Hard disagree. Rational investors have no problem whatsoever projecting the impact to future cash flows and adjusting the amount they're willing to pay now. That's like saying the stock market wouldn't respond quickly to changes in next year's tax law.
And these things have a lead time of years
You cannot repeal that law, though they try again and again and again.
Markets can remain irrational much longer than you can remain solvent.
He flirted with bankruptcy multiple times.
It might not happen that way - someone does need to check - but at 9 months I wouldn't read much in to this study. The physical market would still be reorganising and it seems entirely possible that the eventual impacts are just different than what this study suggests. I'd want a period of more like 5 years to be confident that the data had given everyone in the market enough time to feel the impacts of artificially low rents and reposition appropriately.
Lot of different ways to say you don't know anything at all. This isn't a new market. This isn't the first time laws have changed in this way. This isn't the first time they've had this effect. We already know all of this. You're just waffling and enjoying the sound of your own voice.
Starting with the assumption that all or even most investors / actors are rational is a continuing pox on both economic scholarship and societal thinking
That's not accounting for the time value of money.
Suppose you have a rental unit and before rent control you were planning to rent it out. That now has far less attractive returns and it suddenly makes more sense to sell it as a condo to an occupant rather than keeping it to rent it out. Likewise, other prospective landlords no longer want to buy it at the previous market price (returns went down and they can invest in stocks or housing in some other city instead), so the short-term effect is to increase the number of property sellers and decrease the number of buyers. Short-term, property values going down is the expected thing.
But construction going down is also the expected thing, for the same reason. If property values are lower then the number of viable construction projects is lower and less construction happens.
The lack of construction then continues until rents, even after rent control, are high enough to justify more construction, i.e. are even higher than they were originally, because now to justify the same investment as before you need the current rent to be high enough to account for the inability to increase it later. And with less construction happening, that's the natural result in a growing area. More people have to bid on the same number of units, rents go up. So the short-term effect is lower real estate prices, the long-term effect is higher.
Now you say, if we expect real estate costs to be higher later, why don't investors take advantage? Which is the "time value of money" issue. If you invest there now because the prices will be high later, what do you do with the property in the meantime? If you don't rent it out, paying $1 today to get $1 in ten or twenty years is dumb, so you only buy if the current price is at a discount. If you do rent it out, then you'd be stuck trying to sell a building with a rent-controlled tenant, which isn't worth as much as the same building as empty as you bought it which you could sell as condos or rent out at current rents instead of price controlled ones, and then you still need a discount. And so the current seller has to provide a discount even if the real estate costs will be higher in a few years.
There's no reason to believe that construction companies would accept jobs at prices below the cost of materials and labor. Construction companies frequently let workers go rather than accept large negative cash flows.
Who's talking about cost of material and labor though?
Not only construction companies make good money, but the price of the land is a significant part of housing cost. And this price is entirely driven by the value of the real estate that will sit on it.
Most of the damage was concentrated in Minneapolis, a little south of the river. But what happens in Minneapolis affects St. Paul, and vice versa. St. Paul wasn't unscathed, either. Property values dipped as a result of the riots, and I'd go find more evidence of that if it wasn't just taken as a fact by the people who live there.
There was also an arson on a construction site in downtown St. Paul later that summer that spooked a lot of folks too.
There's also George Floyd Square, an ad-hoc memorial at the intersection where he was murdered. For reasons beyond me, this was a source of controversy for well over a year, and I know a lot of MN righties who took the city's willingness to leave the memorial there as "capitulating to crime" or something.
In short, don't use Twin Cities property values in the early 2020s to make generalizations about economics or policy. It took years for those scars to heal. Things didn't really go back to normal until 2023 at the absolute earliest, and some things haven't ever gone back to the way they were.
It’s not like he was a hero or anything.
If only Fentanyl Floyd had written HIS OWN CRIMINAL RAP SHEET AS A BOOK, instead of just committing the crimes, he might have been remembered as a criminal who wrote a book.
====•
On August 2, 1997, Floyd was arrested for delivering less than one gram of cocaine to another individual, and he was subsequently sentenced to approximately 6 months in jail.
In 1998, Floyd was convicted of thefts that he committed on September 25 and December 9 of that year. He was sentenced to a total of 10 months and 10 days in jail for those two offenses.
On August 29, 2001, Floyd was sentenced to 15 days in jail for “failure to identify to a police officer,” according to court documents. Specifically, he had refused to give his name, address, or birth date to an officer who was arresting him for reasons that are unknown.
On October 29, 2002, Floyd was arrested for possessing less than one gram of cocaine, and he was subsequently sentenced to approximately 8 months in prison.
On January 3, 2003, Floyd was arrested for criminal trespassing on private property, and he was subsequently sentenced to approximately 30 days in prison.
On February 6, 2004, Floyd was arrested for intending to give less than one gram of cocaine to another individual, and he was subsequently sentenced to approximately 10 months in prison.
On December 15, 2005, Floyd was arrested for having less than one gram of cocaine in his possession, and he was subsequently sentenced to about 10 months in state jail.
In 2009 Floyd was arrested for a 1st-degree felony — assault and armed robbery — in which he had participated on August 9, 2007. In that incident, two adult women — Aracely Henriquez and Angel Negrete — were in a Harris County, Texas home with a toddler when they heard a knock at the front door. When Henriquez looked out the window, she saw a man (Floyd) “dressed in a blue uniform” who said “he was with the water department.” But soon after Henriquez opened the door, she realized that Floyd was not affiliated with the water department, and she attempted to shut the door. But Floyd pressed a pistol against Henriquez’s abdomen and forced his way into the house. At that moment a Ford truck pulled up to the house’s main entrance, and five other black males exited the vehicle and entered the woman’s house along with Floyd. While Floyd and four of these accomplices searched the residence and demanded to know where any money and drugs may have been hidden, the fifth accomplice struck Henriquez on the head and sides with his pistol while she screamed for help. Floyd and his gang ultimately found no cash or drugs in the house, but they stole jewelry and a cellphone before fleeing the scene in their truck. In 2009 Floyd was sentenced to 5 years in prison, but he was eventually paroled in January 2013.
