News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by kintamanimatt on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:05PM (#4819981)
Most important part of the article: "What’s happening now is going to spread across the country," Whitehead said. "If you can start early in life getting people accustomed to living in surveillance society then in future it'll be a lot easier to roll these things out to the larger populace."
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mtgx on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:22PM (#4820051)
That's kind of how it happened in UK with the CCTV cameras, I think. I don't think that future generations will be bothered by them anymore, unless the Government does something terrible and oppressive with them and the people find out and revolt about it. Then they might be up for discussion again, and someone who opposes them could get enough political support to remove them.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mibbitier on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:47PM (#4820131)
Please don't peddle the "UK CCTV" bullshit. It's simply not true.

CCTV in the UK is widespread in large cities, but operated by individual shop owners, and has been since the 80s when cameras became cheap enough. There is no big government CCTV operation. Closest thing is probably the London congestion charge cameras, or individual towns who decide to install their own to cut down on crime.

And if you go out of the cities, you can go forever without seeing a CCTV camera.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by sambeau on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:10PM (#4820838)
I worked on the original 1990s UK CCTV research.

The UK CCTV is widespread in large cities and operated BY THE POLICE FORCE. It is also on most major roads: look for the blue cameras.

CCTV does not 'cut down crime' in fact it does the opposite: it increases crime by a small but measurable effect.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by irahul on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:23PM (#4820860)
> CCTV does not 'cut down crime' in fact it does the opposite: it increases crime by a small but measurable effect.

Do you know why CCTV increases crime?

I am not doubting your argument. I am militantly opposed to 1984esque surveillance. I am just curious.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by sambeau on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:26AM (#4821535)
It's fairly simple.

A crime is just a crime statistic. The more police you have the more crimes are recorded so crime goes up. CCTV is like adding an extra cop (sitting in front of 30 cameras).

CCTV generally does not deter any crimes but it acts on the the kind of crimes that are usually ignored: mostly public order offences linked to alcohol.

CCTV operators spend their nights following couples and women hoping to see sex acts. Occasionally they spot someone urinating against a wall and call the cops.

Urinators, drunken vandals, soliciting prostitutes are seen and logged where they would mostly be ignored—crime goes up.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by ramblerman on Friday November 23, 2012 @02:59PM (#4823447)
Did you just try to argue that CCTVs actually cause more crime because "cctv records more crimes so crimes go up".

I don't particularly like CCTVs but this is terribly weak reasoning however you try to twist it. This is akin to me arguing a new cancer test actually causes cancer because we now detect more cases of cancer.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by sambeau on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:48PM (#4823783)
There is more subtlety in my comment than that.

Most people and politicians generally do not understand the difference between a measurable statistic and a physical event. Often in the eye of the law and the lawmakers there is none. Everything you know about crime at a macro-level is actually knowledge of a crime statistic.

Millions of pounds of CCTV cameras were sold on the back of my study that showed a 33% drop in crime that was in fact caused by the simultaneous removal of one of the three police officers patrolling the area. A subsequent study that took this effect into account and showed a 3% rise in crime was buried so as not to embarrass the politicians who ordered the expensive equipment.

Usually a rise in crime is statistics while a fall in crime is good policing. Similarly, politicians call for a 10% drop in cancer deaths but never tell us which death-rates they want to go up to compensate.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jlgreco on Thursday November 22, 2012 @11:09PM (#4820939)
My guess, and I share your attitude towards surveillance, is that installing CCTV cameras increases crime in the same way that broadening the legal definition of rape "increases" the number of rapes.

That is to say, more things are counted than before. Although CCTV cameras may not help solve crimes (I don't know if they do or not), perhaps they make it easier to count crimes.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by sambeau on Saturday November 24, 2012 @11:42AM (#4825624)
Pretty much spot on.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by JohnTh on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:39AM (#4821581)
> Do you know why CCTV increases crime?

