News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by ozgung on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:46AM (#47195962)
I don't want to insult you but your president is a populist and a TV personality. He is not a policy maker, he is more like an actor. So your country went into war mode by changing the name of the Department of Defence to Department of War. This was not a cosmetic change. This means peace times are over and you are in war. Your government acts accordingly.

Since you are still a democracy find those people who make your policy decisions. It's not that yellow man.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by trenning on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:38AM (#47197355)
Ukraine’s TV personality leader, Volodymyr Zelenskyy seems to be doing alright. Also went into war, but not of their own doing, and he has been measured, insightful, aware, throughout this whole war.

There’s more to it than Trump being a TV show personality. Far too complex and insidious than a simple quip.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nixon_why69 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:36AM (#47197326)
I'm not disagreeing with you but "Dept of War" is ENTIRELY a cosmetic change. It's literally just a name. There are people, mostly with desk jobs, who really want to feel like badasses and they really want the Dept of War. The real human consequences of this are unimportant to them and sadly unimportant to the rest of us also.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by delichon on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:40AM (#47197378)
Cosmetic changes are frequently decisive in politics. "literally just a name" discounts the genuine power of names.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nixon_why69 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:41AM (#47197388)
Agreed 100%
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by avaer on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:00PM (#47197609)
If you go to https://www.war.gov/ it says Department of War. The person in charge calls himself the Secretary of War. Warfighters are being sent into Iran. Presumably to engage in warfare. People are gonna die.

What's cosmetic about this?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by delichon on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:27PM (#47197902)
Agree, essentially the Department of War is the Department of Defense with a little less makeup.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by lo_zamoyski on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:01PM (#47198319)
It's cosmetic because it is business as usual.

And the DoW was the original name from 1789 to 1947.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by WrongAssumption on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:49PM (#47203826)
Seems more accurate to me. Department of Defense was the one that seemed like a euphemism.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by pfannkuchen on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:34PM (#47197983)
Wasn’t it originally called the department of war also? If anything “department of defense” was doublespeak, as it was already primarily for war.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by lo_zamoyski on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:59PM (#47198289)
Indeed it was, from 1789 to 1947. It was then changed to Departments of Army and Air Force, later the National Military Establishment, and finally the Department of Defense in 1949.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by coldtea on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:31AM (#47197260)
>I don't want to insult you but your president is a populist and a TV personality. He is not a policy maker, he is more like an actor.

All of them are, even those that haven't had a show on TV.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:00AM (#47196088)
> find those people who make your policy decisions

Genuine question: who put Iran in their policy portfolio?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jacquesm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:26AM (#47197182)
AIPAC is a thing...

And now of course you're going to label me an AIPAC nutter, but in this particular case I think the evidence is fairly plain given the collaboration between the two countries on this. If Israel had done this by their lonesome or if the US had not involved Israel then you could make the case that they reached this point independently, right now it looks to me as if collusion is a 100% certainty and that the US is executing a foreign policy that will not benefit it but that will benefit Israel. It also makes me wonder whether this will end up as a Venzuela re-run where the top names change but everything else remains the same, just with US companies the beneficiaries of the oil, which is, besides policy the main driver behind these things anyway.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by heraldgeezer on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:30AM (#47197240)
ah here come the jews run the USA conspiracy. HN does not dissapoint. Well, no I am dissapointed. But not surprised.

Reddit and HN have been taken over by leftie tankie zoomers and thridies who want to see the West fall while then dream of a life in Europe or worse, live here.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jacquesm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:36AM (#47197316)
You've been uncritically supportive of Israel in plenty of other threads on HN already so I'm not sure if your exaggeration of my comment should even be taken serious.

Israel has a massive lobbying effort in the United States and that's not exactly news, on top of that there have been many documented pieces of interaction between Trump and Nethanyahu that seem to be evidence that Trump is doing a lot of things to please Israel.

[dead]
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jacquesm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:20PM (#47197828)
> Are you a tankie or socialist?

FFS man.

As for stalking your account: if you don't want your comment history to be visible then don't participate on HN.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by frmersdog on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:36AM (#47197330)
Well, we're certainly not collaborating with West Africa to bomb France. Not even the Philippines to bomb China.

I mean, it could just be the evangelicals hoping to start a holy war that heralds the End of Days. And now that I type that out, I have to agree with your implicit position that it's definitely the more rational catalyst.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:50AM (#47197483)
Even CNN is reporting that this unprovoked attack was lined up with a Jewish holiday celebrating the killing of non-jews: https://x.com/chrisbrunet/status/2027665287982502195

The first thing the US/Israel did was murder 80+ children with an attack on a girl's elementary school (warning graphic): https://x.com/ME_Observer_/status/2027787999409266991

Meanwhile, jewish israelis are celebrating the attack in their bunkers: https://x.com/SZade15/status/2027695217286189363

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Seattle3503 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:34PM (#47197993)
There is a lot of breaking news, much of it not verified. wrt bombing schools, people should be cautious about claims like this, this early.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:31PM (#47198642)
There's lots of footage already, I just posted one link. You can see many dead children for yourself.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Seattle3503 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:20PM (#47199134)
We should wait for more corroboration before we jump to conclusions about circumstance and attribution. In the Russia/Ukraine conflict, I've seen Russian's use footage and images from other conflicts to claim Ukraine is doing something underhanded.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:24PM (#47199171)
We've already seen Israel do this over and over again in Gaza. We've seen Zionist media try to lie about it, but if you've been following what Israel has been doing for the past two years, you'll know that this is how they operate.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Seattle3503 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:51PM (#47199442)
These days kinetic wars are accompanied by online information wars. What's the harm in waiting for corroboration and more evidence in a rapidly evolving situation?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:52PM (#47199466)
You can follow the reporting here, and this is by western outlets that have proven to be unreliable when it comes to reporting about Israel: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=iran+school&t=brave&ia=news&iar=ne...
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Seattle3503 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:05PM (#47199611)
Those all cite Iranian government sources.

