Re:California's Digital Age Assurance Act, and FOSS
by jcranmer on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:14AM
(#47243371)
> So… DNS servers are “covered application stores”, right? As is PyPI or GitHub or any other such service. S3 and such, too — lots of facilitating going on.
"Facilitate" implies an active role in the participation of the activity, rather than a purely passive role. A DNS server no more facilitates distribution of an application than the power company providing power does.
PyPI and Github aren't facilitating the download of applications, they're literally platforms for downloading them. If they aren't covered by the law's definition of "application store" [1], then the law itself is badly written, since they're platforms whose primary purpose is to let you download software!
[1] Whether or not the law's provisions should apply to them is a different policy question, but as a category, they are definitely things like application stores.
"Facilitate" implies an active role in the participation of the activity, rather than a purely passive role. A DNS server no more facilitates distribution of an application than the power company providing power does.
PyPI and Github aren't facilitating the download of applications, they're literally platforms for downloading them. If they aren't covered by the law's definition of "application store" [1], then the law itself is badly written, since they're platforms whose primary purpose is to let you download software!
[1] Whether or not the law's provisions should apply to them is a different policy question, but as a category, they are definitely things like application stores.