News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by antirez on Sunday May 31, 2026 @05:51AM (#48344350)
A few years ago, the probability of such shit reaching the Hacker News home page was near zero, because regardless of the merits, here was not full of normies that could not understand when a behavior is unacceptable (I'm referring to the violence of the language of the issue). And now, here we are, surrounded by people that can't tell the most obvious things.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by themgt on Sunday May 31, 2026 @07:09AM (#48344786)
Opening an issue consisting only of some twitter clone screenshot with some "literally who" who found a bug called "Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software" ain't it. That's not a way to tell a maintainer that you disagree with the direction they're taking. This issue is entirely useless. A "fucked up vibe coded" bug report would have been better.

This nailed it. None of the bug reports even attempt to document the claimed "--compare-dest=" regression. I did ctrl-f and I didn't even see anyone mention "compare-dest" again? The people posting worthless AI rage comments could have asked Opus 4.8 to spin up rysnc 3.4.3 vs. 3.4.1, thoroughly document the regression and git bisect the commit that broke it and filed a 1000x more professional and useful bug report.

If you want society to value your human work more than AI work, try to avoid acting like a uniquely human bozo.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by eudamoniac on Sunday May 31, 2026 @11:21AM (#48346417)
They're not mad about the bug, they're mad about the cause of the bug. This is like city council starts flinging stones with a trebuchet into streets, and you're expected to calmly file pothole reports instead of complaining about the trebuchet.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by soerxpso on Sunday May 31, 2026 @01:54PM (#48347919)
Bugs exist in human code too. The AI derangement crowd pounces on any small bug as evidence that AI is a trebuchet, and thinks that if only we didn't use AI there would never be any bugs (like five years ago when all software was perfect, was not being enshittified, and had 0 bugs).
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by bakugo on Sunday May 31, 2026 @03:14PM (#48348738)
> Bugs exist in human code too.

These bugs did not exist in human code. They were introduced by AI.

> thinks that if only we didn't use AI there would never be any bugs

Strawman. These bugs would not exist if not introduced by AI.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by Sacho on Sunday May 31, 2026 @08:08PM (#48351155)
The bugs were introduced because rsync had security issues(i.e. bugs) in it, presumably written into the code by humans.

It's really baffling to see so many people in this thread maintain the position that somehow software was clean and pristine until AI touched it with its evil.

Please try to at least put some sort of constructive argument forward, for example - I don't like AI because it might introduce more bugs than a careful human reviewer. Then we could discuss why a single maintainer is responsible for rsync and how they should handle the pressure of keeping it up to date - should they just stop making further changes, should they look for tools that might help them?

(By the way, if your position is that rsync was perfect before AI got its hands on it, you have a clear solution to all your problems - simply do not update to any newer versions)

Either way, move away from this absolutist nonsense that has no bearing to reality.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by bakugo on Sunday May 31, 2026 @08:48PM (#48351432)
> It's really baffling to see so many people in this thread maintain the position that somehow software was clean and pristine until AI touched it with its evil.

Nobody maintains this position. Again, it's a strawman you made up, because it's easier to dismiss such "absolutist nonsense" than it is to just admit that these specific bugs were introduced as a direct result of careless AI usage.

If the developer is overwhelmed by the maintenance burden (they aren't, judging by how many AI commits they've been making to a large number of repositories), then that's an entirely different problem that deserves a good faith discussion, but delegating the work to AI is not the correct solution.

> By the way, if your position is that rsync was perfect before AI got its hands on it

Again, strawman, nobody said this either. In fact, quite the opposite - we want rsync to continue to be maintained by a human. If the current developer isn't interested in or capable of maintaining the project anymore, they should just say so instead of quietly letting AI take over, because then the likelihood of someone else stepping up to contribute would be much higher.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by weiliddat on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:02AM (#48344403)
Maybe I'm getting too skeptical. I have a feeling increasingly many of the comments on HN and the GitHub issue are just bots ragebaiting other people (incl. the maintainer)...
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by rf15 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:22AM (#48344512)
The fact that you cannot tell the difference anymore speaks for a more fundamental problem in your perception and the world you live in.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by weiliddat on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:30AM (#48344553)
I'm not sure how to interpret your comment. It could be

- a response to my comment saying that I am "illiterate" and cannot differentiate LLM output vs actual human comments (in that case I'm not sure what you're adding to the discussion here beyond a personal attack)

- a general comment saying it's getting harder for people in a position similar to us (i.e. tech / tech-adjacent who interact a lot with others who write with LLM assistance or via LLMs) to differentiate human/AI output.

I'll assume good faith and you mean the second. In that case maybe you can explain the "fundamental problem" you're referring to?

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by rf15 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @02:23PM (#48348219)
It was a general comment. Sorry for being unclear. I'm very bothered by hearing this exact thing a lot lately.

