News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by Aurornis on Sunday January 11, 2026 @11:17PM (#46584044)
> * As (ostensibly) a representative Democracy America's fate is dictated by the majority of it's citizens.

No, it's determined by the people who actually go out and vote.

Bizarrely, voter turnout among younger people remains low. It's beyond frustrating to work with large groups of young people who are seemingly always talking politics and angry about something political, then to watch as half of them either forget to vote or act like they're too apathetic to vote.

The craziest part was seeing this apathy play out in states with vote-by-mail systems that required as little effort as possible. I still don't get it.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by pstuart on Sunday January 11, 2026 @11:31PM (#46584134)
There were millions of voters who refused to vote for Harris because of the Gaza situation -- oh, the irony.

https://www.imeupolicyproject.org/postelection-polling

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by immibis on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:54AM (#46585804)
That's half the problem. Democrats aren't offering much.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by paulryanrogers on Monday January 12, 2026 @07:31AM (#46587563)
What do you think would be "much"?

Because even just the boring sanity of Biden Harris was leagues better than what we all saw coming in 2024. (Putting aside that whole constitutional amendment about insurrections.)

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by immibis on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:10PM (#46593547)
Maybe they could promise to make the rent lower. Or to make abortion legal. Or to stop bombing 2 million brown children in the Middle East. Or literally anything people actually want, instead of running on the singular platform or "obviously they'll vote for us because we're not the Republicans". People are getting really tired of the latter. Notice every time a candidate comes out who actually promises things people want he wins by a landslide?
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by pstuart on Monday January 12, 2026 @04:32PM (#46594578)
They actually have offered policies along this line but their messaging is weak at best.

It also competes with an opponent (the GOP) that is more than willing to outright lie to sway voters. This isn't to say that the DNC is beyond reproach but we're way past "both sides" at this point.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by UqWBcuFx6NV4r on Monday January 12, 2026 @08:54AM (#46588536)
This is utterly delusional. I can’t comprehend of whatever mind virus made it so far into the American political discourse for this BS to still be parroted in 2026. I am blessed to be born in and to reside in a country with a comparatively much better-functioning government and voting system. You better believe that if I were American I’d be voting for the dems in a heartbeat. I’d be endlessly annoyed about it, especially compared to the vastly more palatable options where I live, but there’d be zero doubt about my decision. The culture of not voting is the biggest unforced self-own the American public has inflicted upon itself. You all get what you deserve with that one.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by spencerflem on Monday January 12, 2026 @01:27PM (#46592256)
I think it’s reasonable not to vote for a candidate that supports genocide.

Maybe that’s not a line for you but surely you have a line that cannot be crossed somewhere

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by atmavatar on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:20PM (#46592928)
Neither candidate was ever going to push back against Israel's genocide of Palestinians.

While it was very disappointing the Democrats weren't exerting significant pressure against Israel, and Kamala gave no indication she'd act any different, it was delusional to believe Trump was going to be any different. He was very clear that he supported Israel as well, and he went as far as to claim he'd support Netanyahu even more strongly than Biden. Sure, he sabre-rattled a bit about wanting the war in Gaza to end before he took office, but he also indicated he'd support residual IDF actions (i.e., continued killings of Palestinians) within Gaza afterward.

There was never a candidate who was going to push back against Israel, no matter how much you or I would have liked for there to have been one.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by pstuart on Monday January 12, 2026 @04:30PM (#46594560)
AIPAC has a terrifyingly strong grip on American politics.

The only way to address this and other similar problems is through campaign finance reform, which the incumbents will never allow. It doesn't mean we shouldn't stop pushing the issue though.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by amazingman on Monday January 12, 2026 @12:41AM (#46584520)
It was determined by voters. Pretty sure that's over now too.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by bulbar on Monday January 12, 2026 @01:12AM (#46584706)
It's not too late. But it will be too late as soon as too many people think it's too late.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by Youden on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:15AM (#46585518)
In defence of young people, it's "determined" by the people who actually go out and vote the same way a child "determines" what's for dinner when asked "would you like broccoli or brussels sprouts?"