It's certainly credible that US/Israel bombed a school. But it's also credible that Iran would lie about US/Israel bombing a school. In these situations we need a higher standard of evidence than "credible". I don't think that's a radical position.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:14PM (#47199721)
I find Iranian government sources far more credible than Zionist sources. Believe what you want, but this was an unprovoked act of aggression following two years of genocide and 75 years of ethnic cleansing. It's crystal clear who is responsible for all of the death and destruction.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Itoldmyselfso on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:16PM (#47201522)
The attack was reportedly timed for a surprise attack on Iranian leaders who happened to be in the same location at this time. They even attacked during the daytime for a risky surprise attack. To suggest the attack had anything to do with the holiday is beyond ridiculous. Also ridiculous to think they would intentionally attack a random school.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:08PM (#47208540)
Israel has destroyed almost every school in Gaza. That's what they do. They've also carved stars of david into children's playgrounds in Gaza. They are a theocratic terror state and every single action they take reinforces that.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by csomar on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:43AM (#47197415)
There is no comparison between Iran and Venezuela. Maduro had Cuban guards because his people seem to dislike him more than the US; his administration included. Also Maduro is hated by both neighboring countries elites and peasants. Situation couldn’t be more different in Iran, there are hundreds of thousands of committed supporters in Iran and Arabic countries (watch some videos where the Arabs celebrates the strikes at their own countries)

Also in power balance, Venezuela is a joke militarily. Iran has the capacity to end calm life in the GCC and possibly disrupt oil flows. Really an orange and apple comparison. Case in point today, Iran was able to project its missile to several countries in a couple hours.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:58AM (#47197591)
> Iran has the capacity to end calm life in the GCC and possibly disrupt oil flows

I'm genuinely surprised the mines haven't rolled out, to the point that I believe they won't be. (They were–in the initial strikes–destroyed or incapacitated, or they never existed.)

> Iran was able to project its missile to several countries in a couple hours

To minimal effect. And every launch exposes a missile and firing team to American and Israeli jets flyig in uncontested airspace.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by chunky1994 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:10PM (#47197701)
There is credible reporting (Reuters etc.) that ships are being turned around, so it does appear that the mines (or at least threat thereof) have been deployed. Either way, as long as the threat of sinking is alive the strait is uninsurable and is for all practical purposes closed.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:23PM (#47197846)
> ships are being turned around, so it does appear that the mines (or at least threat thereof) have been deployed

I'd assume, until further evidence, it's because the Strait is an active war zone.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by chunky1994 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:37PM (#47198028)
Fair point, but the IRGC telling ships to turn around, as opposed to the ships themselves doing it (as per reporting) would imply that the Strait has been blockaded in some fashion. It remains to be seen if this is all a bluff, I'm just as skeptical as this would be their last option, but given the strikes on other Gulf countries, the threat seems a bit more plausible of actually being real.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jacquesm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:55PM (#47198241)
That regime has absolutely nothing to lose at this point and they will use whatever they've got.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jacquesm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:57AM (#47197575)
Agreed that you can't compare Venezuela and Iran. But I challenge you to check which are the top three countries in the world by oil reserves.

Israel needs it, Trump wants it, this was going to happen either now or next year. The potential for escalation is massive and I sincerely hope that it will not. Iran is a problem, but Israel is also a problem and the United States is becoming a bigger problem every day. It would be nice if the people in charge of this planet could hold back from throwing matches into the powder kegs for a while.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by csomar on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:19PM (#47197809)
Reserves are irrelevant, you can’t pump oil from the ground at a moment notice and building the infrastructure requires long-term stability especially for oil infrastructure which is large and hard to protect. Iran does x4 times the volume of Venezuela in oil and x10 in gas.

The issue with Iran is that it’s selling energy outside of the US system. This was less of an issue 20 years ago when the persians needed to funnel the money back to the Western system at a cost so that they can access world trade. The situation changed today as they can mostly survive on China imports and completely bypass the US financial system. Iran has half the exports (in total value!) of Tunisia at x8-9 the population. Something doesn’t add up.

> It would be nice if the people in charge of this planet could hold back from throwing matches into the powder kegs for a while

That’s not how the world works. The relative peace of the last 20 years or so was mostly because US hegemony was uncontested. This might be no longer the case. Someone in the far East will be watching for opportunities.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jacquesm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:24PM (#47197871)
> Reserves are irrelevant, you can’t pump oil from the ground at a moment notice and building the infrastructure requires long-term stability especially for oil infrastructure which is large and hard to protect.

Who says these are rational actors. I think it is a bit much for coincidence.

> Iran does x4 times the volume of Venezuela in oil and x10 in gas.

Until yesterday. We'll see whether their infrastructure is going to survive this war.

> The issue with Iran is that it’s selling energy outside of the US system.

I'm well aware of that.

> This was less of an issue 20 years ago when the persians needed to funnel the money back to the Western system at a cost so that they can access world trade. The situation changed today as they can mostly survive on China imports and completely bypass the US financial system. Iran has half the exports (in total value!) of Tunisia at x8-9 the population. Something doesn’t add up.

What doesn't add up is that there are a lot of parties that would like to see regime change in Iran, including a lot of Iranians. The question always is whether the fire that you light remains contained or not and Iran is very much not like Venezuela in that sense.

> That’s not how the world works.

I'm well aware of that too. But that doesn't change how I feel about it.

> The relative peace of the last 20 years or so was mostly because US hegemony was uncontested. This might be no longer the case.