1. See "Perceived security compared to real security" at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security

2. CCTV moves the community's mindset on a crime/non-crime level - "You are (or not) a criminal", "You are a suspect until proven the contrary" (aso.) - and this generates thoughts which aren't always good ones ranging from curiosity/challenge ("wh/if I'll try to overcome this...") till repulsion. An educational way of keeping the criminality rate low is way better than "Big Brother" way. Note, that I don't preach Anarchism here but another way of community management. The force and surveillance must be in the background.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by ZoFreX on Friday November 23, 2012 @07:01AM (#4821920)
The blue cameras on main roads are for congestion tracking.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by switch007 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:14PM (#4820849)
ANPR (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recogni...) is a big mass surveillance operation.

"The UK has an extensive (ANPR) automatic number plate recognition CCTV network. Effectively, the police and security services track all car movements around the country and are able to track any car in close to real time. Vehicle movements are stored for 5 years in the National ANPR Data Center to be analyzed for intelligence and to be used as evidence."

"What we're trying to do as far as we can is to stitch together the existing camera network rather than install a huge number of new cameras," - Mr Whiteley chairman of the ANPR steering committee said"

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by alan_cx on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:58PM (#4820333)
What you describe is the privatisation of CCTV. Yes it is owned by the likes of shopkeepers, but all of it is accessible by the state on demand. So I'm afraid its not bullshit at all. Its just not owned by the government. That should be nice and safe, right? When you get don to it, its rather clever.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by im3w1l on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:07PM (#4820361)
That makes a huge difference though. You have to go out and talk to people and ask for tapes. That ownership structure makes many automations very hard which is a good thing. Routinely scanning for suspicious activity? Nope. Automatically follow a single person from one camera to the next? Nope.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by ZoFreX on Friday November 23, 2012 @07:02AM (#4821924)
> Yes it is owned by the likes of shopkeepers, but all of it is accessible by the state on demand

Yes, if they walk into the shop with a warrant and ask to see their tapes. They can't track us all walking around in realtime, which is a huge distinction.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by lelandbatey on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:23PM (#4820229)
I'd like to expand on your point. There seems to be a misconception that most/all cctv cameras are operated by the government. Currently, and nearly all cameras are owned and operated by private parties, and such as shop owners. No one but the owners have access to the footage from these cameras, and and in fact most are set up to record to static media (tapes or hard drives).
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by keithpeter on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:33PM (#4820252)
I take your point, but there was a little local difficulty in Birmingham UK recently with Police operated CCTV with car number plate recognition.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2010/oct/25/birmingham-cctv-mus...

Of course, CCTV simply pushes street crime away from the central areas.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday November 22, 2012 @07:15PM (#4820519)
>CCTV simply pushes street crime away from the central areas //

I've heard that argued for many years but never seen the stats. Do you have a reference for us?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by keithpeter on Friday November 23, 2012 @12:49PM (#4823009)
Good challenge - mixed results...

"Mixed findings: Birmingham 14 CCTV cameras in the city centre in the early 1990s failed to reduce overall crime levels. However, recorded crime statistics indicate that CCTV reduced robbery and theft from persons, whilst incidences of theft from vehicles rose. The CCTV system was not designed to target vehicle related crime and so was not installed in many car parks. There was some displacement of crime to surrounding areas. Surveys of the public before and after CCTV installation found little change in general feelings of safety for those using the city centre during the day. Nevertheless, for those using the city centre after dark there was an increase in feelings of safety amongst those aware of the CCTV cameras. It is not clear whether these effects were a direct result of CCTV as the area was also redeveloped at the same time."

from http://www.parliament.uk/post/pn175.pdf

The source cited in that summary in reference [3] is no longer available at the Web address given but is available from

http://library.npia.police.uk/docs/hopolicers/fcdps68.pdf

pages 40 to 57 of that second reference contain a detailed discussion of some statistics from 20 years ago in Birmingham city centre, a location I know well. Once sentence on page 50 seems to suggest displacement of street crime to car theft, only as a suggestion. However the whole section gives you an idea of how hard it is to be definite about displacement or reduction in a city centre subject to shifting building patterns and traffic routing.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday November 24, 2012 @07:41PM (#4826940)
Thanks. I'd imagine that there would be a noticeable shift in reported crime from areas of higher CCTV concentration to those [local] areas with lower CCTV concentration. It seems that there were no particularly clear displacement effects in the case-studies in that first doc¹.

