1. The influenza vaccine is a vaccine. Putting "vaccine" in scare quotes is either ignorant or utterly disingenuous. Or, more likely, both.
2. Even 50% efficacy is sufficient to dramatically reduce both the incidence and mortality of the disease.
3. The number of people who develop influenza because they got sneezed on in line waiting to get their vaccination is insignificant compared to the number of people who won't get sick because people get vaccinated.
So nothing I said is factually incorrect, but what I wrote is idiotic? Good job.
> The influenza vaccine is a vaccine. Putting "vaccine" in scare quotes is either ignorant or utterly disingenuous. Or, more likely, both.
Perfectly justified considering it's much less effective than other vaccines. So it is a "vaccine".
> Even 50% efficacy is sufficient to dramatically reduce both the incidence and mortality of the disease.
That's the best case scenario. What exactly is the benefit if it's 5%? What if it's 0%? Those are real percentages from years over the last decade.
Last year was very good. This year? Who knows.
> The number of people who develop influenza because they got sneezed on in line waiting to get their vaccination is insignificant compared to the number of people who won't get sick because people get vaccinated.
You realize you can get something else there too, right? And you'll get it by touching the door or the doctor not washing their hands ... not by somebody sneezing at you.
The definition of vaccine is: A vaccine is a biological preparation that improves immunity to a particular disease.
Nowhere does it say with 100% efficacy...
A vaccine is a vaccine; arbitrary judgments about it's general efficacy over some hand-wavey timespan doesn't change that. And no, it's not justified to redefine it.
That removes the incentive for us to find a real answer.
I took my infant daughter to get her second flu shot last week (babies get two). She contracted a stomach virus at the doctors' office. She was puking for hours, repeatedly, even when she had nothing to throw up. We took her to the emergency room. A day later, fever and diarrhea for me. Same for my wife. Fun, right?
If my baby doesn't get the flu, this will count as a success story. Part of the "50%" that worked. I don't even want to think about the years they don't get up to that 50% ...
And I'm supposed to do this every year?
> Are you really saying that risk of nosocomial infection is sufficient to offset the value of influenza vaccination? Really?
Yes. If you think I'm off, I want to see math, not hysterics and italics.
At best, twice as many people die from nosocomial infection as influenza in the US. At worst, twenty times as many. That's all from the CDC.
[1] http://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/disease/us_flu-related_deaths.h...
Second, nobody disputes the seriousness of nosocomial infection; but to baldly state that you face the same risk in an outpatient vaccination clinic as in e.g. the ICU or the ER is just flat out bonkers.
Finally, I was intemperate in my original language. I apologize.
I don't know what the relationship is between vaccination efficacy and infection rate in this specific case, but on its own a low-ish individual efficacy does not mean a vaccine isn't worth using.
Now, vaccines DO sometimes have complications - last time I got a vaccine (tetanus, 8 years ago), my elbow got swollen to about twice its size and was hard to bend. They weren't sure what went wrong (contaminated vaccine, parasitic infection, ??) but I had to take a two week course of antibiotics (which carries its own problems ...)
I'm sure at the herd level, 50% efficacy for individual vaccines is great.
But on a personal level, I can't find any analysis that takes into account both efficacy ("value") and complications ("price").
And on a personal note, I have the flu maybe once in ten years (if even that), despite hanging around people who get it regularly -- which is why I don't even consider getting a flu vaccine.
There is almost no research about how to improve general immune function, and I believe results on that front would be much more useful than a 50% efficacy vaccine.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infec...
Anti-virus is bad.
This earned you a downvote. I don't know that you're wrong, but you can't make a claim like this without some link to back you up.
"While the vaccine does work, and we still recommend that it be used, it does not demonstrate the kind of efficacy that has often been reported," says study researcher Michael T. Osterholm, MD, of the University of Minnesota Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy." - from "Lancet"
In case of flu it is difficult to measure vaccine effectivness since it is often hard to figure out if someone got flu or was attacked by some other virus that has similar symptoms.
It is usually not feasible to do indepth virus (genetical?) analysis to check which kind of virus attacted given sick person.
Symptoms are so common to many other virsu infections, so the data is very noisy and it can work both againts and for vaccines.
It would be cool if some HN community member figure out to measure that better :)
For the most part, the vaccine is limited to those of the highest level of exposure (infection rate).
http://www.cdc.gov/flu/protect/keyfacts.htm
"The seasonal flu vaccine protects against three influenza viruses that research indicates will be most common during the upcoming season. Three kinds of influenza viruses commonly circulate among people today: influenza B viruses, influenza A (H1N1) viruses, and influenza A (H3N2) viruses. Each year, one flu virus of each kind is used to produce seasonal influenza vaccine."
Why run the risk of endangering yourself or others of infection?
Huh? It's been years since I got a flu vaccine from a doctor. I usually get them at the drug store, when I'm there anyway to pick up a prescription. One year, I got it at a Safeway.
Have you heard of evolution?
The flu "vaccine" however, is at best 50% effective and is frequently 0% effective. Notice how you have to vaccinate every year for it? But not for anything else? Yeah, it's because it's constantly mutating and it's a moving target.
We still haven't figured out how to nail that target. What's worse, you need to go to a doctor to get vaccinated ... guess where the majority of infections occur? The place where many people congregate. Especially sick people.
I'm all for vaccinations, but not if they have to be done on an annual basis and are best-case-scenario 50% effective.