In no small part because of the idiot-in-charge.

> Someone in the far East will be watching for opportunities.

And that's precisely why I think there is a massive potential for escalation here.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by csomar on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:48PM (#47198161)
> Until yesterday. We'll see whether their infrastructure is going to survive this war.

None of their energy infra. was hit and I don’t see it happening. Hitting their energy infra. will result in them hitting the GCC oil infra. This is more likely, in my opinion, part of the negotiations. They couldn’t agree to the terms of their power projection, so they went to the field to test it out.

> What doesn't add up is that there are a lot of parties that would like to see regime change in Iran, including a lot of Iranians.

You are buying into Western propaganda. Not that I know about the conditions on Iran and the Mullah popularity. It’s not possible to gauge that since freedom of information is limited there but I wouldn’t trust the latest campaign either. Only time will tell on this one.

> In no small part because of the idiot-in-charge.

This is where we disagree; though I could agree that the democrats will have handled this differently but not necessarily in a non-violent way.

> And that's precisely why I think there is a massive potential for escalation here.

I still think this one will pass. Though China will probably stick to its own deadlines when it’s ready on its own terms.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by gizajob on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:09AM (#47196197)
Make a genuine guess…
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:14AM (#47196259)
I was hoping someone serious (versus the everything is AIPAC nutters) had put thought into it.

Rubio and Walz have been Iran hawks. But I’m not yet convinced they were unilateral. Instead, it looks like a Rice-Powell alignment of vague interests with enough groupthink that dissenters weren't in the room.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by hightrix on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:07AM (#47196947)
But in this case it literally is the AIPAC. Just because conspiracy theorists blame AIPAC for anything and everything they don’t like doesn’t mean the AIPAC doesn’t have massive influence in American politics. Especially in this case where we are going to war at Israel’s behest to distract from the Epstein Israeli intelligence operations.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:22AM (#47197138)
> it literally is the AIPAC

AIPAC isn't a person. Who is the person who convinced the President to order these strikes? It could be someone at AIPAC. There is no evidence for that, I suspect, because it's highly unlikely.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mixmastamyk on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:51AM (#47197500)
Lindsey Graham and cronies. Tons of evidence, he travels to israel every month or so.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:59AM (#47197603)
> Lindsey Graham and cronies

Lindsey Graham doesn't have that kind of pull in the White House. I'm not saying he didn't influence someone with it. But he isn't the power player.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mixmastamyk on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:17PM (#47197793)
I wouldn’t think so, but obviously things have changed significantly in the last few months.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:25PM (#47197887)
> obviously things have changed significantly in the last few months

Not to the point that Graham makes such calls. (Hint: the person will be in the Situation Room with Trump.)

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mixmastamyk on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:41PM (#47199994)
The "convincers" and those directing military operations are obviously different folks. I'd follow the money from Graham and Trump backward.

Oh, and by the way you don't have to quote single sentences from my responses when they consist of one or two sentences. ;-)

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:28AM (#47196432)
The current Israeli government obviously has a great deal of influence in the US government. That much is not conspiracy theory. The evangelicals involved in project 2025 have a very real interest in middle eastern conflict from an ideological standpoint. If you want a cynical follow the money villain look no farther than Al Saud and friends. Also, this weakens Russia and further restricts oil reaching China from anywhere. Every oil feed reaching China over water is at this point being curtailed. Looking for a single reason is very hollywood, enough interests aligned.

The US president hasn't required a new war resolution since Afghanistan. They each keep stretching it farther and farther. It cannot be rescinded without a veto-proof majority. If there was a veto proof majority willing to stand up to the executive, a conviction and removal would have already occurred.

The assertion that the US is a democracy is nisguided. It will be downgraded by vdem this month to an electoral autocracy. It is also worth noting that it only takes senators receiving the votes of <7% of the total population to filibuster all legislation, prevent overriding any vetos, and halt all impeachment trials. The fact it has looked like a democracy for so long is astounding.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by heraldgeezer on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:31AM (#47197254)
> Also, this weakens Russia and further restricts oil reaching China from anywhere

This is good for the West and EU.

I support this strike, simple as.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:46AM (#47197451)
I can certainly see potential positive outcomes as you say. Also, this stretches the original war powers resolution from Afghanistan a lot less than most US attacks. Iran does actually support terrorism across the globe. I do worry about implementation.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:10AM (#47196980)
> Looking for a single reason is very hollywood, enough interests aligned

Correct. But interests need to be animated to have power. Who was arguing that this should be a priority, and a priority now, who is familiar in the White House?

> The assertion that the US is a democracy is nisguided. It will be downgraded by vdem this month to an electoral autocracy

This is nonsense.

> halt all impeachment trials

False. Senate Rule 193 sets time limits on debate for impeachment trials [1].

[1] https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CDOC-117sdoc1/pdf/CDOC-1...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:17AM (#47197077)
You seem to have a singular villain ready to point at. I do not see it. The president reportedly thinks whatever the last person to speak said. So are you proposing a mastermind or simply a catalyst?

As far as vdem goes, Lindberg has recently as much as confirmed they will down grade the us below democracy status.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:25AM (#47197169)
> Lindberg has recently as much as confirmed they will down grade the us below democracy status

I mean, that's interesting from a political theoretical perspective. And if you want to put sacred meaning into it, sure. I'm not sure most people would take a decade-old Swedish institute as a harbinger of whether or not America is a demoracy too seriously (versus other sources, to be clear).

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:33AM (#47197282)
You are right that unless the eiu or others follow suit it would be less meaningful. On the senate conviction, my point is that only 33 senators need to oppose a conviction to stop it. Or to let a veto stand. The smallest states get the same number of senators. If those votes were evenly split, and it was the typical 50-60% turnout. It would actually only be 2-3% of the populace needed.

