> As for Google I feel it is less of a problem... They don't have a big presence in the UK.
So let me get this straight, you are OK with Google not paying taxes because... they don't provide jobs to the UK? My apologies if I honestly misunderstood your post, but it seems really strange that you let Google "off the hook" since they ONLY remove money from your economy and don't even create jobs there. The way your post is worded its as if you are offended that Amazon and Starbucks provide thousands of jobs.
If Amazon and Starbucks figured out a way to provide the exact same services they do today, minus all those pesky UK employees, would you feel less angry with them?
Google services don't really benefit much from UK infrastructure (except digital infrastructure, which is privately owned for the most part at this point in time).
Amazon and Starbucks simply would not be in business without UK roads, UK police and other UK services; so Amazon and Starbucks are benefitting from taxpayer-funded services while not contributing their fair share to their maintenance.
EDIT: sorry, I wasn't clear -- I'm not arguing that Google should be treated differently, I was just suggesting a justification for the difference in perception.
Google is in a slightly different place because it benefits less directly from this infrastructure. Which doesn't mean they shouldn't pay more than they do now, of course.
The UK hasn't had ring fenced taxes for decades if ever.
But that's beside the point, if you want to take a different view on it, a healthy population is a resource on which these companies draw. In the US model, companies also pay for this, direct to their employees private health insurers. But pay it they (mostly) do.
Well it's obvious why: once you make welfare (almost) free, people abuse of it because they do not see the cost and they have nothing to report to no one.
The standard UK pension is £107.45 per week for a single person, £171.85 for a couple. If you think that's allowing people to live the high life then you and I have a very different view of what the high life is.
£9,000 a year (and this after a 40-odd year working life paying tax) for a couple to cover all living costs doesn't stretch to much in the way of hot springs vacations once you've paid for food, heating and so on.
Benefits are a safety net, they're not some route to easy luxury. Living on benefits is hard and not a whole bunch of fun. Yes there are some people who abuse them (though fewer than many would think) but that's the price we pay for having that safety net there. To get rid of them would be throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
A family member of mine is the head for a large region of Scotland for the Department of Work and Pensions.
They say that it is terrible what goes on. The average pensioner scrapes by and often do not take all that they are entitled to despite paying into the system for decades as you said.
On the other side is a huge amount of people claiming incredible amounts and have never worked in their life.
The people that do work hard and hit a rough patch are consistently those that claim the least, often waiting a lot longer than they need to before claiming anything.
Uk has the 4th largest defence budget in the world of £46.3 billion. We spend £62.3 billion on welfare. [http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/year_spending_2013UKbn_12b...]
Estimates put abuse (fraud, payment through mistakes) at 2%. Yes that's a lot of money, but that's not going to turn the country's fortunes around if it were eliminated. Realistically there is likely to be a minimum realistic level of fraud which balances the cost of catching offenders against the cost of the offence, and the side effects in excluding those who are actually valid claimants.
Those using the system as it's intended (that is being genuinely out of work, unwell or whatever) are a bit trickier. There are bits of Scotland that have terrifying problems. I live in Glasgow and the east end has areas where there are three generations of families who've never worked.
That's obviously a major problem but there are a few things it's worth thinking about:
1) Long term unemployed - that is longer than 12 months - is less than 30% of the overall unemployment figures. That's obviously pretty high (though not surprising, it's harder to get a job when you've been out of work for a while so it's self reenforcing) but many of those will be people who genuinely want a job. The people I mention who've never worked and will never work are a tiny fraction of that.
2) Contrary to popular belief, these people are not living any kind of luxurious existence. People point to satellite TV without realising that most of those decoder cards are pirated and designer clothes without understanding that for the most part they're fake.
3) How you deal with it is complex - pulling benefits from these people is more likely to drive them to crime than to work.
4) How do you make sure you get people who are genuinely on the take without removing the safety net from those who need and want it?
So I'd argue (a) it's a smaller problem than many suggest and that (b) the solutions are a little more complex than the swift kick up the arse that some feel will sort things out.