The second doc² appears to make no clearer claims on displacement either.

Mind you we've 17 years more data now and there must be several areas where CCTV has been installed, removed (or deactivated) and possibly reinstalled.

There really must be better citations than this around. I've no time to dig for them now but these don't convince me that displacement is, if anything, more than a minor effect. Moreover those docs show a shift from direct personal robbery/theft to theft from vehicles; I'd expect that would result in less bodily harm overall at the expense of broken windows and bent door frames, probably a good result.

- - -

¹ http://www.parliament.uk/post/pn175.pdf, 2002

² http://library.npia.police.uk/docs/hopolicers/fcdps68.pdf, 1995

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by dogonwheels on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:28PM (#4820239)
Nothing more than anecdote, but hey:

My Yorkshire village has a playground. They installed CCTV last month. More people complain about the main road changing from a 40mph to 30mph. I don't care if the 'they' is government or centralised or whatever. The numbness to surveillance unsettles me greatly.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mibbitier on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:33PM (#4820250)
What do you think they're doing with the CCTV?

They're almost certainly recording to a VHS tape, which cycles every couple of days.

IF some crime or vandalism happens on the playground, they will then grab the tapes, and check them. The chances of a conviction will be far higher with video evidence.

It's not "numbness to surveillance", because it's not really surveillance.

If you want to be free to take videos and photos of random places/things without being arrested, you should also allow that same freedom to owners of property who want to reduce crime.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jlgreco on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:39PM (#4820281)
I think an important realization is that the public is not generally okay with CCTV installations when they find out they are the recycling VHS type. They are okay with them by default, and don't even bother asking.

I suspect that if you stop random people on the street, point to a camera, and ask them "What kind of camera is that?" the most common response will be along the lines of "I don't know, who cares?" These would presumably be the same people who don't pay CCTV cameras any mind in their day to day lives.

It is not that people don't mind because they are recycling VHS cameras placed by private citizens, but rather that they just don't care regardless. The fact that there is a widespread myth that all the cameras are government installed and networked actually drives home this point. People incorrectly think this and they still don't really care.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mibbitier on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:44PM (#4820303)
That's right. Because the number of instances of "My life was ruined by the state who monitored my every move", or "My love life was ruined when my wife was able to bribe the CCTV operator to find out about my affair"... they don't happen do they.

If CCTV was a problem for people, we'd hear about it. But it's not, so we don't.

The fact I visited a certain shop is on record for 2 days on a crappy VHS tape.... why do I care?

Some tourist probably also took my photograph, but I'm not going to stress about that either.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jlgreco on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:50PM (#4820323)
Nobody, as I read it, is suggesting that the current CCTV installations, or even the imagined CCTV installations, present a threat themselves.

The damage being done, in my opinion, is a shifting of the Overton window. It changes our perception of normal so that other hypothetical, actually dangerous or sinister, developments will not seem as unusual or outside the norm.

There is not a massive tracking network of CCTV cameras today, but people seem to have the idea that such a thing exists.. and they don't care. Give it a few more years and you could probably actually install such a system and the only people who said anything would be considered weirdos for caring, just like you find it weird that people are bothered by the current system.

I should emphasis that I do not think the UK is going to turn into East Germany in any foreseeable future.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mibbitier on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:36PM (#4820421)
As I say, we've had widespread CCTV in shops in the UK since the 80s. In the last 30 years nothing has particularly changed.