I do want to know who the bad guy is though.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:01PM (#47197618)
> unless the eiu or others follow suit it would be less meaningful

Even if they do it's book reports.

> On the senate conviction, my point is that only 33 senators need to oppose a conviction to stop it

Yes. The bar is high for removing an elected executive. That's not a sign of not being a democracy.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:37PM (#47198021)
We got too deep in the tree. Nixon could have gone a different way. Many of the senators that asked him to leave had constituencies that would have supported their refusal to convict. The 33 gop senators representing the smallest states only represent less than 20% of the population, and they usually win by less than 60% in elections with turnouts less than 60%. That is where I get the 90% from.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:22PM (#47197845)
Even taking into account that not all small states are right leaning, and theoretically there could be 100% turnout, we are still talking about a situation wjere it takes over 90% agreement among the population to remove a president. That isn't a high bar, that is a complete lack of accountability. It isn't just removal. The whole system was designed by people so terrified of the tyranny of the majority that they neglected to forsee such uneven populations leading to the potential for a tyranny of the minority. The lack of any meaningful consensus for judiciary appointments is also a solid sign of competitive authoritarianism. But we are getting far off on a tangent. I really am intrigued that I'm missing some actor or faction. Will you get downvoted for the hypothesis? Or have you already replied with it and it got shadow blocked?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:24PM (#47197863)
> wjere it takes over 90% agreement among the population to remove a president

...no? Majority of the House and two thirds of Senators doesn't require 90%. Nixon still had way more than 10% of support in the country when his removal from office was imminent.

> have you already replied with it and it got shadow blocked?

I don't think I've written anything that got shadow blocked for many years.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by galangalalgol on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:41PM (#47198071)
My best guess at who you mean is Netanyahu or Miller? I still think the SA benefits so greatly we should assume their advocacy.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by oldnetguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:16AM (#47197051)
I see this as Trump going after governments that were close to Russia and China. Which is why he is going after Iran, Venezuela and Cuba.

Also there are many countries in the middle east that we are friends with which would be happy if Iran falls.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by bell-cot on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:39AM (#47197374)
> ...would be happy if Iran falls.

Literally, perhaps true...at least initially. But:

- Take a look at how poorly the fall of the Iraqi gov't in 2003 actually worked out for the U.S. and its regional friends.

- Iran has 92 million people, very deep issues with being able to support that large a population, and very long borders. If things really went to crap there, it could produce tens of millions of desperate refugees.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:02PM (#47197629)
> take a look at how poorly the fall of the Iraqi gov't in 2003 actually worked out

This is an immensely risky operation. But part of the reason for Iraq being a shitshow was De-Ba'athification. You don't need to clean house to effect regime change. My guess would be we're hoping someone in the IRGC disappears Khamenei and a few senior commanders and then makes a call to Geneva.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by arw0n on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:56PM (#47198256)
This is assuming a coherent national security strategy, which is unlikely. We know a lot of generals disagree with the attack on Iran, and none of the geopolitical experts I trust think it is a good idea, be they conservative, realist, liberal, leftist or something else.

There's a number of reasons this is happening now that I think are more plausible than American interest:

- Saudis want Iran weak as they are primary geopolitical rivals. There are deep ties between the Saudi dynasty and the Trump dynasty. Without Iranian support, the Houthis will have a much tougher time. (Although they should not be underestimated regardless. They are not an Iranian proxy, but an ally, and field one of the strongest armies in the whole region.)

- Israel wants Iran weak, and pro-zionism is a strong wedge in American politics. Again, there's also a lot of personal business interests involved. Iranian allies and proxies are the chief causes of grief for Israel's expansionist agenda, and a very credible threat to their national security.

- This war conveniently moves the headlines away from a faltering economy, the Epstein files, and ICE overreach. There's probably hope that it will improve chances with the 'war president bonus' in the mid-terms. It could also be a convenient cover for and excuse to increase rigging in the elections.

Expecting positive regime change after bombing a school full of little girls is... naive. This is not how you turn an enemy into a friend.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by oldnetguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:40PM (#47198752)
I know a lot of Americans who remember 1979 and don't care if they are ever friends again. I agree, I also don't think this is a coherent national security strategy.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mrighele on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:30PM (#47197940)
The countries in middle east want Iran to be weak, not to fall.

I think that from the point of the neighbouring countries, Iran is fine as it is. Israel and the USA keep it in check, it is under sanctions, which are both beneficial for its adversaries.

If the regime in Iran were to fall, first of all you would have repercussions on the neighbors, (refugees and the like), and instability. But also, in the longer run, the chance of a more better government, which could make the country stronger than it is.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nostrademons on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:36AM (#47196547)
The rumor I heard was that high-level Pentagon generals had subtly suggested that Trump target Iran. The reason was to distract his attention from Greenland. Logic goes that if you have a reality TV star who built his brand on being a tough guy in the White House, it's far better that he attack a theocratic dictatorship that funds a host of terrorist organizations and whose country is already on the verge of collapse than a NATO ally and fellow democracy that didn't do anything to us.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by qup on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:24AM (#47197157)
He's been talking about Iran since 2011
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by underlipton on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:44AM (#47197425)
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by byproxy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:15PM (#47197761)
From where did you hear this rumor?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nostrademons on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:39PM (#47201755)
Was a news article from a reputable source (Reuters or PBS?), around the time of the Greenland flap in early January, but Google Search now sucks and the results are all polluted with news articles from the strikes today so I wasn't able to find it again.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by ThagH on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:12AM (#47197008)
Indeed, the permanent bureaucracies and think tanks have advised all administrations:

https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7864/j.ctt6wpgvg

This is bipartisan. The long term goals were to start with Libya, Iraq, Syria and then Iran. The latter two required Russia to be tied up in another conflict.