At approximately 8 p.m. on May 25, 2020, someone inside a South Minneapolis convenience store called police to report that Floyd had used a $20 counterfeit bill to buy cigarettes before running outside to a nearby parked vehicle.
What is this character assassination nonsense? To give someone the death penalty you have to go through a trial for a specific crime they did. You can't just shoot first and find excuses later.
Also, where did I “character assassinate” anybody?
Character Assassination: “An attack intended to ruin someone's reputation.”
Artificially holding down rents will result in housing shortages. The lower the rent controlled price, the worse the shortage.
If the rent goes too low, the building owner will stop doing maintenance. Eventually, the building gets abandoned.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S105113772...
Basically if you're in a "rent controlled" unit, you benefit, but live in a dumpster, because the owner don't have the reason to invest in the place.
But the supply of new units is down & all other renters are paying higher rates, because there is no incentive to build new units. NIMBY-ism has the same effect.
No easy solutions here. I do think if rent exceeds half your earnings as a minimum wage worker that’s a failure of the social contract.
Want people to have kids, make it possible to raise them on a working class wage.
Rationally , since it’s impossible to raise a family on what most people make , people aren’t making people anymore. Not at replacement rates anyway.
It will increase the price for new comers, lower the quality of buildings due lack of maintenance funding, and decrease new construction.
Rental control is NIMBY for renters who are already there.
Not always. It can trap the person in the apartment, such as constraining where they can work.
"Trap" here means the deal is so good that they don't ever want to leave.
Yes. I know someone who has a huge rent controlled place in San Francisco and has had it for many decades. Probably worth like 10K/month if you rented it today. I don't know what his rent it, but he says it is so low that he'll never give it up. He no longer lives in San Francisco, lives elsewhere. The SF place gets used occasionally on weekends. So it remains empty, mostly unused, off the rental market because it would be insane to let it go. This is what rent control does. It's great for him and I don't blame him, I'd do the same too. But it's the wrong incentive.
Housing is unused when the revenue from rents is less than the cost of taking care of the renter. Renting out a place can have high costs, like having a bad renter.
Hence, it is less risky to just leave it vacant.
Rent control has all kinds of self-defeating consequences.
They are also headed towards paying more than 50% of whatever income they make to rent that’s the United States, Canada, Great Britain, Australia, New Zealand, and Ireland.
I can’t speak for the other countries, but in United States, the so-called luxury apartment is in fashion, and there is nothing luxury about them, except for the amount of money you will be charged to live there.
The shortage of affordable housing has nothing to do with rent control because over most of the country there is no real rent control effective rent control.
America is the land of luxury apartments currently popping up everywhere. What is also ironic is the fact that there are very few states that have anything like Prop 13 in California, which took a ballot initiative passed by the electorate and was not passed by the legislator’s who supposedly represent the people in short, there will be nothing forthcoming for the majority of people across the country. It’s sink or swim for most you are on your own in poverty.
Oh, it absolutely does. The abandonment of rent properties in NYC is ample evidence.
I don't think rent control is the most efficient solution to the problem, but believing it's a greater problem than the status quo is delusional. The status quo suck, and it mostly sucks because over the past 30 years housing policies in the West have been driven by the belief that markets dynamics are a good way to manage housing.
In the past 30 years, the government has never been more involved in zoning and regulation of housing.
That's just a religious belief of yours. And it's especially off the mark on the “free” part: you can't have a free market for housing, ever, because barriers to entry are always going to be high (and sometimes impossibly high for geometric reasons; there's just so much coastline for instance), and housing is very much not a commodity.
On the flip side, mixed systems in places in most of Europe for several decades after WWII and they were immensely successful. Housing was way more affordable and available back then despite fast growing population and rapidly evolving housing standards that forced owners to constantly invest in their properties to upgrade them.
Dear reader, never believe anyone who says a serious societal problem is "just" anything. Especially on the internet when they use merely a pesudonym to assert their authority.
Especially when the person behind the pseudonym is a one-time washed-out author desperately clinging to their housing stock in Atherton.
It's still the Law of Supply and Demand. Just like F=ma always applies, even if the results are complicated.
What really exists, closest to the limit we will call "hard science" or "physics", is the microcosmic focus on individuals interacting in a market. Everything else -- supply and demand as a theory definitely included -- is a statistical extrapolation from micro-scale interactions. Hence the label of "dismal science". It's dismal because every hardline assumption is inevitably contravened by real life physics.
You've _just_ been told it's not a law.
First, assume a spherical economy in a frictionless vacuum...
(/s)
I’m not clever enough to follow these arguments, but I’m struck by the idea of home prices going down in the face of so much demand. And I think it’s a miracle to have discovered such a lever.
Housing policy debate is not allowed nuance, as unregulated capitalism is the ultimate goal of Humanity.
This seems like too short-term a study. The argument against artificially holding prices down is that people won't produce as much as they would otherwise and people won't be able to get the thing they would otherwise buy. So what we're predicting a rent control policy will do is cause a shortage of rental accommodation in the area.
Now how that expresses itself in an accounting sense, who knows (probably the economists). Good question to study. But I doubt the impacts of rent control would appear in the market this quickly, it'd take years for the market signals to be measurable. Initially rent controls will probably be set near the previously ideal market price, I'd guess there are a lot of 12 month leases and housing construction projects probably don't reset that quickly either.