News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by wmeredith on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:02AM (#4626856)
I don't see how anyone can defend Samsung seriously. I'm sure there is minutiae in the case that could be disputed. However, in the light of evidence like the comparisons in this imgur album [http://imgur.com/a/by8Xq], saying that Samsung didn't copy the iPhone as well as the rest of Apple's trade dress seems silly.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by mistercow on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:22AM (#4626947)
Certainly they copied some things, just as all companies copy good features from their competitors (this is a good thing; it's called progress).

But trade dress protection is not intended to prevent intellectual dishonesty or protect intellectual property or any other notion of fairness between companies. It is there for a specific practical purpose: to protect consumers from confusion.

But Apple's branding is so effective and distinctive that confusing consumers about what is or isn't an Apple product would be quite difficult without straight up violating their trademarks. Look again at the gallery you linked to, and instead of asking "Did Samsung copy Apple?", ask yourself "Could a shopper looking for a smartphone in a store honestly confuse these two products?"

Also, the iPod connector? Nothing to do with the Galaxy S. That's probably just a Samsung iPod connector, for you know, iPods and iPhones. The Galaxy S uses micro-USB.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by culturestate on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:35AM (#4627008)
> Also, the iPod connector...probably just a Samsung iPod connector, for you know, iPods and iPhones.

That is the stock galaxy tab cable.

http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/galaxy-tab-accessories/ECC1...

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by mistercow on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:03AM (#4627135)
Interesting. And I see that it is in fact not interchangeable with the iPod connector. Still, it's pretty hard to imagine someone mistaking a Galaxy Tab for an iPad because of the USB connector.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by headShrinker on Monday October 08, 2012 @01:17PM (#4627811)
It all adds up. Any one thing is not going to cause 'someone mistaking a galaxy tab for an ipad', But when you put everything together, not even the lawyer for Samsung could distinguish the two.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by rayiner on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:45PM (#4627657)
My mom would totally be confused by all of those examples. My mom, like many (most?) people doesn't like to read labels. She sees the general look. That's why trade dress protection exists as distinct from trade mark protection.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by sahaj on Monday October 08, 2012 @04:45PM (#4628672)
I bet your mom also couldn't tell the difference between a Sharp TV or a Samsung TV if they didn't have the labels. I think your point is moot.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by enraged_camel on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:42PM (#4627639)
>>Certainly they copied some things, just as all companies copy good features from their competitors (this is a good thing; it's called progress).

You certainly have a very interesting definition for "progress."

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by mistercow on Monday October 08, 2012 @04:16PM (#4628572)
No, I have a very mundane, standard definition of progress. One of the many negative effects of our society's pathological individualism is this idea that copying an idea is intrinsically immoral. In fact, copying is necessary to innovation and innovation is pointless without more copying.

Ever notice that basically all cars have 90% identical feature sets while only a small handful of special features differentiate any particular model from the rest of the market? How did that situation come about? Did God come down from heaven in 1970 with some stone tablets describing an AMC Pacer and declare "Here is the basic idea of the automobile. Now go forth and add superficial features to this design"?

Of course not. What happened was that manufacturers competed for many decades, incrementally adding new features. And when one manufacturer found a feature that succeeded in the market, other manufacturers copied it.

This is how technology advances: by building on past success.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by enraged_camel on Monday October 08, 2012 @08:06PM (#4629288)
I think you're a bit confused. There's a difference between copying and imitation. For example, all cars may have driver seats, but no two driver seats are identical. They all differ in material, shape, color, comfort, adjustability (or even adjusting mechanism)...

What does not lead to progress is imitation, where the feature in question is copied to be completely identical without any incremental improvements or adjustments for context.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by mistercow on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @10:48AM (#4631783)
Well, Samsung's products aren't even close to identical to Apple's, so there you have it.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @12:45PM (#4632549)
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by jakobe on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:41AM (#4627044)
Only very few of the people who buy smartphones know as much about the technical differences between iOS and Android as we do. Many people just want an iPhone, walk into a store, and end up buying some Android phone because they are told it's the same thing but cheaper. That's what trade dress protection should prevent.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by w1ntermute on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:32AM (#4627301)
> Many people just want an iPhone, walk into a store, and end up buying some Android phone because they are told it's the same thing but cheaper.