I take your point, in theory an evil genius prime minister could install some mass surveillance system. But what the hell would be the point? And the chance of him not getting found out and called out by the media is negligable. Add to that the utter incompetence of government to do anything IT related, and I think we're pretty safe.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jlgreco on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:35PM (#4820886)
As I said, I don't think there is any immediate danger posed by CCTV systems in the UK. You could say I am "concerned" in a largely academic manner.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by moens on Thursday November 22, 2012 @11:36PM (#4820982)
Your point is not academic... there is this new thing called WalMart, er, Asda. Ever hear about it? Cheap stuff for people with bad taste. Oh, and with a side of live-video-surveillance-with-active-facial-recognition feeding a worldwide db which has implicit (subpoena or court order... or not in cases of foreign nationals) access by the NSA / FBI / CIA. Um, and people are cool with it why? Because its all on VHS and has been going on since the 80's. I believe that is what you were saying...
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by ZoFreX on Friday November 23, 2012 @07:04AM (#4821929)
If it's feeding a database, it ain't a 2 day tape loop!
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by scotty79 on Friday November 23, 2012 @05:36AM (#4821746)
> They are okay with them by default, and don't even bother asking.

I think it's even stronger.

I for one am not ok with lack of CCTV installations as in:

"They (stole my bike/slashed my tires/robbed my office) and (there was not a single camera to record this/image from only available camera was so crappy that it doesn't help)."

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Evbn on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:25PM (#4820399)
Why would you imagine it is VHS and not hard drive?
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by finnw on Friday November 23, 2012 @01:59AM (#4821212)
Because at the time it was installed, that was the cheapest option.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by electromagnetic on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:37PM (#4820272)
Coincidence, but I was from Yorkshire and the village I grew up in put a CCTV camera on the community hall to view the playground as it had gotten to the point that a couple days couldn't go by without someone finding a dirty needle. Once that camera went up, the junkies didn't go there anymore.

A camera is far more cost effective to the parish council than sending someone to search for health hazards every morning.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by robk on Friday November 23, 2012 @08:02AM (#4822059)
Uh, in Central London I count at least 6 operated by the council or Met or Transport for London (unclear actual ownership of the outdoor ones but they're mounted on public poles and accessible by Met for criminal investigations). This is a short commute. Seems rather pervasive that I'm tracked visibly for about 70% of the distance covered on foot.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mibbitier on Friday November 23, 2012 @09:25AM (#4822287)
Central London is a massive city. Obviously there's a shit-ton of CCTV there. It's in no way typical of the UK though.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jiggy2011 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:31PM (#4820089)
I'm not sure if I oppose CCTV cameras or not. Sure there's a creepy element to it.

OTOH they are all in public places and the footage is not released to the public without some reason (in contrast to basically anyone just recording with a phone).

People always say they want more police on the street, so if each of these cameras was replaced with a uniformed policeman watching the street would this be better or worse?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by tareqak on Thursday November 22, 2012 @09:49PM (#4820789)
My personal complaint with CCTVs is, "why are they so hidden?" I understand that in a public place (shopping mall, public park etc), people could be watching me. I'm alright with that simply for the fact that those people watching me are themselves subject to the same condition of being watched. CCTVs are often black on very dark wall/ceiling or very reflective against a light wall/ceiling making them very hard to pick out unless you are looking for them. It wouldn't be surprising to me if some of them are even more hidden (embedded in decorations, wall hangings, toys, mannequins etc). To me, some of these CCTVs are effectively an attempt at being robotic peeping-Toms.

I think a CCTV would afford more real security (if it does at all to begin with) by following the norms of a real watchman (being visible).

tl;dr I think I have right to watch the watchmen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%...), even though this is not guaranteed by any law.

If the police feel that hidden cameras are the way to go, then they should surrender the protection that claim to have (not being allowed to videotape or otherwise perform surveillance on a police officer). (I am not at all sure about this last part, please correct me should I be wrong).

edit: replaced <em></em> with *s

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Zak on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:51PM (#4820460)
I don't want more police in my neighborhood.

