News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by harimau777 on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:13AM (#48096113)
I keep reading about how AI will be fine because people can just retrain for different careers. However, I never read what those careers are or who is going to pay for retraining.

I certainly don't have the money or time to go back to college and start a new career at the bottom.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by adjejmxbdjdn on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:33AM (#48096370)
The argument is that “that’s what always happened in the past”.

Which is true, but it’s true as long as it’s not true.

The classic example of how drastically this kind of thinking can fail is Malthusian theory, that populations would collapse because food growth was linear while population growth was exponential. This was true for all of history until Malthus actually made this observation.

At a mechanistic level, the “we have always found other jobs” argument misses that the reason we’ve always found other jobs is because humans have always had an intelligence advantage over automation. Even something as mechanical as human inputs in an assembly line was eventually dependent on the human ability to make tiny, often imperceptibly, adjustments that a robot couldn’t.

But if something approximating AGI does work out, human labor has absolutely no advantage over automation so it’s not clear why the past “automation has created more human jobs” logic should continue.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rayiner on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:51AM (#48096645)
> Which is true, but it’s true as long as it’s not true.

It also isn't true. The story of the last 50 years has been that technology, especially computer and communications technology, has facilitated the concentration of wealth. The skilled work got computerized, or outsourced to India or China. That left U.S. workers with service jobs where they have much lower impact on P&L and thus much less leverage.

In my field, we used to have legal secretaries and law librarians and highly experienced paralegals. They got paid pretty well and had pretty good job security because the people who brought in the revenue interacted with them daily and relied on them. Now, big firms have computerized a lot of that work and consolidated much of the rest into centralized off-site back-office locations. Those folks who got downsized never found comparable work. They didn't, and couldn't, go work for WestLaw to maintain the new electronic tools. The law firms also held on to many of them until retirement or offered them early retirement packages, and then simply never filled the positions. It used to be a pretty solid job for someone with an associates degree, and it simply doesn't exist anymore.

The only thing keeping the job market together is the explosion in healthcare workers. My Gen-Z brother and sister in law are both going into those fields. In a typical tertiary American city, the largest employers are the local hospital and perhaps a university or community college. Both of those get most of their revenue directly or indirectly from the government. It's not clear to me how that's sustainable.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by bilbo0s on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:46PM (#48098153)
>It's not clear to me how that's sustainable

If it makes you feel better, I'm pretty sure it isn't sustainable. (But I'm not an economist so take that with a block of salt.)

I don't think anyone has the answers. It's just some of us are honest enough to concede we have no answers, while others promote an answer that aligns best with their belief system.

"It'll all work out."

"It's the immigrants/blacks/jews/whatever dragging us down."

"Nothing's going to happen and we can all continue doing the work we always have."

"Burn the rich."

Etc etc.

Not a lot of serious attempts out there at even getting a hand on the issues, let alone fixing the issues.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by braebo on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @06:57AM (#48106515)
Socialism has been the answer since I was born in the 90s and the V shaped economy took hold.

We have enough resources for everyone to have food, shelter, education, and healthcare without the need to extract value from their labor.

All of these problems are self inflicted wounds. The solution is for humanity to stop stabbing itself and care for itself instead.

The solution is to let go of greed and embrace our humanity.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by vips7L on Monday May 11, 2026 @03:32PM (#48099597)
Healthcare really seems like the only safe direction anymore. They're needed and a human is still required to physically do it.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by upupupandaway on Monday May 11, 2026 @06:40PM (#48101681)
My wife is a nurse and keeps in touch with her school professors. They said that the number of people flooding into healthcare careers is more than most colleges can handle, and is starting to cause supply glut in some roles.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by vips7L on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @02:22AM (#48104870)
If I was younger it’s what I would do tbh. Engineering, CS, and anything else white collar has such a foggy future right now. No chance would I risk going into something that might have wages suppressed or mass lay offs within a decade. And honestly 3 twelve hour shifts doesn’t sound that bad compared to 5 days a week of corporate bullshit.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by nemomarx on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:48AM (#48096599)
I'm also pretty sure in the past industrial transitions, many of the people who lost their jobs at the start of the change never found better ones. It took a generation or so for new opportunities to really be found and fine tuned and you're competing for those new roles with younger people anyway.