Sorry, but that just sounds like the delusions of an Apple fanboy. If your theory had any truth to it, Android sales would've plummeted a year ago, when the iPhone 3GS became free on contract. But instead, the Samsung Galaxy S3, which has been selling for $200 (the same price as the latest iPhone) has had phenomenal sales.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by mistercow on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:00AM (#4627119)
>Only very few of the people who buy smartphones know as much about the technical differences between iOS and Android as we do.

I'm not talking about technical differences. You can look at phone, or the box, and instantly recognize which one is an Apple product.

>Many people just want an iPhone, walk into a store, and end up buying some Android phone because they are told it's the same thing but cheaper.

On what planet do a salespeople try to mislead customers into buying less expensive products?

>That's what trade dress protection should prevent.

That is simply incorrect. Trade dress protection is to prevent customers from mistaking one product (and/or manufacturer) for another. If a customer understands that product X is not product Y, but believes that the two products are functionally equivalent, then that has nothing to do with trade dress protection.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by salgernon on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:12PM (#4627501)
>>Many people just want an iPhone, walk into a store, and end up buying some Android phone because they are told it's the same thing but cheaper. >On what planet do a salespeople try to mislead customers into buying less expensive products?

I'm sure there's something more authoritative:

http://www.gottabemobile.com/2012/05/04/verizon-employees-pu...

I would also like to remind everyone about the popular chinese tech blogger (self proclaimed) that thought a knockoff iPhone was the real thing.

(Random video of this)

http://www.clicknetwork.tv/watch.aspx?c=1&p=8&v=112

Its obviously in the interest of a manufacturer to create some confusion over the branding in order to produce more sales.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by dpark on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:30PM (#4627587)
> I'm sure there's something more authoritative:

> http://www.gottabemobile.com/2012/05/04/verizon-employees-pu...

That's not a question of trade dress. Verizon sales representatives are well within their rights legally to push Android over iOS (contractually, maybe not, but that's a separate issue). Saying "X is better than an iPhone" is entirely different from saying "X is an iPhone". And actually, neither case is relevant to trade dress, which is about customer confusion due to product appearance, not customer confusion due to salespeople.

> I would also like to remind everyone about the popular chinese tech blogger (self proclaimed) that thought a knockoff iPhone was the real thing.

You'll note that the knockoff was branded as an iPhone. No one disputes that counterfeit devices are designed to confuse. That's why they're call counterfeit devices and not competing devices.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by bane on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:40AM (#4627336)
It's a real shame that this theory is proposed over and over again.

It simultaneously puts the iPhone buying public down as ill-informed shopping sheep and elevates those that go in intending to buy an Android phone from the get-go.

I personally think better of most people. They buy phones for a variety of reasons, trickery by nefarious phone store salesmen, taking advantage of poor victimized and gullible iPhone buyers is probably very low on the list.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by ajross on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:58PM (#4627726)
This argument only makes sense if you're trying to say that all Android phones violate the iPhone trade dress. Since they clearly don't, and the effect you posit exists (which I don't argue), you're simply wrong by construction, no?
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by untog on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:16AM (#4626924)
Well thank goodness that imgur albums can't be submitted as evidence in court. I'm curious about a number of those images- when did Samsung ever use the Apple dock connector (or something that looks like it) on their phones? When did they copy and paste an iOS screenshot onto their phone?
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by magoon on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:27AM (#4626969)
That's the Galaxy Tab 30-pin dock connector, and you can see it compared to Apple's in the third slide of this iFixit teardown: http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Samsung+Galaxy+Tab+Teardown/4...
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by untog on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:36AM (#4627010)
Interesting, thanks. This is why the imgur album really isn't very useful- there's no context/citations.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by BitMastro on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:10PM (#4627487)
It's based on a 30-pin PDMI connector standard (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDMI) but modified by Samsung to be used on the Galaxy Tab
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by rimantas on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:28AM (#4626973)
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by BCM43 on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:38AM (#4627023)
I'm getting a 404.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by viraptor on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:20AM (#4626941)
Considering the pictures start with 1) app icons 2) app menu which well... just makes sense the way it's done - wall of icons design was around forever (win ce phones at least) 3) comparing google maps to google maps - it's not a great way to prove anything.