Citation needed. All the evidence I've seen is that the French are much healthier than Americans.
On the other hand in 2008 Forbes compiled a list of the 15 healthiest countries based on a range of factors. France were number 15, the US were number 11.
Broadly I think they're probably about the same - essentially healthy Western nations who could do better.
For me the most interesting statistic about nationalised healthcare vs. the US model of private healthcare (other models are available) is the cost:
The US pays more per person on healthcare admin than the UK pays into the NHS in total.
"Based on detailed interviews with over 89,000 people, the results showed that 15% of the population from high-income countries (compared to 11% for low/middle-income countries) were likely to get depression over their lifetime with 5.5% having had depression in the last year. MDE were elevated in high-income countries (28% compared to 20%) and were especially high (over 30%) in France, the Netherlands, and America. "
Google is ought to pay taxes like everyone else. Without the UK infrastructure, there would be no businesses to advertise through their service.
Taxes fund healthcare and security. Without healthcare, people would die and Google would have less customers. With no police and justice system someone could just go and bomb Google's UK datacenters.
Trying to rationalize why one company should not pay taxes while others do is bad.
Google extracts profits from UK economy and doesn't pay anything in taxes. It's bad for every UK resident.
If there was no Google, people would use directories/yelps/UK-based search engines which would pay taxes. In this case, from the economic point of view, Google is simply a parasite.
It is not particularly bad if you take into account where they actually make their money.
Would you levy UK taxes on every penny Google makes, simply because their sites are accessible in the UK and used by UK residents? That would make no sense.
Google should be taxed fairly on the business they do in the UK, sure, but nothing more. I think that was the grandparent's point: Google likely does less business in the UK than Starbucks or Amazon, and even then the business that they do perform is more immaterial and it's harder to identify the source.
Thus it makes some sense that Google's evasion is "less surprising" in a way, because it is on a smaller scale. No one is saying that Google should not have to pay taxes on the business it does in the UK; we are simply quantifying what it means to do business and in what way.
This is, in fact, quite logical thinking, and there's no need to be alarmed.
You check they're not using weird accounting to set up a (tiny) business in a low tax regime, and then syphoning money out of the high tax regime into that low tax regime.
Google has customers in the UK buying ads, and people in the UK viewing ads - it seems reasonable that they should pay UK tax on those bits.
After all they make their money in the Bahamas.
Over 90% of companies pay 19% of income tax + over 20% VAT tax. They often times coexist in the markets with the corporations paying 1%.
It's not important whether it's Google or Apple or BP - they should all pay the same taxes the small/medium business owners pay. Corporations use the same infrastructure that small/medium business owners pay for. Meanwhile they say "fuck you!" to said people and pay their 1% in the Bahamas. Additionally, they get enormous competetive advantage through lower taxes while medium or small companies need to gain it through superior products.
To be clear, VAT registered entities do not pay VAT in the fashion you imply. VAT is due on a VAT invoice. Companies usually do not do business with sources that are not VAT registered. It is a round robin scheme for VAT registered entities.
Simple example.
Month one, Google sells a tablet. Customer pays VAT. Google gives VAT income to HMRC ( once per quarter ).
Month two, Google sells a tablet. Google buys goods plus VAT. Google subtracts VAT out from VAT in. HRMC pays Google if amount is negative. Google pays HMRC if amount is positive. This month Company X paid more VAT on stationary than they collected from sales. In this case they get a refund from HMRC.
In no case does Google pay VAT. Nor does any other VAT registered entity.
The entities that pay VAT are those who are not VAT registered. Those that are VAT registered are collectors for HMRC.
Google, Starbucks, Amazon have never paid VAT. They have at most passed on VAT payments made by their customers.
If comes down to the two definitions of fair - is it fair that you pay for what you use, or pay that you pay what you can afford?