At first, more police would probably improve a few things. Fewer people would litter, and the occasional drunk who passes out on the side of a street would be removed faster.

The trouble is, there's not actually much for extra police to do, so they'd eventually find things to do. They'd have to start writing speeding tickets for 5 mph over the limit and picking up stray cats. That kind of enforcement would not make this a more pleasant place to live.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Samuel_Michon on Thursday November 22, 2012 @07:17PM (#4820525)
"start writing speeding tickets for 5 mph over the limit and picking up stray cats"

Aren't those good things? I wish for someone to get a ticket if they drive faster than the speed limit, they're a hazard to themselves and others. I'd like stray cats to get picked up so that they will get taken care of and won't be a nuisance to the neighborhood.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by rizzom5000 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @07:52PM (#4820594)
I completely disagree. Speed limits are not based when someone becomes a hazard to himself or others. A great many people can and do safely travel faster than the speed limit. Also I don't think that stray cats are a nuisance, and that they do in fact keep down the rodent population and are a generally healthy element of the urban ecosystem.

If you are in the US and want more cops in your community, you can make it happen by convincing enough people to vote for the necessary tax increases to hire more law enforcement. Alternatively, you could move to a gated community, many of which hire security guards, that you pay for, who will help take care of the stray cat problem - but you'll still have to contend with the speeders outside the gate.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Zak on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:03PM (#4820615)
Those might be good things in some cases, but usually not. In my area, stray cats are mostly beneficial and not overpopulated. Speeding by such a small amount is not usually dangerous, and drivers paranoid about overzealous speed enforcement are likely to focus too much attention on the speedometer and not enough on their environment.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by baddox on Friday November 23, 2012 @12:42AM (#4821100)
They're good things, but are they good enough to justify taking money from people by force (taxation) to pay someone to do them? Pink lemonade is good too, but I prefer a society where people who want pink lemonade choose to buy it for themselves.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by maaku on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:38PM (#4820107)
> People always say they want more police on the street, so if each of these cameras was replaced with a uniformed policeman watching the street would this be better or worse?

Better, unequivocally. Why wouldn't it be?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by kristopolous on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:41PM (#4820289)
More police mean more people. More people mean more mistakes. And when police make mistakes people die or at best go to jail unnecessarily. Law enforcement is entrenched with a stand-your-ground-to-hell-with-the-facts culture.

Their job is essentially to find "bad guys" so when there are many more cops then bad guys, the category of bad-guy gets vastly expanded.

In 2002 at LAX there were so many cops it was ridiculous. My friend got a ticket for littering and I got one for jaywalking. Actually he was going to arrest me at first.

So yes, please, I want that experience everywhere I go. If I walk briskly, well then I should be stopped and questioned. If I stop slightly ahead of the line at the crosswalk, I should get a $500 fine every time and eventually lose my license.

But the police of course can simply turn on their sirens and go through whatever red light they please, or park in front of a hydrant, or on a sidewalk, they are above the law after all.

This overreaching police state sounds simply wonderful. Where does one sign up?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by im3w1l on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:10PM (#4820365)
Police need to be convinced that your oppresive dictatorship is a good thing. Cameras wont revolt.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Evbn on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:40PM (#4820430)
The history of military recruiting, and even police recruiting, shows that this check is a non-issue. Police departments hire power tripping bullies who enjoy harassing dirty/brown/hippy/communitst/Irish/whatever.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday November 22, 2012 @07:21PM (#4820533)
I don't know more than half-a-dozen policemen but none of them fit that description.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by irahul on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:30PM (#4820872)
Not everyone is an asshole, or on a power trip. But there has been enough instances of cop brutality. The more people you add, the more the number of bad apples increase. Having more people might dilute the percentage of bad apples, but it still increases the number of bad apples. And as another commenter pointed out, when there are lot of cops on the street, and there are no conventional bad guys, the definition of bad guy extends. I certainly won't want to be arrested for jaywalking.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:21PM (#4820637)
Right. 6 people in your anecdotal experience is a good rebuttal when compared with thousands of years of world history where there have been no problems finding people to do awful things. For the most obvious example, go to Germany in WWII.

