News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by bfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @04:35PM (#46396531)
I wonder how this will work with AI stuff generating code without any source or attribution. It’s not like the LLMs make this stuff up out of thin air it comes from source material.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by observationist on Friday December 26, 2025 @05:35PM (#46397093)
Best case scenario is it nukes the whole concept of software patents and the whole ugly industry of copyright hoarding. The idea that perpetual rent-seeking is a natural extension and intended outcome of the legal concepts of copyrights and patents is bizarre.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by LeFantome on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:59PM (#46397729)
I cannot imagine it somehow impacts parents.

Copyright and patents are completely independent concepts.

The “perpetual” part is the issue but “rent seeking” is the entire reason that copyright and patents exist to begin with.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by zmgsabst on Friday December 26, 2025 @09:38PM (#46398560)
No — providing funding to promote creation and discovery is why those exist; granting a temporary monopoly is the mechanism meant to accomplish that goal.

This sounds pedantic, but it’s important to not mistake the means for an end:

> To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;

https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/article-1/section-8...

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by conartist6 on Saturday December 27, 2025 @08:35AM (#46401752)
I wish I could get defensive protection against the millions and millions of bad software parents out there. But there is no such thing.

Did you know that Facebook owns the patent on autocompletes? Yahoo owned it and Facebook bought it from them as kind of a privately owned nuclear weapon to create a doctrine of mutually assured destruction with other companies who own nuclear-weapons-grade patents.

Of course the penalty for violating a patent is much worse if you know you are doing it, so companies are very much not eager to have the additional liability that comes with their employees being aware that every autocomplete is a violation of patent law.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by alienbaby on Friday December 26, 2025 @05:28PM (#46397022)
Llm's do not verbatim disgorge chunks of the code they were trained on.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by perryprog on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:23PM (#46397473)
I think it's probably less frequent nowadays, but it very much does happen. This still-active lawsuit[0] was made in response to LLMs generating verbatim chunks of code that they were trained on.[1]

[0] https://githubcopilotlitigation.com [1] https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/8/23446821/microsoft-openai...

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by bobsmooth on Friday December 26, 2025 @08:17PM (#46398208)
ChatGPT has given me code with comments so specific I found the original 6 year old github.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by DANmode on Saturday December 27, 2025 @12:09AM (#46399313)
How long ago was this?

Doesn’t invalidate your story in the slightest - I just know they’ve gotta be chasing this, specifically, like it’s life or death.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by AshamedCaptain on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:46PM (#46397645)
You can still very trivially get entire chunks of code from Copilot including even literal author names (simply by prodding with a doxygen tag).
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by neilv on Friday December 26, 2025 @07:04PM (#46397767)
They do, and, early on, Microsoft (and perhaps others) put in some checks to try to hide that.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by idle_zealot on Friday December 26, 2025 @05:52PM (#46397249)
Surely they do sometimes?
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @05:59PM (#46397305)
A 26-sided die reproduces chuncks of source code. What's the dividing line?
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by AshamedCaptain on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:45PM (#46397635)
This is a multi-terabyte sized dice that is not at all random AND has most definitely copied the source code in question to begin with.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:52PM (#46397684)
The die is certainly not multi-terabyte. A more realistic number would be 32k-sided to 50k-sided if we want to go with a pretty average token vocabulary size.

Really, it comes down to encoding. Arbitrarily short utf-8 encoded strings can be generated using a coin flip.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by Dylan16807 on Friday December 26, 2025 @07:55PM (#46398082)
The number of sides has nothing to do with the data within. It's not random and sometimes it repeats things in an obviously non-chance way.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @08:50PM (#46398368)
Of course, it's random and by chance - tokens are literally sampled from a predicted probability distribution. If you mean chance=uniform probability you have to articulate that.

It's trivially true that arbitrarily short reconstructions can be reproduced by virtually any random process and reconstruction length scales with the similarity in output distribution to that of the target. This really shouldn't be controversial.

