News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by cocoto on Sunday January 18, 2026 @05:28AM (#46666594)
Simply enable the “cookie notices” list in ublock origin (available on every platform now, even iOS). According to the EU law if you don’t click accept it’s equivalent to denying.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by Fraaaank on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:23AM (#46666876)
> According to the EU law if you don’t click accept it’s equivalent to denying.

The result is the same. Technically there's no such thing as denying, only providing (explicit) consent. If consent is required and no consent is provided, then there is no ground for processing.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by Rygian on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:55AM (#46667062)
How do you object to the site's legitimate interest use of your personal data? That is a legal grounds for processing, which can be enabled by default as long as you are provided with an option to actively object.

https://noyb.eu/en/your-right-object-article-21

Re:Consent-O-Matic by psychoslave on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:30AM (#46667303)
>How do you object to the site's legitimate interest use of your personal data?

With the legitimate individual control over one own data required to run a healthy society and unavoidable to sustain a democracy. If a business can't exist without threatening society, the sooner it's going out of existence the better.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by upofadown on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:18AM (#46667223)
If it is an actual legitimate interest then you would likely be expected to contact the site out of band to object to the use of your data. Depending on the technical details you might not be able to continue using the site after a successful objection. In some cases the site might be able to reject your request.

The cookie banner thing is intended to allow the user to explicitly provide consent, should they for some reason wish to do so.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by Rygian on Sunday January 18, 2026 @03:22PM (#46671758)
The cookie banners are routinely used to object to "legitimate interest" uses and the corresponding sites continue to work normally, not sure what your alternate understanding is based on.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by upofadown on Sunday January 18, 2026 @05:06PM (#46672631)
The cookie banners are for initial consent. You just consent to less stuff sometimes.

A website might claim some sort of legitimate interest for the initial collection of data but might not think that they can claim that for the retention of data I suppose. That would seem kind of dodgy to me...

Just because a website claims something doesn't mean it is valid. There isn't a lot that falls under legitimate interest for a website.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by Rygian on Friday January 23, 2026 @09:35AM (#46732972)
What you state is provably wrong. Consent and objection to legitimate interest are two different things, in the eyes of GDPR, and are managed separately in privacy banners:

Navigate to a website of your choice [1]. Let's assume its privacy banner is served by onetrust.

The text at the top of their "Privacy Center" says, verbatim, "We share this information with our partners on the basis of consent and legitimate interest. You may exercise your right to consent or object to a legitimate interest"

If you then unfold the "Manage Consent Preferences" you will notice that you can, _separately_, provide your consent for a given purpose, by sliding the switch to the right to enable it, and also, _at the same time_, "Object to Legitimate Interests" by clicking on the button labeled so.

Of course, this is a dark pattern to make it as cumbersome as possible to object to Legitimate Interest purposes.

[1] (I took vox dot com as an example.)

Re:Consent-O-Matic by kuschku on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:29AM (#46667293)
Legitimate interest is defined as that usage that is absolutely technically necessary. Which is why you cannot object to legitimate interest.

Legitimate interest is for example a website using your IP to send you the necessary TCP/IP packets with the website's content upon request.

Many websites use the term "legitimate interest" misleadingly (or even fraudulently), but that's not how GDPR defines it.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by prox on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:53AM (#46667439)
It’s also to check if something works. I recently added something new and while I cannot and will not track any personally identifying information, I still need some data if people go through the whole process alright. That covers legitimate interest. It’s the minimum data I collect and its get wiped after some time.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by rglullis on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:10AM (#46667552)
An IP address is not "personally identifiable data". You can not know who the person is just because you got an IP address in the request.

We are almost 10 years into the GDPR, and we still have these gross misunderstandings about how to interpret it. Meanwhile, it has done nothing to stop companies from tracking people and for AI scrapers to run around. If this is not a perfect example of Regulatory Capture in action, I don't know what is.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by Nextgrid on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:20AM (#46667607)
The lack of enforcement is consistent across all companies big and small so I don’t think it counts as regulatory capture.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by kuschku on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:27AM (#46667652)
Tbh, Google and Facebook, after several enforcement actions, now provide a simple "Reject All" button, while most smaller websites don't.

I'd argue that's the opposite of regulatory capture.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by rglullis on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:43AM (#46667758)
Yeap, but the thing is:

- they don't care about the cookies they are setting on their properties, if most of the functionality they have require you to be authenticated anyway.