No idea why the grandparent is being down voted.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by pbhjpbhj on Friday November 23, 2012 @06:38AM (#4821873)
>6 people in your anecdotal experience is a good rebuttal //

No, it's not and we all know that. That's why I phrased it that way. However it does falsify the [apparent] claim of it being a universal truth, for me - obviously you'd need to weigh my trustworthiness as an observer+reporter for it to count as evidence.

Specific to my statement and your rebuttal. I only know about the current UK police's history. What's the earliest police force and how do we know they hired sadistic sociopaths?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Friday November 23, 2012 @01:18PM (#4823113)
I don't think the point was that every policeman was a jackass, or even a majority. The point is, that throughout history, anyone with power has been able to convince a lot of people to do their dirty work. Likely many of these people weren't even bad people, they just didn't have the courage to stand up for what is right.

It doesn't falsify anything, and I have no reason to believe you aren't trustworthy. I just need to be able to provide lots of examples where the opposite is true, and I can. It's trivial.

I don't for a second believe that every German soldier in WWII was as bad a person as Hitler made them be. I do believe they were willing to go well past what most people would admit to doing, likely because they were afraid they'd die if they didn't. But millions of jews were slaughtered because it wasn't that hard to convince people to do it.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by DanBC on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:00PM (#4820168)
Because cctv cameras are not (at present) armed and thus can't kill innocent people. Nor are they racist and thus they can't beat someone close to death thereby starting riots.

And that's real, trained, qualified, experienced, officers. Imagine what it's like if you have people like the UK "Special Constables" (PCSO, Police Community Support Officer) - volunteer police with limited powers (and training). (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_Community_Support_Offic...)

Police on the streets probably aren't much good at catching criminals; from the little I've read there needs to be more detectives but not more beat officers.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jiggy2011 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:10PM (#4820195)
PCSOs are not volunteers, they are paid. Special Constables are volunteers.

PCSOs generally do not have any more rights than any normal citizen in terms of arrest etc and therefor don't really have grounds to make threats against you (apart from using their radio to call an actual police officer).

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by frobozz on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:38PM (#4820276)
Special Constables are properly trained, qualified and warranted volunteer "real" police officers.

PCSOs are paid, barely trained normal citizens with a police-like uniform.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jiggy2011 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:44PM (#4820122)
I mean specifically from a "civil liberties" point of view, i.e your are being watched either way but CCTV happens to be cheaper (though less effective).
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by maaku on Sunday November 25, 2012 @01:00PM (#4828713)
I meant my comment from the "civil liberties" point of view too. CCTV leaves a permanent record, accessible in perpetuity and to the authorities only. But if a police officer were on the street instead, public activities would remain pseudoanonymous so long as he's not paying attention or what you're doing doesn't otherwise stand out as important to the cop in the moment.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jasonlotito on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:25PM (#4820398)
That's a pretty strong stance you are taking. To suggest that policeman trump cameras unequivocally, well, you'd have to ignore history to make that case.

Just reading through various threads here and I see examples of cases where cameras solved problems better then people could have.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mcantelon on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:47PM (#4820133)
The problem with CCTV cameras is camera footage can be processed automatically to track people's movements. This gives the state more power than it reasonably needs.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by jiggy2011 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:54PM (#4820152)
Good point. But OTOH what if some private organisation (cough google) decided to pay private property owners to put street facing cameras on their buildings, record everything and upload it to some server?

