News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by amluto on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @11:43PM (#47243157)
What a crappy law.

> Section 1798.500(e)(1) states:

“Covered application store” means a publicly available internet website, software application, online service, or platform that distributes and facilitates the download of applications from third-party developers to users of a computer, a mobile device, or any other general purpose computing that can access a covered application store or can download an application.

So… DNS servers are “covered application stores”, right? As is PyPI or GitHub or any other such service. S3 and such, too — lots of facilitating going on.

And I’m wondering… lots of things are general purpose computers. Are servers covered? How about embedded systems? Lots of embedded systems are quite general purpose.

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by da_chicken on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:17AM (#47243397)
Christ, that would make Google, Dell, Netgear, and Comcast a "covered application store".

This isn't a law. It's a prayer.

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by jcranmer on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:14AM (#47243371)
> So… DNS servers are “covered application stores”, right? As is PyPI or GitHub or any other such service. S3 and such, too — lots of facilitating going on.

"Facilitate" implies an active role in the participation of the activity, rather than a purely passive role. A DNS server no more facilitates distribution of an application than the power company providing power does.

PyPI and Github aren't facilitating the download of applications, they're literally platforms for downloading them. If they aren't covered by the law's definition of "application store" [1], then the law itself is badly written, since they're platforms whose primary purpose is to let you download software!

[1] Whether or not the law's provisions should apply to them is a different policy question, but as a category, they are definitely things like application stores.

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by bee_rider on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @11:49PM (#47243206)
I guess we will have to replace the OS of every system that can play a violent and inappropriate videogame, like Doom.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by packetlost on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @11:50PM (#47243223)
DNS doesn't generally distribute applications, so no it doesn't apply.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by j16sdiz on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:08AM (#47243324)
but it facilitates the download.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by what on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:29AM (#47243463)
If that’s your bar, then so does the power company and who ever manufactured your router.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by bhhaskin on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:32AM (#47243486)
thats-the-joke-meme.jpg
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by wtallis on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:08AM (#47243742)
Facilitating the download is not sufficient; the service would have to both distribute and facilitate the download to satisfy the definition.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by pona-a on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:02AM (#47245833)
So a torrent tracker isn't in-scope because it doesn't distribute and only facilitates peer discovery?
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by devsda on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:53AM (#47243620)
What if a dns software has an RCE and a prosecutor thinks it satisfies "facilitates download" clause ?
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by wtallis on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:07AM (#47243732)
The clause says "distributes and facilitates the download", not "distributes or facilitates the download".
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by kstrauser on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:00AM (#47243674)
My reading of 2A is that devs can take the word of the OS or App Store. If they say the user’s 18, and the user’s really 13, then the developer’s in the clear for serving adult content to them because they took the word of the certifying entity.

Conversely, if the OS says the user’s 13, then they can’t say they thought the user was actually 18. Guess sucks to suck if you want to buy a movie ticket from your kid’s phone, or if you mistyped your age when you set yours up because you didn’t have your passport nearby.

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by foofoo55 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:05AM (#47243715)
> [distributes] AND [facilitates the download of]

Grouping braces and capitalization mine. So distributing also required. However it's still overly broad, vague, and ambiguous.

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by josteink on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:07AM (#47243733)
> “Covered application store” means a publicly available internet website, software application, online service, or platform that distributes and facilitates the download of applications from third-party developers to users of a computer, a mobile device, or any other general purpose computing that can access a covered application store or can download an application.

So OpenWRT would be covered since they allow the user to download packages (ie software) via apk/opkg.

Awesome!

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by wtallis on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:16AM (#47243802)
Quite possibly, yes. Though maybe a router wouldn't qualify as a general purpose computing device, and maybe the packages wouldn't qualify as being from third-party developers when the binaries that get downloaded are both built and distributed by OpenWRT.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by iamnothere on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:04AM (#47247510)
OpenWRT has a shell. Under the hood it’s just Linux.

If you put it on an x86 box you can attach keyboard and monitor.

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by jdashg on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:50AM (#47244027)
2A just says that if the e.g. client request headers say the age bracket, the server (dev) can trust the reported age, but also shall not ignore it on purpose. No "just ignore the do-not-track flag" escape hatch here. "A bartender can't willfully refuse to check someone's ID if they are presented with it."

For incorrect OS answers, keep reading. 3B covers what happens if there's clear and convincing evidence that the age covered in 2A is inaccurate. (Reported profile birthday, for instance) This is "if someone shows a bartender a valid drinking-age ID but says they're celebrating their 17th birthday, this can't be ignored".

Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by pona-a on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:01AM (#47245822)
The difference is a bartender has a handy thing called a human brain that can integrate every evidence and prior without explicit handling. Which a computer program can not. Now we have another "legitimate interest", potentially _forcing_ us to collect biometric and behavioural data we definitely wouldn't monetize to just cover its cost.
Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS by cwillu on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:02AM (#47245834)
> For incorrect OS answers, keep reading

Nothing there responds to the question. If my 17 year old answers “I'm 23”, what exactly prevents them from posting to /r/nsfw? What constitutes “clear and convincing evidence”? If there's no answer here, then there appears to be no purpose to this law as this sort of thing is precisely what it's supposed to be preventing.