However, I think it's important to remember that LLMs are embedded in larger systems, and those larger systems do learn.
we do also have training on synthetic data. it might compound.
If however I was a frontier lab who solved continual learning and my competitor also solved and released it, I would release mine immediately, obviously.
The point is, continual learning might be solved already, we just don't know and those who might know would rather keep their mouths shut. It isn't my base case (financial situation of frontier labs is such that they'd probably release immediately as long as they have inference compute to serve this revolutionary capability), but it isn't impossible.
The only lab that I can exempt from this is DARPA.
And let’s be honest - rules get bent all the time, especially when valuations are 9 figures. Stakeholders at this point won’t risk killing a golden goose.
I think this is a bit pedantic. Obviously the parent you’re replying to is referring to the concept of “in-context learning”, which is the actual industry / academic term for this. So you feed it a paper, and then it can use that info, and it needs steering / “mentoring” to be guided into the right direction.
Heck the whole name of “machine learning” suggests these things can actually learn. “reasoning” suggests that these things can reason, instead of being fancy, directed autocomplete. Etc.
In other news: data hydration doesn’t actually make your data wet. People use / misuse words all the time, and that causes their meaning to evolve.
And that can be very hard to do given the ui we most interact with them in is a chat session.
Obviously the real people that are classifying AI as human intelligence aren’t going to be the top comment on reviewing LLM’s PhD-level papers. They are on very different, much more problematic areas of the internet.
It’s the people that are the problem, nobody told the grandparent to use “mentoring” as a word, and my argument is that it’s a complete overreaction to classify them as anthropomorphizing AIs, and I’d argue default to that argument would be an insult to them, and it’s super pedantic.
If you say so bud.
> nobody told the grandparent to use “mentoring” as a word
Nobody told people to say "Google it" either; nobody told us to use the word "Kleenex" when we mean tissue; nobody told us to use the word "Chapstick" when we mean lip balm. Nobody told British people to say "Hoover" when they mean vacuum, or "Sellotape" when they mean transparent tape.
This is literally how soft influence works, it's how brands "colonize" language. A professor using the anthropomorphized word "mentoring" when talking about a machine, as if it's a student that can learn and develop relationships, is this same soft influence at work. The AI companies' websites are all riddled with cognitive language, their chat bots all use conversational UI like you're talking to a person, the bots answer with "we," "me," and "I." They created an environment that made anthropomorphized language feel natural, which only helps their marketing goals.
Go ahead and call it pedantry all you want, but that's the whole point. The problem is epistemic.
In other news: That words can change meaning doesn’t mean that every possible change in meaning would be beneficial to communication and therefore desirable. Would you advocate in support of someone suggesting to use “left” to mean “right” simply on the basis words can change in meaning?
what? training is learning, as long as weights are available continual learning is perfectly feasible: just keep training the LLM with the user corpus alternated with a frozen version to prevent catastrophic drift / collapse.
it's not because model providers don't want to provide user specific continual learning, that we don't know how to do it.
it would be a lot more expensive to host user-specific model weights, and would prevent amortizing the weights over many requests in batches...
It’s also because it is so annoying to have to manage the memory of the LLM with custom prompts/instructions manually.
I have not yet played with the long term memory feature, but I fear it will be even less reliable than prompts, simply because in one year or two years so much will have changed again that this “memory” will have to be redone multiple times by then.