It's something I'm racking my brains over, how some people can tell certain things and intentions apart and others cannot - and how that set is different for everyone, and how this "flaw" is currently causing a lot of trouble because we, collectively, are not very well practiced in detecting this kind of thing.

I don't think the internet is dead just yet, because I don't think anybody truly has the concrete intention to destroy all knowledge.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by weiliddat on Sunday May 31, 2026 @04:06PM (#48349242)
No harm done, glad I clarified.

I'm generally an optimistic person and very trusting of others. I'd say I'm also a pretty good reader of intentions / listener based on people who are my friends / worked with me (anecdotal of course, take it how you will).

However, some of the comments in the GitHub issue... I can only assume the worst of intentions to ruin any/all motivation of the maintainer. Given we've seen social engineering and other attacks on other open source projects with increasing frequency, I can only assume that there are ulterior motives in such comments.

I cannot otherwise see how those comments would be constructive towards the maintainer or the other participants in the issue.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by mhitza on Sunday May 31, 2026 @07:15AM (#48344818)
The way Code of Conducts where being pushed on some open source projects in the past, there was enough vitriol and cross-platform harassment.

This one is "tamer", a bit, because the hate goes towards the AI usage, not the person.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by roxolotl on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:37AM (#48344602)
Describing the issue as “violent” is wild. Reading through a bit, it’s massive, it’s clear no one involved has the moral high ground here. The polite response is to close the issue if you believe it’s genuinely off topic.

Still not quite sure what you mean by obvious because to me “Stop. You know nothing. You have shipped 0 features by hand. No one has ever depended on your code.” Is much more violent than “please do not vibe fuckup this software”.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by craigmart on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:44AM (#48344649)
The "Stop. You know nothing." comment was apparently a reference to this tweet. https://x.com/CodyRhodes/status/980680154098757632

Embarassing nonetheless

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by margalabargala on Sunday May 31, 2026 @09:18AM (#48345457)
That doesn't make it any better. At all.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by dormento on Monday June 01, 2026 @02:03PM (#48360426)
That's some very embarassing american (I guess) defaultism.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by cafebabbe on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:06AM (#48344415)
Love that your comment is ambiguous enough to apply to both sides here :)
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by antirez on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:13AM (#48344467)
Nope my comment is against the folks that are criticizing rsync author. Editing the comment to make it more clear, thanks.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by latexr on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:24AM (#48344522)
I think you’re looking at it through rose-coloured glasses. Controversial issues like this which fall outside regular bug reporting have always been submitted and became popular on HN. And developers are capable of such language, we have a reputation for being rude and even used to have a poster boy for it. Blaming this on “normies” (itself typically a dismissive word) is ignoring the problem has always been there and our responsibility in it.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by bakugo on Sunday May 31, 2026 @06:36AM (#48344593)
Similarly, a few years ago, I would've never expected "my magic code generation machine is doing all my work for me now, I don't even bother looking at what it does anymore!" to reach the Hacker News home page on a regular basis, either, yet here we are.

Irrational actions lead to irrational reactions.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by pacifika on Sunday May 31, 2026 @08:29AM (#48345181)
That’s not how LLMs are used by experienced engineers.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by izacus on Sunday May 31, 2026 @09:59AM (#48345729)
And yet this is exactly how it was used for rsync which caused the outrage you're all complaining about.

You're being dishonest with what you wrote when the proof is literally in this article.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by RugnirViking on Monday June 01, 2026 @10:19AM (#48357189)
its not an article, its a github issue. There is no proof, someone posted a screenshot of another person on twitter complaining about a vague bug they experienced. It's certainly not clear the maintainer used an llm in the way described (how would you know unless they told you?). Its not even clear what issues there are specifically, or whether they were caused by ai usage.
Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by ofjcihen on Sunday May 31, 2026 @09:10AM (#48345406)
You could also say that about using dismissive language like “normies”.

Regarding it reaching the front page: is it possible that’s because others feel the same way about a software they might use daily for important work?

Trite as the gh issue is and surely this is thankless work, the bottom line and reality is that rsync is a cornerstone for a lot of sensitive pipelines.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by stevenally on Monday June 01, 2026 @04:14PM (#48362032)
"Trite as the gh issue is and surely this is thankless work, the bottom line and reality is that rsync is a cornerstone for a lot of sensitive pipelines".

Maybe don't piss off the maintainer then?

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by ofjcihen on Monday June 01, 2026 @05:29PM (#48362898)
Maintainers aren’t infallible. Could he have been nicer? Sure. But we don’t need to walk on eggshells around maintainers.

That’s stupid and inefficient.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by 123ahsg6 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @09:57AM (#48345722)
Says the guy who is all in on AI because his company wants to sell vector databases or whatever else AI related.

Your credibility is gone by now.

Re:Please Do Not Vibe Fuck Up This Software – Rsync by moi2388 on Sunday May 31, 2026 @12:12PM (#48346884)
There is no violence in the language. Violence is intentional use of physical force.