If ai does take a lot of white collar work, is it a lot of comfort that maybe jobs in a very different sector will be better in 20 years?

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rayiner on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:56AM (#48096718)
Did the younger people find better jobs? You used to have all these jobs for people who were maybe a bit smarter than average with good judgment. In the 1990s, the local community college used to advertise associates degrees for paralegals. That's a job that doesn't exist in the same way anymore thanks to computers. Now it's become an internship for kids with top credentials before they go to law school. Which is fine for them, but what about everyone else?

It seems to me like all of these people are flocking now to healthcare fields. That seems totally unsustainable.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by joe_mamba on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:14PM (#48097753)
>It seems to me like all of these people are flocking now to healthcare fields. That seems totally unsustainable.

Why? There will never be a shortage of sick/dying people. So medical staff, and also undertakers, aren't going anywhere.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rayiner on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:48PM (#48099058)
Because most healthcare spending comes from tax dollars.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by jhrmnn on Monday May 11, 2026 @03:36PM (#48099646)
Is this a different route to the universal basic income scenario?
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by deflator on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:57PM (#48099185)
My understanding is that healthcare keeps growing because the large Boomer generation is aging. When they have passed though, then we should see a corresponding slide in healthcare growth
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by marcosdumay on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:05PM (#48097640)
Not in all past industrial transitions.

But yes, the argument has been wrong often enough that the people still repeating it as a rule should be mocked and ashamed.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by bobthepanda on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:37AM (#48096451)
It’s also not that true, and highly dependent on a lot of factors.

Anecdotally I see a lot of schadenfreude online about tech jobs after a decade or two of lecturing everybody from Appalachians in coal country, to Midwestern autoworkers, that they should just “learn to code.”

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by antisthenes on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:57AM (#48096724)
> The classic example of how drastically this kind of thinking can fail is Malthusian theory, that populations would collapse because food growth was linear while population growth was exponential. This was true for all of history until Malthus actually made this observation.

Malthusian observation can still be true...It only has to be true once, and the only reason people say it isn't right now is due to industrial fertilizers and short memories.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by jodrellblank on Monday May 11, 2026 @10:55PM (#48103661)
> "the only reason .. industrial fertilizers"

canned food, tractors, combine harvesters, mechanical refrigeration, freezers, chilled trucks, ocean liners, aircraft, antibiotics for farm animals, milking machines, genetically modified crops, satellite/computer weather prediction, modern pesticides, Pasteurization, vitamin and mineral fortification...

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by antisthenes on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @12:57PM (#48110958)
Yes, I appreciate the expanded list.

I should have clarified that industrial fertilizers (and other modern Ag) come from non-renewable fossil fuel exploitation, just as the 90% of the things you listed.

Antibiotics and GMO crops are nice too, but if you don't have the energy inputs to grow and distribute the food, it all goes tits up.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by jodrellblank on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @01:41PM (#48111601)
Malthus wrote in 1798 when world population was 1 billion. It's now 8 billion and famine is rarer, food is more abundant and more food is wasted every day than ever before. Industrial fertilizers do come from fossil fuels, but they aren't fossil fuels. Nitrogen fertilizer uses natural gas for its Methane content, and we can make Methane using electricity, seawater and make Nitrogen fertilizer from that, and we can make electricity from solar, wind and nuclear.

> just as the 90% of the things you listed.

90% of the things I listed only use fossil fuels because they are the cheapest energy, not because they are dependent on fossil fuels specifically. Freeze-dried food doesn't need coal power. The idea that 8 billion humans are just gonna shrug and go "oh well, guess there's no food now, we'll just all give up and die" and not try to invent any way to carry on, is silly.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rurp on Monday May 11, 2026 @12:24PM (#48097108)
Totally agree, and would add another way “that’s what always happened in the past” is a terribly weak argument. Things might have always worked out at the societal level so far, but very often do not at the individual level. Countless successful craftsmen have had their livelihoods ruined by technological changes and spent their remaining years impoverished. How many people funding AI would be willing to throw their own life away for the good of some future strangers that may or may not be born? I'm pretty sure the answer is <=0.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by i_love_retros on Monday May 11, 2026 @08:48PM (#48102806)
At some point there really won't be enough jobs and massive social change will happen. It has to surely? Don't call me Shirley. In star trek WW3 had to happen before the better society emerged. I think a large scale wipe out and cleaning of the slate is inevitable. What happens in a world where people who have spent so much time and effort and money to get educated and establish a career are suddenly worthless and penniless? Nothing good I suspect!
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by protocolture on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @01:05AM (#48104402)
>But if something approximating AGI does work out, human labor has absolutely no advantage over automation so it’s not clear why the past “automation has created more human jobs” logic should continue.

