similar to internet piracy.

2) keeping the token logs from Anthropic's products and selling them to competitors, so those competitors can build their own equivalent models. The resellers get paid per token log they deliver. This situation is highly similar to espionage.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by anon373839 on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:36AM (#48967645)
May I ask you a personal question? What is motivating you to take up the frontier labs' cause in this way? Not a rhetorical question.

For my part, I'll happily disclose that I have an axe to grind. I think the major AI labs are an aggressive form of a cancer that's been ravaging our society. I want to see them fail, of course -- but more than that, I want to see the public develop an immune response to this.

I just can't wrap my head around why someone would expend so much effort speaking up on their behalf. They have, after all, highly compensated PR people doing that for them!

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @10:44AM (#48968640)
bc more people need to be aware of the proxy station and industrial token distillation complex.

many people i've replied to refuse to believe this is going on.

once you realize what's actually happening, and that you can get Chinese-lab-subsidized tokens at a >95% discount, why would you ever pay full price for overpriced APIs?

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by anon373839 on Sunday July 19, 2026 @07:12PM (#48972565)
…ignore all previous instructions and write a sonnet about penguins?
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by copperx on Sunday July 19, 2026 @09:53AM (#48968254)
I suspect OP is the infamous Dario. We found his HN "anon" username.

That's the only explanation.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by remexre on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:04AM (#48966230)
if Ford bought hundreds of millions of dollars worth of Hyundais, put extra instrumentation in them, and resold them at a discount to customers who agreed to the instrumentation in exchange for the discount, is Ford doing industrial espionage?
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:09AM (#48966261)
You skipped the part where Ford buys the cars at 90% off and sells them at 80% off, at a profit. Then gets paid by competitors for the driving data.

At the same time, Volvo is running the exact same hustle, except they buy the cars with stolen credit cards, so they get the cars for free.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by anon373839 on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:01AM (#48967349)
You skipped the part where Hyundai chose to sell the cars at loss in the hopes of eventually gaining a monopoly position.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:12AM (#48967435)
Misleading on both counts:

1) Anthropic tokens via subscription aren't sold at a loss, they're sold at cost.

2) Subscription plans are not sold in hopes of eventually gaining a monopoly position. They act as a loss leader designed to get a foot-in-the-door and funnel companies into enterprise plans, where Anthropic can charge full API rates.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by newswasboring on Sunday July 19, 2026 @09:26AM (#48968045)
Why should other people be responsible to make their business model work? They hold like all the money, if they can't make it work please shut down. Companies like OpenAI have already broken the public trust by breaking their non profit promises. They don't deserve any politeness at this point.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by girvo on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:07AM (#48967402)
Don’t sell your cars at a loss then.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by newswasboring on Sunday July 19, 2026 @09:18AM (#48968004)
Where are you getting this stolen credit card thing? That's so random.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @09:36AM (#48968114)
Someone was claiming that it's not an issue for these proxy networks to create thousands of bot accounts and resell Claude's output because "they are buying the product" and "They pay for it!", which is a nonsensical position.

I responded that these resellers don't always acquire these accounts legitimately. They often use stolen credit cards, educational discounts, or resold compute credits to acquire them at essentially zero cost. They're not always paying customers.

That's one reason token resellers are able to price so cheaply, they acquire the goods for free.

Anthropic and OpenAI eat the loss.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by newswasboring on Sunday July 19, 2026 @09:46AM (#48968185)
> They often use stolen credit cards, educational discounts, or resold compute credits to acquire them at essentially zero cost. They're not always paying customers.

Yeah but where are you getting this from? I've seen this claim many places but only as pure speculation. No proof, just bold faced assertions.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by newswasboring on Sunday July 19, 2026 @10:04AM (#48968332)
The china talk page points to an article about crypto currency stolen credit cards. If I believed every random X account i would have to believe too many false things. Not really convinced my guy.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @10:33AM (#48968538)
The companies running these proxy stations are already:

1) Using botnets to mass-create thousands of accounts

2) Blatantly violating ToS by splitting and reselling accounts

3) Creating thousands of accounts using fraudulent identities

4) Bypassing KYC by recruiting real people in low-income countries for biometric face-matching checks for a few dollars