A tax system tends to walk the line between the two of these but it's very rare than any tax or tax system makes it a simple matter of charging for resource usage. There are elements of that, sure (and Amazon and Starbucks will pay additional road tax, fuel tax, property charges, NI on employees and so on so they are paying more than Google in that way) but part of it is you pay what you can afford.
In the same way prices aren't set based on what something costs, they're primarily based on what something is worth (go look at the cost of a Starbucks Latte and then we can talk if you disagree), that's how many taxes are set. Corporation tax is (or should be) Google paying for access to the market they wish to operate in - that's what the UK government is offering them and that's what they should be paying for. If that's a good deal for them (and even paying full corporation tax it is) then great, if not they can go somewhere else.
It's the equivalent of the argument that taxes are the price we pay for living in a civilized society. Taxes are the price you should pay for operating in an attractive market.
Google have a main office in London http://www.google.co.uk/about/jobs/locations/london/ , and also the campus startup/co-working space at http://www.campuslondon.com/, so clearly they do provide jobs to the UK.
If that's a significant percentage of their worldwide operation, I can only guess. Given that they say about the London office "We’re one of Google’s largest engineering operations in Europe", probably yes.
Contentious - damage, or consumer choice and therefore progress?
> However I feel both are taking the piss when it comes to taxes
While I have zero doubt these companies and others will be taking 101% advantage of the situation, don't forget that the situation has been created by our own governments and an unwillingness to modernise in the face of a globalised world.
For example, it surprises most people to learn that this 'brand value' Starbucks charges itself for (or the fact that these companies charge themselves between entities in the first place) is in many ways a requirement of the corporation to abide by transfer pricing rules.
It's a matter of whether there is a level playing field. I was shocked to hear the representative from Amazon admit yesterday that they only pay 3% tax on ebook sales through an agreement with Luxembourg.
That's absurd.
Ultimately it is the fault of the voters, and as another poster pointed out, this is about a level playing field, not "punishing" big multi nationals.
What we have seen since the 80's is a corporate oligarchy being created, if you can get into it you are set for life.
These people are Nixonian in their attitude, "it's not morally wrong when I avoid taxes". This also stems from the amorality of Ayn Rand's writings, in Randian thinking it is acceptable to expect others to follow a moral code which you yourself break and it's acceptable to admonish others for breaking it.
Big companies don't actually create a lot of jobs, most companies over their lifespan shed workers as they become more efficient. For a healthy free market to operate, it is vitally important that the percentage tax burden is the same for small companies and large companies, governments should not be giving tax advantages to anyone. This economic cherry picking causes "too big to fail" syndrome.
As a UK voter, if a political party said they would simplify the tax code and make all companies who operate in the UK pay taxes on their business here I would probably vote for them.
Maybe you should consider what is really hurting the Economy. The fact that your government is borrowing 5 billions every two weeks on the markets to keep functioning because its damn broke and cannot handle a budget, or the fact that Google did not pay (while absolutely legal) a few hundred millions in last year. If you apply the 80/20 rule, I think your attention is well misguided.
The two things aren't linked, the fact that we need to get our house in order is surely a reason to make sure we're ensuring we can get in whatever revenue we can?
Well, it is fairly obvious that fixing the huge debt problem in the UK and all developed countries in the similar situation is the most urgent thing to do instead of trying to fill the hole with the "missing" taxes here and there, because no matter how Google and other will pay in tax locally it will never make up for the huge hole they are digging everyday through their inability to keep a straight budget.
It's all a matter of priorities, and proportions. And the media (usually state-controlled, at least partly) certainly want you to see the "skin rash" rather than their own mistakes, because you should be way more angry by how lax they are with YOUR money in the first place.
Sorting out the government debt needs to happen but the 600-odd MPs and hundreds of thousands of civil servants employed by the UK government may well be capable of dealing with as many as two things.
I don't buy this. It's absurd that a UK business can pay to place ads on the Google UK website, presenting them solely to UK consumers, and yet the money involved in this transaction never touches the UK.
It goes straight to Ireland, then the Netherlands, to Bermuda.
