News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by throw93949449 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:05AM (#48697186)
> most of them were draftees who didn't necessarily want to be there

It is called forced labour or slavery.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by multjoy on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:23AM (#48697277)
It wasn’t slavery as they were paid and could be expected to be discharged at the cessation of hostilities.

Conscription is as old as society itself.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by freedomben on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:38AM (#48697371)
You're both right. We don't want to water down the term "slavery" by using it for draftees, but it is a form of temporary slavery. Slave's have always been "paid" in the form of room and board (however meager), but it's still slavery.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by throe94944i on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:32AM (#48697333)
Yeah, they were paid!! Plastic ocarinas!
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by danaris on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:53AM (#48697844)
I mean, to be fair, so is slavery.

I think it's important to acknowledge that conscription is a violation of human rights, and absolutely a violation of human autonomy and dignity.

The reason it exists is because historically, the primary source of military power has been the number of armed humans you can put on the battlefield. That's much less true now, but even in WWII the technology wasn't yet up to that point.

And while the US did not end up being materially at risk in WWII (aside from some very small exceptions like Pearl Harbor), that was not a guarantee going in. The Nazis were hellbent on wiping out all opposition to them, and the fear that, if Europe was lost, they would cross the ocean to attack us was not at all crazy. Furthermore, our allies absolutely were under existential threat—and in such a situation, it's frankly irresponsible of a nation not to use conscription if that's actually likely to make a difference.

Either saying "conscription is slavery, therefore it is never justifiable" or "conscription is nothing like slavery, soldiers get treated well" ignores enough of the truth that they're misleading at best. Sometimes you really do have to deal with nuance.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by dmbrThnYou on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:16AM (#48698015)
You have the option to emigrate as opposed to fight, which is fundamentally what differentiates conscription from slavery (and human rights violations). You're not legally obligated to stay in your country.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by throw734848 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @11:57AM (#48699333)
Hello?

Germany introduced law, your are required to notify ministry and get permission, of you leave country for couple of weeks.

Ukraine closed border for men in like 10 seconds.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by danaris on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:40AM (#48698218)
Um...what?

Desertion has, historically, been a capital crime. Trying to paint conscription as not being a kind of captivity because "you're not legally obligated to stay in your country" is at best wildly disingenuous, and at worst just flat-out wrong.

I think you might need to take quite a bit more time to consider this issue, lest you prove your username much truer than you probably want.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by pfdietz on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:00AM (#48698376)
> Desertion has, historically, been a capital crime.

And it remained so for the US in WW2, although the sentence was carried out just once.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Slovik

Major General Norman "Dutch" Cota, who was at the execution, called it "the toughest 15 minutes of his life". For context, Cota was also present at the bloodbath on Omaha Beach, where he famously rallied troops.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by dmbrThnYou on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:46AM (#48698276)
You can absolutely emigrate prior to the conscription coming to fruition. It has to be permanent, or it's draft evasion, but it is perfectly legal.

Sorry for the edits confusing things. I can see earlier how you thought I meant desertion as opposed to emigration.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by danaris on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:40PM (#48699684)
Most people do not have the ability to emigrate. Hell, a great many people barely have the economic ability to move across their own state, but emigration requires that the country you're trying to move to is willing to let you live and work there permanently. I don't know if you're familiar with the difficulties involved in this, but I can assure you they are significant.

Dismissing the loss of freedom inherent in conscription by saying you can avoid it by abandoning your entire life, leaving your country, your job, probably your family behind...even if you do have both the money and a legal path to immigrate somewhere else, which, again, most people do not, that's hardly a reasonable alternative.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by jltsiren on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:07PM (#48699901)
Conscription for wars fought for political purposes is qualitatively different from conscription to defend your country. (But this is a continuum rather than two disjoint categories.) The former happens when the ambitions of the leaders exceed the capabilities of the state. The latter is based on the view that a country is a collective of its citizens, and the citizens are therefore personally responsible for defending it.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by crote on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:29AM (#48698134)
> It wasn’t slavery as they were paid

Being paid some amount of money doesn't magically make it not slavery. Obvious counterpoint: what if a plantation owner "paid" each slave a single modern-day penny a year, would that make it okay?

