Any examples how you see some engineers being left behind?
It is anecdotal for sure, but it's a pattern that seems to be emerging around me that expectations of velocity increases, and those who don't use AI can't keep up.
Kind of.... I don't know. To get placed such requirements from the top down and not fight back, just take it head on, not even maliciously, don't even oppose it on a technical basis, just be like "yeah, you've now gotta ship faster or you're left behind, so therefore LLMs must be the future!", no critical thought attached. Is this shit coming from experienced engineers?
Preposterous we're relying on "it's better because I feel like", "dudes who don't use it are falling behind at work", "they ask for it in job interviews".
I don't know where you live, but around where I live in Denmark you'd fail for not using AI at a senior interview in a lot of places. Even places which aren't exactly AI fans use AI to some extend.
The biggest challenge we face right now is figuring out how you create developers who have enough experience to know how to use the AI tools in a critical manner. Especially because you're typically given agents for various taks, which are already configured to know how we want things to be written.
Additionally there are the AI targets set by C suites based on what everyone is saying on TV, and what we can actually deliver based on the available data sets, integration points, and naturally those sign offs for data governance, and hallucinations guardrails.
> If you don't jump off the cliff you're falling behind
If you can’t interview without immediately reaching for an LLM you are considered unfit to work here.
But it absolutely has to be combined with verification/testing at the same speed as code production.
On the other hand, LLM-generated code comments better than I do, so given a long enough time horizon, it could be more understandable at a later time than code I've written myself (we've all had the experience of forgetting how things work).
> On the other hand, LLM-generated code comments better than I do, so given a long enough time horizon, it could be more understandable at a later time than code I've written myself (we've all had the experience of forgetting how things work).
Writing and rewriting piece of software performs what is called "spaced repetition" [1].[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaced_repetition
You ask questions about code when you implement something and if you cannot answer these questions, you go to code to find answers out and refresh your understanding of it.
For this to work you have to be interested in the understanding of the code and code should be created at the pace you can keep up.
Software engineers usually do create code economically because they need to remember and understand it. Vibe coders do not have this particular constraint, they just do not aim for most understandable code possible. Even if there are more comments in code.
However, this comes at the cost of losing track of the minute details of the implementation because you didn't write it yourself. I find it a bit analogous to code I've reviewed vs code I've written.
However, I've found using AI for code structure summary and questioning tends to be a good way to get around it. I might forget faster, but I also pick it up faster.
reminds me of the experience of reading a math text without doing the exercises, thinking that you've understood the material, and then falling flat on your face when you attempt to apply your "understanding" to a novel problem. there's a significant difference between passively reading something and really putting active effort into it. only the latter leads to actual understanding ime
Then, after it says, yes I'm sure this is production ready and we're good to move on, you have Codex and Gemini both review it one last time, and ask it to address their feedback if it's valuable or not.
After all this, it's the only time I'll look at the code and review it and make sure it's coherent.
Until then, I assume it's garbage.
I'd estimate this still improves velocity by 10x, and more importantly, allows me to operate at a pace I couldn't without burning out.
You're just getting less work done on a slower cadence and asking the questions in design review and in code reviews...
i don't mind managing people, but i don't want to manage machines unless i can control them with the precise languages that the commandline and programming languages use. prompting a LLM is to vague an interface for me, the outcome is to unreliable, to unpredictable.
It would be an honor to be “left behind” by people who practice their craft with such carelessness.
(Frankly, I should probably stop replying to self-professed LLM boosters entirely since there’s a good chance I’m just chatting with an LLM.)
I'm not saying that I'm no longer dealing with code at all though. The way I work is interactively with the LLM and pretty much tell it exactly what to do and how to do it. Sometimes all the way down to "don't copy the reference like that, grab a deep copy of the object instead". Just like with any other type of programming, the only way to achieve valuable and correct results is by knowing exactly what you want and express that exactly and without ambiguity.
But I no longer need to remember most of the syntax for the language I happen to work with at the moment, and can instead spend time thinking about the high level architecture. To make sure each involved component does one thing and one thing well, with its complexities hidden behind clear interfaces.
Engineers who refuse to, or can't, or won't utilize the benefits that LLMs bring will be left behind. It's just the way it is. I'm already seeing it happening.