I am having trouble seeing how this could even mathematically be true. Even given how much easier talent acquisitions are to do, most of the companies in a portfolio won't even get that far. The majority still fail outright. Many talent acquisitions don't even recoup dollars invested; how could they possibly pay for the losers?
So if those numbers still hold true then the bulk of a VC's portfolio (by investments, not dollars) is boosted by the availability of talent acquisitions.
On a side note, Fred Wilson has responded to this thread below[2,3,4,5].
[1] http://www.danshapiro.com/blog/2010/08/vc-insanity-economics...
[2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4828933
[3] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4828936
http://uncrunched.com/2012/08/26/investors-dont-like-acqui-h...
This is wrong. Remember the power law! The vast majority of the value of a VCs portfolio will be represented by their 1 or 2 most successful investments.
(This is probably a violation of their fiduciary duty to represent the shareholders, but who is going to sue?)
†(most of those incidents started with the company encouraging departing employees to purchase their shares)
I've never met a VC who was excited about a talent acquisition. Maybe a very early angel, but this is not what most VCs are looking for.
If your downside is now 1x rather than losing everything, that's a major win for investors. Eliminating downside does not suck.
That said, I think there may be room in this space for some competition. What if you had groups of friends that wanted to work together, but not necessarily take on the risk of a startup? What if you could have some sort of way to develop side projects together in a blatant attempt to market the team, not the product?
The convention wisdom says this is important to understand for at least two reasons:
(i) You aren't going to make a compelling pitch to a VC by focusing on the likelihood of a 1x-2x return, since you'd essentially be pitching a failure to them.
(ii) A 1x-2x return may be lifechanging for you, but since it's essentially a failure for your investors, they will tend to tack your company away from those returns and towards much riskier strategies.
If you think 1x is a major win, you should consider avoiding VCs.
This isn't true. Consumers happily pay for a lot of other things that web companies / tech startups offer: - content & entertainment (hulu, netflix, nytimes) - personal finance (lending club, esurance) - dating (match, eharmony) - ecommerce (bonobos, zappos) - gifts (FB, redenvelope)
In fact, I'd guess there are probably a lot of offline consumer spend buckets that will come online in the next few years if they haven't already.
Perhaps we're quibbling over semantics on how "hard" it is... but trends seem to indicate it is becoming far easier.
I bet that every finance group has a magic Excel spreadsheet that someone built for them years ago. But no one in the office knows how to engineer it anymore, so they keep duct taping little bits here and there to make it adapt to the business years later.
A social networking website can be down for a day for a few users and nobody will care. With enterprise software, that could be a deal-breaker. If engineers have to be woken up at night, then they will be.
You're right that enterprise is about sales, whereas consumer is about marketing. It actually affects the company as a whole more than you might think. Heavily marketed consumer-focused companies never seem to stop marketing themselves. Even in the cafeteria, you're bombarded with the marketing about how this is the best company EVAR and all the cool people are here, etc. Sales is more about relationships and building trust. There are some bad aspects to both, but on the whole I think I prefer a sales-focused company.
Generally speaking, I think enterprise apps are simply easier to deliver than successful consumer apps (most consumer apps aren't successful and nothing is easier to deliver than an app nobody uses). There's a bunch of reasons for this:
(i) famously, the person making the purchasing decision for most enterprise apps isn't the eventual user, so to make sales and achieve usage you need please only during demos;
(ii) the bar is much lower in the enterprise because you are generally solving money problems (increasing revenue or decreasing costs/headcount); most enterprise software is clunky, and the software virtually never delights, but for the most part the line-of-business software deployments I've worked with tend to make lots of money;
(iii) the fit/finish and scale problems that HN people hyperfocus on simply tend not to be problems enterprises pay to solve; also, once a firm verifies for itself that it'll realize a return on a deployment, it'll tend to be happier to simply scale up its Oracle deployment rather than trying to be clever with how it persists data.
(iv) a six figure pilot deployment pays for a whole lots of hardware, and successive purchases, which tend to happen after the firm verifies that the software is worth something to them, are even more expensive.
(iv) relatedly: the financial metric most enterprise software is benchmarked against is "fully loaded headcount cost", which, wow, is a much nicer benchmark to have than "$5/mo" or (worse) $2.99 "premium" app store app.
I think these things tend to add up to enterprise software being much, much easier to build and deploy, even if you want to believe that there's some countervailing cost of additional testing (I actually don't buy that enterprises really demand a higher standard of testing, either).
Things like Yammer and Salesforce are practically the exception that proves the rule; the very rare app that needs to scale multitenant across every company in the world. And a gargantuan swath of the entire Fortune 500 could care less about salesforce management.
