If your downside is now 1x rather than losing everything, that's a major win for investors. Eliminating downside does not suck.
That said, I think there may be room in this space for some competition. What if you had groups of friends that wanted to work together, but not necessarily take on the risk of a startup? What if you could have some sort of way to develop side projects together in a blatant attempt to market the team, not the product?
The convention wisdom says this is important to understand for at least two reasons:
(i) You aren't going to make a compelling pitch to a VC by focusing on the likelihood of a 1x-2x return, since you'd essentially be pitching a failure to them.
(ii) A 1x-2x return may be lifechanging for you, but since it's essentially a failure for your investors, they will tend to tack your company away from those returns and towards much riskier strategies.
If you think 1x is a major win, you should consider avoiding VCs.
I've never met a VC who was excited about a talent acquisition. Maybe a very early angel, but this is not what most VCs are looking for.