- These "smaller websites" are exactly the ones more likely than not to be Google's and Facebook's largest source of data, because these sites are the ones using Google Analytics/Meta Pixel/etc.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by Fargren on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:40AM (#46667735)
This is not my experience at all with Facebook. Since six months ago or so, Facebook is saying my three option are to pay them a subscription, accept tracking, or not use their products. I went with option three, but my reading of the GDPR as that it's illegal for them to ask me to make this choice.

I'm in Spain, this is probably not the same worldwide.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by Nextgrid on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:55AM (#46667832)
The "Reject all" does not in fact reject all. They are taking extreme liberties with the "legitimate interest" clause to effectively do all tracking and analytics under it.

The YouTube consent screen for example includes this as a mandatory item:

> Measure audience engagement and site statistics to understand how our services are used and enhance the quality of those services

I don't believe this complies with the GDPR to have this mandatory.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by close04 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:24AM (#46667628)
> An IP address is not "personally identifiable data".

GDPR says it is [1][2].

> We are almost 10 years into the GDPR, and we still have these gross misunderstandings

Because people would rather smugly and confidently post about their gross misunderstandings. If only there was some place to read about this and learn. I’ll give you the money shot to save 10 more years:

> Fortunately, the GDPR provides several examples in Recital 30 that include:

> Internet protocol (IP) addresses;

From Recital 30:

> Natural persons may be associated with online identifiers provided by their devices, applications, tools and protocols, such as internet protocol addresses

[1] https://gdpr.eu/eu-gdpr-personal-data/

[2] https://gdpr.eu/recital-30-online-identifiers-for-profiling-...

Re:Consent-O-Matic by rglullis on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:36AM (#46667708)
When an IP address is linked to any other data, then it counts as PII. By itself, it's not.

So, sure, if you stick the user's IP address on a cookie from a third-party service, you are sharing PII. But this is absolutely not the same as saying "you need to claim legimate interest to serve anything, because you will need their IP address".

Re:Consent-O-Matic by kuschku on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:58AM (#46667839)
An IP address linked with the website being accessed is already PII.

When serving content, you're by necessity linking it to a website that's being accessed.

For example, if grindr.com had a display in their offices that showed the IP address of the request that's currently being handled, that's not saving or publishing or linking the data, but it's still obvious PII.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by rglullis on Sunday January 18, 2026 @09:16AM (#46667966)
> a display in their offices that showed the IP address (...) that's not saving or publishing

You are not sharing with a third-party, but that sure falls into processing and publishing it.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by close04 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:55AM (#46667828)
IPs are PII even before you inevitably link them to something in your logs. If you can make a case that you absolutely don’t store them anywhere, they’re just transiently handled by your network card, maybe you get away with it but only because someone else along the stream covers this for you (your hosting provider, your ISP, etc.)

Source: I have been cursed to work on too many Data Protection Impact Assessments, and Records of Processing Activities together with actual lawyers.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by rglullis on Sunday January 18, 2026 @10:07AM (#46668362)
Basically we are in agreement: IP addresses, by themselves, are not PII, only when they are linked to other information (a cookie, a request log) then it consitutes processing.

So, apologies if I was not precise on my comment, but I still stand by the idea: you don't need to a consent screen that says "we collect your IP address", if that's all you do.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by close04 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @02:30PM (#46671277)
Not really, no. I don’t think I can make it more clear than I, or the law, already did: IPs are PII no matter what. Period. It’s literally spelled out in the law.

The misconception is that you need explicit consent for any kind of processing of PII. That is not the case. The law gives you alternatives to consent, if you can justify them. Some will confuse this with “must mean IPs aren’t PII”, which is not the case.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by youngtaff on Sunday January 18, 2026 @10:33AM (#46668612)
IP address is considered personal data and can be considered personally identifiable data in some circumstances for example if you can geolocate someone to a small area using it
Re:Consent-O-Matic by Rygian on Sunday January 18, 2026 @03:24PM (#46671781)
Your interpretation does not match GDPR. I suggest you read the link in the post you replied to.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by atoav on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:50AM (#46667036)
Also: the consent has to be informed consent. Me clicking away a nag banner, even if I click "accept" isn't informed consent by the definition of the law.