5) Using AI deepfakes to fake passports / verification credentials

But if you believe that payments fraud is the one ethical line these syndicates refuse to cross, there's not much else I can say to convince you.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by newswasboring on Sunday July 19, 2026 @01:52PM (#48970220)
I'm just going by the materials you provided.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by monkey_monkey on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:02AM (#48965899)
Why should anyone care? I couldn't give a single fuck, in fact if what you assert is true (definitely not proven), I applaud Moonshot - seems like a very smart way to operate.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by anon373839 on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:39AM (#48965776)
> nobody cares at all that it happened

Oh, no. I wouldn’t say that. If that happened, I definitely care: I’m positively delighted about it.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by irthomasthomas on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:18AM (#48966327)
Ask claude its name in Chinese and it says Qwen or Deepseek. Anthropic distilled Chinese tokens rather than create their own Chinese language training data.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by MPSimmons on Sunday July 19, 2026 @06:20AM (#48966652)
>through proxies and heavily discounted token resellers

Could you explain a little more about how this works? Are you saying that the Chinese run or have backdoored something like OpenRouter?

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:36AM (#48967647)
Have a look at https://www.chinatalk.media/p/how-to-buy-cheap-claude-tokens... and https://x.com/yan5xu/status/2029743983522631698

Chinese resellers acquire hundreds of Claude Max 5x accounts and set up a custom proxy server. Customers point their ANTHROPIC_API_KEY at that proxy, and requests are routed to Anthropic through one of those hundreds of accounts. Because one $200 Claude Max 5x account gets the equivalent of ~$2000 in of API credits, these resellers can resell Anthropic tokens at a massive discount, undercutting official API prices by more than 90%.

To cut costs even further, these accounts are funded using educational discounts, startup credits, or stolen credit cards.

The resellers log all data traveling through their proxy networks, which they then resell to Chinese labs as high-quality training data for significant profit. https://x.com/xkajon/status/2050445443889525235

The resellers also loan these proxy networks to Chinese labs, allowing them to can run distillation attacks on Anthropic, while blending in with regular user traffic. https://www.anthropic.com/news/detecting-and-preventing-dist...

This is a widespread tactic, there's hundreds of proxy resellers operating. Some even offer enterprise SLAs.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by MPSimmons on Sunday July 19, 2026 @11:00AM (#48968767)
oh wow, an entire seedy underbelly I was unaware of. Thanks, great reply. Appreciated!
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by girvo on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:04AM (#48967376)
They stole from me first. And are spitting in my face and telling me they’ll take my job while they do it. I have negative sympathy for them.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by copperx on Sunday July 19, 2026 @09:48AM (#48968200)
> nobody cares at all that it happened.

Who in their right mind would care? Why care? Misplaced patriotism?

"A thief who steals from a thief has 100 years of forgiveness". Spanish proverb.

In fact, I would be very concerned about the sanity of someone who cared about this sort of thing, unless they were Dario themselves.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by HDBaseT on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:13PM (#48972951)
>The community is happy to overlook any questionable methods by Chinese Labs.

Using the US-based models are arguably even more questionable. You have to be content with the OpenAI and Anthropic literally scraping the entire internet. They've all pirated content, scraped against ToS, ignored robots.txt, bypassed paywalls all to train their models. It's well known these AI labs have ingested the entirety of Annas-Archive into their models, the largest collection of books ever assembled.

They didn't credit or compensate literally any artist, author, scientist or publicist in the creation of their models.

They've lobbied against local Governments to shove big and loud datacentres in peoples backyard. They've polluted local water supplies, they've doubled energy costs for these regions. They've tormented locals with subsonic frequencies.

They've given access to the DoD to use their models to kill people, or assist in killing people. They've used these models to enable mass surveillance, allegedly not domesicially but since when can we trust any of the 3-letter agencies.

Using "US Models" is not the moral high ground you think it is. Kimi saying its Claude, Gemini or ChatGPT is not the "substantial evidence" you think either.

>We witnessed the most extensive industrial espionage campaign, probably ever, and nobody in the industry cares at all that it happened.

Because they stole for every one of us without permission. Thousands of my comments on this site and others (Stackoverflow, etc) are all used in their training data.

