News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by thunfischtoast on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @07:24AM (#48292542)
AI makes it apparent that the only value some people bring to the table is that they have access to information that you do not. If now they fold that one advantage by just delegating everything to AI (which is in the same position as you informationwise), they will remove themselves from the worker pool soon.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by onlyrealcuzzo on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @07:39AM (#48292701)
Try prompting Claude to fix an arbitrary code base better than someone who knows it, when you're a random non-technical person.

Try prompting Claude for legal advice and getting as good of results as Lawyer would if you're a layperson.

Try prompting Claude for medical advice if you're not a doctor...

I would hope these people are AT A MINIMUM screening the responses they get before passing them off. There's value in that if they are, as if they really are experts they can filter out bs and reprompt better than you likely could if you're not an expert - and in rare cases, who knows, maybe they could actually do it themselves.

AI is just going to speed run bringing out the best and worst in coworkers.

There have always been people that did the absolute bare minimum to not get fired.

AI will just make it more obvious.

And those people will be at the front to be let go when AI inevitably kills white collar jobs as it creates other jobs. They just might not be able to get one of those new ones because they rotted what little brain cells they had to begin with.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by embedding-shape on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @07:44AM (#48292765)
> I would hope these people are AT A MINIMUM screening the responses they get before passing them off

The co-founder of Anthropic isn't even doing this when preparing statements to say after the Pope has spoken about AI, I think you're expecting a bit too much here.

Don't get me wrong, I definitely think that's a must too, but I also think people should test software extensively before deploying/releasing it, seemingly nowadays I'm in the minority about these sort of things.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by mittensc on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @08:05AM (#48292983)
I find your comment a bit funny

> Try prompting Claude to fix an arbitrary code base better than someone who knows it, when you're a random non-technical person.

I've seen people employed working on some code bases that couldn't code at all.

> Try prompting Claude for legal advice and getting as good of results as Lawyer would if you're a layperson.

Some lawyers are downright incompetent and don't know what they're talking about / just want your money.

> Try prompting Claude for medical advice if you're not a doctor...

Some doctors are downright incompetent or malicious. You'd generally find that out by vising another doctor and finding previous diagnostic was bullshit and you lost time.

> AI is just going to speed run bringing out the best and worst in coworkers.

It does help people overall, the worst coworkers are probably going to still be there, just a bit better hidden.

The rest just have a new-age search engine to augment their capabilities.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by dominotw on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @08:40AM (#48293364)
ai good cos some ppl bad.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by throw4847285 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:50AM (#48294365)
I've been calling it the "AI argument from misanthropy" but that's way more succinct. Thanks.

What really drives me crazy is how laden it is with negative emotions, and then people pretend it's just a rational assessment of the world. I was told growing up that if you're anxious or negative, it's just because you are smart and you understand how terrible everything is, while stupid people are happy. Seems like a lot of people got a similar message, and now they're shilling AI.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by scotty79 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:14AM (#48293813)
AI good cos vastly better than most people at most verbal tasks.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by glouwbug on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:26AM (#48294004)
Those low quality lawyers and doctors are still vastly more capable than a layperson at verifying AI output
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by mittensc on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:28AM (#48294037)
Those low quality lawyers/doctors still won't care enough to help the layperson.

So for the layperson, the AI output is still useful. They'll know to search for a different lawyer/doctor.

Tool just brings more knowledge to regular people.

It's like discovering search engine 20+ years ago.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by glouwbug on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @10:04AM (#48294578)
The whole point is that the layperson is not classically trained to know right from wrong which is the entire thesis of knowledge share. Even post doctorate students are required to have their work peer reviewed. It’s why anthropic and OpenAI put disclaimers below their chat prompts
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by Tade0 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:51AM (#48294379)
> Those low quality lawyers/doctors still won't care enough to help the layperson.

I had a pediatrician who I regarded as generally low quality until she correctly identified scarlet fever in my child, while AI and a doctor in training we knew didn't.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by dominotw on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @02:53PM (#48298769)
> who I regarded as generally low quality

how did you come up with this assessment

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by scotty79 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:47AM (#48294329)
Recently someone I know came up with a statement "AI is like opening borders, like abolishing visas."

I think it's very perceptive and you can even view reactions to AI through that lens. Somehow both, the "immigrants" are taking our jobs but they are way worse than all of us at them. And the people from outside any given domain (art, coding, law) that advent of AI suddenly let into it, marvel at this land of opportunities, empowerment and self-reliance that used to be outside of their reach before that.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by Tade0 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:44AM (#48294281)
> You'd generally find that out by vising another doctor and finding previous diagnostic was bullshit and you lost time.

To be fair the human body is immensely complex. Every specialist will look at everything through the lens of their field, as at the very least they can rule out some things this way.

I had a doctor judge that my tonsils need to be removed, but for unrelated reasons I went to two other and both of them figured it's not as bad yet.

The difference between them was generational, as the first practiced an approach from 30 years ago, back when tonsils were indeed commonly removed.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by mittensc on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @10:09AM (#48294658)
I've seen doctors that:

1. Immediately said 'Cancer' to stomach issues on an old person. They just didn't care, another doctor resolved that.

2. Eye doctors that would not investigate anything and just prescribe eye glasses and would recommend local companies that they owned or had a stake in.