Human labor still seems to be cheaper. And then theres opex/capex to be considered. Like if they achieve AGI, and AGI isnt affordable its not going to displace much.

>“we have always found other jobs”

It really depends what humans value and what they have to spend. No one could predict that Banks would need more staff to deal with ATMs. It sucks being unable to predict past a coming automation revolution, but that doesnt mean there isnt something there.

>human labor has absolutely no advantage over automation

Humans are currently needed to manage automation. Theres no clear reason why, even with AGI, that we wouldn't want humans in most loops. Thats before cost and quality.

>The classic example of how drastically this kind of thinking can fail is Malthusian theory, that populations would collapse because food growth was linear while population growth was exponential. This was true for all of history until Malthus actually made this observation.

Malthus is a pretty great example. We did sort out food production. There are risks with the scale at which we have done it. Malthus wasnt able to predict technologies to aid food production, but he did forecast the need.

When I see people complaining the jobs dont exist I find its the same. We dont know what the jobs are, but that doesnt mean the prediction of all of humanity being out of work are correct.

Actually the worst part of this whole thing will be that any incoming job losses being catastrophised as if the whole world is ending due to AI.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by HumblyTossed on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:18AM (#48096179)
> However, I never read what those careers are or who is going to pay for retraining.

There aren't any careers and if there were, you would have to pay. Corporations certainly won't except under extremely rare situations where they have to to compete.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rayiner on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:39AM (#48096473)
It's not going to happen, just as it didn't happen for skilled industrial workers whose jobs got outsourced to China. The government will pay just enough in welfare to keep the situation manageable. Then they'll demonize you in the culture, as a Luddite, etc.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by phyzix5761 on Monday May 11, 2026 @12:00PM (#48096762)
I think the idea of being an employee is fundamentally changing. Not saying its good or bad but it's shifting to a more entrepreneurial phase where people have to step out of their 9 to 5s and find ways to deliver value that others want to pay for.

We saw this pre-ai with uber and door dash. I think as AI automation dies down and most companies are competing at a near optimal level with the new tools we'll need humans again in more traditional roles to build the next generation of innovations. And then the whole cycle will repeat.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by lowmagnet on Monday May 11, 2026 @12:07PM (#48096868)
Uber and Doordash are both examples of abusing workers and their resources to externalize costs on the worker.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by phyzix5761 on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:45PM (#48098150)
What about people who have been out of work for a year and all they can do right now is deliver for Uber and Doordash so they can make rent and put some food on the table?

Is it ideal working conditions? No, but its better than nothing, you can set your own hours, and you can leave when the next opportunity comes.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by RealityVoid on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:52PM (#48098256)
His point is that it's not entrepreneurship, it's employment.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by mancerayder on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:51PM (#48098236)
That's a lot of SV-speak. How exactly do people step into an entrepreneurial phase? They're at work in corporate settings with fixed defined roles. Most workplaces are not many-hatted-donning startup environments, but restricted roles where there are deliverables, deadlines, meetings, etc. Which leaves out of hours for "entrepreneurship" whatever that is.

Github project work on the weekends? That's not possible for most people in their mature/family years (or shouldn't be necessary - what about living life??)

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by ProfessorLayton on Monday May 11, 2026 @03:37PM (#48099663)
>That's a lot of SV-speak. How exactly do people step into an entrepreneurial phase?

Almost half of U.S. employment is from small businesses (250 or less employees). That's means there's a lot of entrepreneurship happening already. I have lots of family running their own small businesses (trades), and it's a lot of work, and doesn't necessarily pay as well as a cushy corporate job, but what I'm trying to say is lots of people can and do start their own enterprise.

