News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by diego on Thursday October 18, 2012 @03:36PM (#4670637)
An explanation of how this deal probably works:

Color had 41M in funding, of which $25M are left. That money goes back to investors. Apple threw in maybe $5M. That also goes to investors.

Apple interviews each employee and decides who stays and who goes. The value for Apple is that a team that works together well is more than the sum of the parts, but only if they keep the people who would fit well within Apple.

The people who stay usually receive a retention package which could be a mix of restricted stock units and cash, vests over three or four years, and is determined by:

- the experience and seniority of each person.

- the perceived value of each person to Apple.

Apple tries to gauge what it would take for the core of the team to stay long enough. Someone may need 500k over four years in addition to salary, someone else may need 2M. It's impossible to say what is being offered to each developer unless you're an insider.

For that reason nobody can know what the deal really costs to Apple, but it's definitely more than what investors get. Otherwise, the really valuable people would not go to Apple just for a paycheck.

Source: I've been involved in deals of this sort since the late 90s, mostly on the side of the acquirer.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by allsystemsgo on Thursday October 18, 2012 @04:16PM (#4670827)
Jeez. How do I become the guy that requires 2M to stick around? Are these often irreplaceable programmers or are they typically product management types?
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by erichocean on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:51PM (#4671290)
I don't think it's that they're "irreplaceable", in the sense that they could never be replaced.

It's more of a time-to-market thing. I've spent years working on distributed systems and sync algorithms, so when the time came to improve our setup to a Google Spanner-like system, it was fairly easy for me to make the changes. From that perspective, my ability to do that right now makes me pretty much irreplaceable at my company.

But I certainly am replaceable, in the sense that any other competent programmer who'd spent as much time as me could presumably be doing what I'm doing. It's just hard to find them. :)

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by 001sky on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:47PM (#4671633)
This is a very analysis. short-term mission critical. and long-term. &etc. well said.
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by digeridoo on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:34PM (#4671226)
Be 20 guys?
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by cube13 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @04:15PM (#4670826)
Or Apple just went to the team directly and hired them, and the $2-$5 mil are signing bonuses.

This isn't an aquihire situation, this is just Apple hiring a bunch of people.

It's unlikely Color has any real leverage in this case.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by diego on Thursday October 18, 2012 @04:36PM (#4670951)
Doubt it. Why would Apple want to alienate Sequoia of all venture funds? It's more likely that Sequoia called Apple and they worked out a soft landing for some people.
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by cube13 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:02PM (#4671097)
Why would Apple feel that it's necessary to keep the investors happy? It's not Apple's fault that Color's board is unable/unwilling to attempt to keep their employees. California's an at-will employment state, remember. Non-compete clauses have also been ruled unenforceable, so that doesn't apply either.

Seriously, this is such a small amount of money for an entire team that I sincerely doubt that anyone on Color's board was involved. If Sequoia was involved at all, I would expect to see a lot more money changing hands(probably somewhere to the tune of $50 million to cover the investors), and the IP moved to Apple. None of that is happening, so it makes more sense that the board and the investors were not involved in the deal at all.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by diego on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:27PM (#4671206)
Your comment suggests that you are not very familiar with the nuances of Merger and Acquisition processes. As someone who has been involved in a significant number of M/A deals in different capacities, I can tell you that your speculation is uninformed. I won't comment further.
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by cube13 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:52PM (#4671297)
I'm arguing that this isn't a merger or an acquisition.

The numbers don't add up for either a merger, a full-on acquisition, or an aqui-hire. It's simply too low to fend off the investors. This sounds, very strongly, more like Apple has decided to hire all of them, and is paying them the money either as a salary or as a signing bonus.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by jusben1369 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:45PM (#4671268)
I think you're essentially saying Apple pays $5 million or so to have the first right to go through the 20 person development team? From there they can make any type of offer to anyone they like or not?
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by drumdance on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:41PM (#4671445)
You mean the guys who made billions off arch-competitor Google? Why would they care about them?
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by diego on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:56PM (#4671486)
Do you know the history of Apple, Sequoia, and the Silicon Valley? Does the name Don Valentine ring a bell?

http://www.sequoiacap.com/us/apple/info

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by drumdance on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:43PM (#4671622)
Yes. The point is that it's silly for the world's largest company to worry about what a VC firm thinks. It's rather the other way around.

Apple and Sequoia have a rich history, but Apple and Adobe have a rich history too.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by diego on Thursday October 18, 2012 @08:48PM (#4671765)
No, it's not silly at all. For example, what if Apple pissed off Sequoia and was always second in line to acquire Sequoia companies? This is a very nuanced topic, especially if you don't know the ins and outs of M/A and VCs. 5M (or that magnitude) is a token amount.

Feel free to speculate, I won't try to convince you. On Hacker News everyone is an armchair expert anyway.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by drumdance on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:28PM (#4672156)
Again, I think in the scenario you describe, it's Sequoia that should bend over backwards. Apple has enough cash to buy any company in the world several times over, and most Sequoia companies would feel screwed if they can't accept an offer from Apple because of politics.

For Sequoia to get pissy and hold out for terms because somebody's feelings got hurt --- and for the news to get out -- would be grounds for a lawsuit from LPs.

And yes, I know the ins & outs of M&A and VCs.

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by robryan on Thursday October 18, 2012 @08:01PM (#4671671)
5 million is such an insignificant figure to apple that it would be be in no way worth even taking the chance of burning bridges over. If they were putting up a billion somewhere to keep sequoia happy it might be a different story.
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by alooPotato on Thursday October 18, 2012 @03:51PM (#4670723)
Why does Apple even have to pay the $5M to Color and its investors.

Why not just offer the employees the package and ask them to quit Color?

Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by diego on Thursday October 18, 2012 @04:01PM (#4670765)
I can only speculate, but these things can get messy. Investors could find a way to sue Apple. 5M is peanuts to Apple compared to the value at stake. If they bother with the acquisition (which takes lawyers, due diligence, lots of boilerplate work), they might as well make sure nobody involved feels shafted.
Re:Color acqhired for $2-5M by kami8845 on Friday October 19, 2012 @07:15PM (#4675775)
Thank you for sharing your knowledge