> and could be expected to be discharged at the cessation of hostilities

Being let go when you're no longer needed doesn't stop it being slavery either. Would you no longer be a slave if the plantation owner released you after the harvest season? You'd just be re-captured for the next harvest, of course - either by the same owner or a different one.

> Conscription is as old as society itself.

So is slavery. That doesn't make it okay.

Definitions of forced labour, like the ILO Forced Labour Convention of 1930 for example, have to explicitly include "by the way, it's totally okay if it is done as part of mandatory military service" clauses for a reason.

There are obviously differences between traditional slavery and conscription, but conscription is still way closer to forced labour than it is to consensual service. Just look at what happens when you try to leave, for one!

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by downrightmike on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:19PM (#48702765)
Last slave was freed in the USA in 1973. Slave masters kept charging for anything and racking up the debt, so they'd never be free
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by dctoedt on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:44AM (#48697402)
> It is called forced labour or slavery.

In war, people who tolerate military conscription and discipline will conquer those who're slaves to pigheaded "you're not the boss of ME!" individualism.

It'd be nice if humans would voluntarily abandon war someday. But a corollary of the First Commandment is to face facts.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by cucumber3732842 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:24AM (#48697636)
That doesn't make it not forced though.

Most of this sub thread people who are unwilling to say "yeah it's forced labor and that's fine considering the details" doing mental gymnastics to make it not forced.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by derektank on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:34AM (#48697699)
Just because something is forced, doesn’t make it slavery. I’m forced to pay taxes; that doesn’t make me a slave. Nor was a tenant farmer in the Middle Ages when required to provide corvée. I think the primary objection in this thread is to the use of the word slavery, which is simply not the same thing.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by bloomingeek on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:45AM (#48697780)
I agree with your account, the problem is how many perceive slavery. Here in the south (USA) many still think the slaves before the Civil War were "happy". They obviously weren't slaves. Until ALL mankind looks slavery fully in the eye for understanding, we will continue to undervalue those other then ourselves.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by throw734848 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:01PM (#48699374)
I remember story how Irish migrants were used to digg deep holes. Walls could collapse any moment, and bury the crew alive. Slaves were deemed too valuable to risk in such jobs!
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by cwmoore on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:11AM (#48697967)
I don’t think there can be a bright line between acceptable and unacceptable coercion of liberties.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by p-e-w on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:01AM (#48698384)
> Nor was a tenant farmer in the Middle Ages when required to provide corvée.

Many historians now concede that there is little to no meaningful difference between various forms of feudal servitude and slavery.

Slaves in the later Roman Empire also had certain rights, including the right to buy their own freedom in many cases. That doesn’t mean they weren’t slaves.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by derektank on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:37PM (#48699660)
I will have to disagree with these historians. There is a fundamental difference between having legal personhood and being chattel. To be bound is not the same thing as to be owned.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by p-e-w on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:15PM (#48699956)
Many, if not most, historical institutions that are universally recognized as slavery didn’t permit slave owners to dispose of their slaves like arbitrary property they owned. If that’s the definition of slavery, it’s an unusually restrictive one.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by mr_toad on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:59PM (#48702996)
> Slaves in the later Roman Empire also had certain rights

Cattle in the USA probably have more legal protections than slaves in the Roman Empire.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by crote on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:36AM (#48698187)
> In war, people who tolerate military conscription and discipline will conquer those who're slaves to pigheaded "you're not the boss of ME!" individualism.

Sure, right up until it leads to fragging. During the Vietnam War about a thousand superiors were killed by their subjects. You can't give someone weapons, try to force them into a suicidal mission, and not expect them to use it to stop the mission. Give someone only a hammer and everything looks like a nail...

