News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:17PM (#47924426)
The best-reasoned criticism of glyphosate is that it disrupts the gut biome (this is a fact). I suspect that many "gluten allergies" are actually gut biome problems from glyphosate-desiccated wheat.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:19PM (#47924470)
Anything that reaches the gut intact disrupts (ie: manipulates, interacts with, alters, stimulates or suppresses, selects) the gut biome. I'm not pushing back on you except to say that as a mechanistic axiomatic claim of harm, it's missing most of the evidence. You could be right, but you could also be wrong; what you've said so far can't possibly be dispositive.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:23PM (#47924515)
The mechanism of action of glyphosate inhibits several important amino acid production processes in the gut. I'm simplifying here, but not having glyphosate in the food supply would be a good thing for the gut, and the science agrees on this.

Glyphosate for field prep also doesn't really come through in food, it's much worse with the pre-harvest desiccation.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by mapt on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:28PM (#47924577)
You are inferring from our crude understanding of processes in general. Evidence is more specific.

Do you have an exclusion trial comparing glyphosate vs non-glyphosate diets? This is amenable to natural experiments where one country bans it on a specific date and the neighbor does not.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by bigbadfeline on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:30PM (#47926926)
> Do you have an exclusion trial comparing glyphosate vs non-glyphosate diets?

That's a rather sneaky way to invert the issue. It's fishing for random luck when you ask for more and harder to obtain evidence given existing facts pointing to possible harm. A single study that doesn't show harm doesn't refute those that do.

You have to provide hard evidence that glyphosate (or another non-essential ingredient) does not cause adverse effects, and thoroughly explain the differences with the studies that show the opposite - until you do that, any in-vitro or other studies that show harmful effects count against the use of the product and you cannot ask for more evidence, you can only accept the remedies.

In this case, the appropriate remedies can be different: banning it altogether, limiting it to specific usage (e.g. no pre-harvest spraying), labeling using LARGE PRINT and scary language or some combination of the above.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:09PM (#47927334)
You can't even get smoked fish accepted through precautionary-principle logic like that. This is the same reasoning that puts cancer warnings on bags of potato chips.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by bigbadfeline on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:24PM (#47928208)
> You can't even get smoked fish accepted through precautionary-principle logic like that.

No, you really can't do that without breaking the Code of Federal Regulations. Smoked products must be labeled "smoked" in addition to many other requirements, and that despite the distinctive stink that self-labels these products. Even the font size is specified to be no smaller than the letters for the kind of meat on the label.

The real issue is why there's no such requirement for glyphosate, having it would be a good starting point.

> This is the same reasoning that puts cancer warnings on bags of potato chips.

I don't think all potato chips deserve, or have, such warnings but some might. Regardless, there might be specific regulations that are over the top and I don't mind admitting or discussing such cases but glyphosate isn't among them.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by mapt on Friday May 01, 2026 @10:49AM (#47975426)
Potato chips (and all other carbs that have been fried/baked/roasted/toasted at Maillard-browning temperatures) have an appreciable amount of acrylamide in them. Acrylamide is a probable human carcinogen and a neurotoxin.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by vkou on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:13PM (#47927381)
Smoked fish is a side, wheat is a staple. Degree matters.

If 90% of the raw food at the grocery were 'processed' in the same way that a smoked fish, or a french fry was, I think we'd have very valid reasons to be displeased with many of the myriad problems that come with that.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:48PM (#47927808)
First, no it isn't, not in the cultures where it's believed to cause stomach cancer. Second: at the point where you're talking about distinguishing public policy based on whether something is a "side dish" or not, I think we've left the realm of plausibility and entered a wonderful new land I call "the voivodeship of special pleading".
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:49PM (#47927127)
Here's a decent one: 13% of the UK reports gluten intolerance symptoms, and only 7% of Germany does. The UK allows pre-harvest glyphosate desiccation, Germany doesn't. I would be happy to bet that the trend continues past my quick Google search.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:46PM (#47927792)
Surely there are no other lifestyle, supply chain, or medical system differences between the UK and Germany! Open and shut!
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by fragmede on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:52PM (#47927864)
I mean, I went to an Ikea and a McDonald's in both those places, and they were the same, so surely everything else must be homogenized!
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by mapt on Friday May 01, 2026 @10:45AM (#47975384)
N=2.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by jandrewrogers on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:50PM (#47924891)
AFAIK the preponderance of the evidence is that most "gluten sensitivity" is actually just a FODMAP sensitivity, which also interacts with the gut biome.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by AnimalMuppet on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:37PM (#47926997)
Off topic, but can someone ELI5 (or at least ELI20) what the deal is with FODMAP? I keep hearing about it, but I don't understand it at all.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by jml7c5 on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:37PM (#47927664)
The Wikipedia page for it is pretty good. Basically, there are a number of short-chain carbohydrates that tend to pass through the small intestine (where nutrients are digested and absorbed into the bloodstream) and reach the large intestine (where water is removed). Bacteria in the large intestine eat these nutrients (fermentation). In some people, this causes intestinal distress. (Bloating, gas, discomfort, watery stool, etc.) It's not clear why this only affects some people.

