News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by gmartres on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:50PM (#4689242)
H.264 is not a "proprietary video codec", it's a patent-encumbered codec. The spec is available for free on the ITU website(http://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-H.264) and several open source implementations exist.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:15PM (#4690135)
Proprietary, as in proprietor, as in owner of property, as in someone with property rights, as in government-granted monopolies, as in patents.

In fact in some contexts, proprietary is a synonym for patent e.g. patent medicine.

edit: from wiktionary, definition 3

Manufactured exclusively by the owner of intellectual property rights (IPR), as with a patent or trade secret.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ramy_d on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:21PM (#4689420)
The spec is useless, even harmful, if 3 years from now MPEG LA decides to start charging content providers a licensing fee for their content, even if that content is distributed for free.

If we start using a codec for which the patents are owned by a company, and that company dictates the licensing terms for that codec, then aren't we handing control to how the content is distributed to said company?

what do we know about MPEG LA?

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by protomyth on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:07PM (#4689790)
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by MatthewPhillips on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:36PM (#4689971)
> as long as it's freely distributed
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by protomyth on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @07:17PM (#4690851)
I was responding to the line "if 3 years from now MPEG LA decides to start charging content providers a licensing fee for their content, even if that content is distributed for free."
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by Dylan16807 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @10:47PM (#4691405)
Aren't encoding and distribution fees both licensing fees faced by content providers? Your overall argument here isn't very strong.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by protomyth on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @05:55AM (#4692296)
If you are distributing free content, they have pledged not to charge you. It isn't so much an argument as a statement of fact.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by Dylan16807 on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @08:10PM (#4695680)
They don't charge for the distribution but don't you have to create content to be a content provider?
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by protomyth on Thursday October 25, 2012 @06:12AM (#4697032)
Which is paid for by the folks making the software tools unless the OS paid the fee for the codec in which case you're good. The camera manufacture either paid the fee or shoots a format that can be converted on the PC.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by JoshTriplett on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:35PM (#4690463)
That says absolutely nothing about h.264 decoder or encoder implementations, such as the decoders needed in web browsers to handle h.264 in <video> tags; that just says MPEG-LA won't charge people distributing h.264 video files.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by protomyth on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @07:29PM (#4690891)
The parent post didn't mention decoders / encoders, it mentioned free content. These articles[1][2] explain the costs and possible increases[3]. Apple, Microsoft, and Google have bought the license for their libraries on their platforms.

[1] http://www.zdnet.com/blog/bott/a-closer-look-at-the-costs-an...

[2] http://www.zdnet.com/blog/bott/h-264-patents-how-much-do-the...

[3] http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/AVC/Pages/FAQ.aspx last question

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by nnethercote on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @08:53PM (#4691131)
Exactly. All they've said is "we promise we won't charge you for sending bits of h.264-encoded data across a wire". It's not clear that they legally could charge for that even if they wanted do!

And yet they've fooled vast numbers of people into thinking that h.264 is free-of-charge as a result. It's the most impressive piece of anti-FUD I've ever seen, sadly.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by azakai on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:20PM (#4689103)
> Unfortunately that dream has failed to pan out. Instead of proprietary plugins, the web ended up with proprietary video codecs, which has created a split in browser support for HTML5 video. Firefox and Opera support the open Ogg and WebM codecs, while Safari and Internet Explorer supported H.264.

Funny, it looks like a major browser was left out there (in fact the #1 browser in usage according to some metrics).

The article is pretty good overall, but is missing a key piece that is important to understand the background.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by mccr8 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:37PM (#4689180)
Yeah, from the "related" links at the bottom you can see this article from January 2011 entitled "Google Dropping H.264 Codec from Chrome Browser" ( http://www.webmonkey.com/2011/01/google-dropping-h-264-codec... ), which has still yet to come to pass.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by cpeterso on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:10PM (#4689805)
Has anyone submitted a Chromium patch to remove H.264 support? I would be curious to see the code reviewer's feedback on the patch. :)
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:31PM (#4689941)
As far as I'm aware Chromium has never supported H.264.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by mtgx on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:59PM (#4690067)
I blame Google for this, too. They should've made Youtube play on WebM by default, with a fallback to Flash in browsers that don't support it. That would've forced the others to adopt WebM.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by Scaevolus on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:22PM (#4690399)
Forcing an inferior codec on users for political reasons is unreasonable.

Have you tried watching 720p WebM compared to 720p H264? The difference is jarring.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by icebraining on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @06:16PM (#4690633)
I watched the Amazing Spiderman trailer[1] in 720p in both formats - using youtube-dl - and I honestly couldn't tell the difference. The webM file is ~16% larger, though.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atCfTRMyjGU

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by av500 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:47PM (#4690512)
Well, Google even decided to bundle Flash into Chrome, so Flash is far from just being a "fallback" solution to them.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by andybak on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:30PM (#4689514)
Does anyone have an opinion on whether Google's purchase of On2 makes any sense now with hindsight?

Did it affect the behaviour of the MPEGLA in any way? I know some of the tech has fed into WebRTC but that battle is far from over.

Was On2 worth the cash?

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ajross on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:58PM (#4690063)
Google acquired On2 in February of 2010. In August of 2010, the MPEG-LA "announced that H.264 encoded internet video that is free to end users will never be charged royalties." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H.264/MPEG-4_AVC#Patent_licensi...)

So... yeah, I'd say it profoundly affected the MPEG-LA's behavior. If Google didn't have an easy out with (what would become) WebM, their Youtube licensing would be much more expensive.