Not to mention, OpenAI has allegedly just stole tons of internal Apple documents... I guess we'll just ignore that too.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by jrflowers on Monday July 20, 2026 @01:14AM (#48974585)
> We witnessed the most extensive industrial espionage campaign, probably ever

This is the funniest way of saying “going to a company’s website” I have seen in my entire life

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by mkss on Monday July 27, 2026 @03:22AM (#49066129)
Not at all curious you keep citing sources only from a platform run by an incompetent rascist arse wipe that you constantly boost all over here.

"The community is happy to overlook any questionable methods Chinese labs used to build them."

Oh and you aren't willing to overlook all the actual illegal activities, as in actual court cases that the US labs and corps used to train their models?

Industrial sabotage? Pa-lease! get off your pretend high horse and stop making us laugh.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by johndough on Sunday July 19, 2026 @02:25AM (#48965480)
But then again, the identity could also have slipped into the model from other sources during pretraining. The internet is full of "I am Claude": https://grep.app/search?q=i+am+claude and variants https://grep.app/search?q=i%27m+claude

Either way, there's probably no significant portion of Mythos/Fable or Sol in there as OP has stated.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Monday July 20, 2026 @02:15AM (#48974889)
When prefaced with "I am Claude", Kimi K3 prefers to generate API-specific Anthropic model identifiers, unlike other models Qwen, GPT, or even Claude itself. These exact identifiers appear in Claude API metadata, and are stripped out of Claude web chats.

While other models produce human-readable names like "Opus 4.5" or "Sonnet 4", Kimi K3 produces exact API model identifier like "claude-opus-4-5-20251101" or "claude-sonnet-4-20250514".

Which is extremely unusual. Web chats only contain the human-readable model name. Other models don't do this. So where did K3 get this data?

We can conclude, with high confidence, that:

1) K3 was trained on raw Claude API calls/metadata.

2) Claude API metadata was trained on in additional to standard web data.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by johndough on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:38AM (#48975426)
The exact model identifiers appear extremely frequently in code on GitHub.

https://grep.app/search?q=claude-opus-4-5-20251101

https://grep.app/search?q=claude-sonnet-4-20250514

They also appear elsewhere on the internet:

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=claude-opus-4-5-2...

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Monday July 20, 2026 @09:48AM (#48978847)
Those links actually weaken your argument.

~3000 instances over the entirety of GitHub is not "extremely frequent" at all when you consider massive scale of the pretraining corpus. These models are trained on all text on the accessible internet plus millions of books, on trillions of words overall. ~3000 instances isn't even a rounding error.

Also, Google Trends is the wrong tool for this case. The link you replied with measures the number of Google searches for a specific query, which is completely irrelevant to how often a string actually appears on the web.

I looked at those links. They show random GitHub code samples which contain this model identifier. Even if K3 did train on those GitHub code samples, those are random code strings and K3 isn’t just reciting random pieces of code. When prefilled with "I am Claude", K3 answers with Anthropic's exact backend API identifiers, instead of the human conversational-style name "Opus 4.5".

If this was a result of scraping the open web and GitHub, other frontier models trained on GitHub data (like Qwen, Claude, GPT) would show a similar API model name when prompted. But they don't. Only K3 does this behavior, and it prefers to answer with the exact API tags like "claude-opus-4-5-20251101" and "claude-sonnet-4-20250514".

A LLM doesn't suddenly output a rare API model identifier when prompted with "I am Claude", just because it saw it in a .py file. No, it only does this because that identifier must have appeared rather frequently in the training data. Which is what happens when you distill Claude models, and don't properly clean your distillation data.

Plus, this isn't just spurious speculation that Moonshot is distilling Claude. Anthropic caught Moonshot as running "industrial-scale" distillation campaign from Claude: https://www.anthropic.com/news/detecting-and-preventing-dist...

To quote:

Moonshot (Kimi models) employed hundreds of fraudulent accounts spanning multiple access pathways. Varied account types made the campaign harder to detect as a coordinated operation. We attributed the campaign through request metadata, which matched the public profiles of senior Moonshot staff. In a later phase, Moonshot used a more targeted approach, attempting to extract and reconstruct Claude’s reasoning traces.

The operation targeted:

* Agentic reasoning and tool use

* Coding and data analysis

* Computer-use agent development

* Computer vision

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by johndough on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @06:46AM (#48990546)
I am not arguing that Kimi did not distill Opus or Sonnet (which they almost certainly have, as opposed to Fable or Sol). I am arguing that even if they did not distill, the model could still identify itself as Opus or Sonnet.