(the other pictures of external design are pretty similar though, no disagreement there)

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by rimantas on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:26AM (#4626967)

  > wall of icons design was around forever
The problem is not the wall of icons. The problem are two icons which are for Apple App Store and for Apple Safari on that wall.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by randomchars on Monday October 08, 2012 @01:05PM (#4627761)
Well and imgur album is hardly a credible source. Is there any context for that?

Edit: there is. That was not a Samsung store but a Euronics one in Italy. Samsung had nothing to do with decorating the store.

http://appleinsider.com/articles/11/09/23/samsung_shop_featu...

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by ralfd on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:27AM (#4626971)
> Considering the pictures start with 1) app icons

Not normal icons. Look at the red arrows: They point to the icons of Safari and the Apple Store. Which makes no sense in a Samsung store.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by h4pless on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:20AM (#4627245)
This mistake was done by a store called Euronics in Italy. Samsung had no part in the design of this wall and it is the store's lack of understanding that should be in question, not Samsung's.[http://bit.ly/PP9V3M]
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by jakobe on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:31AM (#4626982)
There are many ways in which you can implement a grid of icons without exactly copying Apple's style. So why are there exactly 4x4 icons you can move left and right, above a bar with 4 fixed icons?

Same for Google Maps: why is the search field above the maps gray, rounded, and has a light gray x inside a circle to clear? This is not an arbitrary search field. This is not a typical "Google Maps" search field. There are millions of different styles of search fields, why take exactly the same search field as on the iPhone?

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by nollidge on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:57AM (#4627108)
> So why are there exactly 4x4 icons you can move left and right, above a bar with 4 fixed icons?

Because the screen is a certain size and icons need to be big enough and small enough, up-down scrolling would be less ergonomic (longer swipes to switch pages), and there are a few features you always want access to, respectively.

How else would you do it?

As for the maps picture, I have a feeling that's faked, or that it's Google's mapping app, in which case consistent interface would be downright expected.

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by randomdata on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:16AM (#4627210)
From what I remember of that image, it was a Photoshop job where the exact same screen was found in Apple's marketing materials, but it was posted on Samsung's official website for the device for a period of time.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by viraptor on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:18AM (#4627223)
As far as I know, maps come from the google apps package which is not customised by Samsung (it gets updated from the market). Is that not right? Also it looks very different from the version I have now, so it's strange in general. I've never seen rounded corners on a text field.

(see this for example: http://www.gadgetnutz.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/map.jpg - not similar to what's in the posted gallery)

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by mrknmc on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:27AM (#4626970)
The point of the 1. picture is that there are iOS App Store and Safari icons which you obviously won't find on Samsung device.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by randomchars on Monday October 08, 2012 @01:07PM (#4627780)
That was not a Samsung store but a Euronics one in Italy. Samsung had nothing to do with decorating the store.

http://appleinsider.com/articles/11/09/23/samsung_shop_featu...

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by greenwalls on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:28AM (#4626975)
I guess the argument in the article is that someone at Samsung said to make something like the iPhone and did not specifically say to copy it. But to me if someone told me to "make something like X" I would probably copy it closely. This argument in the article makes no sense to me. I agree with you that the photos you linked to show exact copies of software and hardware.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by cooldeal on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:38AM (#4627027)
Is the maps pic real or faked? I doubt the Android one looks anything close to the iPhone one, let alone a pixel perfect clone that looks copy pasted.

http://i.imgur.com/npHlR.gif

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by fhars on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:04PM (#4627466)
They are both displaying google maps, so it is not that surprising that both look similar. But is is a severe blow against the assumption of honesty of the person who created the images.
Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by pkulak on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:22PM (#4627545)
Yeah, that one's faked.

http://imgur.com/xuRTN

Re:Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone by randomchars on Monday October 08, 2012 @01:03PM (#4627748)
Isn't that the Maps website? The Native app doesn't (and didn't, ever) look like that.