There would be taxes on the profits of a UK company, which IMO is the wrong way to go about it; just tax the income made by UK investors who own shares in a company (wherever that company happens to be based). The money can bounce around through as many shell companies as you like, but at some point it becomes an individual's income; tax it there.
I'm no accountant or tax lawyer, but it's obvious Google are playing games with the UK. According to their own filings, they made $4bn from UK sales in the last financial year.
The representative yesterday shrugged it off and tried to make out all Google do in the UK is have a bunch of promotions/localization staff. They (Google UK Ltd) receive all their income from Google in Ireland, and end up reporting a loss, meaning they pay a nominal amount of tax to the UK tax authorities.
$4bn in sales from the UK market and they pay UK tax authorities around $5mn in tax.
That's why people are angry, and that's why their representative was getting laid into by MPs yesterday.
Almost zero for one tax, but they certainly pay lots of other taxes. Mom and pop coffee shops aren't known to be large tax payers either, they probably weren't paying much more than Starbucks is now.
It's not avoiding a reasonable amount of tax that is annoying to most people. It is the transparent exploitation of loopholes to evade tax that is annoying.
Eg: Starbucks has to pay starbucks to use the brand starbucks, which means starbucks pays less corporation tax here, but more in the country where they've registered the company that owns the starbucks brand. (Which just happens to be an office in a building in a country with a low corporation tax rate.)
I guess I just don't understand that viewpoint. I would be shocked if a company wasn't using legal means to reduce its expenses. The problem isn't companies using loopholes, it's that there are loopholes in the first place.
Big companies like loopholes like this because they have the advantage in using them (lots of accountants) and in the US many voters like them because closing them is "raising taxes". At the end of the day it's a gift to large corporations at the expense of small businesses and startups.
Bob should be paying 40% tax. Bob uses normal legal means and reduces his tax burden to 25%. Some people think he's a but cheeky; most people don't really care (or are jealous that he has an accountant); some people say "good on you!"
Ann should be paying 40% tax. Ann uses a bunch of weird interpretations of tax law to squeeze through loopholes. Ann has to keep changing her finances because the loopholes keep changing. Ann pays about 0.5%. Ann then claims that she can hire a cleaner, and so we should be grateful that the cleaner pays PAYE and can buy goods which will have VAT.
At the same time as Ann and Bob are avoiding tax everyone is going through tough times; their jobs are at risk, their services are being cut.
Everyone knows that rich people and companies avoid some tax. Most people really don't care, so long as some kind of tax is being paid.
To blame Amazon is to only look at one side of the argument...
What about the high levels of rent on the high street, and the costs of parking etc.?
Councils, landlords and others all have played their part in the damage to the high street too.
No corporation pays taxes, they simply collect taxes for whichever government entity has its hands out. The reason why this works so well is that in general people are ignorant. It also helps that many are selfish, thinking that since they don't buy from X they aren't subject to the tax somehow.
So yeah, its annoying some companies are not paying into the local coffers but that is only the real issue being buried by those who like the populace clueless in tax matters.
In the states, I am not sure how the UK works, we have withholding tax where taxes are deducted from our pay before we see it. It helps hide the burden of government. So does taxing corporations.
Think about it, if every purchase you made had a line entry for "THIS IS THE EMBEDDED TAX" what do you think people would do?
I want Amazon and Starbucks here. However I feel both are taking the piss when it comes to taxes. Amazon say they run a distribution network or something and so only have to pay minimal taxes. I feel the fact that these companies failed to justify why they pay the tax they do prove that they are doing something wrong - even if its not illegal.
As for Google I feel it is less of a problem. They mainly deal in digital goods. They don't have a big presence in the UK. They just offer their online service's here. As most of the tech work is done in the US or Ireland I don't think they have much to justify with their tax situation. I work for a website-as-a-service company and we have thousands of clients scattered around the world. Around 500 are based in the UK. I don't really see how we could accurately be charged tax based on geographical location of Sales.