They don't explicitly put Iran in their portfolio because for Reality TV it is better to be a peace lover.

Now, undoubtedly the Democrats will pretend to complain, but Schumer and Pelosi want this, too.

[I am expanding on your comment, not trying to contradict anything.]

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Braxton1980 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:26PM (#47197889)
The voters
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by yoyohello13 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:30AM (#47197237)
The Trump admin would sooner drop nukes on LA then cede a fair election.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thiagoharry on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:38AM (#47196574)
I don't think the American people can change their country's policy oriented toward a constant state of war, aggression, and invasions of other countries under the current system. This is a constant state policy, regardless of the party or the president. So it can be said that the United States is not a democracy. Money and capital rule, not the people.This can only be changed by a fundamental shift that empowers people over capital.

Of course, I agree that Trump is worse because, by removing the mask of civility and attacking others without first bothering to create propaganda and a narrative about how it is for the greater good and justice, he made the plundering and crimes faster and more efficient.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:51AM (#47196743)
> don't think the American people can change their country's policy oriented toward a constant state of war, aggression, and invasions of other countries under the current system

Of course we can. People disagreeing with you doesn't mean they don't exist.

These are the Senate seats in play this cycle [1]. How many of those do you think would be flipped based on any foreign policy item?

If you're on this thread you pay attention to foreign policy. The notion that someone doesn't–not isn't informed, but literally doesn't to any degree–is almost more foreign than the strangest countries we read about. But the truth is most Americans have never ranked any foreign policy item as being in their top three issues since the Vietnam War.

We could change it if we wanted to. We don't because it's not personally pertinent or worse, it's boring.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_United_States_Senate_elec...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by somenameforme on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:33PM (#47197980)
Americans ranked foreign policy as the third most relevant issue for them in 2016, tied with immigration. [1] It's disingenuous to ignore that both parties have traditionally had mostly the same foreign policy stance. So you're voting for forever war, or forever war. How can it be a deciding factor for voters in this context?

But 2016 was different because Trump was the first candidate in some time to run on something even vaguely flirting with being anti-war, as he actively called out the endless wars of the political establishment, and argued that America first should not involve us wasting our money bombing countries half-way around the world. It was a relatively weak position but even that was enough to get 13% of voters to declare foreign policy as their key issue, tied with immigration. And Trump ended up winning their vote by an 18 point margin.

Anti-war is one of the relatively large number of issues that Americans largely agree on, but the political establishment makes it impossible to vote for, because you'll never find a mainstream candidate running on a platform that aligns with public interest. So for instance 84% of Americans think that "the American military should be used only as a last resort", that Congressional approval should be required for military action, and so on. [2]

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_United_States_presidentia...

[2] - https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/new-poll-shows-pub...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:56PM (#47198251)
> 84% of Americans think that "the American military should be used only as a last resort", that Congressional approval should be required for military action, and so on

In general, yes. What fraction of Trump voters do you think would agree that Trump should face any consequences for bypassing the Congress?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by somenameforme on Sunday March 01, 2026 @01:09AM (#47204149)
Or Obama's, or Bush's, or Clinton's? By the time somebody is in office and engaging in a pro-war platform, his supporters will look the other way. Even moreso in modern American politics where people are often no longer even voting for people they like, but for people they loathe less than the alternative. It's why electoral choice, which is largely absent in America, is so critical for the functioning of a healthy system.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shadowgovt on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:55AM (#47196803)
That's assuming the people don't vote for this because they want this.

Many Americans have a hero complex. Their national mythology post World War II includes them being the "good guys" against the "bad guys." That mythology needs a bad guy.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by autoexec on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:25AM (#47197167)
Trump ran on "no wars" because he was going to spend all his focus on America instead of burning taxpayer money dropping bombs overseas. I'm sure some people voted for him at least in part for that reason. You can argue that they should have known he was liar, but there is support for it. Also, with the new concentration camps, the soldiers in our streets, and the nazi salutes I'm not sure the whole "good guys" against the "bad guys" narrative is something trump voters care about at all. They seem pretty comfortable playing the "bad guys" part anyway.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shadowgovt on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:11PM (#47203266)
They believe they are the good guys.

But then, history shows this sort always do.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by armada651 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:05AM (#47196157)
The moment they made that name change and stated their expansionist agenda it finally became clear to me that this wasn't just MAGA anymore, this was actual fascism.

Whether you think the current targets are legitimate or not, the fact that the U.S. is going to war without seeking any democratic approval anymore is deeply troubling.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by autoexec on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:28AM (#47197205)
> The moment they made that name change and stated their expansionist agenda it finally became clear to me that this wasn't just MAGA anymore, this was actual fascism.

I'm pretty sure MAGA was always fascism. I mean, all the signs were there and people were sounding alarm bells almost immediately.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:06AM (#47196938)
This is clearly not fascism, and not very different from what the US is accustomed to. Let's not waste the meaning of words by throwing them at any occasion.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by autoexec on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:35AM (#47197306)
What do you think fascism is? What we have is a populist, nationalist, racist, regime headed by a man that can't be held accountable for his actions and who acts like a dictator (as further evidenced in this case by going to war without congress) who uses to the power of the government to attack/threaten/suppress his "enemies" here in the US. If this isn't textbook fascism you must admit that it at least checks a lot of the same boxes
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:48PM (#47198831)
Well this is not fascism, this is, as you said, a populist regime.

The far left loves to categorize everything at its right as "fascist". The infamous Berlin wall was the "antifascist protection wall". In Yugoslavia, you'd hear every day at the radio a rant about the "fascists", even though the country was communist.

There are many definitions of what "fascism" is. The best I think is to refer to the historical italian fascist government, to understand it.