You hear a lot about it because a large subset of people have discovered that a low-FODMAP diet relieves their torment of intestinal distress.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by saxonww on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:35PM (#47927634)
FODMAP stands for fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols. FODMAPs generate gas as side effect of being fermented in the gut. Most people just pass this gas, but for some people, usually people with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), it can be very uncomfortable and amplify their other IBS problems.

People who are suffering from pain and bloating with no obvious cause may be advised to go on a low-FODMAP diet for a few weeks to see if their symptoms go away.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:50PM (#47927833)
We just had a story about de-farting beans on the front page. The FODMAPs are (among other things) the bean farts.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by ottah on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:32PM (#47926943)
I will never understand this bizarre obsession with gut flora. We don't know what is normal, what is a beneficial ratio or when a change happens if that is good or bad thing. No one besides the people who study these things should be much attention to gut microbiomes. We just don't have enough information to let this be an influence on decision making.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by eagsalazar2 on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:00PM (#47927240)
Your comment seems a little flippant honestly. I know what "disrupted" is, trust me. I developed a gluten sensitivity about 10 years ago but only figured it out 5 years ago. "Healthy" is "feels healthy" and "doesn't die young", that is pretty simple.

It sounds like you think this is about hypothetical and marginal health benefits but people have very acute and immediate physical (and cognitive) issues because of disrupted gut biome that are objectively improved by cutting out, in particular, gluten. This isn't just some weird obession.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by array_key_first on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:20PM (#47928170)
Gluten intolerance is a real thing but I don't think that necessarily means that your gut flora is damaged or whatever. Plenty of people are lactose intolerant, and their gut flora is fine, they're just lactose intolerant.

I don't think you could solve gluten intolerance but just improving your gut microbiome, so they're probably not related.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by onlypassingthru on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:59PM (#47928455)
Why not? A fecal transplant seems to work for C. difficile sufferers.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by array_key_first on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @12:31AM (#47930476)
A fecal transplant definitely doesn't work for celiac disease, which is the only gluten intolerance you have to worry about.

Other gluten intolerance is probably not gluten, gluten is just a close enough proxy. Could be FODMAP + IBS or maybe some other sensitivity.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by mint5 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:40AM (#47935315)
Why are you narrowly focusing on gluten intolerance when this line of comments appears to be denying whether gut biome is worth caring about due to having impacts on health?
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by array_key_first on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @12:13PM (#47936440)
Because the parent used their anecdote of gluten intolerance to explain why caring about the gut microbiome matters. But traditional gluten intolerances are not related to the gut microbiome.

We also don't really understand why things like a FODMAP diet work. It's not that feeding your gut bacteria is bad, it's actually pretty good. But for some people it's bad, and they get symptoms they attribute to gluten intolerance.

Legumes, onions, whole grain etc that are high FODMAP are good for you. Fiber is good for you, it lowers your risk of metabolic diseases and helps your digestion. But, for some people, it's bad for their digestion. That's weird.

So all that is to say that, while gut bacteria matters, it varies person to person and we can't definitely say what food is good for the microbiome and what isn't.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by onlypassingthru on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @12:39PM (#47936851)
I think the interesting point as evidenced by the fecal transplant therapy is that it's not "the" microbiome, it's "your" microbiome. Maybe some people have bad (C. difficile) or incompatible (various E. coli strains) microbiomes and need a microbiome hard reboot.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by wasabi991011 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @12:41PM (#47936892)
> Could be FODMAP + IBS or maybe some other sensitivity.

Seems extremely unlikely. Of someone is eliminating gluten they from their diet they usually aren't also eliminating dairy, legumes, and other high-fodmap foods; gluten-free is restrictive enough already.

The only other sensitivity I could think of in which this makes sense is wheat sensitivity (but not other gluten containing grains which are less common).