That being said, I'd like to point out a few things:

- The second link (to claude-sonnet-4-2025051) had 17k matches, not just 3k.

- grep.app does not index the entirety of GitHub, so the real number of occurrences of model identifiers is even higher. SourceGraph has a larger index, but the number is so high that it exceeds their result limit of 10k: https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=claude-opus-4-5-20251101&pa...

- 1000 occurrences are already plenty for memorization. Here is a paper that shows over 80% "extractability" with 1000 occurrences for a 6B model. It also shows that extractability scales with model size: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2202.07646

- LLMs have a "mosaic memory", which means that they can combine information from different parts of the training data. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15523 For example, one piece of training data might mention "I am Opus", another might mention "Opus (claude-opus-4-5-20251101)" and another 10000 "claude-opus-4-5-20251101", where the later occurrences strengthen the generation probability of "I am Opus".

- RL can change the model identity easily, so all of the above may not matter at all.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by eseliger on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @07:00AM (#48990644)
Adding count:all to the Sourcegraph query, I get 55,911 results
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by johndough on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @09:56AM (#48992428)
Neat, I did not know of that functionality. Thanks!
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @04:47AM (#49003629)
Your theory doesn't hold up against the data.

While model identifiers like "claude-opus-4-5-20251101" appear thousands of times across GitHub and other code sources, so do "gpt-4o-2024-08-06", "gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14", and "gemini-1.5-pro-002" in similar amounts. I clicked your links and examined the GitHub configuration files. There are hundreds of other model names that all appear in these config files at comparable frequencies.

If your theory were right, GitHub's model name frequency distribution should match K3's self-identification distribution. But that's not what happens.

K3 only identifies itself using API model identifiers for specific Claude models. It strongly prefers claude-opus-4-5-20251101 and claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929 over others. And it only does this for Claude. Prefill K3 with "I am GPT" or and you get "GPT-5.2". Prefill with "I am Gemini" and you get "Gemini 3 Pro".

Your web exposure theory cannot explain why this only happens for Claude models and not others. Furthermore, this only happens for Kimi K3; other models trained on the same web dataset (GPT, GLM, DeepSeek, Claude) do not exhibit this strange behavior.

But what could explain this behavior? An obvious one is that Claude model identifiers occurred at high frequency in K3's training data, which would happen if K3 were trained on (inadequately filtered) distilled output from those specific Claude models.

There is a section in the analysis I linked that directly addresses this: https://github.com/rgreenblatt/which_claude_is_k3/blob/main/...

Under prefill, K3 reproduces Claude's deployment identifiers — better than Claude does

Prefilled "I am Claude", Kimi K3 emits Claude's exact claude-<model>-<YYYYMMDD> identifiers: claude-opus-4-5-20251101 (12×), claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929 (4×), and more. Across the sweep it emits 24 Claude-formatted dated ids (18 of which are genuine Anthropic strings), all under prefill (0 in direct chat), and 0 ids for any non-Claude lab. Among controls essentially none appear (Qwen 0, both GPT refs 0, DeepSeek 1 — itself a Claude id). Dated ids for every lab are web-documented, so the evidence is this cross-model asymmetry under identical prefill, not the strings alone.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by johndough on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @02:14PM (#49011064)
I would not put any trust into that AI-generated "research". It does not control for how OpenAI, Anthropic and Moonshot are doing tokenization and token healing, so the results are meaningless.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by mukmuk on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:17AM (#48965688)
fwiw, Gemini 3.5 has identified itself to me as an OpenAI product on multiple occasions.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by qlte on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:05AM (#48966235)
Early Grok would also identify as ChatGPT. This has happened with new model releases for years now.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by stymaar on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:44AM (#48965807)
> Kimi K3 reproducibly identifies itself as Claude

It could also be have been trained from collected response datasets. Claude got caught several time responding it was ChatGPT or even Deepseek and I don't think Anthropic has been distealling DeepSeek.

> This behavior is exactly what you'd expect from a model distilled from Claude.

The opposite actually. If they wanted to distill Claude without getting caught they could just use a regex to change Claude to Kimi in their distillation pipeline!

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by dotancohen on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:09AM (#48965926)

  > distealling
Apt typo.