Btw presidential immunity is not fascist, many countries have similar laws.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by dns_snek on Sunday March 01, 2026 @04:35AM (#47205151)
> The best I think is to refer to the historical italian fascist government, to understand it.

Sure, why don't we:

- leader with a cult of personality

- an idealized story of the prosperous past (make america great again)

- pinning blame for the nation's downfall on marginalized minorities and persecuting them (immigrants, socialists)

- aggressively anti-socialist/leftist, protection of capital and suppression of labor rights

- glorification of violence (ICE, hate crimes, "department of war")

- ramping up existing and starting new imperialistic conflicts (Venezuela, Cuba, now Iran)

- rolling back personal liberties (freedom of speech, right to due process, women's rights)

- suppression of the free press given unfavorable reporting (revocation of TV licenses, revocation of access to white house)

- clear desire with ongoing attempts to dismantle democracy (capitol attack, violating separation of powers by illegally withholding funding for programs and violating court orders)

- demands complete subservience rather than competence in all appointed roles

- all of this with full support of the elites (clear shift in the 2nd term)

If you want to argue that the US isn't fascist because Trump hasn't completely dismantled the judicial branch yet, be my guest.

But fascism isn't just a concrete political system where a dictator has absolute power, it's an ideology, and Trump and the Republican party are clearly fascist in that sense - that is their goal. It's just a question of whether they'll succeed in dismantling the judicial branch before his term is over.

The only people who benefit from this sort of language policing are the fascists themselves.

P.S. I probably shouldn't be saying this but the fact that you refer to people sounding the alarm as "the far left" really gives the game away.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @06:03AM (#47205653)
Each point, aside from the cult of personality regarding Trump, is shallow.

For instance, the US didn't start a war against Venezuela or Cuba under Trump. America was much more aggressive in the 80´s, if you want to compare.

Immigration can totally be a problem, and voters in the western world increasingly ask their leaders to address it. It's not "democracy" when it suits your ideas and "fascism" when it doesn't.

Opposing socialism isn't "fascist" and afaik the Trump admin has done nothing significant about it: social expenses and the deficit are still growing faster than ever. What is mainly happening is that ressources are being redirected toward the retired, who are influencial voters and a growing demographic. It's the same everywhere in the western world.

Again, all of those measures are very superficial and nothing like what real fascism did in Italy or what Nazis did when they came to power. You can't reason just with outrage and headlines.

By the way, most of those points have their Democrat counterpart with a different style, it's mainly linked to the evolution of the governance style in the US. Democrats also had their DEI unsuited hires, censorships (Meta was censoring on the order of the White House), and so on.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by dns_snek on Sunday March 01, 2026 @07:17AM (#47206034)
> Immigration can totally be a problem, and voters in the western world increasingly ask their leaders to address it.

Stop equivocating. I didn't say that opposing immigration = fascism, I said that identifying marginalized groups, pinning all of the nation's problems on those groups and then persecuting, victimizing, terrorizing anyone who looks like they belong to one of those groups - that is fascist.

> Opposing socialism isn't "fascist"

Again, stop equivocating. I didn't say that opposing socialism is fascist, I said "aggressively anti-socialist", as in, violent anti-socialist rhetoric. Similar to the previous point.

> afaik the Trump admin has done nothing significant about it

That's wholly detached from reality. The only reason he hasn't dismantled all of the social programs yet is because the courts have stepped in and intervened when he tried. See: USAID, withholding SNAP funding, Medicaid, the whole DOGE disaster.

> Again, all of those measures are very superficial and nothing like what real fascism did in Italy or what Nazis did when they came to power. You can't reason just with outrage and headlines.

Those are the core qualities of fascism. I get it, you don't like being called a fascist so you sea-lion about the differences to distract from the overwhelming similarities.

Even when Trump dismantles the judicial branch, people like you will maintain that the US isn't fascist because people aren't speaking Italian like they did in fascist Italy, or German like they did in nazi Germany.

I feel comfortable saying this because we're not just disagreeing on whether the US is fascist right now and there's still room to have argue there, but we're disagreeing on whether Trump has a fascist agenda and whether he's actively working to transform the US into a totalitarian regime following the fascist playbook, which he absolutely is.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @07:40AM (#47206186)
I'm not American, I'm not even Trumpist so your ad-hominem falls flat. I however live in a country where the soviet propaganda was crying "fascism" every single day of the year, for 60 years, so when I see people do the same I tend to be skeptical about it.

I still don't understand why "aggressively anti-socialist" policies are fascist. Fascism is itself a branch of socialism (Mussolini was one, in France the fascist leader Jacques Doriot was one as well, for instance). Being a totalitarism, it aims at engulfing every aspect of the daily life, which means supporting socialist policies (similar to communism, another totalitarism).

Authoritarian regimes in the 30´s that were "aggressively anti-socialist" weren't fascist. Franco or Salazar are relevant examples, even thought today they would be categorized as such, since you guys seem now to have only single word left to designate populist or authoritarian regimes then don't like.

Trump lacks deeply indeed the socialist aspect of fascism; it would likely be better defined as plutocratic cesarism, even though he did not make a coup (yet).

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by dns_snek on Sunday March 01, 2026 @09:35AM (#47207083)
> I'm not American, I'm not even Trumpist so your ad-hominem falls flat.

You don't have to be American to be a fascist-sympathizer, which you clearly are, since you label opposition to totalitarian methods as "the far left", lie about matters of fact, and grossly misrepresent the events that happened in fascist Italy while trying to represent yourself as someone intimately familiar with the matter.

For example:

> Fascism is itself a branch of socialism (Mussolini was one)

> Authoritarian regimes in the 30´s that were "aggressively anti-socialist" weren't fascist.

