News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by jrflo on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:39AM (#48193926)
I wonder if people thought something similar when moving from writing low level machine code by hand to high-level languages. No one looks at the actual machine instructions anymore! Will our ability to understand low level instructions atrophy?
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by snek_case on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:50AM (#48194089)
The difference is that LLMs are not compilers. You can't trust the output to be correct. They routinely make bad design choices. If you're prototyping some kind of throwaway MVP, you're just sketching something, it's probably fine not to review it. If you're trying to build a piece of software that's going to survive for years, why are you doing this? The tech is clearly not yet fully mature.

Just yesterday, I was trying to use Claude Opus 4.7 to debug an issue in a program that I wrote, and its solution was to remove a feature, change the design to eliminate the problem without consulting me. I only found out that it had removed this feature through testing. Imagine not reviewing things like that. How can people argue for this with a straight face? We'll probably get there eventually, but there's no need to rush before the tech is ready. Doing that is just being clueless.

Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by soraminazuki on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @12:39PM (#48195680)
The comparison with compilers is absurd on its face, yet some keep pushing it as if repeating it enough times will make it true.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by DerArzt on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:39PM (#48198355)
Why is it absurd?
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by soraminazuki on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:38PM (#48201131)
For the same reason others have explained here and elsewhere, with some writing entire articles on the topic. Compilers produce semantically equivalent translation of source code into target code. That's not at all what LLMs do. They produce unpredictable results from ambiguous specifications written by people who may or may not understand software engineering. Big difference.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by snek_case on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:43PM (#48199332)
The people who make that comparison are just showing how clueless they are IMO.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by cortesoft on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @12:08PM (#48195235)
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by cguess on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:50AM (#48194103)
It did atrophy, but more importantly understanding what's going on below the code you are writing, even if your project isn't assembly, also atrophied. When you're coding an Electron app with Javascript you're so far removed from any concept of the efficiency a modern CPU can achieve you stop caring about optimization. Speed and memory management don't matter and then you get... well, the modern web.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by hootz on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:53AM (#48194138)
And the modern web being usable is basically thanks to the people who understand lower level optimization.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by dadoum on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:58AM (#48194216)
The compiler has been written by a lot of very smart people, it is very well tested and sometimes has even been formally proven to output exactly what the language specifies, and I have a mental model of what the code it outputs does in relation to what I write.

Nobody can be sure of what the LLM will output for a certain prompt. If you don't review what it outputs, it will not necessarily match your expectations. You could argue that it is the same as when you assign an intern to the task, but I personally would check what the intern writes (and in my experience they are more reliable than current AIs, of course not as quick).

Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by hedgehog on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:46AM (#48194012)
There's clearly a range of outcomes, from the people pushing the envelope in system performance (look at the state of networking ASICs and the code to drive them) to people adopting hyper-complex frameworks for cloud orchestration and job coordination that turn a few screens of code into system so slow and complex it needs a team to maintain it. It's all happening at once, and it's probably ok. Keep in mind, knowing how to write assembly and knowing how to get good performance out of a CPU are two different things, modern chips are insanely complicated and the mental model is a long way from the days of the 386 or 68030 (let alone pre-MMU computing).
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by linksnapzz on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:51AM (#48194109)
The move to HLLs created new classes of problems that assembly programmers didn't face; so while the # of problems that necessitated understanding hw didn't shrink, it did relative to the list of things that could now go wrong.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by hootz on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:44AM (#48193985)
And they did atrophy! I only know assembly because I deliberately studied it and practiced it for reverse engineering. But in my view, no longer being able to understand high level code is a much, much bigger problem than not understanding assembly.
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by weakfish on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:05PM (#48196903)
Especially because Markdown --> code is _non-deterministic_
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by hootz on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:31PM (#48197314)
Yeah. Actually, that's a cool thing to think about. Will it be possible in the future for an LLM to be deterministic enough to the point of becoming essentially a text to code compiler? Like, an entire class of LLMs that are meant to be deterministic to the point that even upgrades to the model wouldn't completely change the outputs (it could have some breaking changes).
Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by dijksterhuis on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:48AM (#48194065)
reality is more nuanced. some people still need to inspect machine code by hand. people who primarily write SaaS django boilerplate don’t. the arguments were made back then, im sure.

but, according to the worst offending and persistent ai-hyper comments on this site, this is apparently a paradigm shift unlike anything that’s done before. according t them we don’t even need to understand high level languages, let alone machine code. which is frankly ridiculous.

i’m an “AI luddite”. but i accept there are useful use cases. that’s not where all the wasted money is going though.

Re:Going full AI engineer, not touching code anymore by righthand on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @10:46AM (#48194019)
This analogy is always weird to me, the change your talking about was still deterministic. Switching from programming to describing programming and having a machine make a best guess is not a deterministic shift as previously happened.