News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by debacle on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @11:30AM (#4688545)
The solution is to unionize. I really don't understand why we don't have an IT union, especially for network ops and engineering - it's a very logical aspect of the industry to standardize and unionize.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by killface on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @11:45AM (#4688614)
I think the reason we haven't is many-fold:

- We all believe we're above average in our field, and unions would hold us back.

- We all know people who have skated by on incompetence, and wouldn't want a union to protect their jobs.

- Our field moves quickly, and we don't want a union that would hamper our ability to make quick moves.

- Union is a dirty word, especially when the mind disease of libertarianism is more prevalent among tech workers.

I think the easier way to solve this is for IT/computer workers to stop being paid salaries, and get paid hourly. If it weren't for a special exemption from congress that was passed in the 90s, we would be paid hourly as a matter of law. I know I've been treated MUCH better since I switched to consulting.

Employers value your time when they have to pay for those extra 2 hours of meetings each day, when they have you work a Saturday, or stay a couple hours late to push to the finish line. In addition, things like software efficiency upgrades where I can show 10 hour savings for 3 hours of cost are suddenly on the table, where on a salary you're not a "team player" if don't just put in the extra hours for free to save the company some bucks.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by codewright on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:37PM (#4689179)
>I know I've been treated MUCH better since I switched to consulting.

This has been my experience as well. My time was considered more valuable, people respected my input and expertise more, I was treated with more courtesy. The works.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by LearnYouALisp on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:02PM (#4689751)
Isn't that funny? You could be the same person with the same experience as you had in a company somewhere, and in one place it's undervalued and in a new place it's fairly valued (hopefully).
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @12:37PM (#4693686)
I've seen it in the same company. At a previous employer I trippled the hourly rate and was amazed at how the same customers treated me completely differently.

These customers seemed to be valuing my time by how much they paid for it.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by codewright on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:32PM (#4689955)
I had less experience then than I do now, despite that, still had a better run of it.

Maybe I was just better at picking my work when I was a consultant. Hard to tell.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by mcguire on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:09PM (#4690359)
I don't want to weigh in on the union issue, but those last two paragraphs are spot on. I worked for IBM as a contractor a number of times and you are describing exactly the differences between those of us who were hourly and the salaried regular employees.

On the other hand, I wouldn't recommend working for IBM at all; there are reasons my resume reads like a list of major software project disasters of the '90's and it has a suspicious dearth of shipping products.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by qdog on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:54PM (#4689254)
I think it's mostly the first one. I've met a lot of people with huge egos who think they are above the problems, and so far there is enough work. Someday, though, that might change, who knows when, though.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by GabrielF00 on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:50PM (#4690278)
My grandfather was an aeronautical engineer who spent most of his career at one company - he joined early enough that he was friendly with the founder. That didn't stop them from laying him off right before he would have been able to collect his pension. (They did this with their other older engineers as well). This was around the end of the cold war when that whole sector was shrinking.

Say what you will about unions, but they do exist for a reason.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by lambersley on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:14PM (#4689369)
Completely disagree! I work in a unionized IT environment and I would accept a reasonable offer to go back to IBM.

Unions further complicate the relationship between employer and employee. It created "us vs. them" in every single implementation of unions. In the traditional 'Employee Relations' model, you could at least find a handful of good employers that value people. Not so the case in unionized environments. Employers' hands are forced to treat every employee as equal; the amazing, the good and the horrible all get the same treatment.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by huhtenberg on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @12:22PM (#4688789)
I hate unions and everything about them.

You don't like working conditions in the company - leave. You don't like conditions in your industry - switch specialty, go elsewhere. Too lazy to switch or too gifted to leave? Well, sure, OK, let's instead arm-twist and blackmail employer.

Given, there are circumstances when you can't leave or switch. Say, if you are a miner in a small mining town. One employer, one skill set, no possibility of re-training. But unions are essentially an artifact of the 19th century.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by knieveltech on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:04PM (#4689006)
The very concept of work/life balance is an artifact of unionization. You hate everything about unions? Fascinating. How many have you worked for?

Edit: upon reflection my original comment left a lot on the floor so I'm circling back to pick some of it up.

Here's what a "typical" union experience looks like:

The union hall staffs individuals that find work for you. The bulk of back-office paperwork and other hassles (including wage negotiation) are handled on your behalf by the hall. When you first hire on it's typically as a pre-apprentice (no prior experience) or apprentice (some applicable experience to the trade). OJT and training/certification materials are provided for you.

Your coworkers are trained, experienced craftsmen. All applicable safety guidelines are rigidly enforced. From day 1 you are presented with the kind of benefits package that is no longer available to your average worker. In addition to credible health insurance this includes pension, annuity, on the job training and certification, and death benefits. In addition to your wage you are guaranteed additional compensation for overtime and hazardous work.