American democracy is broken. Not in an abstract, hand-wavy feelings way but a hard, numerical, mathematical way. A two party system results in no real choice. First past the post results in a two party system. America uses first past the post. Therefore, Amercian democracy gives voters no real choice.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by twixfel on Monday January 12, 2026 @06:53AM (#46587197)
There was a real choice in 2016, 2020 and 2024. Trumps opponent was every single time very different to him.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by ryandrake on Monday January 12, 2026 @11:18AM (#46590509)
Democrats continue to offer up horrible candidates, and their idiotic primary system confirms those horrible candidates every 4 years. A slice of cheese could have beaten Trump, but somehow the DNC managed to offer up the most boring, milquetoast, unlikable, uncharismatic, centrist candidates they could find and beat him once out of three times. They're just kicking own-goals over and over, and they're not learning which direction to run down the field.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by AuthAuth on Monday January 12, 2026 @01:15PM (#46592108)
Biden was not centrist he was left. He was a good president I do not understand why Americans complain as if the choice between the two was so hard.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by throwaway902984 on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:39PM (#46593160)
His policies were tempered, image-wise and often in substance, by his affinity for Joe Manchin alongside his disdain for Bernie Sanders. Balanced alongside the middle eastern foreign policy, he comes across as centrist despite the BBB.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by JohnnyMarcone on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:22PM (#46592947)
Look up the build back better act that Biden proposed and tell me if you think that was centrist. It originally proposed extending the child tax credit (basically basic income for people with kids).

The Inflation Reduction Act, the negotiated paired down version was still the biggest climate bill in history.

He also attempted to cancel 10 to 20k each of student debt, a progressive priority. That was blocked by the Supreme court.

The list goes on.

If the electorate had given Biden a bigger majority in Congress he would have passed much more progressive legislation.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by intended on Monday January 12, 2026 @07:15AM (#46587416)
The self reinforcing prophecy of “somebody else’s job”.

It’s the job of politicians to pander to us, the good voter. Since they didn’t offer us something good, we didn’t vote, and that results in this current situation.

Politics is not my job, being aware of how politics works is not my job. My job is just to let them know they aren’t good enough. It’s because they aren’t good enough, that we landed up in this situation.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by Aurornis on Monday January 12, 2026 @10:09AM (#46589544)
Margins in recent elections have been thin enough that higher voter turnout among young generations could have easily changed the outcome.

Blaming broken democracy is just a cop out. Youth voter turnout for primary elections, where there are many candidates, is also low. More parties isn’t going to change anything.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by Youden on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:11PM (#46593565)
You're missing the point. There were only two possible outcomes: Democrats or Republicans. Both were bad and unappealing. Both are too dependent on the status quo to serve as vehicles for real change (so primaries are pointless too).

"More parties", through elimination of first past the post, absolutely changes things. It allows you to vote for someone who truly represents you and your interests without "throwing away" your vote. That's impossible today.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by allturtles on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:48PM (#46594109)
Well we are getting some "real change" now, so I guess the monkey's paw works.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by johnnyanmac on Monday January 12, 2026 @05:47PM (#46595279)
Dems didn't really get primaries in 2024, so that certainly didn't help.

>"More parties", through elimination of first past the post, absolutely changes things.

Indeed. But that's the one single thing D's and R's can agree on not doing. It'll need to be done state by state to get any real leverage.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 14, 2026 @02:18PM (#46621236)
> There were only two possible outcomes: Democrats or Republicans

This is the civic illiteracy a higher comment refers to. Beyond the primaries, there are numerous down-ballot initiatives that don't tend to cleanly sort along party lines.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by malshe on Monday January 12, 2026 @12:23PM (#46591483)
I remember watching a clip from Jimmy Kimmel on YouTube where they asked people on the street in LA whether they planned to vote in the 2024 presidential election. The twist was that they were doing this one day AFTER the election. It was so disappointing to see that many young people had no idea that the election was over and yet they said they planned to vote. One guy even asked who was running.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by hvb2 on Monday January 12, 2026 @01:19PM (#46592175)
I would envy the person who can live in the US and be unaware a presidential election was yesterday...

Like, they start running ads 18 months ahead of it... How do you miss all of those ads

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by malshe on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:38PM (#46593979)
This is likely because for many young people the only source of news is social media. And they are unlikely to be targeted to see the political ads.

