Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by bombcar on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @09:56AM
(#47517409)
This is why I'm so glad when I find an open source project that has a book or similar that I can buy - I can expense a 50/500 book easily, getting a $5 expense for software approved is a PITA.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by Ferret7446 on Thursday March 26, 2026 @03:30AM
(#47527611)
Maybe FOSS products should offer PDFs of the documentation as a "tip jar".
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by bombcar on Thursday March 26, 2026 @09:17AM
(#47530077)
Format the documentation as a PDF, enable it on https://www.lulu.com/ and sell it for $100-200 (and a hardcover at some stupid high price).
You’ll collect a few.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by TheNewsIsHere on Thursday March 26, 2026 @05:30PM
(#47536038)
I’d do that even in my personal capacity. Buy a new copy every major version release (where that’s applicable).
At least the new edition would be a worthwhile expense.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by PurpleRamen on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:13AM
(#47517629)
If all they need is an invoice and some papers, then it seems like a business-opportunity? Offer the service to manage their donations to OSS-projects, maybe offer some additional software for managing which OSS they are using and how much those need in donations. Seems like something the FSS should offer.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by thayne on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @11:18AM
(#47518533)
That may work for some businesses, but IME, the people who hold the purse strings generally aren't ok with just giving money to a project without getting something in return. Especially if it isn't a 501(c) non-profit they can get tax deductions for. I think it is actually a bit of a gap in tax law, because I don't think such a donation would count as a business expense either if you don't get something concrete in exchange.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by bpt3 on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:35AM
(#47517896)
You just described Github Sponsors, Tidelift, and a couple other less well known competitors. It's a business opportunity, but not a great one from what I can tell.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by amelius on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:12AM
(#47517609)
It would be great if all open source required payment of at least 1 dollarcent for enterprises, to make sure the purchase accounting layers are working in case anyone wants to send more money.
For 1 cent, we can still call it "free" even as in beer, the amount is small enough for that to be fair.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by chuckadams on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:13AM
(#47517631)
And if the penny isn't paid, no source? Then it's not open source. And practically speaking, no one will pay that.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by amelius on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:27AM
(#47517804)
If the penny isn't paid, they can still have the source.
But their legal department will have a problem.
I hope you understand the point now.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by chuckadams on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @11:30AM
(#47518718)
Going after them with legal claims is an odd definition of "can".
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by amelius on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @12:24PM
(#47519521)
Nobody is going after them.
And remember this is only for enterprises.
Re:Open source isn't a tip jar – it's time to charge for access
by TheNewsIsHere on Thursday March 26, 2026 @05:32PM
(#47536064)
This does require large players acting in good faith.
Or, at best, competently.
Sometimes both of those, or neither, are in evidence.
But I like the way you think. Make it a contract performance issue for legal teams to police internally.
The same process is why open source is such a hit among the developers that actually accomplish real work in such corporations.