News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by jpxxx on Sunday October 07, 2012 @02:55PM (#4624030)
I think that there's something kind of fascinating and romantic about the idea that an entire world and the ongoing social affairs of thousands of people can fit on a single server blade in the middle of nowhere.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by bsphil on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:03PM (#4624059)
That's what makes EVE so much more interesting to me. There's only one server. The monthly fee can be earned in-game. The economy is tied to actual dollars because it's so reliable. There have been plenty of universe-spanning conflicts that impact the entire game with genuine political drama, and the dev team steps back to let it unfold with minimal intervention.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by pooriaazimi on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:47PM (#4624208)
Can someone explain what EVE is? And explain it like I don't know anything about it (and I don't). Wikipedia, etc. don't cut it and I still don't understand what EVE is and why people like it.

Thanks a lot!

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @04:56PM (#4624428)
Let's slingshot you into the future, where empires span hundreds of solar systems, spaceships abound everywhere, cloning technology is available to an elite class called capsuleers, and human beings still act human.

You're a capsuleer. A capsuleer is someone who can pilot certain specially designed ships. As someone who has ascended into virtual godhood by the benefit of effective immortality, you have entered a new plane of power dynamics. And because you're a gamer, the galaxy is an oyster to exploit for your amusement.

The simplest play is to fly around and shoot things. There are pirates, other players, other factions. They all shoot back, probably. Some of them do it better than others. Eventually, you run out of ammo, or your ship is destroyed, or you want something bigger and badder. That gets you to start thinking about how you shoot things and how to do it efficiently and effectively. That gets you thinking about which ship to fly, which guns to put on it, and so on... and how to get all those things cheaply, or at least for a smaller cost than it takes to make money with it.

The ships, the guns, the ammo: these all come from somewhere. Other players make it. They do it by stripping asteroid belts of resources, holding territory where they can conduct R&D, and build every bullet you expend, every ship you pilot. Some of those resources are more elusive: they come from gas clouds which are hard to detect, or components found in uncharted systems. There are ways to get there and exploit those resources, too.

And naturally, with so many moving pieces, so many different agents, you get hierarchical organizations, larger infrastructure, traders conducting arbitrage and moving freight, bigger and badder ships and bigger and badder groups to hold vaster tracts of territory. And with that comes opportunities to scam and con others, opportunities to be a leader or a spy, and so on.

And all of that is supported by the game. You're constantly going to have to deal with the social repercussions of whichever path you take: a lone pilot won't have support infrastructure from their corporation; an alliance leader has to maintain the interest of his members; time spent shooting things is time not spent mining asteroids; and so on.

What sounds cool? What do you want to do? Can you stomach what it'll take to be in that role? Can you understand mechanics and people well enough to make it happen? Then you can probably do it. That's EVE.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by pooriaazimi on Sunday October 07, 2012 @06:25PM (#4624641)
Thanks a lot. It suddenly seems so clear.

But I wish you hadn't responded! I suddenly want to be 14 again so bad it's hard to get back to work on the app I'm building ;-(

EVE will be around for a few years, I hope. And by then I should be able to play it.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by sliverstorm on Sunday October 07, 2012 @06:53PM (#4624713)
It sounds really cool, but I've done some reading and it sounds like the most amazing moments of emergent gameplay (like the hostile takeover of a monster in-game corporation a few years back) are brief and rare, and the rest of the time I'm told it winds up feeling like a second job.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by mquander on Sunday October 07, 2012 @09:28PM (#4625121)
I played for about two and a half years fighting in the big war leading up to that event. I'd say it was about 10% having really exciting and fun things happen, 60% plotting how to have future fun things with other people, and 30% feeling like a second job.

Thing is that the 60% is actually pretty fun too if you find people you like to hang around with and if you like thinking about how to optimize stuff and achieve goals. So all-in-all I enjoyed it a lot. But I don't recommend it unless you figure out who those people will be before you start.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by podperson on Sunday October 07, 2012 @07:30PM (#4624794)
I think obsession with EVE is yet another example of the kind of Stockholm Syndrome like devotion intentionally tedious MMOs engender in players (I speak as a recovering victim, although not of EVE which is unbelievably tedious and boring even by the pretty vaunted standards set by earlier MMOs).

http://loewald.com/blog/?p=59

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by doesnt_know on Monday October 08, 2012 @12:50AM (#4625540)
As an EVE player I don't usually make a habit of defending it so sorry if this comes across as "fanboyish". I'm in one of the largest alliances in the game and general consensus is that it can be "a terrible game", but there is so many things that are wrong or is just misunderstood in that post that it would take me all day to go through them individually.