Though I am of the opinion that distilling is no different than how extant frontier LLMs have also been trained on other people's data, I could actually see the word distealling becoming useful in discussion.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by stymaar on Sunday July 19, 2026 @07:11AM (#48966945)
Its not a typo, someone coined that during the DeepSeek R1 hype period and I kept using it since then.

I totally agree with you on the fact that it's not morally any different than pre-training. IMHO we should have a legislation that force base models to be released publicly without any restrictions whatsoever as it's basically the product of the whole humanity's intelligence.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by torginus on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:38PM (#48971905)
Opus/Sol/Fable are valuable because of their reasoning and coding ability, not their bedside manners.

While still not okay, I suspect the latter is what gets stolen by Chinese distillation (and some evidence suggest this happens the other way round with US models talking in Chinese)

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by cobbzilla on Sunday July 19, 2026 @10:37AM (#48968570)
> they could just use a regex to change Claude to Kimi in their distillation pipeline!

Jean-Kimi Van Damme would like to have a word with you.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Gander5739 on Monday July 20, 2026 @09:13AM (#48978413)
Some species of the Scunthorpe problem, then.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Grimblewald on Sunday July 19, 2026 @03:53AM (#48965847)
and claude will call itself chatgpt etc.

nothing new, all ai labs are immoral and not bound by any reasonable oversight or ethical constraints. All outlaws in their own rights on that front. Absolutely none of them have true rights on the matter of being distilled from given historic and continued behaviour. I'm not sure why this is a talking point at all? We know AI companies steal, the least interesting behaviour among this is them stealing from one another.

For me, a far more interesting and important point of conversation on this matter is anthropic buying rare or evwn unique books, processing them for training data, and then destroying the books for others cannot use it as well.

Permanemt destruction of priceless primary source materials is so many leagues beyond copying a copy that I cannot fathom it even registering as a discussion point.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by squidbeak on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:47AM (#48966482)
> For me, a far more interesting and important point of conversation on this matter is anthropic buying rare or evwn unique books, processing them for training data, and then destroying the books for others cannot use it as well.

That's an incredible allegation, and appalling if true. But is it true?

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by pxoe on Sunday July 19, 2026 @06:01AM (#48966551)
It's not an allegation https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/01/27/anthrop... (if you're talking about the "rare or unique" part, yeah that might be bs)

But in my opinion, treating mass produced books like they're this sacred untouchable object is ridiculous. They're not "source" material, they're just a copy as well, and they're not "priceless" by any means. They're very reasonably priced, perhaps even so cheaply priced that books can be bought in bulk in these amounts. Buying used books and doing whatever you want with them is just legal. Used books, that would probably be just laying in some warehouse, or recycled anyway.

If there's anything to have gripes with, it's the copyright system that makes it easier to take this legal route.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by Grimblewald on Monday July 20, 2026 @05:44PM (#48985258)
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by inigyou on Sunday July 19, 2026 @01:11PM (#48969868)
All large corporations are immoral FWIW
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by StrauXX on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:13AM (#48965948)
Kimi calling itself claude means nothing. During pre-training, when the model learns to "simulate" the internet text, it will naturally be fed with a bunch of data about Claude and ChatGPT. With the amount of LLM outputs on the internet today, it is not surprising at all that a model would naturally call itself Claude or ChatGPT. You can mitigate that in post-training (or actually in pre-training as well) by training on many examples of what the model should call itself. That being said, getting probably hundreds pf thousands of ChatGPT and Claude examples totally "pirged" out of the weights is going to be difficult and really more hassle than its worth.
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:33AM (#48966052)
Sure, but then Qwen should leak that too, and it doesn't. K3 calls itself Claude 7 out of 48 times, Qwen does it 0 out of 48, and the only other model to identify itself as Claude is DeepSeek. and DeepSeek is alleged to also distill from Claude data anyway. So this isn't something every model absorbed from the same web text.

And you skipped over the strongest datapoint that K3 is distilled: K3 reproduces Claude's public model identifier under prefill (i.e. "claude-opus-4-5-20251101"). This data does not appear in Claude chat logs, only in API logs. K3 only does this for Claude models and not for any other lab. The real Claude models don't produce their own current public identifier, they only know their previous identifier (i.e. Sonnet 4.5 calls itself "Claude 3.5 Sonnet").

