Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by cedws on Thursday March 05, 2026 @02:51PM
(#47266400)
Yes, this has been an issue for so long and GitHub just doesn't care enough to fix it.
There's another way it can be exploited. It's very common to pin Actions in workflows these days by their commit hash like this:
- uses: actions/checkout@378343a27a77b2cfc354f4e84b1b4b29b34f08c2
But this commit doesn't even have to belong to the preceding repository. You can reference a commit on a fork. Great way to sneak in an xz-utils style backdoor into critical CI workflows.GitHub just doesn't care about security. Actions is a security disaster and has been for over a decade. They would rather spend years migrating to Azure for no reason and have multiple outages a week than do anything anybody cares about.
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by gfody on Thursday March 05, 2026 @03:09PM
(#47266629)
yikes.. there should be the cli equivalent of that warning banner at the very least. combine this with something like gitc0ffee and it's downright dangerous
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by WorldMaker on Friday March 06, 2026 @11:25AM
(#47277044)
A YAML linter for it, too. I was appreciating the cron input overlay in the current GitHub Actions VS Code extension. In ghost text beside a cron: 'something' input it gives you a human-readable description. Seems like it could also do a similar thing for actions commit refs, show a simple verification if it corresponds to a tag or not in that repo.
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by tomjakubowski on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:38PM
(#47267671)
> But this commit doesn't even have to belong to the preceding repository. You can reference a commit on a fork. Great way to sneak in an xz-utils style backdoor into critical CI workflows.
Wow. Does the SHA need to belong to a fork of the repo? Or is GitHub just exposing all (public?) repo commits as a giant content-addressable store?
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by sheept on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:48PM
(#47267769)
Needs to be a fork.
Related: https://trufflesecurity.com/blog/anyone-can-access-deleted-a...
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by PunchyHamster on Friday March 06, 2026 @03:53AM
(#47272622)
It appears that under their system all forks belong to same repo (I imagine they just make _fork/<forkname> ref under git when there is something forked off main repo) presumably to save on storage. And so accessing a single commit doesn't really care about origin(as finding to which branch(es) commit belongs would be a lot of work)
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by varenc on Thursday March 05, 2026 @09:51PM
(#47270252)
This trick is also useful for finding code that taken down via DMCA requests! If you have specific commits, you can often still recovery it.
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by causal on Thursday March 05, 2026 @01:17PM
(#47265163)
Yeah the way Github connects forks behind the scenes has created so many gotchas like this, I'm sure it's a nightmare to fix at this point but they definitely hold some responsibility here.
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by est on Friday March 06, 2026 @02:31AM
(#47272071)
I don't understand, how exactly does `npm install github:cline/cline#b181e0` work?
b181e0 is literally a commit, a few deleted lines. npm could parse that as a legit script ???
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by Kalabasa on Friday March 06, 2026 @04:48AM
(#47272952)
I think it's pointing to a version of the repo, so npm installs the package.json of that version of the repo.
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by WorldMaker on Friday March 06, 2026 @11:30AM
(#47277121)
In git a commit is a full tree snapshot, even though most commit views only show the diff with the previous commit. npm is using the commit hash as a "version number" and grabbing the full git tree snapshot for that point in time. (Just like in git you can always `git checkout b181e0` to end up in a "detached HEAD" state at that commit's tree. So many developers were doing that unintentionally which is why `git switch` requires the `--detach` flag to checkout the tree at a commit, but the same thing is possible `git switch --detach b181e0`.)
Re:A GitHub Issue Title Compromised 4k Developer Machines
by rcxdude on Friday March 06, 2026 @04:25AM
(#47272813)
I've seen it used to impersonate github themselves and serve backdoored versions of their software (the banner is pretty easy to avoid: link to the readme of the malicious commit with an anchor tag and put a nice big download link in it).
https://github.com/cline/cline/commit/b181e0