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:46PM (#47927092)
We know that it's really important to neurological function, which is enough reason to be careful.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:00PM (#47927248)
By itself, it's simply an argument that proves too much. Anything you ingest impacts your gut flora. There can be gut microbiome hypos about glyphosate! But you have to actually have them; you can't stop at "it impacts gut flora".
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:44PM (#47927771)
Well, I didn't intend that as a conversation-ender, but it is true. This particular substance inhibits a particular function of certain gut flora that seems important. I think it's safe to call that significant.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:49PM (#47927824)
What "particular function" is that? If it's "the part that influences neurological function", you don't have a complete argument. If you can't be specific about this, your argument falls apart, because almost everything we eat potentially "inhibits" (or accelerates) different areas of our gut flora.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:54PM (#47929217)
I'm not trying to make a complete argument, I'm trying to raise a flag. This issue is not well-studied and has very large corporate sponsors who would like to keep selling Roundup-Ready™ crops. One particular measurable function is inhibition of the shikamate pathway in many different bacteria (the majority of the volume of your gut flora is affected).

Here's a decent paper that shows an adverse effect: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10330715/

I understand that this is the realm of crunchy weirdos, but thinking holistically doesn't mean you need to lobotomize yourself.

Here's another paper examining some brain effects of chronic gut inflammation, which could be reasonably inferred as a potential consequence of long-term glyphosate exposure: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10661239/

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:03PM (#47929283)
You haven't raised a flag! You've observed (and cited a paper that shows in mouse models under relatively high human dosages) that glyphosate can impact certain gut bacteria species. That's plausible! But all sorts of things do that, and you haven't presented evidence that connects that to an adverse human health outcome. In particular: you haven't cited a source showing glyphosate is causative of gut inflammation.

"It impacts the gut biome" isn't a get-out-of-jail-free card for these arguments; if it were, you could knock down all sorts of things, including specific diets (and most abrupt changes in diet).

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:12PM (#47929364)
Call it (pun intended) a smell test. I have cited a study that shows biomarkers of gut inflammation strongly correlated with glyphosate exposure. Perhaps you should have read it.

I have raised a flag. Lowering your exposure to a novel chemical agent that directly impacts a massive and poorly-understood symbiotic system within the body isn't a bad response. Glyphosate exposure certainly isn't beneficial, so I'll treat it like Pascal's wager: avoiding this has more upside than downside.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:37PM (#47929540)
I obviously did look at the paper. Glyphosate isn't going anywhere, so Pascal's Wager isn't on the table.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:31PM (#47929883)
You can absolutely avoid glyphosate in your diet. This is obviously some sort of emotional issue for you.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:16PM (#47930106)
I don't think there's much glyphosate in any of our diets!
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by mint5 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:38AM (#47935284)
“I don’t understand it well enough in my opinion so we shouldn’t care about it”?

I’m pretty sure there’s hundreds of things we rightly understood are detrimental centuries before we knew how it worked. Aka pretty much everything bad before 1900.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:06PM (#47928023)
Changing your diet disrupts the gut biome. When I started eating bran flakes it massively disrupted my gut biome. Should I be alarmed? Or are you slipping a double standard in there, perhaps from the naturalistic fallacy?
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:04PM (#47929295)
Maybe you should see if you adjust to the bran flakes, cut them out if you don't improve, and see if there's a difference? All sorts of things can disrupt gut biomes, and I think ancestral diets are an interesting area of study. Gut inflammation is absolutely rampant.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:44PM (#47929956)
That misses the point I was making.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by array_key_first on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:17PM (#47928134)
People who have gluten allergies have a legitimate disease, typically celiac disease.

Being tired after eating bread or whatever is not a gluten allergy, that's just how food works. A lot of people claim to have gluten allergies but no, you would know for sure if you had a gluten allergy.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by brightball on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:55PM (#47928424)
Posted this above, but will repost here because it's relevant.

There are numerous studies that show glyphosate binds with aluminum and other metals, having negative impacts on public health.

"Aluminum and Glyphosate Can Synergistically Induce Pineal Gland Pathology: Connection to Gut Dysbiosis and Neurological Disease"

https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=53106

"Glyphosate, a chelating agent—relevant for ecological risk assessment?"

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5823954/

"Glyphosate complexation to aluminium(III). An equilibrium and structural study in solution using potentiometry, multinuclear NMR, ATR–FTIR, ESI-MS and DFT calculations"

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01620...

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:01PM (#47928847)
And, as noted above, the paper you're citing here is a joke. Its primary author isn't even a subject matter expert; their PhD is in computer science.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by rpmisms on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:06PM (#47929313)
Can you attack the methodology or data instead of the author?
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:36PM (#47929530)
I did, across the thread. If we want to argue about the paper, there's where we should do it.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by hinkley on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @03:19AM (#47931354)
Roundup also contains a very strong surfactant and we know that those totally fuck up your GI as well.