You want to share my data with your 300+ "partners" legally? Good luck informing me about all the ways in which every of those single partners is using my data. If you are unable to inform me I can't give consent, even if I click "Accept all". That is however a you-problem, not a me-problem. If you share my data nontheless you are breaking the law.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by neodymiumphish on Sunday January 18, 2026 @09:54AM (#46668246)
Undoing whatever data collection and sharing, as well as seeking and obtaining restitution, is probably a much harder problem to solve (for you) if you select accept.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by JCattheATM on Sunday January 18, 2026 @11:44AM (#46669305)
A lot of the notices provide exactly the info you need to be informed, it's on you if you want to read it or not.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by atoav on Monday January 19, 2026 @02:38AM (#46675983)
Are you sure? Most notices provide a list of partners. What needs to be provided is a list of who gets to see which data for which purpose.

Most lists I have ever seen are lists that are not informing me of that, especially the lengthy ones. The only ones that comply are very short lists by privacy conscious website owners.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by JCattheATM on Monday January 19, 2026 @08:13AM (#46678614)
I'm not 100% sure, no. I wonder if any studies have been done on this? At a minimum I would assume sites from big corps would be in compliance.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by gempir on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:23AM (#46666875)
Breaks many websites though and you'll be wondering why something doesn't work and then you have to remember you checked that ublock checkbox a few months ago.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by benjojo12 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:33AM (#46666930)
I think in the last 12 months of using that unlock list I've only counted less than five times where sites have broken with that list enabled, I don't have to even disable the entire list. You just disable u-block for that specific site
Re:Consent-O-Matic by lol768 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:30AM (#46667301)
I've found it to happen much more frequently than that, unfortunately. Usually it's because the modal is two DOM elements - a backdrop, that fades out the rest of the content and sits on top of it/prevents interaction; and the actual consent modal. Websites then use various mechanisms to prevent scrolling. uBlock is often only removing the actual dialog, so you end up with a page you can't scroll up or down and can't interact with.

If you're going to turn the filters on, it's worth being aware of this because it's far from flawless.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by thevinchi on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:50AM (#46667034)
Until this moment, I did the same thing… but right now I realize, this behavior incentivizes a domain owner to intentionally break their site, to trick the visitor to disable their blocker.

Then the browser: refreshes the page, downloadz all the thingz… presents cookie banner.

I’ve been using uBlock (or Brave) for years now, and when “something doesn’t work right” the first thing I often do is lower my shields… :facepalm:

From now on, I’ll just bounce. Keep your cookies, I’m not hungry.

Re:Consent-O-Matic by guenthert on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:10AM (#46667163)
Complain and use a different site. There are only few websites which offer a truly unique service. If enough complain and walk away, something might finally change.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by Dilettante_ on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:22AM (#46667251)
Thanks for the warning, I'd turned on those lists when I read the parent comment and would not have had a good time troubleshooting that.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by worble on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:39AM (#46667361)
I've never seen a website break from this, got any examples?
Re:Consent-O-Matic by linker3000 on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:51AM (#46667809)
LinkedIn - it takes you to the allow/deny page but doesn't automate things. It used to be that the LinkedIn login would get stuck in a cycle around this, but now it just dumps you on to the consent page.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by rsynnott on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:50PM (#46670867)
I mean, no great loss.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by nextlevelwizard on Sunday January 18, 2026 @08:28AM (#46667663)
If a website gets broken by this it isn’t a site worth visiting
Re:Consent-O-Matic by bcye on Sunday January 18, 2026 @06:16AM (#46666838)
This extension gives you more choice than denying or allowing everything though, you get granular choice automatically applied to all websites where it works
Re:Consent-O-Matic by cocoto on Sunday January 18, 2026 @07:55AM (#46667456)
I think most people don’t want to give consent to any of this so a simple block list is enough.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by bcye on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:05PM (#46670329)
Well it does change if you have more of a choice than reject all or allow all (without needing to go into complicated settings each time). Telemetry is not that unpopular - I'd like devs to fix bugs I encounter.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by geor9e on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:28PM (#46670629)
But I don't want to auto deny. I want my shopping carts to work. I want websites to save my login and preferences. I just don't want the pop-ups. So this extension is great.
Re:Consent-O-Matic by cccbbbaaa on Sunday January 18, 2026 @01:38PM (#46670755)
Login, preferences, or shopping cart cookies (aka “functional cookies”) do not need consent. I never saw a banner that allowed me to disable them.