This could then be used for all kinds of purposes but AFAIK they wouldn't be breaking any laws in doing so, so in this case it doesn't give the state any extra rights than a private company has.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mibbitier on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:37PM (#4820273)
You're once again believing the ridiculous notion that somehow all CCTV cameras feed into a central state monitored control station. They don't.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mcantelon on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:22PM (#4820642)
Note the use of the words "can be". What's the trend of modern states? Is it towards limiting or increasing surveillance?
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by djisjke on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:42PM (#4820117)
Is there not any other ways to stop violence than with threats of violence (like more police and cctv who will make sure the cops gets you if you do crimes)? A better, but harder way, is to design society so that crime is low because it's not as necessary as it is today.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by pepve on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:02PM (#4820175)
History is littered with designed societies.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by qu4z-2 on Sunday November 25, 2012 @10:07PM (#4830239)
History is littered with societies in general.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:25PM (#4820645)
I don't want either. I'd prefer more people took care of themselves. An armed society is a polite society.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by natrius on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:32PM (#4820654)
"An armed society is a polite society."

Do you really believe this platitude? On a purely logical level, there are so many counterexamples that one has to be embarrassed to state it as fact.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @09:26PM (#4820745)
I'm still waiting on your counterexamples, but in the mean time here are a few links.

In Switzerland, most 20-30 year olds are in the militia, and have automatic assault rifles in their homes. After their service, they are made into semi-automatic rifles and generally kept by the servicemen in their homes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_politics_in_Switzerland 2006 - 34 gun killings, 7.6mil population - rate of killings or attempted killings with firearms at about one for every quarter million residents yearly

DC - poster child for gun control, had 137 gun killings last year with a population of 600k. http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2007/11/18/effect...

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by rmccue on Friday November 23, 2012 @03:39AM (#4821386)
In Australia, we've decreased to about 0.1 gun homicides per 100k: http://guncontrol.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/1995-200... (Note: somewhat biased site)

That's compared to 0.22 for DC, or 0.04 for Switzerland, so it's still higher than Switzerland with vastly higher gun control. However, I think that it's more about the surrounding gun culture than it is the laws: most Australians are against gun usage (see the response to the Port Arthur massacre or the Monash Uni shootings), whereas for Americans, it's their right to hold arms, and they seem to defend that adamantly.

See also, this opinion piece by our former Prime Minister: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/brothers-in-arms-yes-...

Edit: http://www.gunpolicy.org/firearms/region/australia notes 30 gun-related homicides in 2008 for a population of ~21 million.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:43AM (#4821591)
That's not a counter example though. Having a place with gun control that isn't full of gun crime isn't that shocking, though it hasn't worked in the US. What you need to prove me wrong would be one without any gun control that has huge lawlessness and gun crime compared to similar places with gun control.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:44PM (#4820670)
I do. Please show lots of examples of people with their HCP committing crimes.

Look at Switzerland. Do they have huge mass murders happening on a daily basis?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by gabemart on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:33PM (#4820655)
>An armed society is a polite society.

Is the subtext of this statement "An armed society is a polite society because rude people get shot"?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:45PM (#4820674)
No. It's that criminals think twice about robbing or raping someone if they know they are armed.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by gabemart on Friday November 23, 2012 @12:32PM (#4822952)
>No. It's that criminals think twice about robbing or raping someone if they know they are armed.

Then wouldn't a more appropriate aphorism be "An armed society is a safe society"?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Avshalom on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:33AM (#4821559)
The Swiss then do not count as an example, what with them not actually being armed in any sort of public-ish space.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:40AM (#4821584)
You only get robbed in public?
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by scotty79 on Friday November 23, 2012 @05:47AM (#4821773)
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by clarky07 on Friday November 23, 2012 @09:08AM (#4822224)
30% was at home, which is over 100k.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by scotty79 on Saturday November 24, 2012 @07:34PM (#4826924)
Which is kind of surprising considering that possibility of home owner having a gun is mentioned as strong deterrent for criminals.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by alexakarpov on Thursday November 22, 2012 @09:50PM (#4820790)
It's probably way cheaper with cameras..
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by conradfr on Friday November 23, 2012 @05:04AM (#4821662)
Some studies point that operating cameras is expensive and in some way just move or change crime, therefore less efficient than real police at the same cost.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by itsprofitbaron on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:17PM (#4820631)
Noone in the UK cares about CCTV, I certainly don't and my friends don't either. The average person in the UK is seen 300 times per day[1] on CCTV and the number is probably higher now.