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by dctoedt on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:43PM (#48700171)
Yes, that's an edge case — my comment to which you responded was not meant as a complete statement of Reality.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by TomK32 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @08:40AM (#48697740)
In peacetimes, yes, but if it's defensive war I don't see many arguments against a draft, it can't be generalized though.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by crote on Saturday June 27, 2026 @09:30AM (#48698138)
If there's anything worth defending, people will volunteer to defend it.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by esafak on Saturday June 27, 2026 @11:43AM (#48699225)
What if people do but not in enough numbers? Farewell, sweet country!
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by WJW on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:24PM (#48699565)
If the country doesn't have enough people to defend it, perhaps it's good and just that some other community gets to control the territory? A country isn't really anything except for its people, after all.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by esafak on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:16PM (#48699966)
The occupying power may be interested in your country's resources rather than its people.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by WJW on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:54PM (#48700265)
How does that change matters? If anything that makes it even worse. If not enough of your people can't be bothered to join the military even when an enemy army is invading, perhaps the country in question should draw the conclusion it's not viable as an independent nation.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by Jensson on Saturday June 27, 2026 @04:37PM (#48701525)
What happens in those cases is that the majority vote to force everyone to defend the country. Its just easier that way since it means you wont be defending alone, if everyone defends together then its very unlikely the country will fall while if just volunteers does it then almost any country will fall.

Thinking you can defend a country just via volunteers is like thinking you can pay for a country just via charity, we vote to tax everyone for a reason. And people do that voluntarily afterwards, they are fine paying taxes as long as everyone is required to pay, same with defending the country.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by p-e-w on Saturday June 27, 2026 @10:06AM (#48698424)
Indeed, and there are many historical examples of this.

Today’s average Western nation-state tends to be a rathole that spits into the faces of its citizens every single day, until the moment the state is under attack, at which point everyone is told that they owe their lives to their sacred motherland that has done so much for them.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by mitthrowaway2 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @12:25PM (#48699573)
Seems like there's a clear free-rider problem, the volunteers make the sacrifice and the non-volunteers reap the benefits.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by dctoedt on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:47PM (#48700209)
> If there's anything worth defending, people will volunteer to defend it.

That's a pretty binary view of the situation. It's not enough for something to be worth defending: People have to recognize that it's worth defending — and that might not happen instantaneously, because "people" come to appreciate things at very different rates.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by throw734848 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @11:58AM (#48699339)
There is shit ton of opposition, people are literally defending themselves with guns from kidnappers !
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by mrob on Saturday June 27, 2026 @01:18PM (#48699976)
States have a legitimate right to taxation. Taxes can be used to pay volunteers. While there are still people owning wealth above the poverty level, there is no excuse to force people into military slavery. And even if literally everybody has been taxed into poverty, there are more ethical alternatives than slavery, e.g. tying the right to vote to military service like in Starship Troopers. Freedom from slavery is extremely high on the scale of ethical importance, even more important than democracy.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by Jcampuzano2 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @04:29PM (#48701471)
There certainly are arguments against a draft at the individual level - Example being if the people being drafted do not believe in their own governments ability to lead.

A draft is by definition forced labor either way - because if enough people volunteered there would be no need for a draft in the first place.

But usually it doesn't matter either way. Either the people believe in their own government/territory and see it as worth defending, or alternatively they don't believe in it, but their government is authoritarian and will force you at risk of punishment or death into being drafted.

In both cases a draft is still forced labor for those who did not volunteer to participate.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by Jcampuzano2 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @04:32PM (#48701489)
Not sure why this is being downvoted.

A draft is by definition forced labor and a form of slavery. If you are drafted, you are being forced to do something you did not volunteer for.

If enough people volunteered there would be no need for a draft in the first place.

People can argue whether they think its "correct" or not all day, its still forced labor.

Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by mr_toad on Saturday June 27, 2026 @07:55PM (#48702971)
If you’re not conscripted to fight the invaders, there’s always the risk that you’ll be conscripted by the invaders.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by IAmBroom on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @11:33AM (#48734208)
Neither is moral.
Re:The US Army Issued Ocarinas to Soldiers in World War II by mr_toad on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @07:26PM (#48740553)
What part of war is ever moral?