Yes, lots of them will fail at running their own business, but it's not like corporate jobs are getting any safer either.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by mancerayder on Monday May 11, 2026 @09:07PM (#48102926)
And what ARE those businesses? There's delis everywhere, should I open up a 24/7 bodega? Start selling knives I learn to forge on the Internet and make YouTube videos about knife making? That's going to replace our financial commitments will it?

Here's another problem - how do you get healthcare without a corporate group plan? In my state the ACA offers expensive in-network only plans where you wait months for appointments.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by Terr_ on Monday May 11, 2026 @05:44PM (#48101065)
> That's a lot of SV-speak. How exactly do people step into an entrepreneurial phase?

Oh, you simply decide to use grit and willpower to pull yourself up by your bootstraps, placing some calls to people you met at certain parties aided by a small 6 digit loan from your family. /s

My default expectation of "employees should be more entrepreneurial" is that's it's a kind of victim-blaming. I'm especially cynical if the concept seems is getting introduced by groups that spent the last several decades putting up barriers to entry, drafting non-compete contracts, capturing regulators, and basically pulling up the ladders behind them.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by mancerayder on Monday May 11, 2026 @09:09PM (#48102938)
It's comfort (for the already made men) for the possibility of a dystopic economy where tech jobs become very rare. A scenario which could play out as we compete harder with each other for the pickings.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by RealityVoid on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:51PM (#48098238)
> We saw this pre-ai with uber and door dash.

Oh, yeah? Did the Uber drivers and door dashers accrue the surplus value?

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by vips7L on Monday May 11, 2026 @03:40PM (#48099684)
How the hell is uber or door dash entrepreneurial?
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by Ifkaluva on Monday May 11, 2026 @10:09PM (#48103372)
lol what? Are you seriously suggesting the miseries and abuses of the gig economy are a suitable comparison for the future of displaced SWEs?
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by ahartmetz on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:40AM (#48096491)
The second part seems obvious to me: the ones who are getting retrained. If it's some kind of formal education, depending where you are, maybe the state at least for part of it.

Education in what, though? No idea. And if there was one answer, and it's true that there will be fewer software developers, you'd likely be competing with many people for few jobs.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by radiator on Monday May 11, 2026 @04:41PM (#48100387)
Start with the basics, perhaps? Languages, Mathematics, Geography, Economy, History.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by realharo on Monday May 11, 2026 @12:12PM (#48096941)
Yeah, that's just a copium answer from people who simply want to hand wave away the issue instead of admitting they have no good answers.

Like a politician who's asked about this in a town hall, but thinks that "our plan is to do absolutely nothing" doesn't sound very appealing.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by bdcravens on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:24AM (#48096252)
The same is true of the industries that software disrupted.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by kypro on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:57AM (#48096728)
Also, it's not necessarily true that there will be other great careers available. This seems to just be an assumption people are making.

Of course, there are jobs that will still require human labour for some time yet, but in reality a lot jobs that require physical human labour are now done in other parts of the world where labour is cheaper.

Those which cannot be exported like plumbing or waitressing only have limited demand. You can't take 50% of the current white-collar workforce and dump them in these careers and expect them to easily find work or receive a decent wage. The demand simply does not exist.

Additionally, at the same time as white-collar jobs are being lost an increasing number of "low-skill" manual labour jobs are also being automated. Self-checkout machines mean it's harder to get work in retail, robotaxis and drone delivery will make it harder harder to find work in delivery and logistics, robots in warehouses will make it harder to find warehouse jobs.

It seems to me there is an implicate assumption that AI will either create a bunch of new well-paid jobs that employers need humans for (which means AI cannot do them) and jobs which cannot be exported abroad for cheaper. What well-paid jobs would even fit the category of being immune to AI and immune to outsourcing? Are we all going to be really well paid cleaners or something? It makes no sense.

A lot of the advice we're seeing today about retraining in construction worker or plumber seems to assume that there's an unlimited demand for this labour which there simply is not. And even if hypothetically there was about to be a huge increase in demand for construction workers, it would take years to even have the machinery, supply chain and infrastructure in place to support the millions of people entering construction.

The most likely scenario is that people will lose their jobs and will be stuck in an endless race to the bottom fighting for the limited number of jobs that are left in the domestic economy while everything else is either outsourced or done by robots and AI.

The better advice is to start preparing for this reality. Do not assume the government will or can protect you. When wealth concentrates corruption because almost inevitable and politicians have families to look after too.