> Trump lacks deeply indeed the socialist aspect of fascism

Fascism is not a branch of socialism, fascism frames socialists as enemies of the state and pledges to destroy socialism. Mussolini was clearly not a socialist ideologically, as he had them killed. That was the entire MO of the blackshirts.

> since you guys seem now to have only single word left to designate populist or authoritarian regimes then don't like.

No, we're just using the word appropriately and you hate it. You'd rather lie and make up a story about fascism being a branch of socialism than admit that Trump is a fascist.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @01:28AM (#47228864)
> Fascism is not a branch of socialism

You should read more about this, the creator of the fascist doctrine stated plainly that fascism was socialism with nationalist characteristics.[0]

Socialism and fascism share many similarities, given that they developed in the same context with the same roots : youth movements, focus on controlling education, citizen's health seen as a responsibility of the State, strong management of the economy, and so on. Both tend to classify political ennemies as a single group ("communists" in the case of fascists, "fascists" in the case of socialists), without distinction, just like what you are doing.

The fact that Black Shirts (which don't have a Trumpian equivalent) didn't like the other socialists doesn't make fascism less socialist, just like the soviet campaign against Trotskists doesn't mean that the USSR was less communist.

> we're just using the word appropriately

Rubio just admitted that the US participated in the strikes against Iran to please Israel. There is nothing fascist about this, and again plutocracy is a much more efficient explanation for the current regime actions. Saying that something isn't fascist doesn't make me a fascist.

"If you are not with me, you're against me" type of thinking... where did I see this historically?

[0] https://fee.org/articles/theres-no-denying-the-socialist-roo...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mint5 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:12AM (#47197016)
Are you claiming Harris or Biden would have bombed Iran like this? That does not sound credible, but if the other party wouldn’t have attached Iran then this is not business as usual, it’s the GOP as usual.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by etc-hosts on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:59AM (#47197598)
from 2024:

"Harris to Jewish voters: ‘All options on the table’ to stop Iran from going nuclear In pre-election High Holidays call, US vice president says diplomatic solution still preferable to keep Islamic Republic from the bomb, charges Trump won’t stand by Israel"

https://www.timesofisrael.com/harris-to-jewish-voters-all-op...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mixmastamyk on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:07PM (#47197676)
Maybe not exactly but Dems have started many wars, often to look tough due to the perception of them being weaker.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:44PM (#47198777)
Biden and Harris didn't have any problems shipping tons of bombs to Israel, aimed at being exploded on dense civilian zones so I don't think that there is are dramatic differences between the two parties.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by CrossVR on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:57AM (#47204109)
The dramatic difference is that Biden had Congressional approval to ship weapons to Israel and Ukraine.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @08:24AM (#47206487)
Trump doesn't need congressional approval to launch operations shorter than 60 days, per the War Powers act, a law introduced by Democrats, by the way.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Powers_Resolution

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by CrossVR on Sunday March 01, 2026 @08:56AM (#47206716)
This isn't a simple operation, killing a foreign head of state is about as clear of a declaration of war as you can imagine. The law was introduced to put a check on the president's use of military force, it didn't give the president the power to declare war on another country.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by CrossVR on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:31PM (#47199238)
> Let's not waste the meaning of words by throwing them at any occasion.

Honest question, but if this is not fascism, then what is? Aren't you also wasting the meaning of a word by refusing to acknowledge any application of that word?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:55PM (#47200707)
There isn't a single accepted definition of what fascism is. The USSR and their left-wing allies in Western Europe would define everything that wasn't communist as “fascist”. It still continues to this day.

I'd suggest you read about fascist Italy to get a sense of what fascism is. So far I haven't seen Democrats repeatedly kicked out of cars in Times Square after drinking a bottle of castor oil. Trump said that he wouldn't look to be reelected for a third mandate.

The Iran war is mainly a consequence of the Israeli influence on US politics; it has nothing to do with fascism, and it is in continuity with the previous administration.

So yeah, populism likely, a plutocracy (evidenced by the role of AIPAC in elections) but not fascism.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by CrossVR on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:34AM (#47204020)
> I'd suggest you read about fascist Italy to get a sense of what fascism is. So far I haven't seen Democrats repeatedly kicked out of cars in Times Square after drinking a bottle of castor oil.

January 6th had all the hallmarks of the black shirts marching on Rome. And ICE is definitely pulling people out of cars and homes in Democratic cities. But I guess everything is fine because they're not making them drink castor oil.

Immigration enforcement is necessary, but these actions clearly have less to do with people's immigration status and more to do with political reprisal.

> Trump said that he wouldn't look to be reelected for a third mandate.

They'll always say they'll follow the Constitution to legitimize themselves, but their actions don't reflect it.

> The Iran war is mainly a consequence of the Israeli influence on US politics; it has nothing to do with fascism, and it is in continuity with the previous administration.

It has everything to do with fascism, not because of its motivation, but it's lack of democratic approval. This administration has a clear disdain for the democratic process.

I sincerely hope there was some secret vote by Congress that we don't know about.

> So yeah, populism likely, a plutocracy (evidenced by the role of AIPAC in elections) but not fascism.

I would've agreed with you if we were talking about Trump's first term, that was clearly just populism. This second term goes far beyond what any populist leader has done in Europe.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @02:58AM (#47204673)
> January 6th

Trump has no structured paramilitary militias like the Squadras or the SA. The January 6th was mainly a crowd movement, participants were a heteroclite bunch with very different political ideas.

> ICE

ICE is a state agency, which existed before and has never been known for its benevolent and non-violent actions. The problems mainly arise from the overhiring, lack of training, and braindead managers. By the way, many members agency are not white, which contradicts the racism narrative. Alex Pretti was shot by two latino officers, for instance.