Setting aside all the inaccuracies and misunderstandings of basic game mechanics in it (which is in part due to the steep learning curve of the game I admit, so it's somewhat understandable) EVE Online at it's core is ultimately a geek social hierarchy with a thin veil of "science fiction video game" masked over it.

Nowhere in the post did it mention ever interacting with other players, let alone leaving the safety of high security space to join one of the established social powerhouses in player controlled space. This is where the real "game" takes place and which is why the retention rate of new players is so extremely low, they don't get to see it.

If you are wondering why people keep playing this game, it isn't because they are stuck in some kind of "WoW-like" grind trance and just want to see a progress bar inch forward. It's ultimately the chance to ruin another social groups day and proclaim that your social group or culture "is better then theirs". You can visibly view a generated map of player controlled space[1] and say "we own this, we took it from you". The large super capital ships used in these battles are also worth upwards of $1,000 USD. A battle not long ago[2] resulted in the destruction of somewhere around 13 to 15 thousand dollars worth of capital ships.

Ultimately, EVE Online is a social experiment first, a war simulator for privileged first world geeks second, and a science fiction video game somewhere down at the bottom of the list.

[1] http://go-dl1.eve-files.com/media/corp/Verite/influence.png

[2] http://themittani.com/news/supers-tackled-station

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by podperson on Monday October 08, 2012 @08:41AM (#4626556)
I am sure there are good things about EVE that keep players engaged, but the initial experience with the "game" is so terrible as to boggle the mind. It isn't sold as a "social experiment". (Its qualities as a "war simulator" I won't go into -- it's a simulator of its own assumptions, which aren't terribly interesting.)

As an aside:

Way back in the early 80s, I was acquainted with a fellow who ran a worldwide play-by-mail game called "Cluster II", and a number of my friends were players. There had been an earlier game whose title I leave as an exercise to the reader. The game was run using Australian Tax Office mainframes in downtime. It was conceptually kind of a gigantic interstellar conquest run using Traveller's "High Guard" combat rules, and it allowed players to operate as corporations, spies, or straight out interstellar empires.

My point: the experiment has been run before.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by doesnt_know on Monday October 08, 2012 @09:29AM (#4626729)
"My point: the experiment has been run before."

And as long as there are new generations that want to spend their free time with such an experiment, history will repeat itself. Not to mention experiencing it in a new medium (heh, play-by-mail) and taking it to another scale. Hell, our alliance has it's own custom authentication application that strings together dozens of various applications that serve our coalition. We have a small team of system admins that run our services. A single jabber broadcast for a fleet reaches thousands of members instantly, followed by a flurry on logins to the game server.

As far as the "initial experience" being terrible, I completely agree with you on that one. CCP have put a lot of effort into improving the new player experience but it's still extremely lacking and I honestly don't think this will ever change.

I also admit choosing "war simulator" may not of been the best phrase. You're right, it's a simulator of something, but when you are in a science fiction setting where spaceship pilots are immortal, it's never going to represent any war we are familiar with. You're wrong about it not being interesting though, if it wasn't interesting, thousands of us wouldn't log in at one time to take part in a battle over a bunch of pixels.

In regard to your comment about it not being sold as a "social experiment", you'd be surprised. CCP went in that direction with their marketing material for a few years:

"The Butterfly Effect" - http://youtu.be/08hmqyejCYU

"Causality" - http://youtu.be/uGplrpWvz0I

"I Was There" - http://youtu.be/OSxSyv4LC1c

I'm stop posting about EVE now. I fear about coming across as overly defensive about the game, when that isn't really my intention.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by podperson on Monday October 08, 2012 @04:17PM (#4628576)
I appreciate the insights. I'm hardly immune to the alleged charms of EVE (I'm an old school tabletop/board wargamer and game designer), I just think the price (in terms of poor gameplay) outweighs those charms.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by jiggy2011 on Monday October 08, 2012 @09:54AM (#4626819)
Disclaimer: I haven't played Eve in about 5 years.

The learning curve at the start of Eve is pretty steep and just keeps getting steeper as it goes along. The first time you get your brand new cruiser that you mined rocks for 5 hours to afford destroyed by a pirate you might want to cry (Stuff that is destroyed in the game generally stays destroyed).