Please take this seriously. Even if I'm wrong it's better to prepare for the worse rather than to assume everything will be find and you'll be able to retrain into a new well-paid career.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by whodidntante on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:35PM (#48098870)
+1

50% of the workforce was in farming near the end of the 1800's. Today, 2% 40% of the workforce was in manufacturing early to mid 1900's. Today 8% 60+% of the current workforce is white collar. What will it be in 20 years ?

LLM's are only a couple of years old, we have no idea where this will go. Maybe it will be a big hallucination, maybe we are looking at the very early version of farm and manufacturing machines.

The ENIAC was larger than a person, we now have watches that are significantly more powerful. Maybe in the future, your Apple watch will have more compute than several racks of H100's.

When they came for the farmers, no one else cared - everyone got cheap and bountiful food. When they came for the manufacturers, no one else cared - everyone got cheap and bountiful products. Now they are coming for the white collar workers, and their highly paid laptop lifestyles.

Who is left to care ? The billionaires ?

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @05:01AM (#48105876)
There’s over a century of history of workers “caring” and fighting back.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by whodidntante on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @06:40AM (#48106395)
Yes, that is true. However, each time this happens, those people are eventually labelled as getting in the way of progress, luddites, etc, and it is easy for those that benefit (cheap food, cheap products) to simply go on with their "better" lives.

I don't think there was a lot of support, outside the farming industry, to prevent machines from taking over peoples jobs even though 1/2 of the workforce were farmers. Similar for manufacturing.

And I do not believe the answer to those changes was to do farming or manufacturing by "hand". I also do not believe that the answer to AI is to not use it.

But, in the same way, I also do not believe that people will really care that call center workers will be replaced, that designers will be replaced, that many programmers will be replaced, that most admins and middle managers (anyone who pushes paperwork, creates reports, that just communicate and report on work "progress") will be replaced.

I also believe that these workers will get retrained and find better jobs is a fallacy - because it has not happened in the past. Farmers may have done this, but those who lost their well paid manufacturing, most lost their place in society. Blue collar workers in Detroit are not today's laptop warriors.

We will be undergoing a fundamental change in how society functions. It is quite possible the end result will be good, or at least looked at as good. But there was a lot of pain in the previous transitions, and the distribution of "winners" and "losers" will undergo significant change.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Wednesday May 13, 2026 @06:27AM (#48120084)
> Yes, that is true. However, each time this happens, those people are eventually labelled as getting in the way of progress, luddites, etc, and it is easy for those that benefit (cheap food, cheap products) to simply go on with their "better" lives.

Is that a historical fact?

> I don't think there was a lot of support, outside the farming industry, to prevent machines from taking over peoples jobs even though 1/2 of the workforce were farmers. Similar for manufacturing.

Is that a historical fact?

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by jhrmnn on Monday May 11, 2026 @04:21PM (#48100168)
When no work is safe from mechanization, surely the value of labor wrt capital must fall, and the societal pressure on redistribution will rise. The ultimate outcome of technological progress is either extreme inequality or massive redistribution
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by tavavex on Monday May 11, 2026 @06:09PM (#48101338)
I feel like by the time the societal pressure starts rising in any major way, it won't matter anymore. By that point, the people who will profit will become gods with a prepared response for every action the lower classes could take.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @04:50AM (#48105808)
I feel like this subthread is full of passive acceptance of defeat.

How many years did it take for HN to go from “worker unions bad because I make a lot of money” to “Of course there is a capitalist/worker war going on and in fact the capitalists might become technology-assisted gods”? I guess we’re all vulgar marxists when we think it’s too late to fight back.

Where did the can-do hustler attitude go? Only applicable for looking out for number one?

But now that we are all, at least the non-millionaires here, in the same boat? Curious sudden onset of catatonia

-----

To countermand the insane negativity for a second: LLMs are brains in a vat and therefore cannot by themselves do any tasks that goes beyond simulating keyboard & mouse in front of a computer screen.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by tavavex on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @11:13AM (#48109523)
Sometimes it almost feels like there's more than one person on HN holding more than one opinion.