By way of comparison, working in the trades for a non-union shop is at best a crapshoot. There's no guarantee SS and other taxes are being taken out correctly or at all. I've known several subcontractors who've gotten royally screwed by the IRS come tax time when they found out that they (unexpectedly) owed thousands in taxes. Safety guidelines are routinely ignored, it's nothing to get shorted on your paycheck (or go weeks without pay), benefits are typically non-existent, no guarantees of overtime, and you're working sink or swim with whoever the boss could scrape together to form a crew, typically for less money than you'd make in a union shop and that's after dues. General contractors also tend to maintain a good-ol-boy network, so you go rocking the boat about substandard pay or unsafe working conditions and it's a very real possibility that you could find yourself blackballed in your area.

TL;DR: Union: guaranteed pay, safe working conditions, training provided for career advancement, benefits, retirement plan. Non-union: good luck, buddy.

Full disclosure: I worked in the trades (both union and non-union) for several years before changing career tracks to become a programmer. I do not regret my time with the Union and would go back in a heartbeat if for some reason coding was no longer a viable career option.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by TheCapn on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @05:08PM (#4690353)
Based on anecdotal experiences mine were nearly the opposite. Now I was never a trades worker but I did work for a unionized company. Up to a few months ago before leaving for private sector.

Union:

- Everyone is complacent with work, majority of time is spent faking work or finding ways out of work (pay raises are not tied to performance)

- Net pay below average for industry (Below 50th percentile)

- Under-skilled workers protected by the union from being let go.

- Successes & Failures of the company are shared amongst the entire employee base. As a result there is no motivating drive to work harder to push better products out faster because there is no direct feedback resulting from it

- Training is provided on a seniority basis

Non-Union:

- Identical benefits (or at the very least negotiable) but higher base wage

- Skilled workers who are hired based off of recommendation of trusted employees exclusively

- Strong motivating factor to produce more deliverable work as it is a direct correlation to the business's success and therefore yours (profit sharing)

- Pay raise is tied to performance

- Training provided on an as needed basis -> The new guy might get training before the 10 year vet because he/she is the one going to be working with that particular skill set in the short time frame

----

Shared amongst those is equal work/life balance and safety. Labour laws have protected the workforce from shady practices you experienced (arguably an isolated incident). I'm thankful for what unions of the last few centuries have brought for us, but speaking in the majority of cases I've heard of, (anecdotal: take it as you will) they are now power hungry bodies that are corroding industry from the inside out.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by knieveltech on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @11:51PM (#4691562)
I can't speak to your experiences other than to say it's disgusting mismanagement if true. I've heard similar stories involving non-trades union companies. I've also heard amazing success stories involving companies bought out of bankruptcy by their employees and turned into financial success stories. Guess it depends on the people involved.

One thing I can address is this:

" Labour laws have protected the workforce from shady practices you experienced (arguably an isolated incident)"

In manufacturing and trades (especially trades) this isn't even slightly accurate. Laws don't protect people, they provide a theoretical framework for compensation or punitive action after the fact. In practice a private citizen has almost no chance against a corporate lawyer in court, so it's almost impossible to prove workplace safety violations. On the rare ocassion that something does stick in court companies caught violating worker safety laws typically get a slap on the wrist, meanwhile whistleblowers better have a spare career up their sleeves or line up a settlement big enough to retire on because they won't be working for any outfits in their industry once they pull the trigger on a court case. Good luck proving the last company you interviewed you didn't hire you because you blew the whistle on your last employer. :/

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by TheCapn on Friday October 26, 2012 @10:22AM (#4702234)
You're probably right on trades but what you said about management is entirely right. You can have good workplaces and bad ones regardless of union status.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by PakG1 on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @01:14AM (#4691714)
Your definition of union is completely different from this conversation's definition of union. I wasn't even aware of your definition of union until I interviewed at this company that made software for unions as you describe them. Those unions are indeed exactly as you describe, and that company's customers used the company's software for tracking work of their union members, which were at what level of competency, even dispatching jobs, and so on. They were indeed tradesmen and craftsmen.

The unions discussed in this conversation are collective bargaining units that negotiate employment agreements with a single employer, and such negotiations are often huge, nasty, and difficult. I went through such a dispute with a telecom, and everyone not unionized had to work as a scab (doing the job of those who were unionized and not working). The union people would picket outside our building and insult us when we went for lunch, and we pulled 80 hour days to do their work (with fortunately amazing OT pay, and I was part of a team in charge of trying to automate everything in sight). But it was a nasty dispute.

The current NHL lockout that's happening is another similar union dispute, though you obviously don't see NHL players picketing NHL headquarters. :)

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by namdnay on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:05PM (#4689015)
The problem is that the employee-employer relationship is imbalanced: you only have one employer (in the vast majority of cases) but you have many employees. If for example you are in an area with only one company in your field, you're very vulnerable: quitting would mean having to move yourself, your spouse, your children, sell your house etc... Some will use that to exploit you.

Unions are a way to redress the imbalance. Think of union membership as a mutual defence agreement.

You shouldn't evaluate the worthiness of unions based on the average HN situation of a young professional with relatively little debts/commitments working in a specialised and in-demand field.

