News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by vidarh on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @03:15AM (#46131582)
Even if we postulate that he fear is unwarranted and irrational, the fear is still real, based on Oracles history of lawsuits, and so the explanation still holds.
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by gf000 on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @05:12AM (#46132674)
It explains nothing.

Java is possibly the safest bet on the future, it's open source both in spec and in the most common implementation (OpenJDK), and is so widely used that there are multiple FAANG companies critically dependent on Java working that alone could continue the development of the platform were anything happen.

Besides, Oracle has been a surprisingly good steward of the language.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by cwillu on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @06:04AM (#46133054)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_.... is not what I would call “good stewardship”
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by gf000 on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @08:34AM (#46134306)
What relevance does it have at the topic at hand? Can you give an example of what could happen that would make sense to worry about?
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by TimTheTinker on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @08:39AM (#46134356)
It's a lawsuit by Oracle against a FAANG company that relates in some (even tangential) way to the FAANG company's use of Java.

That's all that's needed to create a sense of caution for would-be adopters.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by gf000 on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @09:07AM (#46134619)
Running Java is not remotely the same as copying the API interface of the whole standard library and providing an alternative implementation, just to avoid paying Sun, who specifically intended on getting money from mobile usage.

Oracle lost the lawsuit and I do agree with the decision in that APIs should be freely replicated, but let's not pretend that Google was some saint good guy here fighting the good fight, they were just cheap and aggressively capitalistic.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by sroussey on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @10:24AM (#46135543)
Doesn’t every open source implementation just “copying the API interface of the whole standard library and providing an alternative implementation”?
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by lenkite on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @01:02PM (#46137761)
But Google did NOT copy the open source implementation. Google copied parts of the closed-source proprietary Java SE API specifications in order to have compatibility and without taking a license. Kindly remember that Android started using OpenJDK very late - around 2015–2016.

Legally the case was about copying declaring code from a proprietary product, not an open source one.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by cwillu on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @04:36PM (#46140498)
And they lost, because it was fair use, which was obvious to most people in the field. The fact that the lawsuit happened in the first place is why I will never trust Oracle.
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by TimTheTinker on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @07:46PM (#46142400)
Yes - this.

The implications of a judgment in favor of Oracle were staggering. Any codebase that is extensively dependent on a proprietary API is legally locked in to using that company's proprietary implementation as long as that company asserts copyright on its API. Anyone who implements the same API to offer a drop-in alternative to the proprietary product is infringing -- even if a someone privately reimplements the API without distributing the reimplementation.

Which immediately implicates WINE (Windows), Mono (.NET), ReactOS (Windows), Darling (macOS/Darwin), GNUStep (Cocoa/OpenStep), Anbox (Android), Ruffle (flash), GNU Octave (MATLAB), Mesa 3D (Direct3D), ZLUDA (CUDA), and DXVK (Direct3D 9/10/11), to name a few of the most popular...

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by lenkite on Thursday December 04, 2025 @01:07AM (#46144305)
It was not all that obvious from a legal point of view. Google vs Oracle was the first US Supreme Court case directly testing whether copying API declarations can violate copyright. It was also decided later in the EU as well in that SAS vs WPL case where the EU Court of Justice finally ruled that software functionality, programming languages, and file formats are not copyrightable.

These famous cases set the legal tone for the entire world actually.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by vrighter on Thursday December 04, 2025 @09:02AM (#46147740)
But they didn't copy code. Because the code was proprietary and they didn't have access to it.

Reimplementing an interface != stealing code.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by krzyk on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @10:51AM (#46135891)
FAANGs are not something people care or like, those are new axis of evil. So any lawsuit they loose is a good thing.
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by thesurlydev on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @10:43AM (#46135778)
Immediately read this as "prostate" and proceeded to spit out my coffee. Carry on
Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by krzyk on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @10:50AM (#46135876)
We could also postulate based on left-pad that npm and javascript in general shouldn't be used.

It has similar bases on facts.

Re:Anthropic acquires Bun by veidr on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @11:30AM (#46136471)
"npm and javascript in general shouldn't be used" — stipulated