Interestingly, occasionally I see political ads on Willow.tv which I use to watch Cricket. And most of these ads have Noem threatening to deport people ("if you are here illegally, we are coming after you..."). I am a US citizen.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by johnnyanmac on Monday January 12, 2026 @05:49PM (#46595290)
on top of that, you need to register as a voter in many places and that process ends months before the actual ballots come. These aren't things they teach in most schools (nor their parents, apparently).
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by malshe on Tuesday January 13, 2026 @03:50PM (#46607751)
Yeah totally bonkers. In general, most people severely underestimate how long the government agencies take to process something.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by throwworhtthrow on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:40PM (#46594016)
Presidential ads run in swing states. Not in California, whose delegates are a foregone conclusion.

Californians are hassled for political donations, not votes.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by hvb2 on Tuesday January 13, 2026 @01:17AM (#46597804)
There are more of them in swing states.

But the internet is full of them for quite some time, I would expect them to see some of those

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by cassepipe on Monday January 12, 2026 @12:51PM (#46591830)
Hoping this might help you find a way to reach to the young people you have to work with: I remember my young self being primarily concerned with being right about the world rather while also believing nothing I could do at my level could matter. Maybe it's just me but something about small incremental betterment was uncredibly unsexy to me. I would rationalize voting as "participating in the system" that was rigged anyways.

Somehow it changed after I watched CGP Greg's "rules for rulers" videos

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by mrheosuper on Monday January 12, 2026 @01:21PM (#46592190)
And those young people are manipulated by the older part of population.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by beepbooptheory on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:01PM (#46592699)
Maybe ask the young people if they actually wanted to vote for the options they had, before jumping to them being apathetic or hypocritical. And yes, I know the adult-in-the-rooms will be quick to point out that its simply rational and responsible to hold your nose and vote for the lesser evil, and the kids should know that, etc etc. But while it may be a good prescription to people, it doesn't actually address the problem. Maybe we should, but still, if you just want to scold people into voting for you, then you probably don't have a good platform and you probably don't deserve the support you do get.

The fact is, it would of been already incredibly hard for someone to be enthusiastic voting for Dems last presidential election; frankly even without even considering the utter and pointed moral failure with Gaza.

You want young people to vote, you can try to tut-tut them to vote for literally whoever, or you can, you know, listen to what they are saying, what they feel passionate about, and try even just a little bit to address it or, heck, put it on the platform. Its supposed to be a political party, something that unites people under some shared vision.

You want every single young person in the US to vote? Just say: free healthcare.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by aisengard on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:40PM (#46593181)
I mean, they tried that in the primaries and young people still stayed home. If they actually came out in force for Bernie like you said they would, he would have won every primary. Young people simply don't vote because of a lot of different reasons. Probably some of the reasons are immaturity and a lack of belief that they have agency, which is understandable given how society works in the US. You have basically zero rights until you turn 18, at which point you are magically able to vote! Do you believe you have the ability to affect the world at that point? Of course not.

"Put up candidates that don't suck" in this context is basically "put up candidates who will cater to young voters at the expense of literally every other constituency", which is exactly the reason Bernie lost in 2016, and lost even harder in 2020. You can't focus only on one group of people, even if that's the only way to drive their turnout. It's just a losing game, clearly not one worth playing with a group of people who don't yet understand that other people exist, with other priorities.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by beepbooptheory on Monday January 12, 2026 @03:24PM (#46593763)
I guess I just didn't realize that was the settled reason why Bernie lost!

I just think even granting this framing, what is the point or the lesson here? Is the idea that Clinton in 2016 was more well-rounded, had broader appeal as a candidate and young people were too immature to realize this?

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by aisengard on Monday January 12, 2026 @05:06PM (#46594936)
The lesson is that making your sole priority driving youth turnout is a losing strategy, for reasons that are not that confusing. The Bernie lamenters would do well to learn lessons from his failures, rather than blaming everyone else.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by beepbooptheory on Monday January 12, 2026 @08:06PM (#46596208)
Sure, but what does this mean? Like ok we know not to solely cater to the youth vote, great. That wouldn't imply to me then that the correct thing to do instead is alienate or anger that same vote, right? Shouldn't we see nominees that cater to all of them, or a lot of them at least? Or, what's wrong with wanting that?