I'm not sure about "social experiment" but I do remember thinking Eve looked a lot like what I imagine an anarcho-capitalist society would look like. There is literally a price tag on anything.

I do think that Eve is something best played with others, even towards the beginning, if you want to survive it is best to hang around with a few "mentor" types who can help you get through the jump gates to low sec where all the interesting stuff is (the gates are usually camped by some alliance or other who tend to be trigger happy).

I quit playing the game because the time investment was not worth what I felt I was getting out of it but I don't think it's really fair to write it off as just another MMO.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Monday October 08, 2012 @09:13AM (#4626675)
> My point: the experiment has been run before.

Good job on having 20k players. I'm impressed your email system was able to handle that.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by podperson on Monday October 08, 2012 @04:14PM (#4628563)
It didn't have 20k players, but beyond a certain point "scale" doesn't change much (most of the kinds of phenomena referred to in EVE occurred in Cluster II -- I know of no cases of real world crimes being perpetrated for in-game advantage though).

Who said anything about email? This was play by mail. Each turn comprised getting a combination state-of-your-holdings/order-form on computer fanfold, filling in and tearing off the order section, and sending it back. Some aspects needed to be handle out-of-band (e.g. if you designed new warships I believe they were verified legal manually -- one of my friends was given free play in exchange for verifying ship designs -- and then entered into the system).

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @11:50PM (#4625446)
I had a similar experience with WoW, except that mine was pre-launch. After following it for some time, it was announced that cities could not be captured and I realized it was just not going to be a deep enough game to be worth paying attention to anymore.

I did finally run a trial of it earlier this year, after I had tired of Rift and SWTOR, and it was about as vapid as I expected; I got to level 20 and stopped.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by debacle on Monday October 08, 2012 @08:45AM (#4626564)
How did you find it in relation to Rift and SW:TOR? I tried the free version of Rift and found it cool but not worth a monthly fee. I got a few WoW characters up past level 50 a long time ago, but the only other MMO style game I've played since then would probably be Hellgate: London.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Monday October 08, 2012 @09:10AM (#4626661)
Unremarkable. Of the three, I'd rate SWTOR the highest because (1) crew skills are an interesting mechanic and (2) the sheer overwhelming quantity of effort they put into the story was palpable and very impressive for an MMO. I'd like to see a new MMO borrow the crew skill concept and take it to the next level; it was under-exploited in SWTOR. The story made it enjoyable as a single-player experience, but it was otherwise meh. (I didn't finish any storyline, though I did make progress on all 8. My consular nearly finished, but I quit.)

With Rift, the invasion mechanics feel like something I'd enjoy, but that's probably it. I find myself feeling a bit lost about the mix-n-match class structure, but that is more a lack of research on my part than Trion's fault. The invasion mechanic is probably just like EVE's incursion mechanic. Neither was novel to me, though I had never seen it done in formal phases before. (I have experienced masses of suddenly-spawned enemies in GM-directed waves.)

And in WoW... all I experienced was the 1-20 grind of quest lines and vague storyish backdrop. I didn't have a build worth remarking on or any hint of the endgame, so I'm sure my experience is easily dismissed by people who believe you need to be level 80 before you're fit to judge the game. /shrug

I've never tried Hellgate. I did try out The Secret World for a little, but horror as a genre bores me (existential terror doesn't really do anything for me), and I found it hard to figure out what to do in a lot of cases. I didn't put a lot of effort in it.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @11:23PM (#4625382)
I actually made it a point not to focus on the brief and rare aspects. Exceptional events that make headlines are, by their nature, exceptional and often glossing over a lot of the necessary and boring foundation that makes it possible.

My chief advice for playing is to find a good group of people with whom to try to achieve something specific and ambitious. You're probably not going to make any headlines, but you're a lot more likely to have fun despite the grind.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by willvarfar on Sunday October 07, 2012 @05:09PM (#4624457)
suddenly I understand http://0x10c.com/ :)
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by CDRdude on Sunday October 07, 2012 @04:20PM (#4624333)
EVE is a MMORPG, where people fly around a galaxy (this one: http://go-dl1.eve-files.com/media/corp/Verite/influence.png ), in spaceships. Unlike WoW, there are no player classes (warrior, shaman, mage, etc), there are just different spaceships you can fly. You can't jump into any spaceship you want right off the bat though, you have to spend skill points in order to have the skill "Pilot spaceships of type X". Also, some are horrifically expensive, and can take up to two weeks of real-world time to construct. If your spaceship dies, you have to buy a new one. A rule of thumb is never fly what you can't afford to lose.