I'm from the younger, lower end of the job market, far from the average HN user. You could accuse me of being excessively cynical. That's what happens when the systems you assumed would be there tell you to get bent the moment it's your turn to enter the job market. There's very few people my age I know who aren't angry at something. What you can't accuse me of is hypocrisy. I was never in the ranks of the SV money-above-all billionaire-loving population that's so common here, and I never wanted to join them. All I wanted was a career in something I enjoyed doing and an ability to sustain myself. I really don't understand why I am the one person you decided to turn your snarky, enraged tirade towards.

And it doesn't matter that LLMs can't act on their own. You don't need to literally replace every worker to the last one to get to the place I was talking about. A productivity boost that leads to 20-30% of all white collar workers losing their job would be horrific, and it would only get worse from there. That seems entirely possible to me. Nothing I'm talking about is particularly insane, it's all just a continuation of what's already been happening, with the same people ruling over it.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Wednesday May 13, 2026 @06:24AM (#48120062)
I don’t have a problem with people being very negative and cynical. I have a problem with people being very negative and cynical and also defeatist. The things that I alluded to were examples of fighting back. Not just dreading the hypothetical future.

That I brought up things that cannot be automated right now was to demonstrate that we won’t go from the status quo—which is after all not a white collar automation wipeout, right now we just have layoffs from big firms that are arguably struggling but pinning it on the “Agentic Era”—to freaking mass employment + killer robots. And maybe that won’t last forever. So maybe we should fight back while we can.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by tavavex on Wednesday May 13, 2026 @08:36PM (#48129645)
> I have a problem with people being very negative and cynical and also defeatist.

Why? Does it honestly seem like there's a serious possibility that this will turn out well, that there's something people will do to stop it? Can you name a time in recent history when something like this had happened and the crisis was averted? I'm not saying I've given up, but I can't influence the situation and, with what has happened so far in my life, expecting things to get worse seems like a pretty safe guess to me.

> The things that I alluded to were examples of fighting back.

Can you spell them out for me? I read the comment again, but most of it was just rallying up against my perceived hypocrisy as a supposed representative of the tech elite. I honestly can't see any allusions to actions or anything of the sort.

The status quo right now isn't just mass layoffs, it's a very noticeable sag in the job market, especially the junior job market. I don't know if it has ever been this bad, even in past crises that affected this field. Large-scale unemployment seems like a reasonable possibility because even seasoned professionals who aren't AI salesmen are all saying that the tooling skyrockets their productivity, and because we know there's a good chunk of white collar workers doing relatively simple work that would be low-hanging fruit for automation. Also, where did I mention killer robots?

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Tuesday May 26, 2026 @01:07PM (#48282582)
I’m sorry. I thought that I alluded to it but I didn’t.

The fact that I have a 40-hour workweek is because Labor (not any political party) fought for it. The Weekend also. And getting enough income to be “middle class” rather than proletarian.

What would the modern Westerner say if they uniformly had to work 12-hour days? Probably something about Orwell’s boot stomping on a face forever and then getting back to work.

Also America’s 1950’s middle class boom.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Thursday May 28, 2026 @07:55AM (#48307646)
And this part.

> LLMs are brains in a vat and therefore cannot by themselves do any tasks that goes beyond simulating keyboard & mouse in front of a computer screen.

Meant to imply that (a bit obtuse writing style?) even if LLMs cHaNge evEryThing for white collar work... you still need embodiment in order to do many “human” jobs. Thus even with the maximalist take-our-jobs outlook, labor itself will not be wiped out in one fell swoop. Which means that those who are left can fight back. Because they have their labor as leverage.

I didn’t feel like spelling that out because replying to two-sentence defeatism with multiple paragraphs is a lot of work.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by bluefirebrand on Monday May 11, 2026 @07:40PM (#48102270)
> the societal pressure on redistribution will rise.

And then we'll see if the wealthy and powerful people will just send automated killer drones after the poors, because culling us would be more preferable than sharing their wealth

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @05:00AM (#48105869)
Good for them that the poors on this board are too smart/polite/civilized to become NeoLuddites and sabotage their efforts.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by Mezzie on Monday May 11, 2026 @04:40PM (#48100379)
> Are we all going to be really well paid cleaners or something?

I work for a corporation that includes cleaning brands and I've got bad news...

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by tavavex on Monday May 11, 2026 @06:05PM (#48101297)
> A lot of the advice we're seeing today about retraining in construction worker or plumber seems to assume that there's an unlimited demand for this labour which there simply is not.