> lack of democratic approval

Lack of democratic approval for a war isn't facism. It's a strong presidential regime. France has the same and is not fascist. And it's legal in the current form[0].

> farther than any populist leader

Politics aren't a 1d political spectrum were the ends are facism. Afaik declaring a war to satisfy the billionaires of another nation is clearly not fascism, nor even nationalist in the strict sense.

Words are important because if you earnestly want the situation to change, you need to assess it clearly. The Trump presidency has a more to do with the influence of money in US politics, and the media system which favors outrage and "loud" candidates. Democrats also commited a historical blunder with the botched Biden candidacy and the lack of a credible replacement (Kamala was clearly not convincing from the early start).

[0] https://time.com/7380309/iran-war-legal-trump/?utm_source=ch...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by CrossVR on Sunday March 01, 2026 @03:57AM (#47204975)
> Trump has no structured paramilitary militias like the Squadras or the SA. The January 6th was mainly a crowd movement, participants were a heteroclite bunch with very different political ideas.

The black shirts were no different.

> ICE is a state agency, which existed before and has never been known for its benevolent and non-violent actions.

Much of the prosecution of minorities in fascist regimes was not done by the militias, it was done by law enforcement.

> Lack of democratic approval for a war isn't facism. It's a strong presidential regime. France has the same and is not fascist. And it's legal in the current form[0].

A hallmark of fascism is the refusal to acknowledge any democratic limitations on the power of the leader. The article you reference states clearly that he has no legal authority to start the war, as he would need congressional approval.

France has the same system as the U.S., only parliament has the power to start a war.[0]

> Words are important because if you earnestly want the situation to change, you need to assess it clearly.

I'm glad we agree on that.

> The Trump presidency has a more to do with the influence of money in US politics

Fascists regimes have historically been well-funded by money in politics.

[0] https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Saline9515 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @07:59AM (#47206302)
> The black shirts were no different.

You can alternatively read the wikipedia article about squadrism and see that there is nothing in common between the people that did Jan 6th and squadrists, which were a highly organized and violent paramilitary force.

> Much of the prosecution of minorities

There are many latinos in ICE - the Axel Pretti murderers were latino agents. All of this rethoric about ideology hardly matches reality, which is more likely a chain of incompetent people mismanadging the situation.

> illegal war

Article states that "Under the War Powers Resolution, which dates back to the 1970s, if a president enters the military into hostilities without congressional authorization, the operation must end within 60 days unless Congress expressly authorizes it.". Trump is within this framework, similar to the previous strikes on the enrichment plants.

> Succession

As usual with this kind of cesarism, it is tied to an individual and will deflate after Trump's mandate. Since they didn't cancel elections (like a true fascist would do, by the way, as it is not a democratic ideology), it may end up this year when they'll lose the congress.

> money

Fascist regimes had rich donors, but it was for ideological reasons first - Henry Ford's support of the nazi party comes to mind. The current donors such as Miriam Adelson or the tech bros fund him to steer the policy towards their interest, or just pure corruption, as we saw with CZ (Binance). I mean look at it, 13 members of the government are billionaires. This is a classic case of plutocracy - rich people's government.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by armada651 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @08:43AM (#47206618)
> Since they didn't cancel elections

There's still time for that, but canceling elections would make it too obvious, then even people like you would realize what is happening. That's why these days autocrats prefer to simply subvert the electoral system. That way people who prefer to look away can simply continue to pretend everything is above board.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by bluescrn on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:21AM (#47197119)
But the Iranian regime isn’t at all fascist, right?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by autoexec on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:49AM (#47197475)
The existence of fascism elsewhere doesn't excuse its existence here.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by lo_zamoyski on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:12PM (#47198449)
I an opposed to Trump's unhinged offensive, but let's not fall prey to media narrative. Nobody called similar actions "fascism" before (or they did, as the word is thrown around casually in the US, but then nothing has changed). Similarly, when Obama vastly expanded deportations and the like, nobody cared.

I don't like Trump. At all. I think he's a terrible president on the whole and a shameless opportunist. But I don't like one-sided politics and hypocrisy even more so, and I dislike hysteria. History and long term trends paint us a different picture of current events. Most people's horizons are limited to the shallow, tendentious, cherry-picked, and sensationalist news cycle, unfortunately, regardless of outlet. Should we criticize Trump? Yes. But we should criticize all leadership when they do what they should not be doing.

BTW, the Dept. of War was the original name from 1789 to 1947. Curiously, it was soon after the change to Dept. of Defense that people like Eisenhower began to worry about the Military-Industrial Complex. That should give us pause. The name change conceals the intention, and coincides with a hungry imperial war machine that WWII helped bring into existence. Recall that Americans were largely isolationist before that.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by gslepak on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:57AM (#47196057)
An honest discussion about this cannot be had on this site, it's kinda funny how pointless all the comments are here. Yours is the closest anyone is allowed to get and I wonder if yours will stay up.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by peyton on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:20AM (#47197105)
The guy’s in the World Wrestling Entertainment Hall of Fame. He’s been seeking or serving in office for over ten years. We all know. It’s old ground.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by gslepak on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:45AM (#47197442)
No I'm talking about who is responsible for all of this. You're allowed to misunderstand (as you did here), you're allowed to downvote (as they do to me), you're allowed to lie, and allowed to be mistaken. But truth is nowhere to be found on Hacker News on this subject. There can be a million comments. All of them varying degrees of wrong or closer to the money and then removed.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by rHashg on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:25PM (#47197877)
It is funny that the AIPAC influence narrative is allowed now, but think tank papers are greyed out and will disappear soon. So I guess "blame Bibi" is one of the desired narratives now.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by epolanski on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:18PM (#47199115)
I'm not American.