Unlike WoW, there are no raids and bosss. There are NPC spaceships that you can kill for loot, but that sort of thing is small potatoes--there's no equivalent to a 40 man raid grouping up for a boss fight to get good loot. EVE has no stated goal, there's no endgame, except for what you make of it. Also, the mechanics of EVE let player created alliances control territory, in the form of star systems. Right now, I understand that Reddit and SomethingAwful are the two giants in the galaxy (Test Alliance Please Ignore, and Goonswarm Federation in the map I linked above). There's also a bit of the galaxy set aside for NPC space, where people are somewhat safe from other players, which is the bit in the middle of the map I linked.

Another interesting aspect of EVE is the economy, which is quite a bit more in-depth than other MMOs. Since I don't play EVE myself, I can't say much about it, but I do know that people can become fairly wealthy in-game, just by playing the market, even to the point of paying for their subscription. I'll just say that EVE is noted for it's economy, and leave it at that.

But the most notable thing about EVE is the politics. Because everyone is in the same game world (again, unlike WoW, where there are hundreds of identical Azeroths on different servers), the stage is set for conflicts on a huge scale. Also, the developers are notoriously hands-off. A spy infiltrated your alliance and stole your entire treasury? It's happened before, and it will happen again.

If you have the time, I think you should consider reading a little bit of this: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=881..., which is a snapshot of an interesting event in EVE, that I put together from various sources a few years back.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by joshstrange on Sunday October 07, 2012 @06:07PM (#4624603)
I just read through that entire EVE post and WOW was it long. It was a really good read, even if somewhat repetitive, and just wanted to say thanks for linking to it!
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by Evbn on Sunday October 07, 2012 @10:15PM (#4625218)
Does the TAPI name trick anyone for profit?
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by pests on Monday October 08, 2012 @05:53AM (#4626152)
It's a joke on the reddit post with the highest score:

test post please ignore

http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/92dd8/test_post_please...

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by inopinatus on Sunday October 07, 2012 @05:34PM (#4624530)
Do you remember how Excel 97 included an easter egg flight simulator? It's like that, only inverted.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by TazeTSchnitzel on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:52PM (#4624226)
EVE Online's a space massively multiplayer online game. Unlike World of Warcraft, instead of there being multiple servers for a given areas (hence not everyone sees the same people in that area), EVE allocates one server per area, or something like that, meaning there is only one EVE online world. EVE's considered very interesting because there's a quite sophisticated virtual economy and a larger emphasis on trade.

I don't play the game though, so I might be wrong :)

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by njharman on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:59PM (#4624253)
If you don't know what a MMO is then you need to back up and ask that question first.

Eve is an single "shard" MMO with a starship piloting theme. Similar in ways to Elite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_(video_game) The economy (and related such as production, resource ownership, politics, warfare) are, to an extent not found in most MMOS, player driven. That is what sets Eve apart.

People are a varied lot and thus like it for varied reasons. There are several ways to enjoy game.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by Tooluka on Sunday October 07, 2012 @04:05PM (#4624269)
EVE is a spreadsheets with a chat. Why people like it? Because everything else is so much simpler and dull (except elves in armored bikinis of course). It's like comparing Lego Mindstorms to a Barby game set. The latter is way more popular though :) , just like WoW and Lineage vs EVE.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by jpxxx on Sunday October 07, 2012 @11:07PM (#4625338)
Someone once referred to Eve Online as 'Ayn Rand's Battle Spreadsheets".
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by DigitalJack on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:39PM (#4624183)
There are many servers in eve. Each time you go through a jump gate you are usually hopping to a new server.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saurik on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:45PM (#4624204)
I don't think he means in terms of implementation detail like "how many machines are running the world": the idea is that there is only a single shard (to use UO terminology; I believe WoW calls these "realms"), which means that everyone is playing together in a single massive alternate universe.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by DigitalJack on Sunday October 07, 2012 @04:47PM (#4624402)
I agree, that is probably what he meant, but it was factually incorrect.

Even so, in eve there are only small aspects that span servers simultaneously (the market place, and maybe other things too--I haven't played in a year or so).

The unique thing about eve is being able to jump between "realms" or servers or "shards." That gives the illusion of playing together in a much larger world.