CCTV in the UK is essentially completely privatised anyway & thats even considering that the government run cameras to track car plates etc. Similarly, the government can request that the shop keeper etc hands over the CCTV footage but seriously who cares?!

[1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/2071496.stm

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by nickbarone on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:29PM (#4820084)
Sticking my foot out - Panopticons are not a bad thing. They're actually a really good thing, because they, theoretically, let you get a lot more security without losing a lot of liberty (instead, you lose privacy).

The problem people have - universally in my limited experience - is with the people and institutions behind the cameras, not the cameras themselves. If CCTV is Big Brother, isn't neighborhood watch something like Little Brother?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mcantelon on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:52PM (#4820143)
>Sticking my foot out - Panopticons are not a bad thing.

East Germany is a historic example of why surveillance states aren't a positive thing.

>If CCTV is Big Brother, isn't neighborhood watch something like Little Brother?

Neighbourhood watches aren't centralized and funded to the degree that state surveillance is.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by viraptor on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:05PM (#4820184)
> East Germany is a historic example of why surveillance states aren't a positive thing.

Street CCTV is not the same as a microphone hidden in your light switch, without you knowing about it. Not nearly the same thing.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mcantelon on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:21PM (#4820224)
The ability to eavesdrop through cell phones, even where they're not making calls, is pretty similar (although probably more effective) to the capability of bugging light switches:

http://news.cnet.com/2100-1029-6140191.html

Street CCTV can augment traditionally eavesdropping intel, tracking movements and, from that, extrapolating relationships and activities.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by viraptor on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:07PM (#4820362)
I'm not even sure what this thread is about anymore, sorry. Passive CCTV is one thing. Massive spying on unrelated civilians is another. Bugging criminals' phones if you have a warrant is yet another. I don't believe any reasonable discussion can take place if you throw every possible reason and means of recording anything into one bucket.

There are different uses and different situations. People can have different opinions about them too. I believe for example that CCTV is exactly as legal as anyone taking a photos / movies of the police for example (and the other way around), while bugging phones by law enforcement needs to be very tightly regulated. But those scenarios should have very little in common.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by mcantelon on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:55PM (#4820471)
>I'm not even sure what this thread is about anymore, sorry.

The thread started with someone positing that panopticons aren't a bad thing, hence the mention of East Germany (a low tech attempt at a state panopticon) and segued to discussion of the modern state's surveillance capabilities in comparison with East Germany.

>I believe for example that CCTV is exactly as legal as anyone taking a photos / movies of the police for example (and the other way around)

They both fall under similar laws, yes, but the big difference between ad-hoc amateur surveillance and centralized, automated surveillance is the capability of realtime analysis of location, association, etc.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Zigurd on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:03PM (#4820616)
> Passive CCTV is one thing. Massive spying on unrelated civilians is another.

By that you seem to be implying we don't have both

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by krapp on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:41PM (#4820116)
<paranoid>Within a surveillance society, however, most of the effort involved with the loss of liberty is taken care of by the loss of privacy. Once you can track someone's whereabouts constantly, in realtime, and gain access their communications, know where they've been, where they plan to be, what assets they have, and who their friends are, ending their liberty becomes a minor exercise in telling the black vans where to be and when.</paranoid>
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by prodigal_erik on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:01PM (#4820171)
We must negotiate with nosy, judgmental primates for food and shelter. "Liberty" to ruin my life is meaningless; I can't actually do or say anything sufficiently controversial without privacy.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by skreech on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:55PM (#4820153)
It seems you don't get security from cameras.

http://www.aclunc.org/issues/technology/blog/san_francisco_s...