3. Fake gynecologists that did C-Sections brutally without any experience

4. Fake plastic surgeons with no experience just going by word of mouth taking rich peoples money

5. Fertility doctors doing human egg-trafficking.

6. General doctors forcing appendectomy if under-18s came to the hospital with any stomach complains (they could not refuse, doctor got money for the surgery)

Sure, human body is complex. That wasn't my point.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by Tade0 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @11:21AM (#48295700)
Where I'm from half of these points mean actual jail time for the physician attempting them, most of the rest (like kickbacks) result in standing in front of an ethics committee.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by sillyfluke on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @05:00PM (#48300605)
In what context did you witness all these cases?

It's one thing to know these cases exist because they all have been reported in the news or having made a note of it through separate and unrelated word of mouth interactions, but one person having direct experience of all these cases is unusual for a civilian (ie non-medical or healthcare professional).

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by mittensc on Friday May 29, 2026 @05:13PM (#48329351)
3 would be either direct or friends/relatives with experience and I got involved to help, other 3 would be through news and incidentally knowing some people.

> but one person having direct experience of all these cases is unusual for a civilian

Sure, still, indirect stories I have a lot more, just stopped at those 6

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by cryptonym on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @08:00AM (#48292936)
I mostly use it because I'm lazy on the presentation, not so much on the content. I provide full knowledge and content plan in my prompt. I do manual review & fix.

Someone informed can tell the content is generated. I don't really care, that's still my knowledge and I can discuss content in depth.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by Laurel1234 on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @12:24PM (#48296596)
If you can't even be fucked to write your great knowledge nobody will be fucked to read it.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by cryptonym on Thursday May 28, 2026 @08:53AM (#48308249)
It provides far better illustration than I can draw. I can focus on solutions while iterating quicker on presentation.

TBH I don't care much people not reading it "because it's AI". It's just work, if you don't need it then don't use it. That fine for me, no hard feeling.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by jerf on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @08:40AM (#48293360)
If you're in a particularly fiesty mood you can lean into that. "If all you are is a proxy to an AI, exactly what value are you adding to the organization?"

While most of us actually commenting are obviously firmly on the "don't do this" side, for any lurkers who may have done this in the recent past or are considering doing it in the future, I would advise you to consider this point for your own actions. If all you are is an AI proxy, you are volunteering to step to the front of the firing line. For all that companies are just starting to recoil from the costs of AI, AI is still much cheaper than you are.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by hectdev on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @11:45AM (#48296005)
I'll give the counter example:

I'm currently leading the adoption of AI at my company and given my extensive use of it both at work and in my personal life, my value at the company has risen as someone that knows how to get the most out of the tool. The whispers are towards needing to get more people to move as fast as I can with the subtle implication that not using AI is seen as less productive or at least slower.

Not saying I know for a fact where all this lands in the future but both view points are at play right now but I would push back that people are just being proxy for AI, they are learning how to get the most out of every interaction to get to the next step of decision making which, for now, is still a very human intervention.

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by jerf on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @01:06PM (#48297199)
If you are taking AI output and interactively working with it to come to some particular solution, that process of working with it is the value you are adding. The "AI proxy" is specifically about the case where you send a question to someone and literally all they do is paste it to the AI, then send back what the AI said without further work. Literally all they did was proxy your question to the AI.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by hectdev on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @02:41PM (#48298576)
Yea, but that's just a straw man argument mixed with a little No-True Scotsman. How do you know those people aren't just learning how to use AI and will change over time to be early adopters adapt and using the tool to get work done faster.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by nitwit005 on Thursday May 28, 2026 @02:23AM (#48305324)
If you go back to the article being discussed, the core issue is people not even reading the output. You can't learn from blind copy pasting.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by hectdev on Thursday May 28, 2026 @09:54AM (#48309000)
I'm aware of the article. My point is it may be catching a slice of the person's full journey with AI. When I started using it, I blind copied and pasted all the time. Heck, I had a job interview that allowed me to use AI to build an app and I just flat prompted "build out this" and never refined. If you judged me only from that period, you'd miss out that now I am able to iterate, refine, to build a robust program and can spin off tasks with the knowledge that I need to understand what I'm letting it implement before just accepting it.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by engeljohnb on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @01:40PM (#48297696)
Do you find talking to an AI with your colleagues as a middleman faster than talking to your colleagues?
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by hectdev on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @02:39PM (#48298559)
Sometimes, yes. Some coworkers ramble and give too much information, some leave out information. Sometimes there's a bit of a language barrier. If I can get to the nugget of what needs to be communicated and understood, it can be faster. But also, sometimes just having a conversation/meeting and having a transcript to break things down via AI is convenient and fast.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by engeljohnb on Friday May 29, 2026 @08:08AM (#48322087)
Fair enough, though my experience is that AI is much more prone to rambling than my colleagues are.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by woah on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @12:15PM (#48296480)
"If all you are is a proxy to an AI, exactly what value are you adding to the organization?"

Prompt Engineering

Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by dogwalker5000 on Thursday May 28, 2026 @06:26AM (#48307005)
Prompt engineering is such a weird thing. Isn’t interacting with AI using natural language one of its main selling point? You don’t have to learn an artificial query / programming language.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by tardedmeme on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @09:35AM (#48294146)
Organizations will become even less about adding real value and more about making the boss feel good about you.
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by andai on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @10:02AM (#48294550)
So the oldest strategy becomes the newest strategy...
Re:I'm Tired of Talking to AI by batshit_beaver on Wednesday May 27, 2026 @11:56AM (#48296166)
Always has been tbh