The reason for walling a garden is to create a microclimate that protects the garden from the wind. It's like a greenhouse. It's protection for species that would otherwise not survive in the area.
The way to get non-walled technology is government intervention. That's how the internet was invented. Then, as it was deployed and commercialized, it "won out" because it was open, while services like AOL, Delphi, GEnie, Prodigy, Apple's eWorld, CompuServe, and MSN were closed, walled garden online services.
Cognitive dissonance is painful!
In real life, you pull the weeds or specifically target them with pesticide. A wall is too granular of a filter to keep weeds out.
In software, the most successful filters -- such as e-mail spam filters --- specifically target malfeasors. A "wall" type of solution to e-mail would instead only trust e-mails from specific domains or recast the problem as "Facebook messages", eliminating interoperability.
Walls don't exist to keep out weeds, they exist to keep out neighbors or poachers -- aka, competitors.
> There is a reason walled gardens work.
Amazing, how often this is forgotten. And way to often the attitude on HN is similar to that in Orwell's farm: "four legs are good, two legs are bad". Walled garden? Bad. Open? Good.
The truth however is that goodness or badness is not defined by this.The original idea of some magical screen you walk up to with all of these abilities and none of the limitations of walled gardens is also wishful thinking; however it doesn't go so far as to claim it's an example of how to accomplish this.
I was using an example I figured everyone around here would be familiar enough with to extrapolate the possibilities. If it actually existed, we wouldn't be wishing for it to happen. The whole point is that it's *not" "magical", it's completely possible, yet it doesn't actually exist.
Your NFC idea is a lot more plausible than the original idea.
Sorry if I came off as hostile, it was a miscommunication.
Story of the internet, really. I get down-voted a lot on Reddit because people confuse my directness for hostility. I've tried couching my arguments with a more passive voice but sometimes it becomes too much of a hassle.
How is it supposed to recognize you, but then have no clue or trail that you were even there?
The tech community is smarter than this. Location-free, hardware-free, non-walled technology is the goal. Let's start going there.
And who's going to pay for the platform to do all of that?
How do you keep the weeds out of your garden? Simple, build a wall. There is a reason walled gardens work.