I think that most advice like this is individual - not systemic. We all won't fit into the remaining fields when white collar work gets less demand, but someone who's just pivoting now still could. There's no systemic solution that will actually be implemented. The only advice left to give to people is to not be too late. There's only so many people that can be trained to do this range of work (has a physical component that is difficult to automate + can only be done here + has an education/certification moat) just based on spots in educational programs, and they'd probably be better off getting on that sooner than later if they think that their current job is going to be in the crosshairs soon.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by srj on Monday May 11, 2026 @10:52PM (#48103643)
One way it seems different today is that wealth inequality is already quite high in the US. Even if AI delivers massive productivity gains the windfall is only likely to be more concentrated. When manufacturing was outsourced at least median housing wasn't 7x median income.

I'm curious what you mean by prepare, to have savings?

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by agentultra on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:50AM (#48096627)
This is the story that's been written since the Luddite revolts, as far as I know. The successors in that case were the capitalists who spent a significant amount of time and money convincing the constabulary and political figures to side with them. People were shot and jailed in the worst cases. The best case, workers were left without work or sent off to work-houses where they became indentured servants to the state.

The last work-house closed in the 1930s.

That all started not because people were afraid jobs were going to be replaced by the new loom. People had been using looms for centuries. They were protesting working conditions: low wages, lack of social protections when people were let go, child labor, work houses, etc. There were no labor laws at the time to protect workers... but there were these valuable new machines that the capital owners valued greatly. The machines were destroyed as leverage: a threat.

Since the capitalists ultimately "won" that conflict it has been written, by technocrats, that technological progress is virtuous and that while workers will initially be displaced the benefit to society will be enough such that those displaced will find productive work else where.

But I think even capitalist economists such as Keynes found the idea a bit preposterous. He wrote about how the gains in productivity from technological advances aren't being distributed back to workers: we're not working less, we're working more than ever. While it isn't about displacement of workers, it is displacement of value and that tends to go hand in hand.

I think asking, "Where do I go?" is a valid question. One that workers have been trying to ask since the Luddites at least. Unfortunately I think it's one that gets brushed under the rug. There doesn't seem to be much political will to provide systems that would make losing a job a non-issue and work optional.

That would give us the most leverage. If I didn't have to work in order to live I could leave a job or get displaced by the latest technological advancement. But I could retrain into anything I wanted and rejoin the work force when I was good and ready. I wouldn't have to risk losing my house, skipping meals, live without insurance, etc.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by keybored on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:52AM (#48096662)
The most future-proof “career” right now is having money. At least multiple million dollars. That’s a skill that is very much in demand.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by RealityVoid on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:53PM (#48098269)
Whoo, deff a field where I would try breaking in.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by djeastm on Monday May 11, 2026 @11:48AM (#48096586)
At least in the US, the only major non-AI growth field seems to be healthcare to deal with the swell of baby boomers living longer than people have before.

But if we're waiting to be paid to retrain there, I wouldn't hold our collective breath.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by bluGill on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:24PM (#48097892)
Baby boomers had already started the face of dying though. The next generation is still going to be right there. That generation is smaller. These people will always be dying. However, I wouldn't hold my breath if you're a young person in that field. Maybe but maybe not
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by srj on Monday May 11, 2026 @10:54PM (#48103657)
Probably many legally protected professions such as medicine and law will continue to be okay. There's a cap imposed on the number of residency positions that will keep those jobs scarce.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by badc0ffee on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @12:09AM (#48104100)
There are plenty of law grads unable to find work in their field.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by dominotw on Monday May 11, 2026 @12:50PM (#48097471)
AI cannot create art by itself.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by dugidugout on Monday May 11, 2026 @04:18PM (#48100132)
Hopefully the capital owners care to tell the difference.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by insane_dreamer on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:08PM (#48097674)
> I never read what those careers are

Exactly. I have yet to read a single logically sound argument that even gives a hint of what those professions/jobs might be (remember, they have to be plentiful enough to employ large numbers of people, so "I quit my corporate job and making more as a TikTok influencer" doesn't count). Remember that a new profession has to open up new hitherto unknown revenue streams otherwise there are no companies who will pay you.