Whether that patent promise has any bearing on the Mozilla decision is a more complicated issue. People have strong opinions on both sides.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by othermaciej on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:47PM (#4689649)
MPEG-LA? No. But MPEG itself is working on a royalty-free profile of AVC called WebVC: <http://mpeg.chiariglione.org/meetings/geneva11-1/geneva_pres.... That may not have happened without VP8.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:27PM (#4690187)
H.264 was already well entrenched when On2 was bought. Whether or not it was a good purchase will be seen more by a) how H.265 fares, b) how well AAC holds up against patent free mp3, Vorbis and Opus, c) how IETF's proposed Internet Video Codec and VP-Next fare (and they may potentially become a single project), and d) how many people are still paying for H.264 licences when it's no longer technically impressive, software-based companies in particular seem poised to jump off the upgrade treadmill early unlike earlier hardware based generations that could be milked for far longer.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by macinjosh on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @12:41PM (#4688866)
This is great news. There will now be a de facto standard codec for HTML5 video!
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by lucian1900 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:11PM (#4689042)
Except it'll be the wrong one, sadly.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by acdha on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:34PM (#4689963)
The wrong choice is Flash.

H.264 vs. WebM is a far more nuanced tradeoff – widespread support and higher-quality implementations versus [hopefully] freedom from patents. Either way, the web wins if there's more <video> and less <embed> depending on an opaque binary blob from a single vendor with a track record of platform neglect.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by lucian1900 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:05PM (#4690088)
Sure, but it could've been so much better, with almost no extra effort.

In the end, we have the worse of two options for absolutely no gain.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by acdha on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @09:46AM (#4692881)
You say "no extra effort", as if widespread platform support, hardware acceleration, more than one high-quality implementation, significant support by authoring software, and direct-to-format hardware capture would happen for free. Avoiding royalties would be nice - although it's almost certain we'd still have lawsuits absent patent reform - but as a business decision that's a LOT to give up.

I really think Mozilla did the web a disservice. They should have implemented platform codec support immediately and added other formats so content vendors could adopt HTML5 video independent of the codec wars

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by anonymfus on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:49PM (#4690277)
In the end patents will expire. 15 years left.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by wtetzner on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:18PM (#4690388)
And that's one of the biggest problems with software patents. In 15 years, we'll likely be using a different codec (or, at least I would hope we'd make some progress in that amount of time).
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by protomyth on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @07:36PM (#4690909)
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by streptomycin on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:28PM (#4689491)
On the plus side, the situation is much less dire than it was back when Mozilla first made the argument against H.264. WebM is a serious alternative, and if MPEG LA tries anything funny, people will be able to switch.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by meatmanek on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @08:07PM (#4691012)
Unfortunately, WebM isn't _really_ a serious alternative. It's a fine codec and produces great quality video in a similar filesize to H.264, but it's not supported on the majority of mobile devices. H.264 is also what many consumer video cameras produce, like iPhones and most DSLRs.

Pragmatically, I'm happy that all the major browsers (with the exception of Opera) will now support one common codec, even if it's patent-encumbered.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by streptomycin on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @09:07AM (#4692724)
Depends on the threshold for calling something "serious". It's far more serious than any alternative before WebM, that's for sure. No competing format will ever be an instant drop in replacement for an entrenched format, but there is a continuum of scenarios below that.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ramy_d on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:20PM (#4689107)
Exactly, this news is hardly any good, it's just convenient.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by glhaynes on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:17PM (#4689393)
For the vast majority of people with any stake in video on the web, convenient is good.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by cpeterso on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:13PM (#4689831)
I hope content publishers will find publishing HTML5 video convenient enough to drop Flash. Once publishers are all on board the HTML5 video train, they have the opportunity to experiment with new (and unencumbered) codecs without affecting their user experience.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by rimantas on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:39PM (#4689987)
Lots of video will be played on mobile devices, so any codecs without hardware support is very likely to affect user experience in a noticeable way.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by vetinari on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @06:20AM (#4692334)
Is is very difficult to find any HW without VP8 support. Android mandates it since 2.3, so since then the SoCs used in mobile devices support it.

Only Apple does not support it for political reasons. Just like they never supported Vorbis.

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by jfb on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:27PM (#4689916)
From certain political points of view, absolutely. From a image quality point of view, not hardly.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by nitrogen on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @06:55PM (#4690771)
How do they plan to defend against vulnerabilities in the system codecs? Especially a GPU-accelerated codec has the potential to wreak all sorts of nefariousness.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by J_Darnley on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:57PM (#4689270)
crosses fingers Please use libavcodec! Please use libavcodec! Please use libavcodec! reads article and is disappointed
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by pgeorgi on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:41PM (#4690003)
By deferring to system codecs, they manage to defer some licensing questions, too.

It's a nice compromise, and it still encourages using royalty free codecs (since those are the only ones with a chance of guaranteed deployment, even if Apple is still acting funny these days)

Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ibotty on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:03PM (#4690328)
they will use gstreamer (which won't rule ouy libavcodec).
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by av500 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:45PM (#4690503)
gstreamer itself will use libavcodec
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by ibotty on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @02:12PM (#4694212)
that's what i was implying (with my typo). but gstreamer might use something else as well.
Re:Mozilla Plans H.264 Video for Desktop Firefox by andrewkerr on Thursday October 25, 2012 @01:32PM (#4698536)
Contrary to the article, h264 is not currently working on Android Firefox (2012-10-11 release), or at least it doesn't for me.