What I do find outrageous is the way certain unions start getting heavily involved in politics. They should stick to protecting employees from abusive action by specific companies.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by sageikosa on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:45PM (#4689220)
If there's only one company in your field, you likely have chosen the wrong field. You are trying to fight a non-competitive labor market with anti-wage-competition tactics. If there is only one company in your field, it is likely they are a niche, which can only expand payroll (as a percentage of earnings) to a certain degree before they damage investment return and collapse the capitalization of their enterprise.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by debacle on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:07PM (#4689023)
Your comment is at odds with itself. On the one hand, you say that if you don't like the working conditions, leave, on the other hand you point to one of the most unskilled and exploited labor positions (mining) as a good use for a union.

Which union do you think has more power: The AMA or a union for miners? In one, the employees are scarce, limited, and irreplaceable. In the other, the employees are numerous, easy to train, and very replaceable. Why would you try to justify a union for one and not the other when it's clear that there's no value in dealing with a mining union - it's cheaper to just bring in new employees.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by wnight on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:57PM (#4690303)
Exactly, that was the point. Miners need unions more because it's easier for them to be exploited. They probably need legal protections because they aren't coming from positions with many valid choices.

On the other hand, tech workers aren't in a commonly harmful, let-alone fatal, profession and we enjoy pretty good mobility. We don't need unions half as much as we need to take a principled stand and vote with our feet.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by dredmorbius on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:37PM (#4689974)
Please turn in your 40 hour work week, 2 day weekend, paid vacation, overtime, paid holidays, medical benefits, prohibitions against child labor, minimum wage, and unemployment insurance.

http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/03/05/148930/top-five...

Thank you.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by trhtrsh on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @12:38PM (#4688850)
Unionization really only makes sense in industries where work is very much to spec, and many people perform the same function, to the same standard of quality, and there is no reason or benefit to exceed that quality. Otherwise, a unionized work force becomes a market for lemons, with everyone driving average quality down.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by debacle on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @12:55PM (#4688958)
Yes, because there aren't national unions for professional engineers, doctors, lawyers, actors, writers, professional athletes, or teachers.

The main role of a union is to provide for collective bargaining agreements.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by namdnay on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:12PM (#4689048)
The unions for doctors and lawyers aren't really the same thing as "normal" unions. They're more advocacy based.

The unions for teachers exist because teachers are (wrongly IMHO) considered by their employer to be in the parents poster's category. If teachers weren't considered a commodity I think they would have less need for unions.

And professional athletes unions are usually restrained to sports where the employers are a cartel (or even a single entity). The cartel phenomenon is similar in the case of actors.

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by hkmurakami on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @02:17PM (#4689394)
And professional athletes unions are usually restrained to sports where the employers are a cartel (or even a single entity). The cartel phenomenon is similar in the case of actors.

Interesting point about the employer cartel, since the SV Tech Giants (Google, Apple, etc.) were outed as colluding to keep salaries down and not poach employees from one another earlier this year. Maybe that is a starting point for grounds to consider unionizing? Maybe?

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by namdnay on Wednesday October 24, 2012 @07:32AM (#4692455)
I agree, if the companies collude to keep salaries down there is no reason employees should not collude to keep them up.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by sageikosa on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @11:49AM (#4688633)
Are you going to force people to join?
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by debacle on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @12:57PM (#4688974)
No, I wouldn't see any reason to. Having a union that endorses members will create a professional body that is superior to non-unioned workers, making being part of the union a clear advantage.
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by sageikosa on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @01:37PM (#4689177)
I'm not following how being a member of a union would make me any better than a non-union worker; thus I am not seeing the clear advantage of membership being a positive endorsement to me.

"Having a union that endorses members" doesn't lead directly to the creation of "a professional body that is superior to non-unioned workers". IT/IS workers are usually considered "superior" (and thus more marketable) based on the degree of their knowledge and the effectiveness of their problem solving skills, to which membership in a collective bargaining society adds neither.

Perhaps rather than forcing people to join, you want to force employers to exclude non-members? So that rather than being "under management's thumb" I can be under the "union's protection"?

Re:Don’t mess with IBM by padraigm on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @03:08PM (#4689792)
I think your parent's point was that if the union can guarantee that its members are high-quality, it will have a lot of leverage to negotiate with employers. A union taking that approach doesn't need to stipulate that employers only employ union workers or anything like that; it simply says "all of the best people work for us - if you want to hire them, you have to agree to our terms (re. salary, benefits, working conditions, etc).
Re:Don’t mess with IBM by sageikosa on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:38PM (#4690237)
"Having a union that endorses members will create a professional body that is superior to non-unioned workers" looks (to me) like an assertion that the value is in the union endorsement (and that it thus create the professional body), as opposed to the workers themselves.

As I've asserted, information workers are valued for their knowledge and problem solving skills, so unless this hypothetical union were going to certify people as having certain knowledge and problem solving skills and include/exclude members based on that certification (or give them a grading level), it will be meaningless as a value indicator to any employer. If I think the level they give me is too low, I won't be likely to stay associated with them. If employers think they rate people too high, they'll avoid them also.

If the "professional" union is just a middleman, I'd prefer not to have it, and I'm fairly certain sure employers wouldn't either.

Of course, professional bodies (outside of trade organizations) exist like this, but they are called consulting companies.