1. I didn't disclose how to do it, merely that it was possible.
2. By "get" I in no way mean harvested. I just manually incremented the ID in the URL by hand in my web browser to see how many users could be affected.
3. Since I never saved any of the information (just viewed the pages) I no longer have it since the flaw was patched.
Nothing malicious was done.
I'll update my comment above.
As it stands we don't know whether hostile agents (silently) got copies of the AWS keys of every user on the site. That should be incredibly concerning for you, but apparently it's not.
I'm still trying to improve my English. Next time I'll try to be more clear. Thank you.
The problem with this is that people become more skeptical in general about new products/companies, which is bad for the community as a whole.
The issue here is how do you deal with this kind of thing? Assuming it is in fact bad for others who are trying to get people to test their prototypes, how do we help avoid basic pitfalls like this one? This could be a service...
You can find a security hole and report it. That's nice and good behavior. But when you say "I have compromised the data with me", then you are being evil.
I signed up to the app because I liked the idea and wanted to support them. I knew that their app was in alpha stage yet.
I'm upset about his behavior. I'm upset that his behavior might hurt 2 nerds' inspiration.
I'm not upset about he got my keys.
But you are right. His behavior is still better than not saying anything.
I'm hoping they're inspired to write secure code from line one.
--
"Still managed to get a few dozen AWS keys though"
Good for you! What a nice person you are. Please abuse more small projects like this. Even if they say they say it was "was only meant for friends to test out".
Oh I see, you just found a security hole and trying to get some reputation? Cute. Please do it by abusing the small power you found and hurting innocent users. That's really, really nice of you.
"Still managed to get a few dozen AWS keys though"
Wow. Just wow.
You sir, just ruined my night. Thank you.
Ps. I am really concerned about your company and its users. If you can do something like this, I wonder what else you could do (or doing) at your current company. I hope, I'm assuming wrong.
edit: "the" » "your". last paragraph.