Businesses will often refuse to buy from companies they regard as likely to disappear in a few years-- unfortunately, most startups tend to get lumped into this category by default. The burden of proof is on you to prove otherwise. (This is rational behavior on their part, by the way.) Managers are naturally conservative. They know that signing a slightly too-expensive deal with, say Oracle (to pick a random example), won't get them fired-- but signing a deal with some startup that fails to deliver surely will end their career.
Finally, there's the problem that because sunk costs in existing systems are often high, it can be hard to break into a market. This is what keeps COBOL and even FORTRAN chugging away in corners of the world. Costs might be lower a few years after replacing these systems-- but then again, they might not. It depends on who you get to put in the replacement, and if you have trouble telling the good developers from the bad, maybe you are better off not touching it. Building and deploying is one thing. Selling is quite another, and it's not easy or cheap. Forget about word-of-mouth and friends-of-friends.
Do enterprises demand a higher standard of testing? I think it depends on what your product does. I work in enterprise storage, so for us there absolutely is a higher standard of testing. I can't speak for other applications, though.
Things like Yammer and Salesforce are practically the exception that proves the rule; the very rare app that needs to scale multitenant across every company in the world.
Yeah, but that's where the fun is for engineers. And in time, companies like these will reduce the need for so many companies to build custom solutions.
Do you have any numbers to show that? I'm fairly positive you are wrong here.
Getting enterprise customers to pay serious money is somewhat of a pain. It's a costly and long sales cycle. Not to mention the margins are increasingly getting worse (both from software vendors, i.e. SaaS, and service vendors, i.e. outsourcing). Then couple that with increasingly changing buying behaviors and pricing models (consumerization of IT) and it's not all roses.
-- FYI [2x to 5x] are ~wins, not bailouts.
Portfolio returns in the aggregate of 20%+ are fine. A 2x on 1 year investment, for example, is outstanding performance. But overall, HR acquisitions are "operational failures" for the founder and the VC, and nothing to boast about. You're startup has only proved it can out-perform the HR department of a Big-Co. Not hard to do with a pile of cash, really.
Take Chris Dixon's post [1] as an example. He's now a VC. He wants to diminish the stigma around talent acquisitions. Why? Because that's how VCs get paid in the vast majority of cases. Those big wins when a company goes public are pretty rare. Big acquisitions? Also relatively rare. Most are 1x-5x "bailouts" I would guess.
Paul Graham's most recent essay [2] was excellent but remember this site exists as a funnel for YC finding teams and companies to invest in.
So, to address Fred's points:
> 1) the consumer web has matured
This is a strange argument. It wasn't mature 2 years ago? 3? Twitter and Pinterest (which he mentions) did get a "standing start".
> 2) the consumer is moving from desktop/web to mobile/app
The trend in recent years has been for startup costs to be going down. $50,000 can buy you a lot of Web development and hosting these days. Labour costs (engineers) are probably going up. Everything else is much cheaper.
Mobile seems to buck this trend. I imagine the cost of developing a Web site plus apps for Android and iOS is significantly more expensive. Well it must be by definition because you still need the Web site (in most cases). It's partly why people will target one platform first (typically iOS).
> 3) the momentum/late stage investors have moved from consumer to enterprise
This is a symptom and it seems to be the elephant in the room that Fred isn't mentioning: the consumer Web space is crowded.
To draw from PG's essay, enterprise has both the "schlep" and "unsexy" factors going for it and it's an area that, depending your market, can be hard to penetrate but also far easier to get paying customers. It's hard to extract money from consumers except for three things: games, advertising and, to a certain extent, hardware.
I've thought for at least 2-3 years that if I were to start a startup it'd be somewhere in enterprise space. The fact that VC funding is, according to Fred, going there too just confirms that.
> But it is a tougher time for early stage consumer internet companies than I have seen since the 2001-2004 time frame.
This to me was the strangest point of all. 2001-2004 were on the whole terrible. But it's still way cheaper now making bootstrapping just that much more viable than it ever was 10 years ago.
To me this is just more evidence that we're not in a bubble because the VC "market" is acting quite rationally. For every Instagram there are a hundred failures and many more acqui-bailouts. Yet many people--too many people (IMHO)--are working on shit that just doesn't matter ("it's a social network... for cats!" as the cliche goes) in a very crowded space and most are going to be disappointed.
What I believe Fred is doing here is signalling that he (and by extension USV) are interested in non-consumer startups. They don't want to come out and say "we're not interested in consumer startups" as that'll put them at a disadvantage when it comes to funding hot startups/teams.
I agree: enterprise and even infrastructure (particularly cloud-related infrastructure) seem to have stronger opportunities than consumer web (IMHO).
[1]: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4825418
[2]: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4806852