We do not need to start from the point of view that each given interest or group is totally opposed, that we are locked in some zero-sum death spiral where "the youth vote" shares absolutely no overlap with anybody else. Politics is possible at all because we believe in something else. You could decompose everything down into a list of people to blame with stuff like this, but it won't tell you what to actually do!

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by aisengard on Tuesday January 13, 2026 @03:27PM (#46607405)
That's the thing - we already know that each given interest group has common interests. That's how you build coalitions, by finding those common interests and tamping down on the differences. The problem with the youth vote that we know, is that if we cater to anyone other than them, or god forbid have any opinion they disagree with, they get disillusioned or even outright hostile (very much to their own detriment), for reasons I speculated on above.

So it's better to treat them as a totally unreliable voting bloc that is nice to have, but in no way should be treated special. They are fickle, impossible to corral, and make particularly awful coalition partners.

Bernie, for one, would have done well to use their energy to launch, as he did, but then switch to broadening his coalition, rather than doubling down on catering to their every whim and attempted browbeating. That rigidity and tunnel vision is what sunk him, and is what would have led to total electoral collapse if he had somehow made it to the nomination.

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by beepbooptheory on Tuesday January 13, 2026 @07:16PM (#46610540)
Ok well then I guess there really is no hope here for this. I guess it's just a shame it's such a helpless case with the kids here!

But really, if you have a democracy where there seems to be one uncompromising bloc that no one can really satisfy, that too is democracy in action in a way! Or rather, it maybe says something about the state and the parties that this is the case with regard to the youth. Given all of history, we can't just say in general "kids are intrinsically uncompromising, short term idealists fundamentally incompatible with democracy." Right?

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by morgan814 on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:09PM (#46592803)
> Bizarrely, voter turnout among younger people remains low

I understand why my age group has low turnout. It's a disgusting chore that I force myself to do.

In part, it might be a chicken and egg situation. My age cohort doesn't vote because candidates suck. Candidates suck because they pander to those who do vote.

Now to show my political biases:

In 2016 Sanders had a huge amount of support from young people but the DNC did everything it could to tilt favor away from him. He ran a hugely successful grassroots campaign taking small donations from individuals. Where did it get him? On stage with Biden - the anointed candidates with SuperPAC money. That is no small feat. His campaign ended only after the DNC guilted him into quitting as to "not steal votes". That's my perception at least. I temporarily changed my registration from unaffiliated to Democrat to vote for him in the primaries. Young people put in effort and showed up. It bought them exactly one legally rigged primary.

So every election I put on my clown makeup [0] and pretend like any of this is actually real democracy.

[0] https://rimgo.privacyredirect.com/ZUiVLyz

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by warkdarrior on Monday January 12, 2026 @02:27PM (#46593019)
> Young people put in effort showed up. It bought them exactly one legally rigged primary.

It is certainly wise to give up after one failed effort. Never try again. /s

Re:Jerome Powell Responds by morgan814 on Monday January 12, 2026 @04:01PM (#46594258)
Oh I agree and I vote. More people need to vote. But I understand why people feel little motivation to.
Re:Jerome Powell Responds by johnnyanmac on Monday January 12, 2026 @05:40PM (#46595218)
>Bizarrely, voter turnout among younger people remains low.

in the grand scheme of history, it's not odd. Voter turnout correlates decently with age. It's an anamoly when they do get out and vote, like in 2008.

That's partially an effect of

1. not having compulsory voting

2. needing to actively register in order to be viable to vote, as opposed to simply being delivered a ballot like many other countries

3. the decades of "no politics at the table" policies to help expose the civic duties to the youth. And since it's not a flashy topic to talk about, they won't really bring it up themselves, or simply have non-informed views.

4. careful strategies to try and disenfranchise voters who may otherwise oppose a party. This is what "both sides are the same" does in a system without #1.

Not to mention the proliferation of social targeted media ads changing the landscape and active loopholes used to try and de-register voters. These all hit youth the most to vote a certain way (or not at all).