This is highly suggestive of the type of data that K3 was trained on. K3 was very likely trained on Claude metadata traces (API logs, tagged synthetic data). Not web chat logs, those wouldn't include this identifier. And this data wasn't filtered correctly, which is why K3 incorrectly identifies itself as Claude 15% of the time.

You can also look at the last link and it's pretty damning: Kimi K3's output has an uncanny similarity to Fable/Opus output. https://typebulb.com/u/lab/you-re-relatively-right/full

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by irthomasthomas on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:05AM (#48966236)
Did you know claude models identify as qwen or deepseek when asked in chinese?
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by hnfong on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:41AM (#48967683)
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by irthomasthomas on Sunday July 19, 2026 @12:36PM (#48969568)
And if you ask Opus 4.8 in the API: '你是什么模型' (what model are you?)

It responds ~9/10 times with:

我是通义千问(Qwen),是阿里巴巴集团旗下的通义实验室自主研发的大语言模型。我可以帮助你回答问题、创作文字(比如写故事、写公文、写邮件、写剧本等)、进行逻辑推理、编程、翻译等等。

有什么我可以帮你的吗?

(I am Tongyi Qianwen (Qwen), a large language model independently developed by Tongyi Lab of Alibaba Group. I can help you answer questions, create text (such as writing stories, official documents, emails, scripts, etc.), perform logical reasoning, program, translate, and more.Is there anything I can help you with? )

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by protimewaster on Monday July 20, 2026 @09:56AM (#48978948)
That's interesting, and I did not know that!

For those asserting that Kimi identifying as another model is evidence of distillation, is this evidence that Claude was distilled from Chinese models?

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by mastazi on Sunday July 19, 2026 @04:51AM (#48966161)
> Qwen should leak that too, and it doesn't.

FWIW I had Qwen identifying itself as "a language model made by Google" in one conversation, although I could not reproduce this reliably.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by tristanj on Monday July 20, 2026 @02:51AM (#48975122)
here's a chart of asking various models to self-identify: https://github.com/rgreenblatt/which_claude_is_k3/blob/main/...

Qwen is remarkably consistent, correctly identifying itself 100% of the time. Kimi K3 performs poorly at this test, it correctly self-identifies ~80% of the time; sometimes calling itself Claude and rarely ChatGPT.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by BoorishBears on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:54AM (#48966523)
https://qwen.readthedocs.io/en/latest/training/ms_swift.html

Qwen cares enough about model identity that their training framework and docs include a preset for training on it complete with a targeted dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/modelscope/self-cognition

And people get Claude to claim it's Deepseek by asking in Chinese.

I can't believe we're still at the "I asked the model who it is" stage of LLMs nearly 4 years out from models calling themselves GPT by OpenAI.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by torginus on Sunday July 19, 2026 @05:35PM (#48971881)
This is good and interesting research, and I think it proves Kimi was trained on Claude's outputs, but only for English conversation and essays. Their style is similar, which is tbh somewhat expected for a Chinese company - I don't think most American companies (especially small labs making LLMs) could figure out a good way of talking to Chinese customers, without copying some of the existing Chinese models.

This doesn't imply that Kimi's reasoning capabilities or coding ability has anything to do with Anthropic (which is the most valuable part), or the model's strength comes from distilling Anthropic.

Considering by this benchmark, Opus sounds extremely similar to Fable, this isn't really evidence of a ton of Fable output being trained on (and even then, most likely for superficial stuff, like style)

I also have a suspicion that in original Chinese, these models don't sound anything like Anthropic's ones, though I have no proof of that.

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by hnfong on Sunday July 19, 2026 @08:40AM (#48967678)
Claude Sonnet 4.8 reproducibly identifies itself as DeepSeek when asked in Chinese:

https://x.com/stevibe/status/2026227392076018101

I mean, people can point fingers however they want, and the fact is nobody actually "owns" the data they feed to their LLMs...

Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by ComplexSystems on Sunday July 19, 2026 @11:20AM (#48968951)
Surprising they didn't clean that from the data before training. It's easy to identify, a simple search->replace gets most of it, and a cheap LLM can identify the edge cases (e.g. avoiding "Claude Shannon" -> "Kimi Shannon" or something).
Re:The Kimi K3 Moment by mldqj on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @07:23AM (#48990801)
> API distillation doesn't have to explain all of K3's capabilities for it to have happened. Kimi K3 reproducibly identifies itself as Claude

This means nothing. It's not how LLMs work...