News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by coldtea on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @04:04AM (#47409819)
Did anybody else find the original story mediocre stuff? Interesting premise, but neither novel nor that deep. PKD has done 100x with much less.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by pinkmuffinere on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @04:16AM (#47409892)
I loved the ideas! The premise was novel to me, and I also don't think I've encountered the same idea since (except for in reference to the original story). I'm not a fan of the writing style though. It's very stiff and heavy-handed, as if the writer's only goal is to setup the next twist. But I can't complain that much, it reminds me a lot of my own writing.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by Nition on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @04:10AM (#47409852)
I really liked it and all the little interesting ideas within it, like the antimimetic worms that live everywhere. However, I didn't think the recent rewrite was as much of an improvement as others seem to. The later parts were improved but I thought some of the smaller edits to earlier parts arguably came out worse.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by johnke on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @05:13AM (#47410243)
There were also some examples of sloppy editing in the updated edition, like multiple uses of the word "perimetre" which the author acknowledges was an 'incautious find-and-replace from the US English "meter" to UK English "metre"' https://qntm.org/antimemetics#komment6913d2eb6c240
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by ethmarks on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:09AM (#47411567)
Which is especially odd because the author (Sam Hughes) lives in the UK and wrote the original in UK English, but apparently wrote the rewrite in US English. For example, a chapter in the original was titled "Case Colourless Green", but in the US edition of the rewrite that chapter is "Case Colorless Green" (without the 'u'). So Hughes, a native UK English speaker, wrote the rewrite in a non-native (to him) dialect, then had it (lazily) translated into his native dialect.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by rtkwe on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @09:35AM (#47412455)
It was probably to deal with the transposition [0] out of the SCP universe into a new one. SCP is vaguely 'set' in the US because that's how a majority of the contributors naturally write and spell things, which sets the voice of the world indirectly.

[0] AKA "filing the serial numbers off" when it's explicitly fanfiction instead of a shared universe model like SCP

Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @12:54PM (#47415253)
I liked it for the interesting ideas within it. My favorite part of a story is the worldbuilding, the author's unique take on an idea, the special ways that different characters think and act. There's not a great deal of artistry I require in the introduction of a 49-year-old greying woman deep in some giant bureaucracy to imagine how other people relate to her, I'm interested more in the idea of a bureaucracy that deals with antimemes.

Perhaps that comes from reading too many online stories - including the whole of qntm's site [1], including the rough drafts. The quality of the editing, prose, or dialog isn't that important to me if the quality of the worldbuilding and the concepts are high enough.

https://qntm.org/fiction

Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by pwdisswordfishy on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @04:24AM (#47409939)
Indeed, it works fine as an introduction to a longer series, but on its own feels pretty unfulfilling.

I think the story where she detains her own husband would work much better in a stand-alone adaptation.

Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by axus on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @05:54AM (#47410547)
My standard for website fiction is lower. When you're unknown, there's less pressure to go through a long editing cycle. Pale and SEEK have been good though.

Would not consider myself well-read, if I read enough PKD stories I could probably find some mediocre ones; really liked the popular ones I did read.

Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by tgv on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @07:16AM (#47411132)
I thought the short movie was also mediocre. It should have been much shorter.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by throw310822 on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:30AM (#47411745)
I did find the introductory short story (this one) brilliant, as it's short, shows a clever and surprising inversion of roles midway, but especially because the premise- antimemetics- is actually extremely interesting. I even wonder if it has been developed seriously- I mean the study of antimemes as a communication/ propaganda technique.

It's true that the whole novel, despite a few good moments, seems mostly interested in plot and entertainment. Having read quite a bit of qntm's stuff online, I'd say he excels in the short story format where he can quickly present a clever or surprising idea and there isn't the need to sustain a plot or work on character development etc.

Anyway, comparing a random author to one of the best and most influential sci-fi authors ever is a bit pointless, don't you think?

Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by InitialLastName on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @03:36PM (#47417190)
> I even wonder if it has been developed seriously- I mean the study of antimemes as a communication/ propaganda technique.

Tell me you can't see the fnords without telling me...

Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by renewiltord on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @08:48AM (#47411933)
The idea was entertaining and I enjoyed the read. The author is clearly accustomed to shorter works. The final book has the feel of an anthology. Regardless, one my top 1000.
Re:Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [vi... by jpfromlondon on Tuesday March 17, 2026 @10:28AM (#47413189)
thought the idea quite fun, the execution incredibly amateurish.