News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by victorbjorklund on Friday April 03, 2026 @05:59AM (#47624862)
I don’t think that is a useful definition even if technically true. With that logic even Linux isn’t privacy because in theory they can push code that will only run for you.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by palata on Friday April 03, 2026 @07:03AM (#47625276)
I think the argument is that when you load a webpage, you download the code everytime you want to run it, from servers owned by the company building the service. So they can choose to serve you different software (e.g. with a backdoor), just this one time and just for you, and you won't know (not that it would be impossible, but it is generally impossible in practice).

When you download a program on Linux through the distro package manager, you download it once and run this, every time. You know very well when it gets updated. You can compare the hash of your program/package with the one distributed by the distro, and the distro is not the developer of the program (so there is another layer there). You can audit that code (if open source), and at the very least you can compare with others to see if they receive the same code. And again, the program is served by the distro, not by the developer. The backdoor situation would require asking the developer to implement a backdoor, and then asking the distro to server you a different executable, and then hoping that you never, ever check the hash of that program that you own offline. It's a lot harder.

In a way, for ProtonMail (in your browser) to be "end-to-end encrypted", you have to trust Proton. But that kind of defeats the purpose of end-to-end encryption.

Same applies to e.g. WhatsApp Web, which is an interesting example because there exists a browser extension allowing you to "validate" that you run the code Meta expects you to run. Though you still have to trust Meta: the extension only helps making sure that nobody other than Meta is abusing you. The WhatsApp mobile app doesn't have that problem, as it is distributed as an archive by a third party (Play Store).

Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by IAmBroom on Friday April 03, 2026 @08:24AM (#47625880)
> In a way, for ProtonMail (in your browser) to be "end-to-end encrypted", you have to trust Proton. But that kind of defeats the purpose of end-to-end encryption.

Yes, and every VPN in the world (that isn't self-hosted) relies on trust that they won't share your info, not even your fingerprint - which defeats the purpose of VPNs. It's very hard to have perfect security. OK, impossible.

Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by palata on Friday April 03, 2026 @09:22AM (#47626402)
Sure, it's always a tradeoff. There is no "perfect" security, but there is "better" and "worse" for the threat model.

My point here is that when you run a webapp from a browser, you have to trust the server. When you run a program that you download on your system, it's easier to check that it doesn't change and to make sure that others get the same one.

Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by mapontosevenths on Friday April 03, 2026 @10:00AM (#47626745)
Exactly, as with all security you have to ask what the threat model you're defending against is and what you're willing to pay.

If it's "Google knows too much and I want an alternative" Proton is great, cheap, and convienent. If it' "my own government might kill me" then it might be time to think about self hosting.

Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by palata on Friday April 03, 2026 @11:08AM (#47627533)
> "Google knows too much and I want an alternative" Proton is great, cheap, and convienent.

I think that Proton does a good job with the suite (docs, sheets, calendar, password manager), and I believe they have a good VPN (for what we may expect from a VPN).

Interestingly, Proton started with ProtonMail, and I find it's the least convincing of their products:

1. As an individual, writing from your ProtonMail account to (probably) someone on GMail doesn't change anything.

2. As a company, writing from Proton to Proton is a good idea, but there is no need for end-to-end encryption: just choose a mail provider you trust, I guess?

3. The ProtonMail end-to-end encryption in the web browser defeats the purpose of E2EE: you have to trust Proton anyway, because they serve the code every time your employees load the page.

Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by maweaver on Friday April 03, 2026 @06:30AM (#47625040)
Using what mechanism? Most Linux updates are not pushed but rather pulled at the user request. You can use Linux totally offline. This is fundamentally different than a webapp, where code is sent with every visit
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by izacus on Friday April 03, 2026 @07:05AM (#47625285)
The automatic updates most distros have enabled by default. Signal desktop outright stops working if you don't constantly pull updates from them.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by the8472 on Friday April 03, 2026 @07:53AM (#47625637)
Distros have mirrors and they don't know which one you use. The updaters don't send user IDs and downloading the package lists is separate from downloading the packages. So targeted backdoor distrubution is much harder than a company's web UI with user logins targeting a specific user.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by 63stack on Friday April 03, 2026 @07:38AM (#47625516)
Debian requires unattended-upgrades to be installed (it's not installed by default), Mint and Fedora has the option of enabling automatic updates (disabled by default), Arch has no mechanism for automatic updates.

Which ones are these "most distros"?

Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by littlestymaar on Friday April 03, 2026 @07:12AM (#47625329)
Signal pushing updates every other day is pretty much a security anti-pattern though. It makes it almost as vulnerable as a web app to this kind of thing, but this isn't the typical Linux software experience by any stretch.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by izacus on Friday April 03, 2026 @01:03PM (#47629204)
A typical user experience is Ubuntu/Fedora with Auto Updates from repos enabled.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by victorbjorklund on Friday April 03, 2026 @04:17PM (#47631686)
Can you honestly say that you never ever updated anything in a Linux distro without first reading all the code, comparing all the checksums etc?
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by aragilar on Saturday April 04, 2026 @12:50AM (#47635880)
The checksums are verified automatically, based on a key bootstrapped by the original install (which could, though likely not done, be verified by other means). As happened with xz, you either get everyone or no-one.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by progbits on Friday April 03, 2026 @06:28AM (#47625033)
How will they push it?
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by victorbjorklund on Friday April 03, 2026 @04:19PM (#47631708)
Push or pull is just semantics. Can you honestly say that you never ever updated anything in a Linux distro without first reading the source code, checking all the checksums etc? Be honest.
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by 63stack on Friday April 03, 2026 @06:17AM (#47624957)
Linux as in the kernel? Who is "they"? Torvalds?
Re:Proton Meet Isn't What They Told You It Was by victorbjorklund on Friday April 03, 2026 @04:21PM (#47631726)
Choose if you think Windows is just the kernel or the operating system.

The ones that control whatever source you are pulling the updates from. Very very few people are building everything from source and reading the source in full everytime.

Notice I am not saying this is likely. I am saying that it is theoretically possible anytime you accept code from the outside (doesn’t matter if it is pull or push)