News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by noduerme on Thursday February 12, 2026 @10:44PM (#46998677)
How hard would it be to sell a solution that makes it easy for a consumer to set up on-site recording? Ship a small box loaded with Tailscale and some software that connects to cameras over a LAN, and runs a webserver that allows user logins through a web interface. Nothing needs to go into the cloud. Yes, then you sell it once to a customer and that's it. No subscription or planned obsolescence. Fine, so factor that into the price. Make your money and go on to do other good things.
Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by dylan604 on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:12PM (#46998839)
They have been selling NVR based camera systems for decades. It's clunky. It takes a network savvy person to open up their home network to allow remote access. It takes an even savvier person to not do that in a way that guarantees getting their network pwnd.

Having a cloud based solution from an ethical company would be the consumer friendly solution people are actually wanting. Lots of people are willing to spend money to make problems go away.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by crote on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:11AM (#46999156)
This isn't an inherently unsolvable problem. Peer-to-peer file sharing and video calls have been able to work around it for ages.

The same approach could be used for cameras - see for example Home Assistant's remote access. Sure, you'd still need a cloud-based STUN-like discovery service, but a small one-time fee should easily cover operating it.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by noduerme on Friday February 13, 2026 @12:35AM (#46999265)
Right..Or instead of STUN/TURN just use Tailscale for now. I think the reason no one's packaged this into a slick Ring-like plug-and-play probably comes down to corporate greed and how hard it is to raise money if your intention is to start a business that doesn't have ever-expanding verticals. Like, this is a set of solved problems. They just need to be smoothed and packed for the user.
Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by dylan604 on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:00AM (#46999757)
You seem pretty sure of yourself. So when will you be releasing this product that you claim is such low hanging fruit? Right, now you know why this product doesn't exist.
Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by fc417fc802 on Friday February 13, 2026 @02:53AM (#47000103)
He just explained why. Because packaging, QA, setting up a storefront, customer service, the sum total requires significant up front investment to get off the ground. Good luck raising money when your pitch is "we won't be greedy and do the things that could make even more money".

Or was your intent merely to taunt him for failing to be independently wealthy?

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by noduerme on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:02AM (#47001372)
Like, thank you. Obviously. This is why I don't want to start a public facing business and why it's almost impossible for a person with some good ideas and a modest savings account who could build something better to do it without putting themselves in a compromised position by taking investment. If you go it alone, you basically have to put your entire net worth on the line to see whether something works, and then the second it takes off, God help you you are going to be litigated or bullied into the ground. But I still kind of have some of that old 90s / early 2000s faith that I will one day hit upon the Big Idea that I can code and bootstrap myself, and turn a profit from day one when I launch it, and never need investors. I doubt a home camera system is the one. But I have a whole wall in my office with taped-up post-its and index cards and papers, each with hand-written startup ideas. Any of which I could conceivably code and profit from if I wasn't afraid to spend 6-12 months on it and thought it could survive the regulatory environment and everything else that might come with releasing it onto the world. And that's not my job - I just keep those up there and add to them for inspiration. I just want to make shit, not deal with the business of navigating the whole corrupt world of funding and kosherizing it.

Anyway, thanks.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by fragmede on Friday February 13, 2026 @06:24AM (#47001522)
> Any of which I could conceivably code and profit from if I wasn't afraid to spend 6-12 months on it and thought it could survive the regulatory environment and everything else that might come with releasing it onto the world.

The problem is, you have to be young and dumb and oblivious enough to think that your idea is golden, while also being old and wise enough to be able to implement the idea. You don't want to wake up one day, a decade later, and someone's independently thought of the same idea, and gotten rich, and you're still driving a taxi. My email address is on my profile page. Email me.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by noduerme on Sunday February 15, 2026 @01:39PM (#47026172)
Friend, while I was driving a taxi in 2001, I conceived of a system that would let anyone directly order a taxi driver from a pool of drivers who signed up through a central SMS messaging system and updated their zip code when they were waiting for a fare. The main problem with that idea was that it was completely illegal because it was outside the licensed taxi system.

When Bitcoin emerged, I wrote a gambling site. That also was illegal in America, so I kept it closed to the US but tried to get my original games licensed in Nevada, which was a fool's errand since it takes $500k just to get them to look at a game and there's a 3 year waiting list, mostly Bally. And look where we are now with online gambling.

The lesson of my life isn't that I need ideas with a bigger moat. It's that being able to code my ideas well is meaningless compared to having half a billion dollars to buy off a legislature. I'm a coward, I guess, because I never wanted to break the law. Now I live in a timeline where every major company in those two sectors achieved market dominance and legality because the people who started them were willing to flout the law, raised enough capital and fought off lawsuits long enough to bribe their way into legitimacy.

I have a fantastic idea for an AI service, too, and it wouldn't be hard to implement... but it will almost certainly raise dozens of legal issues until someone with more balls than me comes along and just does it. Money is nice but I don't need that kind of trouble. That's why those ideas stay on the wall.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by noduerme on Friday February 13, 2026 @05:48AM (#47001289)
hey dude, it's a free idea, you're more than welcome to it. I just thought of it a couple hours ago as I was writing that. I thought it was pretty good - especially the part about using an old smartphone with Tailscale as the hub because it has backup connectivity and power. Maybe I'll throw a prototype together this weekend if I have nothing better to do. Or maybe you should. You could be that guy.
Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by noduerme on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:51PM (#46999054)
I know businesses that have these setups and outside tech support to maintain them. I've also seen them have all kinds of issues when routers are replaced or they change ISPs. That's why I was saying a company could sell a box preloaded with Tailscale and a custom installer that walks a non-technical person through it. The default setup for a tailnet is pretty safe. Yeah you could have your own signaling servers or whatever, but TS usually manages to punch right through most NAT issues. They don't need a reverse proxy to login to their private webserver, although I guess you could provide that as an add-on service. They just need TS on their phone.

[edit] To my mind, the biggest hurdle wouldn't be networking to allow this box to host its own app that was accessible to the user from elsewhere. The hurdles would be things like lack of "smart" reporting / facial recognition, backup power, backup connectivity, etc..But in theory, a repurposed smartphone as the platform could solve the backup power and connection issues.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by izacus on Friday February 13, 2026 @10:24AM (#47003728)
I never had to use a "network savvy person" to have people connect to their TP-Link or Reolink cameras at home. The cameras record to SD cards (or NVRs) just fine.

Stop spreading lying FUD please.

Re:Ring cancels its partnership with Flock Safety after surv... by iamnothere on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:00PM (#46998781)
It’s called an NVR and there’s a whole industry of companies catering to this, though you rarely hear about it in the news. There are plenty of consumer options in the space too.