My point is that matching sequence length and distributional similarity are both quantifiable. Where do you draw the line?

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by Dylan16807 on Friday December 26, 2025 @08:57PM (#46398400)
> Of course, it's random and by chance - tokens are literally sampled from a predicted probability distribution.

Picking randomly out of a non-random distribution doesn't give you a random result.

And you don't have to use randomness to pick tokens.

> If you mean chance=uniform probability you have to articulate that.

Don't be a pain. This isn't about uniform distribution versus other generic distribution. This is about the very elaborate calculations that exist on a per-token basis specifically to make the next token plausible and exclude the vast majority of tokens.

> My point is that matching sequence length and distributional similarity are both quantifiable. Where do you draw the line?

Any reasonable line has examples that cross it from many models. Very long segments that can be reproduced. Because many models were trained in a way that overfits certain pieces of code and basically causes them to be memorized.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @09:05PM (#46398430)
> Very long segments that can be reproduced

Right, and very short segments can also be reproduced. Let's say that "//" is an arbitrarily short segment that matches some source code. This is trivially true. I could write "//" on a coin and half the time it's going to land "//". Let's agree that's a lower bound.

I don't even disagree that there is an upper bound. Surely reproducing a repo in its entirety is a match.

So there must exist a line between the two that divides too short and too long.

Again, by what basis do you draw a line between a 1 token reproduction and a 1,000 token reproduction? 5, 10, 20, 50? How is it justified? Purely "reasonableness"?

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by Dylan16807 on Friday December 26, 2025 @09:35PM (#46398552)
Why do you want me to pick a number so bad?

There are very very long examples that are clearly memorization.

Like, if a model was trained on all the code in the world except that specific example, the chance of it producing that snippet is less than a billionth of a billionth of a percent. But that snippet got fed in so many times it gets treated like a standard idiom and memorized in full.

Is that a clear enough threshold for you?

I don't know where the exact line is, but I know it's somewhere inside this big ballpark, and there are examples that go past the entire ballpark.

I don't care where specifically the bound is.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @09:58PM (#46398654)
Ok, 1 it is then.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by Dylan16807 on Friday December 26, 2025 @10:06PM (#46398698)
That is not good faith, my dude.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Friday December 26, 2025 @11:23PM (#46399118)
It sounds like you do care where it is then, no?
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 27, 2025 @12:47AM (#46399478)
I care that it's within the ballpark I spent considerable detail explaining. I don't care where inside the ballpark it is.

You gave an exaggerated upper limit, so extreme there's no ambiguity, of "entire repo".

I gave my own exaggerated upper limit, so extreme there's no ambiguity. And mine has examples of it actually happening. Incidents so extreme they're clear violations.

Maybe an analogy will help: The point at which a collection of sand grains becomes a heap is ambiguous. But when we have documented incidents involving a kilogram or more of sand in a conical shape, we can skip refining the threshold and simply declare that yes heaps are real. Incidents of major LLMs copying code, in a way that is full-on memorization and not just recreating things via chance and general code knowledge, are real.

You're the only person I've seen ever imply that true copying incidents are a statistical illusion, akin to a random die. Normally the debate is over how often and impactful they are, who is going to be held responsible, and what to do about them.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by kelseyfrog on Saturday December 27, 2025 @05:16PM (#46405875)
To recap, the original statement was, "Llm's do not verbatim disgorge chunks of the code they were trained on." We obviously both disagree with it.

While you keep trying to drag this toward an upper bound, I'm trying to illustrate that a coin with "//" reproduces a chunk of code. Again. I don't see much of a disagreement on that point either. What I continue to fail to elicit from you is the salient difference between the two.

I'm trying to find a scissor that distills your vibes into a consistent rule and each time it's the rebutted like I'm trying to make an argument. If your system doesn't have consistency, just say so.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 27, 2025 @07:57PM (#46407256)
I have a consistent rule. The rule is that if an LLM meets the threshold I set then it definitely violated copyright, and if it doesn't meet the threshold then we need more investigation.

