Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by chongli on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:35PM
(#4823760)
Sure, I can envision that. But that's not what the original idea was. It was a box which recognized you (presumably via some form of computer vision). How could such a device work without having a database to match against people's identities?
Your NFC idea is a lot more plausible than the original idea.
Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by freehunter on Friday November 23, 2012 @05:28PM
(#4823885)
I had read the original post as being open to the authentication method of choice. What you describe is certainly one authentication method (inherence, aka what you are or do). Most common is knowledge, aka a password or unique URL. NFC would be ownership, or what you have. Two of these would allow you to keep your own database. I guess the confusion came from our different interpretations of what the original poster meant by "recognize". I linked recognition with authentication, of which there are three methods to be used, and picked the most likely in my mind. I'm knee deep in authentication principles most of the day.
Sorry if I came off as hostile, it was a miscommunication.
Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by chongli on Friday November 23, 2012 @07:15PM
(#4824129)
>Sorry if I came off as hostile, it was a miscommunication.
Story of the internet, really. I get down-voted a lot on Reddit because people confuse my directness for hostility. I've tried couching my arguments with a more passive voice but sometimes it becomes too much of a hassle.
I was using an example I figured everyone around here would be familiar enough with to extrapolate the possibilities. If it actually existed, we wouldn't be wishing for it to happen. The whole point is that it's *not" "magical", it's completely possible, yet it doesn't actually exist.