I've never played WoW, so I don't know if you can jump between shards or realms, or if they are treated more like parallel dimensions.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by mquander on Sunday October 07, 2012 @09:12PM (#4625075)
It wasn't factually incorrect, you just didn't understand him because you're not using the video-game-specific meaning of the word "server."

As you suggested, it refers to multiple "parallel dimensions" between which the playerbase is split to avoid overpopulation; that's how almost all other MMOs work. Whether each of those runs on a single physical computer is irrelevant to anyone except the host.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @11:24PM (#4625386)
The original poster, jpxxx, was clearly referring to a physical box. His words were "single server blade".
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by chmodd on Monday October 08, 2012 @08:08AM (#4626453)
Depends on the definition of jumping. Besides paid character transfer (which is a "true" jump from realm to realm) a lot of activities in WoW take place in "instances" and players from different realms may participate in the same instance (PVP matches, dungeons, raids). A few weeks ago crossrealm zones were introduced, so normal questing areas can now span several realms too. It's kind of a hybrid between EVE's approach and classic UO's "shards as isolated universes" system.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by podperson on Sunday October 07, 2012 @07:15PM (#4624773)
WoW is not that sophisticated. Or perhaps a better way of thinking of it is that Blizzard wants to provide a highly predictable customer experience. The world has no real state so it's simply like being locked into parallel _identical_ dimensions.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by astrodust on Sunday October 07, 2012 @04:56PM (#4624429)
There's only one game context, but there are undoubtedly many servers involved.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by antihero on Monday October 08, 2012 @06:36AM (#4626236)
Unless BoB was involved, in which case they jacked up their areas and played as part of the corp.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by kahawe on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:21PM (#4624109)
Also a lot of EVE is actually played outside the game... think about traders and crafters and their excel spreadsheets or websites put together for trade networks.

And of course the spies! Their activities went so far as cutting an important fleet commanders electricity so his thousand-of-real-world-dollars titan could be shot down.

EVE is fascinating!

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by tome on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:25PM (#4624129)
They cut his real world electricity?
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by rcxdude on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:44PM (#4624197)
I think it was seriously discussed, but never actually executed.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by ben0x539 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:28PM (#4624142)
That's how the story goes, anyway.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by Alex3917 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:00PM (#4624052)
This hack is eerily reminiscent of Morpheus coming to free the minds of all the people trapped in the matrix...
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by thornofmight on Monday October 08, 2012 @04:31PM (#4628624)
It's probably against HN etiquette to say things like this, but I really love this post.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by adrianonantua on Sunday October 07, 2012 @11:14PM (#4625357)
Among everything I read in this thread, this was by far the most insightful.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by jiggy2011 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:22PM (#4624116)
I'm going to assume it's much more than one physical box, probably big chunks of several data centres.

In MMO terminology "server" seems to refer to a single self contained game world.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by saraid216 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @05:00PM (#4624438)
"Server" refers to player load balancing, not hardware. Generally speaking, a group of solar systems is run on a single physical box. (If you search through their dev blogs, they explain it a little in the ones where they're improving performance.)
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by aesopiate on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:09PM (#4624079)
You could easily be a Night Elf's World of Earthcraft avatar on some server blade in some cooler universe than ours.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by eric_bullington on Sunday October 07, 2012 @03:18PM (#4624103)
As you probably are aware, this is not entirely unlikely:

http://www.simulation-argument.com/

An interesting read by world-renown philosopher Nick Bostrom.

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by Evbn on Sunday October 07, 2012 @10:36PM (#4625262)
Um, my money is on this option: "(1) the human species is very likely to go extinct before reaching a “posthuman” stage"

I am going to wrote allmy papers like this, "Either some ridiculously unlikely scenario will never be reached, or some other unfalsifiable scenario is true."

Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by brown9-2 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @04:04PM (#4624265)
Neal Stephenson's "Reamde" had some very interesting takes on this topic.
Re:Entire cities dead on some World of Warcraft realms by singlow on Monday October 08, 2012 @01:31PM (#4627897)
After reading the review I was afraid that it was going to be primarily about in-game action - but was relieved when I read it that the online game was mostly a backdrop and only a few scenes actually occur there. I absolutely recommend this book to anyone who has played a MMORPG for more than a few hours and enjoyed the concept of it - even if you were never addicted. It is not a masterpiece like Cryptonomicon or Anathem but a very enjoyable read.