We have proof of LLMs going over the threshold. So that answers the question.

Your illustrations are all in the "needs more investigation" area and they don't affect the conclusion.

We both agree that 1 token by itself is fine, and that some number is too many.

So why do you keep asking about that, as if it makes my argument inconsistent in some way? We both say the same thing!

We don't need to know the exact cutoff, or calculate how it varies. We only need to find violators that are over the cutoff.

How about you tell me what you want me to say? Do you want me to say my system is inconsistent? It's not. Having an area where the answer is unclear means the system is not able to answer every question, but it doesn't need to answer every question.

If you're accusing me of using "vibes" in a way that ruins things, then I counter that no I give nice specific and super-rare probabilities that are no more "vibes" based than your suggestion of an entire repo.

> What I continue to fail to elicit from you is the salient difference between the two.

Between what, "//" and the threshold I said?

The salient difference between the two is that one is too short to be copyright infringement and the other is so long and specific that it's definitely copyright infringement (when the source is an existing file under copyright without permission to copy). What more do you want?

Just like 1 grain of sand is definitely not a heap and 1kg of sand is definitely a heap.

If you ask me about 2, 3, 20 tokens my answer is I don't care and it doesn't matter and don't pretend it's relevant to the question of whether LLMs have been infringing copyright or not ("verbatim disgorge chunks").

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by afiori on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:05PM (#46397349)
IIRC at a point it was 6 line of code
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by ranger_danger on Friday December 26, 2025 @05:51PM (#46397238)
Everything humans make up also comes from source material.

The real (legal) question in either case, is how much is actually copied, and how obvious is it.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by beardbound on Friday December 26, 2025 @07:08PM (#46397782)
I mostly agree with you, but if a human straight up copies work under copyright they’re violating the law. Seems like a LLM should be held to the same standard unless they should be even less beholden to the law than people.

It’s also incredibly hard to tell if a LLM copied something since you can’t ask it in court and it probably can’t even tell you if it did.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by ranger_danger on Friday December 26, 2025 @07:34PM (#46397936)
From what I have seen, the (US) courts seem to make a distinction between 100% machine-automated output with no manual prompting at all, versus a human giving it specific instructions on what to generate. (And yes I realize everything a computer does requires prior instruction of some kind.)

But the issue with copyright I think comes from the distribution of a (potentially derivative or transformative in the legal sense) work, which I would say is typically done manually by a human to some extent, so I think they would be on the hook for any potential violations in that case, possibly even if they cannot actually produce sources themselves since it was LLM-generated.

But the legal test always seems to come back to what I said before, simply "how much was copied, and how obvious is it?" which is going to be up to the subjective interpretation of each judge of every case.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by viccis on Saturday December 27, 2025 @12:09AM (#46399316)
Not true. That's philosophical skepticism and was roundly refuted long ago.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by ranger_danger on Saturday December 27, 2025 @11:08PM (#46408348)
Source:
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by userbinator on Friday December 26, 2025 @04:53PM (#46396711)
Everything is a derivative work.
Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by benced on Friday December 26, 2025 @11:42PM (#46399204)
I don't think anyone really disputes what should be done when an LLM violates copyright in a way that would be a violation if a human did it.

Questions about LLMs are primarily about whether it's legal for them to do something that would be legal for a human to do and secondarily about the technical feasibility of policing them at all.

Re:FFmpeg has issued a DMCA takedown on GitHub by EagnaIonat on Saturday December 27, 2025 @01:12AM (#46399583)
> I wonder how this will work with AI stuff generating code without any source or attribution.

It's already fixed. Anything you make with AI cannot be protected in any way (UK gives some leeway on certain types of creations).

So if it mimics code from ffmpeg for example, then ffmpeg wins.